Exploiting Symmetries to Test Programs - Semantic Scholar

INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE

Exploiting Symmetries to Test Programs Arnaud Gotlieb

N˚4810 Avril 2003

ISSN 0249-6399

ISRN INRIA/RR--4810--FR+ENG

THÈME 2

apport de recherche


     !"#%$& '( )* -+ ,/.103246587:9=@?BA1C DFEHG/IJ K'LNMPO/QHRSJ(TVUXWYRVZ[RSJ/T J[\]Z[^_T`ZabT#cedfI'g3UXTVR`hYabJ ikjlU_mnJ[\]o^_Q:pqJ rs^_tHt3UXju\]pqJvjlJ/Z EHJ/jlZ EHJwQ'x_yBzH{/|}L~€fjuRVTK_|Y|X‚ LƒK_|*tb^XWXJ/c †„ … ‡/ˆ[‰‹ŠHŒXˆXŽ dfIIJ\ujlRVJ/csUX‘’\uJ/Q8^_tHt3J/^Xj“^XcstHjuUYt:J/je\lRSJ”csUX‘I^XQBd-^_ju\uRS•:Z[^XTcuJ\u\uRVQHWYc/–F—˜Q8ikjlUXWXj ^_I DJ/ce\uRVQHW:™X\lEHJ[dZ[^XQg:J“€fRSJ/š›J”p^XcktbjuUYt:J/je\lRSJ”c1U_‘#tHjlUXWYjl^XIc1^_QbpZ/^_Qg3J]abcuJ/p\uU'Z EHJ”Z œ'\lEHJ“Z[UXjljuJ”Z\už QbJ/clc]UX‘k\uEHJZUYItHaq\uJ”p8UYaq\lZ[UXIJ/c/–“—˜QŸ\uEHR`cPtb^_t3J[j”™ š›JZUYQbceR`pqJ/jPcudfIIJ[\ujlRSJ”cs\lU†g3J*t3J[jlI'aq\ ^‹\lRSUYQ jlJ[T`^‹\lRSUYQbcPg:J[\nš›J/J[Q"tHjlUXWYjl^XI¡J¢qJ/Z[aq\uRVUXQbc(^XQbp£abcuJ*\lEHJ[I¤\uU¥^Xaq\uUYI^_\uJ\uEbJ\uJ/ce\uRVQHW¥tHjlUqZJ”cuc/–¦}J RVQB\ujlUqpqabZJP^'cuU_‘’\nšF^_jlJF\uJ”cn\lRSQHWtb^Xjl^YpqRSWYI§Z/^_TVTSJ”p Ž dfIIJ\ujlR`Z]DJ/ce\uRVQHWb™fšEHJ/juJP^_aq\lUXI^‹\lRVZs\uJ/ce\pb^‹\l^ WYJ[QHJ/jl^_\uRVUXQ}RVc Z[UXaHtbTSJ”p}šRS\uE¨cudfIIJ[\ujlRSJ”c(Z EHJ/Z œfRVQHW-\uU¥aHQ:ZU‹€XJ/jv‘©^_aHTS\lc RSQbcuR`pqJ\uEHJtbjuUYWXj ^_Ic[–~ tbjl^YZ\uR`Z[^XTtHjuUqZ[J/pqaHjlJ*‘ªUXj(Z EHJ/Z œfRVQHW\uEb^_\'^†tHjlUXWYjl^XI¡cu^_\uR`cn•bJ”c(^†WYRS€YJ[Q"cedfIIJ\ljud¥jlJ[T`^‹\lRSUYQŸR`c(pqJž clZjlRVg:J”p«–sDFEHJ tb^Xjl^YpqRVWXI%I^XœXJ/c]abcuJ U_‘¬MPjlUXaHt\lEHJ[UYjuJ[\uR`Z(juJ”ceabT­\ c]^Xc“^‘ªUXjlI^_T#g:^XcuRVcs\uUIRVQHRSIRV®[J \lEHJQfaHI'g3J[j UX‘›tHjlUXWYjl^XI¯J¢qJ/Z[aq\uRVUXQbcvjlJ/hBaHRVjlJ/p8gfd¥\lEHJIJ\lEHUqp«–DFEHR`c(^_tHtHjlUY^YZ EŸ^_tbt:J”^_j c]\lU¥g:J UX‘]tb^Xje\lRVZ[aHTV^Xj*RVQB\uJ/juJ”cn\‘ªUXjtHjlUXWYjl^XIc(‘ªUXjšEHR`Z E°QbJ[RS\uEHJ/j^_Q°UYjl^YZTVJX™1QHUYj^_Qfd"‘ªUXjlI^_Tcet3J/Z[R­•3Z[^‹ž \lRSUYQ8R`c“^ Ž @D ?™ šEbRVZ E8^XRSIc]^_\s\uJ”cn\lRSQbWRSIt3J[j ^‹\lRS€YJ(tHjuUYWXj ^_Ic‘ªUXj“šEHR`Z E¥QHJ[RS\uEHJ/j“^XQ¥UXj ^XZTVJX™bQHUXj]^XQfd†‘ªUYjuI^_TpqJž clZjlRVtq\uRVUXQR`ckjlJ/hBaHRVjuJ”p«– ¦}JPZUXQ:ceR`pqJ[j›cedfIIJ\ujlRVJ/c1\lU g3J]t3J[jlI'aq\ ^‹\uRVUXQjlJ[T`^‹\lRSUYQbckg3J\nšJ[J/QtHjlUXWXj ^_I J[¢qJ/ZaH\uRVUXQbcF^_Q:p†abcuJ“\uEHJ/I \uU^_aH\uUXI^_\uJP\uEHJP\lJ/ce\uRVQHWtHjuUqZ[J/clc[–1MPRS€YJ[Q\uEHJvRVQB\uJ[ju‘©^XZ[J“UX‘ ^*tHjlUXWXj ^_I ^XQbp ^ cedfIIJ\ljudjlJ[T`^‹\uRVUXQ™ Ž D Z[UXI*gHRSQbJ/c-^_aq\lUXI^‹\lRVZ8\uJ/ce\¥pH^‹\ ^°WYJ[QHJ/jl^_\uRVUXQ ^_Q:p¼cudBIIJ\ljuRVJ/c Z EbJ/Z œfRSQbW(\uU*aHQbZU‹€YJ[j1‘©^XaHTS\lcšR­\lEHRVQ\uEbJ]tHjlUXWYjl^XI-–MPjuUYaHt\lEHJ[UYjuJ[\uR`ZjuJ”ceabT­\ c›^XjuJsa:ceJ”p^Xc^(‘ªUYjuI^_T g:^XcuRVc/™YZ[UXQq‘ªUYjuIRVQHW ceU \uEHJ“š›J/TSTSž>œfQHU‹šQ^YpH^_WY6J ACB9DEFG @´ l³‹´ DEH]I´ CJ=LKM2u² D=:N´ 6 ³ªWBZ[Vp ? U_‘\nšU8QHUXQHž>QHJ/WY^_\uRV€XJRVQY\lJ[WYJ[j 9c W ^XQb&p X"^_Qbp°ceaHtbt:UBceJ\lEb^‹N\ S°R`c \lJ/ce\uJ”p šRS\uE£\lEHJ‘ªUXTVTSU‹šRVQHW-\uJ”cn\ pH^_\uaHZ I Y[W*\^]`_badcVefXg\Thdcd_ i™#^Xaq\uUYI^_\uR`Z[^XTSTVd8WXJ/QHJ[j ^‹\lJ/pŸgBd}^j ^_Q:pqUXI \lJ/ce\PpH^_\l^†WXJ[QbJ[j ^‹\uUYj/–s~]T­\lEHUXabWXE#™ šJ*^_TVTœfQHU‹š EbU‹š \lUZ[UXItHaq\lJ \uEbJ*WBZ[pU_‘1\nšU†RVQB\uJ/WXJ[j c j”™ R­\PRVc kml é oÖ n]oÖ n@cu^’\lEb^‹\]Z/^_Q-g:J ‘ªUYaHQbp-RVQ 'V={ +(?– n ‰    ?‡ >©?ˆ > ]  Co[ L Ll³‹µ˜²  ´'A² $I "V µ u³ b ´ H²‹I´ ’ µ ©² pj \ Yf]]Sdi'³ ]
† µ  9 [qQLgGCsr \ Y5]tS * * D i(µÉ² b[ µ  G< bG Gu³‹mµ 07I$u ÝÝ Ù.t[ïLu=veî

  ³D
Ms²_µo =F -

—É\PZ[^_Qg3J'cuEHU‹šQ†\lEb^‹\27IZ[^_QbQHU_\sg3J WXJ/QHJ[j ^‹\lJ/pgfd†TVJ/clcF\uEb^XQ\nš›Ut3J[jlI'aH\l^‹\lRSUYQbc/–›ºsJ/QbZJQJ]j e&r K R`c^ceJ[\sU_‘WXJ/QHJ[j ^‹\lUXj c¬UX‘IRSQbRSI*aHI cuRS®/JX– ~6‘ªaHQ:pH^_IJ[QB\ ^_T#QHUX\uRVUXQ-RSQ8MPjlUXaHt\uEbJ[UXjldR`cFWXjlUXaHt-EHUYIUYIUXjltHEHR`ceI¡¶ -¾
C >ª9ˆ > ] C
[ du² D=aH² ² ²  d `´ s du² D=bH² ² ²  d `´ Iu²  6 ³ du² D= µ˜²6³ du² D=a s² ./G' µ  '´[³  ² ªgb^YceJ”pvUXQ ^XjuRS\uEHIJ[\uR`ZUXj«\ljuRVWXUYQHUXIJ\ljuR`ZUXt3J[j ^‹\lRSUYQbIc ?–#—˜Q cuUXIJkZ[^YceJ”c[™ ܪá Ý#ܒß


S²’µ 

µ ´Pµ˜²´µu² l³*´ 7

TVUqZ[^XT#cedfIIJ\ujlRVJ/cFU‹€XJ/j\uEHJ”ceJ(UYt:J/jl^_\uRVUXQbcFI^’\nšU(J¢qJ/Z[aq\uRVUXQ:c1šR­\lE\uEbJ]cu^XIJ RVQHtHaH\WXRV€XJ8\uEHJ£cu^XIJŸjuJ”ceaHTSI\ ?– Ž UXIJ}U_‘v\uEHJ}juJ[‘ªJ[jlJ[QbZ[J/cUX‘(\uEHJ}RSQbtHaq\€YJ/Z\uUXj†I^354%6>7X
#  ;#(7}
#¢O71
#¢:Ž  h

TN

*B@pqRVce\uRVQbZ\s‘ªjuUYI jUXsj r ?–)(dabceRVQHWtHjlUXt3UYcuRS\uRVUXQ£{X ™ Z/^_Qg:J šjlRS\e\uJ/Q8^Xc“^•bQHRS\uJZUXIt3UYcuR­\lRSUYQ¥U_‘\uEbJ \nšUt:J/juI*aq\l^_\uRVUXQbc j8^_Qb,p r–“o#J0\ 6\j 3r 0* *j*3g:J'\uEHJ g3J[WYRSQbQHRSQbW-UX‘cuabZ E}^Z[UXIt:UBceRS\uRVUXQ >’\ ^_œfRSQbW^XQfd¥U_\uEbJ[j(Z Eb^_RVQ"pqUfJ/cPQHU_\ Z Eb^XQHWXJ*\uEbJtbjuUfU_I‘ ?s\lEHJ[Q SQij 4r 6*j* *E\ 2  "! '5Y*jVi  SQ4r 6*j* *bgfd^XtHtHTVdfRSQHWUYQHJ(U_‘ \uEbJ(\nš›UEfdft3U_\uEbJ/cuRVc^XQbpjuJ”Z[^XTSTVRSQbW*\lEb^‹\ 'R`cs^XclcuUfZ[RV^_\uRV€XJY– #baHju\uEHJ/j/™HRS\]R`ct3UYclceRVgHTVJ“\lUR­\lJ[j ^‹\lJ(UXQ\uEHJ'Z[UXIt3UYcuR­\lRSUYQ-Z Eb^XRSQ"¶ Smij 4r 6* *j*E\  "$ '5Y jVid 2 "! 'Y*r idSs * *j*E\ 2 "! '5Y*jVid 2 "! 'HY(r id *j* *