Cloud Computing Security by Integrating Classical ... - Science Direct

Available online at www.sciencedirect.com

ScienceDirect Procedia Computer Science 42 (2014) 320 – 326

!@F7D@3F;A@3>A@87D7@57A@)A4AF()! %76;53>3@6)7:34;>;F3F;A@ )A4AF;5E3@6!@EFDG?7@F3F;A@A@8()!

>AG6A?BGF;@9*75GD;FK4K!@F79D3F;@9>3EE;53> @5DKBF;A@ #AADAE:AA63DL; 3443E=3D;?; 3 +

/:+7/8>9097:?>/E 63F3 3@6 BDA57EE A@ :;E AI@ 5A?BGF7D3@6A@F:7AF:7D:3@6 63F3E7DH;57EBDAH;676 4KF:75A?B3@K3@6F:7H7@6AD3D7 =7BF;@F:75>AG6 EAF:3FF:7GE7D6A7E@AF=@AII:7D7FAEFAD7F:763F33@6:3E@A5A@FDA>AH7D;F !@F:;EB3B7DI7FDK3:K4D;6 ?7F:A6A>A9K A8 ?A67D@ 3@6 5>3EE;5 5DKBFA9D3B:;5 3>9AD;F:?E 8AD BDAH;6;@9 63F3 E75GD;FK ;@ 3 5>AG6 7@H;DA@?7@F

© The Authors. Published by Elsevier B.V. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC-ND license M2014 +:7GF:ADE (G4>;E:764K>E7H;7D -

(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/3.0/). (77D D7H;7IG@67DD7EBA@E;4;>;FKA8F:77@F7D8AD G?3@A;6)A4AFE3@6;A *7@E;@9 G)AE

Peer-review under responsibility of the Center for Humanoid Robots and Bio-Sensing (HuRoBs) /CA975FD;5;FK93E3@6F7>7B:A@7 3E3@7EE7@F;3> @776 !@EG5:353E7GE7DEFDK43E76A@F:7;D@776E3@6@A?3FF7DI:7D7AD:AI3 E7DH;57 ;E 67>;H7D76 FA 93;@ 3557EE +:7 IAD>6 A8 5A?BGF;@9 ;E ?AH;@9 D3B;6>K FAI3D6 F:7 67H7>AB?7@FA83BB>;53F;A@EF:3FDG@A@;@6;H;6G3>5A?BGF7DE3H3;>34>73E3E7DH;578AD?;>>;A@EA8 GE7DE DA? F:;E BA;@F F:7 EFDG5FGD7 ;E E;?;>3D FA 5>AG6 ?3EE F:DAG9: I:;5: F:7K 53@ 3557EE 3BB>;53F;A@E 8DA? 3@KI:7D7 ;@ F:7 IAD>6 IAD>6 +:7D78AD7 5>AG6 5A?BGF;@9 8DA? F:7 H;E;A@ A8 ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 ;E 3E 3 =;@6 A8 B3D3>>7> 3@6 6;EFD;4GF76 EKEF7?E I:;5: D787D FA 3 E7F A8 H;DFG3>

ADD7EBA@6;@93GF:AD +7>

7+36+..>KEGBB>;763EA@7AD?AD7G@;8;765A?BGF;@9D7EAGD57E43E76 A@E7DH;57>7H7>39D77?7@FE @5DKBF;A@3>9AD;F:?E8ADE75GD;FK;@5>AG6:3H7 3=7KDA>7 +:7D73D7 FIA53F79AD;7EA85>3EE;53>3@6?A67D@5DKBFA9D3B:;53>9AD;F:?E I:;5: 3FF:77@6A8AGDBDABAE3> I;>>475A?B3D76I;F:3@KA8F:7E73>9AD;F:?E

+:77@5DKBF;A@3>9AD;F:? ;EF:73>9AD;F:?AD?3F:7?3F;53>8G@5F;A@F:3F6G7FAF:7BDAB7DF;7E D7CG;D76;@5DKBFA9D3B:K53@47B>3576;@ 5DKBFA9D3B:;5BDAFA5A>E +:7F7D?7@5DKBF;A@3>9AD;F:? ;E 3 5A?BD7:7@E;H7 5A@57BF 3@6 3@K A8 F:7E7 3>9AD;F:?E 6;D75F>K GE76 FA 7@5DKBF 63F3 3D7 @AF EGBBAE76FA47GE766;D75F>K3@6 ?7D7>KF:7GE7A85DKBFA9D3B:K;E5A@E;67D76

!@ F:7 B3EF AD93@;L3F;A@E 3@6 5A?B3@;7E F:3F D7CG;D76 7@5DKBF;A@ AD AF:7D 5DKBFA9D3B:;5 E7DH;57E :36 G@;CG7 7@5DKBF;A@ 3>9AD;F:?E D36G3>>K ;F 4753?7 5>73D F:3F EA?7 ?39AD;F:?EF:3F :36 835;>;F3F76 4D73=;@9F:75A67E

+:3FE I:K FA63KE 7@5DKBF;A@ 43E76 A@ =77B;@9 E75D7F 7@5DKBF;A@ 3>9AD;F:?E :3E 477@ 34A>;E:76 !@F:7@7I7@5DKBF;A@?7F:A6E;F;E3EEG?76F:3F5A?B>7F7;@8AD?3F;A@A87@5DKBF;A@ 3>9AD;F:?E ;E BG4>;E:76 3@6 F:7 7@5DKBF;A@ =7K ;E A@>K I:3F ;E :;667@ %3;@>K ;@ F:7 I3KE A8 7@5DKBF;A@ I7 :3H7 5>3EE;53> 3@6 ?A67D@ F75:@;CG7E >3EE;5 ?7F:A6E 3D7 GE76 AH7D F;?7 4GF F:7;DGE7:3E675>;@76 7@7D3>>KF:;E FKB7A87@5DKBF;A@IAD=EA@3>B:347F>7FF7DE

!@AD67DFA7@EGD763F35A@8;67@F;3>;FK;@F79D;FK3@63H3;>34;>;FK! EFAD397BDAH;67D?GEF A887D F:7 ?;@;?G? 8G@5F;A@3>;FK ;@5>G6;@9 F7EF;@9 F:7 ?A67> A8 5DKBFA9D3B:K FA 7@EGD7 F:7 E75GD;FKA8FD3@E35F;A@E3@6 F:3F 3>>3EB75FE 3D7 ;@ E:3D76EFAD3977@H;DA@?7@FE

+:75;B:7D ;E3@3>9AD;F:?FA7@5DKBF3@6675DKBF?7EE397E !@3@G@BDA87EE;A@3>GE73 5;B:7D 7@5DKBF76;E6;E5GEE763EF:75A67 AI7H7DF:75A@57BFEAGF>;@76 GE;@9 F:7E3?7=7K8ADF:7 BDA57EE7E A8 7@5DKBF;A@ 3@6 675DKBF;A@ 5>3EE;5 7@5DKBF;A@ 5;B:7D ;E 3 =;@6 A8 7@5DKBF;A@ I:;5: :3E 477@ GE76 AH7D F;?7 4GF 5GDD7@F>K GE;@9 F:;E =;@6 A8 5A67 :3E 675>;@76 7@7D3>>K 5>3EE;57@5DKBF;A@IAD=EA@ 3>B:347F3@6>7FF7DEEG5:3E E;?B>7?75:3@;53>;?B>7?7@FE4K:3@6 AD ?35:;@7

;9 -;7IA8?A67D@3@65>3EE;53>7@5DKBF;A@3>9AD;F:?E

321

322

Koorosh Goodarzi and Abbas karimi / Procedia Computer Science 42 (2014) 320 – 326

+/=+< 61927 +:;E5A67;E3FKB7A8EG4EF;FGF;A@5;B:7D;@I:;5:735:>7FF7D;ED7B>35764K38;J766;EF3@578DA? F:7 ?3;@F7JF I;F:AF:7D5:3D35F7DE AD7J3?B>7F:7 H3>G7FD3@E?;EE;A@F:7>7FF7D I;F:F:7 >7FF7D3@63@63D7D7B>3576 !FE@3?7;E67D;H76 8DA?F:7)A?3@7?B7DAD"G>;GE37E3D 7 GE76F:;E?7F:A6FA5A??G@;53F7I;F::;E 5A??3@67DE

37E3D7@5DKBF;A@;E678;@764KF:78A>>AI;@98AD?G>3 (#?A6

( ;E 344D7H;3F76 3E B>3;@ F7JF ;E 5A@E;67D76 F:7 EK?4A> 7@5DKBF76 F7JF # 3>EA ;E 3 =7K EK?4A> %A6 AB7D3FAD ;E 678;@76 3E ?A6G>A A8 F:7 5A?BGF7D ?73@;@9 F:3F F:7 D7?3;@67D A8 F:7 D7EG>FEA4F3;@768DA?F:7EG?A8(3@6#F3=7@A@3@68AD?

/-9.381 #KF:7ABBAE;F7675A6;@93>9AD;F:?3@6;E678;@76 3EF:78A>>AI;@98AD?G>3 ( N #?A6

% 61927 !@F:;E3>9AD;F:?F:7;@BGF63F3 3D76;H;676 ;@FA 4;F B3DFE #7K3>EA;E;@5>G676 4;FE4GF;@ BD35F;57;F;EA@>K 4;FE 3@6 4;FE3D7 GE76A@>KFA5:75=AGFF:7B3D;FK +:7 3>9AD;F:?5A@E;EFEA8

EF397E;@I:;5: 735:EF397;EE;?;>3DFA F:7 AF:7D EF397E 3@6735:>7H7>;E53>>763DAG@6 +:7 F7JF EGBBAE76FA477@5DKBF76;E8;DEFEG4B7D?GF3F;A@ +:7@3E7D;7EA85A?B>7J 35F;A@E67B7@6A@F:7=7K3D7F3=7@A@;F3@68;@3>>K;EEG4 B7D?GF3F;A@

#6+C0+335764KFIAAF:7D5:3D35F7DE3@68ADF:;EEG4EF;FGF;A@ F:7K GE7F:7F34>7F:3F;EE7F?GFG3>>K355AD6;@9FAF:75A@FD35F +:;EF34>7E:AG>647?@AD;@AF:7D IAD6EF:7D7E:AG>6@AF4734>3@=57>>;@F:7F34>7 F34>7 ;EF:7?AEF 3BBDABD;3F7

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


>AG6 5A?BGF;@9 BDAH;67E H7DK E?3DF>K 3 E7F A8 E7DH;57E 3BB>;53F;A@E ;@8AD?3F;A@ 3@6 ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 3H3;>34>7 FA GE7DE 3@6 F:;E >736E FA EFAD397 A8 3 9D73F 673> A8 ;@8AD?3F;A@ I:;5: ?AF;H3F7E :35=7DE

*A F:7 E75GD;FK E:AG>6 47 BDAH;676 ;@ ;@8D3EFDG5FGD7 63F3 3@6 ;@8AD?3F;A@ EFAD397 EKEF7?E 3@6 BD;H35K BA>;5;7E *75GD;FK;E4DA36>K6;H;676;@FAFIAFKB7E

*75GD;FK;EEG7ED7>3F76FA F:75>AG6BDAH;67D *75GD;FK;EEG7ED7>3F76FAF:75>;7@F

>AG6BDAH;67DE@776FA7@EGD7F:3FF:7D7;E367CG3F7E387FK3@6E75GD;FK;@;@8D3EFDG5FGD7EA 3F 6;887D7@F>7H7>E F:7K E:AG>6 GE7 BDAB7D BA>;5;7EEFD3F79;7E3>9AD;F:?E3@67CG;B?7@F +:7 ?3;@ FKB7A8E75GD;FK;E63F3E75GD;FK;@5>AG6EKEF7?E ;@I:;5: F:7D73D7BDAH;676?3@K9AA6?A67>E 4GF F:7E7?A67>E3D7 @AF7@AG9:FA5A?B>7F7>KBDAH;67F:7E75GD;FK

,@8ADFG@3F7>K F:7 7JB>3@3F;A@E 3@6 F:7 EA>GF;A@E 9;H7@ EA 83D :3H7 83;>76 FA 9G3D3@F77 F:7 E75GD;FKA85>AG65A?BGF;@9 +:7D78AD7F:73>9AD;F:?E3@6 ?7F:A6E3D7A8 ?AEF;@F7D7EF 9DAGBE

$GA 7F 3>

GE76 6;H;67 3@6 5A@CG7D 3BBDA35: FA F:7 E75GD;FK A8 F:7 63F3 !@ F:7 BDABAE76 E5:7?73>>E75GD;FKD;E=E 3D7 ;67@F;8;76F:7@ 3@3>KL76 3@6;@F:77@63>>D;E=E3D7 5>3EE;8;76

!@366;F;A@355AD6;@9FAF:76;H;673@65A@CG7D3>9AD;F:?8AD3@KE75GD;FKD;E=E3@363BF34>7 E75GD;FK EA>GF;A@ ;E A887D76 +:7 8AG@6 D;E=E 3D7 6;E5AH7D76 355AD6;@9 FA F:7 EA>GF;A@E BDAH;676 3@6E75GD;FKBDA4>7?E3D7D76G576 D7>;34;>;FK

*3>77? G>>3:$3D3@6:;E5A>>739G7E;@ BDABAE76F:763F3E75GD;FKEFD3F79K3E3E7DH;57 !@ F:7 BDABAE76 E5:7?7 I:;5: ;E 67D;H76 8DA? F:7 E75GD;FK E7DH;57 AD;7@F76 3D5:;F75FGD7 E7DH;57 AD;7@F76FA?77FE75GD;FK E75GD;FK;EBDAH;6764K F:7E75GD;FKE7DH;57EE75GD;FK;@5>AG6E75GD;FK E7DH;57;E?7F

%3D=A %3>; 3@6 5A>>739G7E FA ?3;@F3;@ F:7 E75GD;FK A8 F:7 F7JF ?7EE39;@9 GE76 7@5DKBF;A@ EKEF7?355AD6;@9 FA * *F3@63D6 3@6)3K@67> 3>9AD;F:? *:A4:3 )3>739G7E;@ GE76 %/2'%(+ 3>9AD;F:? FA 7@5DKBF 63F3 !@ F:7;D ?7F:A6 F:7 GF:7@F;53F;A@ A8 GE7D ;67@F;FK;E9G3D3@F7764KF:7BDABAE76 3>9AD;F:?

+:7 (DABAE76 >9AD;F:? 'GD BDABAE76 ?7F:A6 ;?BDAH7E F:7 5>3EE;53> 5DKBFA9D3B:;5 3>9AD;F:? I;F: ;@F79D3F76 F75:@;CG7EA8?A67D@7@5DKBF;A@?7F:A6 !@F:7BDABAE76?7F:A637E3D 5;B:7D;E5A?4;@76I;F: *EFDG5FGD3>3EB75FE 7D7B>3;@ 4;F F7JF;E7@5DKBF76;@ >7H7>E4K*3@63FF:7 7@6F:7 ;?BDAH763>9AD;F:?3@6F:77@5DKBF76AGFBGF7@F7D;@FA3 B:3E7A8 +:7 37E3D7@5DKBF;A@EKEF7? 3@6;E6;H;676;@FA4>A5=E3@6735:4>A5=;E9;H7@FAF:77@5A67D7;E3D3@63FF:77@6F:7 4>A5= 5;B:7DE 3D7 ?;J76 3@6 8;@3>>K AGFBGF ;E 35:;7H76 55AD6;@9 FA F:7 835F F:3F ;@ 5>AG6 5A?BGF;@9 3D5:;F75FGD7 7H7DKF:;@9 ;E A887D76 3E 3 E7DH;57 ;@ F:7 BDABAE3> 3>9AD;F:? :3E 477@ ;?B>7?7@F763E3E7DH;57

323

324


;9 -;7IA8?A67D@3@65>3EE;57@5DKBF;A@3>9AD;F:?

! ;887D7@F 3>9AD;F:?E 8AD 7@5DKBF;A@ ;@8AD?3F;A@ 53GE7E F:7 5:3@97 A8 F:7 ?7EE397 FA 3 @7I ?7EE3973@6735:A8F:73>9AD;F:?EF:3F :3E 5:3@976 ?AD74;FE:3E 347FF7DB7D8AD?3@57 !@F:;E E75F;A@ I7 I;>> BDAH;67 3@ 7J3?B>7 FA E:AI F:7 78875F;H7@7EE A8 AGD BDABAE76 F75:@;CG7E 3@6 8;@3>>K ;@ F:7 @7JF B3DF I7 I;>> 5A?B3D7 F:7? I;F: AF:7D F75:@;CG7E 4G;>F 43E76 A@ F:7 78875FE

!@ F:;E E75F;A@ 5>3EE;53> 3@6 ?A67D@ ?7F:A6E A8 7@5DKBF;A@ EG5: 3E 3>9AD;F:?E * ** (>3K83;D -;97@7D7 3@6 F:7 BDABAE76 3>9AD;F:? 43E76 A@ F:7 78875F A8 7@5DKBF;A@ 3D7 5A?B3D76

#7KE3@6B>3;@F7JFE 3D7GE76FAF7EF

% #0,1&

($!&+/+!**+)

#$


#0,1&

&AII75A@E;67DF:7=7K 3F F:7E3?73EF:7BD7H;AGE=7K3@6A@>K4K5:3@9;@9A@75:3D35F7D;@ F:7;@BGFF7JF ;F ;E5:3@976FAF:7IAD647>AI ($!&+/+!**+) #0,1&

#$

8875FA87@5A6;@9 F:7 ?3;@AGFBGFA8F:7;@BGF &/B>

:3@9;@9A@74;F;@F:7;@BGFF7JF

.;F:F:7:3@9;@9A8*3EI7E77;@F:73>9AD;F:?34;F;@ 4;FE ;@BGF;E5:3@9763@6 F:;E?73@EF:3FA8;@BGF 4;FE3D75:3@9764K5:3@9;@9A@75:3D35F7D &AI8ADAF:7D3>9AD;F:?E 3E 34AH7I7 5AG@F +:78A>>AI;@9F34>7 3@6;9 E:AIE F:7 ;?BDAH7?7@F AGFBGFEA8E;?G>3F76 D7EG>FE

+34>7 *;?G>3F;A@D7EG>FEA8F:7BDABAE763>9AD;F:? (7D57@F

8875FEA8@5A6;@9

@5DKBF;A@>9AD;F:?

4;FE

*

4;FE

**

4;FE

($0!)

4;FE

-!&)

4;FE

()'('*$')!+ %

9 +:7E;?G>3F;A@D7EG>FE A8F:7 ;?BDAH7?7@F BDABAE763>9AD;F:?

325

326


8F7DA4F3;@;@9F:7D7EG>FE8DA? F:75A?B3D;EA@A8?A67>EI753@BDAB7D>KE:AIF:7?;@F:7F34>7 3@667E5D;47F:7;D78875FE +:734AH7D7EG>FE5>73D>KE:AIF:3FF:7BDABAE76E5:7?7;EEGB7D;ADFA AF:7D 67E;9@E 3@6 ?AD7 78875F;H7 *A F:;E 7@5DKBF;A@ I;>> BDAH7 F:3F 63F3 E75GD;FK ;@ 3 5>AG6 5A?BGF;@9 7@H;DA@?7@F ;E 78875F;H7 3@6 F:7 DG>7E A8 5A@8;67@F;3>;FK 3D7 ;@ 5A?B>;3@57 I;F: F:7 !

?A@9F:7 D7EG>FEA83>>F:7F7EFEF:3FI7 :3H7 53DD;76AGFF:7D7 3D7 47@78;FE3@636H3@F397E A8 F:7BDABAE76?7F:A6 +:;EEFG6KE:AI76F:3FF:7IADEF>AI7EF78875F7H7@F6D;H7@A83>9AD;F:?E I3ED7>7H3@FFAF:7-;97@7D7?7F:A6F:3FE:AI764;FEA8 F:76;887D7@57 8AD735:5:3D35F7D3@6 I7E3IF:3F(>3K83;D:3647FF7DD7EG>FE3@6;F:364;FE6;887D7@F8DA?F:7@A@ ?A6;8;765:3D35F7D

*F:3FI3E >7H7>E5D73F764;FE6;887D7@F8AD3@G@7H7@4;F3@6AGDBDABAE76F75:@;CG7 3D7 4;FE 6;887D7@F 3@6 E:AI76 F:3F F:7 BDABAE76 ?7F:A6 ;E 47FF7D F:3@ F:7 AF:7D ?7F:A6E 53GE;@9 ?AD7E75GD;FK3@6?3;@F3;@;@9F:75A@8;67@F;3>;FKA863F3E75GD;FK;@35>AG67@H;DA@?7@FI;F:F:7 !DG>7E

$?CC+%*/9%(/8?19:+6C?>?//7=@96 ::

%+//.+8.!$+=23.8>/13816+==3-+68-398A3>2!9.//398+69?/< %-3/8-/809398&/-289691C(%$%&@96 :: %+69798+>+:A9/7=+8.8.?=>