HELSINKI UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY Department of Computer ...


    
 
 ! "#%$'&)(+*+,-#/.0*132415,-$768*9#%(;:%:?# &3.>@A
B.8C5#%#%(EH+H+&)(LK+6

> MNO QPRO OST
UOV
WO   XY ;XZ
B" O[SF5


XY&3H9*9#%(]\^HBJ8#/HE&3HMaI#%#/.bH+68a',b@t#/.>C5CŽ&)(+#b@8#%(E(+1]¾²b*9(`&3:?#/H&)(E#:?15.>@76>:?*9#/@¦15.‡*+J8#@>#(E#%$7rD&3:?#?­ ,-#/.G*$k15rf@>&)(E@A:%&3:EJ>Cb$I15rDH+*+&/e)&)*ez&3Ì rD:?#Rh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ’é mhDl)h÷é *+J8#%(EH‡h hh h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ3® mhô£ ;132d*Or=C313(E,bH¹hh h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ3® mhô£hDl 132d*n h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ3® mhô£hô£ 132d*;@YJ7&3.>:?#üh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ3m mhô£h÷é $>*+,b,b&)(E²Èh h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûõ5© mhôõ
4¾$'@A#/:?1;@>*+r=15&3@Y­Ø*9(E&3:?#3i'T&)(+C3#!:%&3:EJ>#/HAh hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hû®3o phôõhôõ TO ­Ø*9(E&3:?#3is;,b&3rfrk:%&3:`J8#/HŽh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûm3õ phôõh÷é TO ­Ø*9(E&3:?#3iIn&)(EC3#!:%&3:EJ8#/Hth!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hûm5© phôõhô® *+J8#%(9­Ø*9(E&3:?#3iz;,b&3rDrI:%&3:`J8#/H hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hÇ©l phôõhôm *+J8#%(9­Ø*9(E&3:?#3ikn&)(+C3#j:%&3:EJ8#/Hóhh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hÇ©)® 86>,b,b&)(+²üh!h h hh h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h h hh!h hh h hh hÇ©)p

ˆ —'«T°GÏL“nŸ– d—k« ò j …¹ ¤MÏL d—'¨7˜’š>§M•kÀ



‹tϐ—7Ÿ/Ÿ]š>˜]À


nò

ù

zx  L›Š“Ïdš>”]—7˜
'ý ShDlÈ&3:EJ8#-;(+13a'r=#/,bH4_# HEJ8156>rD@brD1013¬-@¦r=#/&)(`.b2(+15,*+J>#_13(+¬HB132z1568($>(+#/@8#/:?#/H+H+13(EH%hVJ8# $'&3H9*TH915rf68*+HTJ>&/e3#&3rDr5(E#%e315r=e3#/@j&)(E156>.>@!,c6>r=*+@×*+J8#Z6>H9#%(EH†J>&]e3#YaI#%#/.×#/@76>:%&)*9#/@¶.>6>:%CŽ*+J8# *9(`&’¸‡:¦J>&]e3#¦aI#%#/.ª@8²;e’&3.0*+&)C3#/H41327:%&3:`J>.>&/e3#ak#%#/.$7(+#/H9#/.0*nC &3.7@Ye;&]e3#-ak#%#/.¥&grD&)(EC3#j2L&3:?*913(!@b,-13(E##/H9*+J8#%*+H+@t_&/²;H*91 &3rfr=#%e(E13a7r=#/,bH,c6>H9*aI#2d1567.>@zh J>&)$>*9#%(t$>(E#/H9#/.G*+Ht&3.Ë1]e3#%(Ee#Y´Š#%aÔ&)(E:`J>#g(+#/±06>#/H9*9#/@×@81;:%6>,-#/.0*-&3.>@$I15H+H+,-#/.0* #b:?15.G*9#/.0*!*Ͳ0$I#3i #?¾;$7,-#/.0*+H&)(E#!_(E&3.8C5Cª#´Š#%asi$7&)(EH9#&3.7@b@8#?¾c*+J8#/,&3.7@bH+J8156>rf@¹*+J8#@81;:%6>,-#/.0*B:?15.0*+&3(EH+(+13a7r=#/,¦H15.Z*+J8# ´Š#%anh OHH915,-#cH9#%(+e3#%(EH&3.>@Y@>1:%6>,b#/.G*+H&)(+#j,-13(E#!$I13$76>rD&)(*+J7&3.Ž13*+J8#%(EH/i'*+J>C3#/H9*+&]e3# *91Š_&36>:?#*+J8# &3,-156>.0*s1328@>&)*+&rD@.813*s(E#/rD#/&/e;:?#*+J8#*9(E&’¸‡:)h J8# »'(EH9*H+15rD68*+#c2d(E&3H+*9(E6>:?*+68(+#3i7_156>rf@Že3#%(+²ArfrD@YH9*+&)$>$7&)*B& ,b13(+##?¸‡:%H+C*+J>#:%68(+(+#/.0*V(+#/H9156>(E:?#/HB,c6>H9* aI#V2156>.>@zhJ>H9#/@Z*91g*9(E&3.>H+,¦*+J8# :?15.>.>#/:?*+H H+*+&)(+* &)*!&ŽH+rD1]_Ó(E&)*9#b*91Y&/e315&3Hak#%#/.Ž2d156>.7@t*91baI#*+J>#!:%&3H9Ð # Q÷õ3{o RØh O (+#/:?#/.G*¹H9*+&)*+@ª&/e3#ZaI#%#/.ÐH+&3.7(E&)*+&;i&367@>@³e#%18hµO,-15.>CZ*+J>#/H9#g,-#/@>r=²µXZË_156>rf@r=#/.7@ª(+#/H+HE:?#†*+J8#t6>H9#¦132 :?15,b$>(+#/H+H+6>:?#j*+J8#j*9(`&’¸‡: 15.Y*+J8#c´Š#%a¥,¦@Z MH_@>#/H+*9#%(µ£Î$>(+#/H9#/.0*+HY&3.Å1–e3#%(+er=*+@Ð*+J8#/(+13$I#%(+*+@¹H9132d*:%&3:EJ>C *9#/:EJ>.>15r=13C3²b&)$>*9#%(¹®t*+J8#‡FGqB
­·&)*+&j@ H+15rD68*+Hc*91ª(+1–e3#g*+J8#AH9$I#%#/@132*+J8#Ž´Š#%ash×OH-*+J8#Ž13a8K #/:?*+H¦(+#/±06>#/H9*9#/@‘a² *+J>#¦6>H9#%(EH&)(E#b132e’&)(+²;#/H*+J8@ # ÚSôxÕGF

E H? N OQP@B?RC I AM@>? NOQP@B? CSKLAM@>? U T H PVWVYXZ@?VYH@¦#/H+*+&)*B*+J>#6>H+#%(EH4_156>rD@b»'.>@¦&cH9*+&3r=#/.>#/H+HB(`&)*+* ­ &)a'r=#3hVJ>rD&)*+CjH9*+&3r=#/.>#/H+HJ>&3H*+J8#&3@8e’&3.0*+&)C3#*+J>&)*15rD@8#%(13a;K9#/:?*+H J7&/e3#¹r=1]_H9*+&3r=#/.8#/HEHe)&3rD68#/H_J>rD@¦*+J7#HEJ>&)(+#/@‡ak#%*Í_#%#/.tH9#%e3#%(`&3rk67H9#%(EH%i0*+J8#&3:%:?#/HEH9#/H132z*+J8#13*+J8#%(67H9#%(EH ,¦&)*+&)$7*9#%(g$>(+#/H9#/.0*+Hg&3.¶1]e3#%(+e;r=*+&/e3#‡ak#%#/.ª&g$7&)(+*132*+J8#-´Š#%aH+:?#bC8hc 1]_&3@>&/²;H¹,b&3.0² $I13$767rD&)(_#%aY$7&)C3#/H6>H9# C3(E&)$'J>$I13(+*!@>rD@J>&]e3#t*91ZaI# 67H9#/@g&3HH9#%$'&)(E&)*9#!&3HaI#%#/.b(+#/:?#/(+#/HEH+(+13$I15H9#/@¥213(E,b&)*+H_&3rD@‡r=15H+H+r=#/HEHB:?15,-$>(E#/H+H+#j*9(E&3.7H+,brD@ZaI#-:?15.Ge3#%²3#/@ª*91Ž*+J8#-6>H9#%(/h¹J>&)*c*+J>&]e31:t® #  œ ÔWôdÑcéØ)fÑdÕ¯B˜M£lØýòlôÓÚ&3H @>#/H+:?(Er=15&3@g*+H9#/@t@8_*+J>HaI#%*·_#%#/.*+J8#/H9#†*+J8(+#%#‡&)(E#»º V aI#%*Í_#%#/.:%rD(E1/¾;²µ&3.>@hº X aI#%*Í_#%#/.A$>(+1/¾;²t&3.>@ŽH9#%(+e3#%(]h ¼naYepaYe

½dli
¾nk7jg&s6v

 .0*9#%(+#/H9*+&)(E&3.;­ :%&3.¶*+J8#¥a7&3.>@8_#Š$>(+1/¾;²Ð&3.7@Ð*+J>#¥:%rf&)**+J>r=15&3@‡*+:%&3:`J8#/@ba²*9#/HB.8#%#/@8#/@b*91 aI#2d#%*+:`J8#/@ 2(+15,þ&†2L&)(9­·&/_&/²µH9#%(Ee3#%(/hj .Z*+J>#c13a8K #/:?*+H2(+15, *+J8#-2L&)(9­ &]_&]²ŽH9#%(+e3#%(_156>rf@gJ>&/e3#j(+#/H+6>r=*9#/@gr=15&3@t*+#/@-&3HV*+J8# J7#%(+#¹#/&3:EJªJ7rD@taI# .813*9#/@zi'*+J>&)**+J>&]e3#@8#%(`@>rD#15.>r=²¹(+#/:?1;@>&)a7r=#13a;K #/:?*+H13(aI13*+J¦(+#/:?1;@>&)a7rD#&3.>@ .815.;­Ø(+#/:?1;@>&)a7rD#13a;K9#/:?*+H%hV2s*+J8#(+#/:?1;@>&)a7r=#&3.>@t.815.;­Ø(+#/:?1;@>&)a7rD#13a;K9#/:?*+H&)(+# ¬3#%$>*15.;­Ø(+#/:?1;@>&)a7r=#13a;K9#/:?*+H:?1)­·J>&)a7&)(+#-H15.>r=²t15.8# $>(+1]¾²†*91‡&3@>,¦#%(+#t*91Y(+#/:?1;@8{# ,ç#/:?1;@>H+#%26>rH9#%(+e;@¥&)**+J8#¹$>(E1/¾;²3is(+#/:?1;@>H+,¦rD@-aI#6>H9#/@b213(*+J8#:%&3:`J8#3i8&3H$>(+#/H9#/.0*9#/@g*+J8#H9132*:%&3:EJ7&)(E@Š213(!r=15H+H+² :?15,b$>(+#/H+H+H9#%Ð # Q÷£3{o RØh 132d*4:%&3:`J>$I13(+*M&rD&]²3#%(+#/@¦:?1;@>#%(+#H915,-# 132!*+J8#Zrf&/²3#%(EHt:%&3.ËaI#A(+#/,-1–e3#/@¶_*‡,b&)¬;.6>H+&)a7rD#3höJ8# FGqB
­Ø2d13(`,b&)*J>&3H*+J8#/H9#$>(+13$I#%(+*+@>&)(E@t@8#?»k.8#/H&j$7(+13C3(+#/H+H+(+13C3(+#/HEH+.7:?*+&3rD@8#/@(+13C3(E&3,¦H &3.>@ª:%6>(+(+#/.0*+r=²Z&3rfrVa>(+1–_H9#%(EHj&3.>@µ,b&3.0²¥13*+J8#%( e;(+13C3(`&3,bH&)(+#!&)a'r=#*91¦@8#/:?1;@8# &3.>@ŽHEJ81]_Ò$7(+13C3(+#/H+H+#/.G*jFGqB
Ö(E1568$s\^HcrD(E&)(E² Q¼l/{m R@>&3.>@zi;:?15.0*+&3#†132*+J8#g:?15r=13(b:?15,-$I15.8#/.0*+Hja'68*c.>#%e3#%(-ak13*+J³rD6>,¦&3.>:?#†&3.>@:EJ8(+15,¦&3.>:?#3h J>#A:?15r=13(‡:?15,b$k15.>#/.G*+H-15.ÐrD&/²3#%(`H‡õié8ipŠ&3.>@ÎoŠ&)(E#A.813* $7(+#/H9#/.0*%h ;:?#V*+J8#:?10#?¸‡:%H9# h ^¥JÃÛ

 

à4ÚVÝ á N ¹ Ü â ’ ܹáë॔#á#â

 J8#b$>(+13C3(E#/H+H+:?1;@>##?¾;&3:?*2d13(E,¦&)*4132'*+J>##/.>:?1@>#/@bH9*9(+#/&3,R&3.>@-&3.0²t$>(+13C3(+#/HEH+(+#%e;HrD&/²3#%(@>68(EC (E#/:?1@>#/HVH&3.>@¥*9115r a'&)(EH%h 813(b(+#%2#%(+#/.>:?#3i4*+J>#†e)&3rD68#/Hc213(-*+J8#ts#/.>&’­·@ªl/é õ á &)*r=#%e3#/rBl)h OH_#cH9#%#!2(+15, *+&)a7r=#j®hôõik*+J8#j¨7œ l%¢3¢Ðá m’é8h ©Ðá ®3ohôoêá ®3®hô®êá ®3õh^¢Fá õ5©0hômêá £3mhôpêá £3õhDlìá l/oh ©Ðá l%¢;hôoêá

&)a7r=#!®hôõ…,b&)C3#jH+:?#!&3.7@g*+J8#%(+#%213(+# @81¦.>13*:?15,-$>(+#/H+H_#/rDrØh ^¥J&%

\ ß-ãä㙒£M ‰

J>&)$7*9#%(AJ>&3Ht$>(+#/H+#/.G*9#/@Ò&‘HEJ813(+*t1]e3#%(+e;#b$>(+13C3(+#/HEH+# .8#%_Ò13a;K9#/:?*»7*+H# :%&3:EJ8#3h £h´ËJ>#/.8#%e3#%(V*+J8#:%&3:EJ8#HE&3HBaI#%#/.‡(+#%2#%(+#/.>:?#/@ *+J>#µr=#/&3H9*Ž(+#/:?#/.0*+r=²3hç813(Y*+J>(+$I15H9#3i:?#/@zhJ>HT&3rfH91*91aI#68$z@>&)*9#/@j_J8#/.j&:%&3:EJ8#/@c13a;K9#/:?*V13*aI#%#/.t(+#/:?#/.0*+r=²‡(+#%2d#%(E#/.>:?#/@zi>rD&)*rD@taI#(+#%2#%(+#/.>:?#/@A&)C5&3&3H‡aI#%#/.Ð&e3#%(+²×$I13$76>rf&)(¦$I15rDH9#/@Ð_:EJ¶&3H†*+J8#µ;±067(E1/¾;ü ² Q÷õ3{® RØh 1]_#%e3#%(/iI(+#/:?#/.0*(E#/H9#/&)(E:EJZJ>&3H$>(+1]e3#/.Y*+J>&)**+J>*+.0*132M#?¾*9(`&b@>&)*+&-(+#/±6>#%_#%(MH9*9(E&)*9#%C5&]e3#HErD:?##!(+#%$7rf&3:?#/,-#/.G*H+*9(E&)*9#%C3²3i 15.7r=²¦#?¾;*9#/.>H+#/:%#/:%13**91¦(E#/,-1]e3#¹&b(+#/:?1;@>&)a7rD# 13a;K9#/:?*a768*H9*9#/&3@A(+#/:?1@>#/H:?# *+H9*&3rDH+1‡aI#¹,-1@7#/@c&)C5&3(+#%2#%(*+J>#!(+#/:?1;@8#/@Ye3#%(EH+H *+J7&)*j&3.Š13a;K9#/:?*!*+J7&)*!15.>r=²¥J>&3H &Ž2d#%_ rD&/²3#%(EH!132@³&3,¦:EJ>&3.>@>(E&3.@>#%(EH9* aI# H+rf&)*9#/@g_,-#/@Z:?15.>H9*+&3.0*&3.>@¥:%&3.Z*+J8#%(+#%213(+#jaI# (E#/,-1]e3#/@zhjÍ2*+J8#-:%&3:EJ8#bJ7&3.>@>r=#/H&t,j67r=*+@8#j132@>#†e)&3rD68#†13G2 º # _1567rD@ªaI#t@>@g15.A*+J8#j:%rD#‡C315&3r132*+J>#/H9#†J>#/68(E#¥&3@>e3#%(+*+#%(E&)*9#/@Aa²t&-(+#/&3rz$>(E1/¾;²t&3.7@g_1567rD@t*+J8#/. &3:?*!a7&3H9#/@¥15.Š*+J8#-$'&)(E&3,-#%*9#%(EHC5#b&3,-156>.0*132@>&)*+&g$>(+1]¾;@-:?15.G*+&3H *·_1Z@7&/²;H _13(+*+Jµ132&3:%:?#/H+H9#/H/hgÍ*!HEJ8156>rD@¥aI#¦.813*9#/@ª*+J>&)*jHE:?#-*+J>(+1/¾;²J>&)*+6>(E&3rDr=²3i8&)$>$I#/&)(#!r=13C)»'r=#3h õh*+J8#%( J>@¹&3@caI#%#/.cHE&3.>H9#%(EH/h J8#b*9(E&3:?#†2(+15,äS15H9*915.³ .7H+#¦132*+J8#‡rD1]_ .6>,jaI#%(132MFGqB
H&)**9(`&3:?#3h T&)a7rD#©0hDlªH+J81–_Hg*+J8#.06>,jaI#%(g132j(E#/±068#/H+*+H%i*913*+&3r!.6>,jak#%(g132-,-#%C5&)a²*9#/H :?15.0*+&3:?#B&)*9*+&3(+#/@zh J8#/H9# .6>,jak#%(`H&)(+# $>(+#/H+#/.G*9#/@Ž°5œ uA …¹uY €c L›ª6 œ 09Ÿ/œ(° 2

> éGé p á £;Œ l á £h÷éG£3® TO  l/é p á p á $ é8hô®;l/p *+J8#%( éGé o á õ)Ð ¢ á £hDl/õ3® T&)a7rD#j©0hô£ …XZ&’¾;,çJ7a²*9#!J>@Ž@81–_.>r=15&3@g*+ACÀ°œ© ±KÁ?Ÿ] ¢«Ájžh±„º{œxŸj©?D ±„«fÄGœ ±„{¿ ¼½ŸED°¦$D

0/124345768-,l; 6/.436P8è=€å6P>@5u†

éG£

8(+15,Ç*+J>#Ž.06>,jaI#%(EH-rD15&3@µ*+#/H_#%(E#¦#/H9*+#‡&3:?*+6>&3rH9#%(+e;(+#/H9#/.0*(E#/H9#/.G*+H*+J8#&3,-156>.0*132 FGqB
H&3.>@YMH# *9(E&3:?#/H%h €˜–š7°5œ F  Ä vj‹†Ÿ¦—'ž F  Ä!v!‹tŸb—7ž F ‹ty%ƒŸb—7ž F ‹†y%ƒŸb—7ž ˜–œ æs“Tœ0Ÿ%”–Ÿ ¤IÀz”]œŸ ˜’}œ æs“TœŸ%”]Ÿ ¤IÀz”]œ0Ÿ

> l%Ð ¢ á l/ê m á ®3é m á õ3é £ á nO  £;Œ l á £3ê £ á õ3é m á l/é m á *+J8#%( l/é m á £3ê õ á ®3é m á £3é o á T&)a'r=#j©0hôõ …F5q
HCË&]e3#caI#%#/.¥:%rf6>@8#/@Ž.;­ @>#%(EH9*+&3.>@>#$I15H+H+@Y&bH9132*:%&3:`J>:?#Y132jH9132*t:%&3:EJ>C(+1/¾;²Î&3.>@¶:%rDH9#/@zh4J>#HE,b&3rDr=#/H9*_#%(+#15.g*+J8#13(E@8#%(132 ®bXYS¶_J7r=*@>H9#132k*+J>#H+,b&3rDr7&3,-156>.0*4132s,-#/,-13(+Ȳ X#,b&3:EJ7@5u†

éGõ

*+J>#†13$I#%(E&)*913(]iB&3.>@H+#/@213(¹*+J8# HE.813*:%&3:EJ>&3HaI#/:?15,-# H+*+&3.>@>&)(E@t$>(`&3:?*+1568(@>*+#b,b&3@>(E1@>67:?*+@>Cª15.Ë_J>rD@aI#‡&3@8e)&3.G*+&)C3#%1567H¹2d13(¹*+J8#†(+#/:?1;@>1Z_156>rD@‘.>13*-_&3.0*b*91µ_&3H9*9#Ž*+&3HBH+#/±068#/.7:?#/H4213(4*+J8# 13$7*+1]_Ë(+#/:?1@7&3HaI#%#/.A,-1;@>@>6>:?*&3.t#?¾;$I#%(E# .813(E,b&3rT8±06>@t.81

0/124345768-,l; 6/.436P8è=€å6P>@5u†

éGm

H9#/@Ya0²Ž(E#/:?1@>@8#%(&3.A#?¾8:?#/H+H+(+1)­ :?#/HEH+H+#¦&gH+,¹­ ,¦&)(E1]_ö*+J>#%²‡_#%(+#!:%rD&3HEH+°5œ xs›ªš7ÏLψjš>°)•nœŸ wš7˜–¨'œŠˆjš>°)•Tœ0Ÿ

> ®inl%¢;ik£)¢;ik£3® ®)¢;inl%¢3¢;iI£)¢3¢;i7é5¢3¢ nO  ®inl%¢;ik£3®ik®)¢ l%¢3¢;iI£)¢3¢;i7é5¢3¢;ikm)¢3¢;iIp)¢3¢ *+J8#%( ®inl%¢;ik£3®ik®)¢ m)¢3¢;ikp)¢3¢ &)a7r=#!phDfl …BT&)(+C3#j&3.>@gHE,b&3rDrz:%&3:EJ>#jH+,-#/.0*$I15rDHJ>1]_Ò&¹(+#/:?1;@8#/@g13a;K9#/:?*@ &)(E#‡$>(E#/H9#/.G*9#/@,b` . _µ(+#%2#%(EH*91†*+J8#¹H9#/:?15.>@Z:EJ815@‘phôõŠH+J>1]_ó*+J>&)*b°5œ ò ø

> ¢ p nO  £ m *+J>#%( ¢ p T13*+&3r £ £3£ &)a7r=#!phô®…#%2(+#/H+J>,-#/.0*$I15rD#/HcèLSê OC5&31568C5J*+J8#Ž nO ­Ø*9(E&3:?#ŽaI#/.8#?»7*+H¹,-13(+#g2(+15,Ã*+J8#Žrf#/r*+J>&3._r=*+H &)(+#†&3rD,-15H9*c õ õ3õ nO  l/m ¢ T13*+&3r l/o õ3õ T&)a'r=#!phôm…B#%2(+#/H+J7,-#/.G*$k15rf#/HcèL°5œ ò ø

> ¢ p nO  é é *+J>#%( ¢ p T13*+&3r é £)¢ T&)a7rD#!ph ©}…#%2(+#/H+J7,-#/.G*$I15rD*+$I15rD*9$k#%(E2d13(E,*+J8#.813(`,b&3r>$I15rDCAe3#%(EH+: ­ *+Hjr=15&3@*+:`JJ>&)(`@8#%(j*91Za>(EH+#¦_J8#/.³&3. 13a8K #/:?*:?#/@†*+J8#»7(EH9**+r=*+H&)(+#j#/H%i'#/H%i' èLT ê

m3o

0/124345768[ZÊ; 86ó†7Eƒ‚5u†

NLANR − Large caches, BHR (LRU)

1 0.95

BHR as percentage of maximum

0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 0.7 0.65

LRU LRU−SC LRU−SOFT OPT−HARD OPT−SOFT

0.6 0.55 0.5

100

200

300

400 500 Cache Size / MB

600

700

800

M&3r=2T@768#*91b(+#/:?1;@>H9# *+J>#%(+#b_&3Hj.813*!#/.81568C5Jª&]e’&3##?¾;$I#%(E&)*:?156>rD@†aI#(E6>.si@Š® m áÖC5&3@¥&)(+1567.>@ŠF ® áÖC5&3#jH+&)(`@-e3#%(EH+#13$>*+#†$7(+#%eHc#?¾$I#%(E*+r=*+H132B*+J>#‡*+J8#%(9­Ø*9(E&3:?#b&)(E#bH+#/H%i'S èLT ê

Other − Large caches, Time (LRU)

1

LRU LRU−SC LRU−SOFT OPT−HARD

Download time as percentage of maximum

0.95

0.9

0.85

0.8

0.75 550

600

650

700 Cache Size / MB

750

800

*9#%(]h r=*+H!15.³*+J8#‡(E#%2d(+#/HEJ>,-#/.0*!$I15rD@(+#/:?1;@>#ak#/H+*4H9*9(E&)*9#%C5@-& rD&)(+C3#.6>,jaI#%(V132k(E#/:?1@>@b*91¹²;@tr=*+H15.A*+J8#j nO ­Ø*9(E&3:?#c_:`JArD&)*9#%(/h J8#!13*+J>#%(*Í_1†*9(E&3:?#/H_J>:`JYJ7#?»7*+H 213(cH+132d*¹:%&3:EJ>*B&3rDH91 .>@8#/.7r=²b&¹H+,¦&3rDrk2d(E&3:?*+:?#¹13a;K #/:?* HE&)**+J8#-:%&3:`J8# :%&3.YJ815rD@g,-13(E#13a;K #/:?*+H/h OH†@>#@>#%2&36>rD*M:%&3:`J8#H+(+1–_H9#%(/i51*+J>@!#%e3#/.¹&)*_#%(+#B*+J8#:%&3H9#3i5,-15H+*T$I#%13$7r=# _156>rD@t$7(+13a7&)a7r=²†H9#%**+J8# :%&3:`J8#jHEH132,-#%C5&)a²*9#/H&)*,¦&’¾;,gh J8#b(+#/HE6>r=*+H 2(+15,ä*+J8#‡$7(+#%eH :EJ7&)$>*9#%(cHEJ81]_ iM*+J>&)*j2d13(¹&AHE,b&3rDrB:%&3:`J8#3i4rD@aI#Ž&3@8e)&3.0*+&)C3#%156>H¦*916>H9#ŽH9132*¦:%&3:EJ7@‘&³;@Ò*+J8#%(+­Ø*9(E&3:?#Š:?15,-#¥2d(+15,U$>(+1]¾;#/&)(†*+J>#Z6>H+#%(EH%i&3.>@ËrD@†H9#%#/,gi8&)*:%&3:EJ8#/H.>#/&)(+#%(*91¹67H9#%(EH H+#%#Y&ªHE

p;l

.¦*+J8#HEH+*+:?#b:?156>.0* 132B*+J>#-13a;K #/:?*%hbJ8#-:EJ815HEH9#/@†ak#/rD1]_ h hBJ&%

4 5¹Ý N

ÚVà Ý“

” ’£Mq’ãäàMåkàPMzæ

 .Z&†H+132d*:%&3:EJ>#%(+#c#!:%&3:EJ8#¹:?156>rD@A2d15rfr=1]_Ò*+J>#j&3rsH+*9(E6>:?*+68(+#!132V#/&3:EJY13a;K #/:?*%ika768**+J>rD@ :?15,b$7rDrf@bJ>&/e3#*91!aI# *9(E#/&)*9#/@Y@>(+#¦*91Y*+J8#‡(E#/&3r4$7J0²HE&3.>@>rD:?#Y132 aI13*+Jg132*+J8#!,b1@>@>H9#%($>(+#%2#%(+#/.>:?#/H213(@>

#/@76>:%&)*9#/@ªC56>#/H+Hj:?# :?1567.G*%i3@81#/Hn#B$>(E(E13a7&)a7(+*+J8#%(H9*+6>@>²3h

o





ì 

 

î

+qp

Q¼lSR¹hsS#%(E.8#%(EH9­·s#%#¦&3.>@ª"jhM15.>.815rDrD²3hsrutGív]SwUxyxSzs{BׄóU؃كô ØX|Êô~} ÕfÙL œ ó€ÕfÒþð ™ œ Õ ™ƒ Ø ‚„_†…4‡’ik 1–e3#/,!aI#%(cl/o3o3®h

Q÷£{R¹hBS#%(E.8#%(`H ­·s#%#3i!hBMC8i&3.>@Ð!h8(+²;H9*·²¬'hˆr~tèí‰]Š‹Œyz6{¥×„óUØHÙSô ؍|_ô Ù £ Ù @bqh15H+:`J8¬)&;hsqT#%(E2d13(E,¦&3.>:?##/.8C5CA@81;:%6>,-#/.0*+H 2(+15,þ*+J8#¦ ;Oj\^H _#%aH+#%(+e3#%(/h¦ . DÙRlò„Ø„ØfÑÓÒB™