Measuring and Modelling Data Quality for Quality ...

12 downloads 2615 Views 471KB Size Report
Performance and confidence guarantees Exploratory Data Mining - (EDM) [22] ...... ditions such as promotional and advertising campaigns undertaken, and the.
                         

           

   

                                                                                                            ! "  # $  ! %  ! "  #

 

                                    &                                             '(                      '(                          !              )**+ &        ,                   -  .     /                    



     

  0       #    ,                              1  !         1     )2*+ 3   )45+ 6  )78 89+     )2 :4 :9+   )77 ::+    );;+  , ):5+    )8+   );*+    6 )2;+   .   )27+      )*4 ;5+       )  #&0* -9  #$0* -  ?  @  #.$* -!  #(3* A #.%*     6 

  ! #3'*   :  8 : 7 622 #)% )3* -      9   6     4     

      A !   "      

    2   

     #)& &3*         5  

  5  #..* @   !       /  

      -

           2             ; !      "   

  8B    A !  

                              > .                        )**+ !  )     7   !  I@  )**+                               

*

     

             #                                    )79 ** 48+ ?                 %             1    -      ' (      /     -         .       /                             >             -     / &            0   -    .     /      1  !      ,        )      )4+                3                  A                    H                   C                        

                                   -

/  

%   !  &  '($

                 - /                  -   /                    )2*+                6

.

  

     

(#( 0 #    1 #2!!!$ !     # $ 

-  /                                               !                         !          %   )755+   );2+    )!2  $  = ?               , /          -       , /  !     ,      ,       !     ,                     !#                  !     ,           ,     -    / &  =*        !#                         !#                 

 =2                    1   

A B  C   B   B-   (  &D (&B" (&B E A B C=    B   B(  & (&B!0''' (&B E A B C    B F  BF (&B" (B E

   

 ,       ,                   =4                    - &  J ;/                          &  =:                                             

/

     

                                            -     /                       !0  6    0    0    ?  D!!   ,      !7  J :          -/              - / J             - / J    !*  !2  J :                   >                         &                                        A        1 # '  0 5.  '''

   -0  ''' 5. '' '''

 

'' '''

6/. 0 '''   ,#6/ ; @ ''G 5.

4 '''

   @ C & ''- = ''- 2= ''- .9= ''-

= ''- C= ''0=

       '     75  7:            2555  ;555   255555  ;55555 G         :555  9555        (                                        ,    0     1             - /                 ,             - /        H        6        & 0     E                  $               $                             E                                                        

    !   " 

 # $

.

 ,       0 >    '  (    )75+                                                              ,               

! " 

                                                                      D!!              >                                      -       /                    Æ      Æ                     ,   ,                  

# .@ $"    4 0 " A B.--%C # $ 

!  !   )"  !

 $ )  @ (!@ ! 2 .--% #  9#5 ! @ @

/+D.* E 2 $!   @

 @ 2 0  $ F #2!   !!      :! G

9 B//'C  !     !   (!

! $ 02! $2  # $    ! #    !    @  

$

 ! !

  !  ! ! $ $ # " ! A6 9  ! A"!4  //'@ %@   24 2   2 2   9  H B//C    $  GG   

"2!  @ (!@ !

2 ,2

@ ! @ ! H $   

BHC @ ',*D'-+ F! $:! $ 2 @ &@      !GG ( #

 ( B//&C  !  ! ! 2     5  G ! (!)@ (!@ ! 2 @   E!42! !    ! !    B C @ &-D*%  $  @ '@ ! ( (G F B.--'C 

$ $

! !   ! 5  G 2

 0  

0!;@ ! !    2 *B.C@



     

*@ ! ( (G F B//C #! $ ! 

H !

  0 !;

! ! 

! ! 6 @

 0  ! ! : !"$  

  $  $ B0:C .'B.CI&/D&%@ +@    0   ! # B//&C    !    



!!  ! !   @ 0 !      2 % @ ! @ ! !   #! $ BC 2 $2  2 @ ,@ 6  2  ( 2 2 0 B//%C  ! ! ! #2!

! !  4$@ (!@ !

  !4 $

#  9:1/% E!4 2! ! 

 $ !  4$   5)J ! !  !  @ +D- E 2 $!   @ -@  J! 5 9 #!  F   E ! > B//'C "!! 2I  9   !2 !     !  ! @ 02@ @  ! )  9! @

 ./@     B//*C     " 

I      ! ! 5  

!  !   # $ : !"@ @  @  $H$ ! ! @ ..@   4! # #!!  > B//%C       !

$  )  $     #  @ (!@ ! 2 -2 #  9: ! @ ! : !"$  !    # $ B:C @ %-D&, E 2 $!   @ .@ ! G$2! ) # ( H B//&C  "!4 !  

!   2 

@ (!@ ! 2 .  #  9#5 E!4 2! ! ! !    !  !   B  C @ '-*+ (   @ .%@  $ # : $ F A$    > B///C 5I    $ 

  ! 5   @ (!@ !

/// #  9#5 ! @ @ -%D./&   0K

 # .*D.,@ .&@ !  # B.-,/C     ! !   @ ! !   #  $  %I&'D',@ .'@  2 # !2" 4  E 4  9!)$  B//%C  #4I   $ $ ! !6  ! #2 $@ (!@ ! 2 ,2 @ ! @ ! ! !    B C # 0 ) $ @ .*@  !  B//C  " 2   ! @ #  "@ .+@  !  !2 " # 9 2  4 9 #

 ( B///C 0! 1

)  !    !        

0!!@ (!@ ! 2 *2 @ ! @ ! H $    BHC @ *.'D*.,  ! $ ) ./D.&@ .,@ 4! > #!  > B.--'C ! 1 E2!    @  ! @ &.B.,C@ .-@ 2 2   9 J : 9  H #!"  B//%C !)    Æ    GG #2 ! 5     $@ (!@ ! 2 //% #  9#5 @ ! @ ! # $  !  @ %.%D%&   $!  @ /@ 2  ( 2 2 0 F$  # B//&C )   ( 5 !    4$  I 2I LL $@ @ @ L 4$@2@ (!@ ! 2 ,2 ( 3 

 ! @ !   : !"$  !    # $ B(:C @ *%,D*&+      # *D,@ .@  M E ! > B//.C  $ 0 $ ! 9   E2!  0  ! ! @ (!@ ! 2 +2 @ ! @ ! H $    BHC @ &+.D&,/ !  ) ..D.&@ @  0 >!2 ! 0 B//%C 6!!  # $     $@ E  A" M!4@ %@  0 >!2 ! 0 # 2 4 2   24  4 H B//C # $ )     ! F!" !        !" @ (!@ ! 2 // #  9#5 @ ! @ ! # $  !  @ &/'. # !  E  @

    !   " 

 # $

%

&@  9 !! 9 )!   G # !   B//&C 04 $ !

    

$ ! 2! $2 !  (   @ (!@ !

2 .  #

 9#5 E!4 2! ! ! !    ! !   B  C @ +D%& (   @ '@  9  J  ) J  B.--C 02  3 !   $  $   #   !

! !     @ >!   ! ! "   .+I/'D.+@

*@   (   A#  )  B.-++C #6    4 2!! ! !     2 # $! 2@ >!   !

2 !    ! 

%-I.D%,@ +@ J)  B//%C 

!  !   !     @  0  !

! : !"$     $  $ B0:C .'B.CI..,D.%'@ ,@  #! 2 E H! 4  >!2 ! 0 !G  ($ )!  B.---C   2

$    @ (!@ !

2 '2 #  9: ! @ ! : !"$

 !    # $ B:C @ *D.*   $!  @ -@  4 #9 H4 ! H $  : B//C 0 !I  !  4$ 0!!)!6@ (!@ ! 2 .-2

@ ! @ !   $  $ B C @ .D,

 >!   @ %/@  $ 2  B.--,C ! $  E2!    



! !   @ E  A" M!4@ %.@  :  F # 4  2 $  B//.C  ! $   !   $ H  ! N  ! A    $ ! @ ! !    *B,CI%'D*'*@ %@ $

(    B.-*-C  02!

! !  4$@ >!   !

2

     

!  !  *&I..,%D../@ %%@ !6      0 B.--&C 02 A! ! !          

!  ! ! (!

$   # $  %/B.C@ %&@ 92 F !   2 2   !     B//.C     $I  $ $ #!   $! 2 @ (!@ !

2 -2

@ ! @ !

H $    BHC @ %+.D%,/ ! @ %'@ 9!!2  # > !  @ B @ B.--,C     9!$2  !  ! I ! ! !   FO  @ %*@ 9 ! 

 ! (9 :!  A     B//%C 06 >! 

# ! E) 

$ ! @ (!@ ! 2 .2

@ E! E  E)

! @ BEEEC @ -/D./.    F $@ %+@ 9 !   ! (9 >$ 2 FH :!  A # 2 4 2   (        B//.C

$ $  #

! !6   $

(!

$@

   $  $    !@ & !@ & )@  %,@ 9    #  9  $  ! 5        #!

!  B//'C $ $   E2!

$   9  6

!      !   !  9E@ (!@ ! 2  

@ E!4 2! ! 

$ ! 2      B C   $!  @ %-@ F $ E B.-'/C ! $   !! $ ! @    02  >!   -BCI.&+.*/@ &/@ F  G # ! !  B.--,C "!   I  

$   2 #$L( $ (!)@  # $   : !"$  ! B.CI-D%+@ &.@ F! E P2 $ P B.--'C  2  $ )  ! 

I      !2@ (!@ ! 2 .--' #  9#5 @ ! @ ! # $  !   >!   @ &@ F  $ :  M E $  B.---C    ! !   : !"$ # $  @ (   F A" > @

&

     

&%@ >4 # >  #@   6  H

  ( B.--,C 2       

 E2!  @ (!@ !

2 ./2

@ ! @ !  

! !

   $  $ B C @ -%D..% (  @ &&@ >  #  6  >4 # B.--,C 

$    

!     ! !  E2!  @ (!@ ! .+2

!

@ ! @ !   #! $

BC @ %&-D%*  $!@ &'@ >!2 ! 0  0 B.--,C ! $ #

 F $2 

!    @ (!@ ! 2 &2 @ ! @ : @ -D%% A" M!4   A" M!4 @ &*@ :2  ! $  E $  B//C

! !     24I (! 

    ( ! @ !@ ! 2 # &'B&CI.,&D.-@ &+@ : !  A$  B.--,C $! 2 ! # $     5   $   @ (!@ ! 2 &2

@ ! @ ! H $    BHC @

%-D&/% A" M!4   @ &,@ Q  A 2 ( P   B.---C     ! #  I   $ H "@ (!@ ! 2 @ E!4 2! !

   !$  (!$ $ B (C @

.+&D.,'  ! @ &-@   9    H B.--/C     ! !I 02!   ($  @ #@ 44@ '/@       > ()24   2 ! > B.--%C      3 ! )  $ ! @ (!@ ! 2 -2 @ ! @ !   $  $ B C @ -&D%/. H     @ '.@   >  )  B.-,+C     

" 2 #

$ @ E  A"M!4@ '@   2  B//C !  !     @ (!@ ! 2 +2 @ ! @ ! ! !    B C # 0 ) $ @ '%@ ! 2  B//.C    : !"$ # $ I 02      !2@ #!$ :  @ '&@ !" E  #  $ 0E B//.C  : !"$  !2 !       !   $@ ! !   *B,C@ ''@ #   A $ : $ F B///C Æ     $ !

F $2

 

!    " 2   ! !    #2 $@ (!@ ! 2 *2 #  9: ! @ ! : !"$  !    # $ B:C @ .*-D.+, ! !  # @ '*@ # 2  9  2   H  # B///C

$    !  # ! !   !    4 $@ (!@ !

2 %

@ E) E!4 2! @

-%D-,   0K @ '+@ #

 (   B//%C  #   

!  #! ! ! !     @ (!@ ! 2 ,2 @ ! @ ! ! !    B C # 0 ) $ # @ ',@ #! $  B///C #2 $ $! 2 E 2      !  @    $@  @ %B&CI.&D/@ '-@ #  F    $ > B//&C # $

! ( !  !

@ (!@ ! 2 .  #  9#5 E!4 2! !

! !   

! !   B  C ! J  ! " 2 # (5L 9#5 @ '.D ', (   @ */@ A      $ > B.---C     $ ! ! F! $ ! ! !   @ (!@ ! 2 '2 @ ! @ ! H $    BHC @ &&+&',  ) $2 ! @ *.@ A   B//C        " $ ! $ ! !   @ A *.  $@

    !   " 

 # $

'

*@ A! 9 B//.C  9  0!  ! !6   $ #2 $@ # !      %%B.CI%.D,,@ *%@ A"!) F :  ># 6 ! > > ( B.-'-C  !   4$ ! H  ! @    .%/ @ -'&D-'-@ *&@ 5! G  5  4  B.---C  ! $ 

!  !     ! $ !  @     $   )  ! @ B1--C @ %,D&-@ *'@ (      E B.--.C  #      # $  $   !  5  #2!!!$@ >!   !

! !    'B.CI&,D

**@ **@ (  F #2  # 2  

  2  

B//%C     

    ! #2 $@ (!@ ! 2 @ ! @   A  ! ! (!

$   BA (C @ .&/.D.&/, H !    2 !!) @ *+@ ( ! : B//C  # $  !

!    

!

! @ (!@ !  # @ ! @  # $@ *,@ (  ( B//C  # $ ! #   @ A '',  $@ *-@ (  # 9 ! # !  (!!   G  B///C )    @ 2 .&I   )  02 !!$   

$ @ 2 F!  @ &,'D'/-@ +/@ (  # !  9 ! # B @C B//C ! !   )   

@ 02 : "   !    !   )     '@ +.@ (  B.---C  ( ! !  # $@ #!$ :  @ +@  

 4 ( B//%C !  4$ ! 9 !$  )  @ (!@ ! #  9:1/% E!4 2! !   $ !  4$   5)J ! !  !  @ &/D& E 2 $!   @ +%@ 2  ! F B///C   $I (!)      !2 @    $@  @ %B&CI%D.%@ +&@  H F  ># B//.C (!1 E2I      $  @ (!@ ! 2 *2

@ ! @ ! H $    BHC @

%,.D%-/ ! @ +'@  0 B//.C    I 02   9 @  $  (

   @ +*@ !2 )$ > B.--*C # !  !       ! $ @ (!@ ! 2 .   # ! @ ++@      ! #  0 B//%C 0  $     !!   ! !   @ (!@ ! 2 @ ! @ ! !!  ! !   B!! C @ %'&D%*-      @ +,@   ! # (   (   B//&C ( #I  #2!!!$ !    !    ! (#(   #@   # $  !  !    ! !    #! !$2 B#  C 2@ +-@ 2  > B.--+C  

!

! #    @ 2 R F@

,/@ 2  > B.--.C  $   !   24 $ )  @ (!@ !  E!4 2! ! : !"$  ! )  @ ,.@ 22  E!!  : 2 H B.--%C I

$    )  02 !!$ ! !    @ (!@ !

@ E!4 2! ! (!$ $ " 2

!$  )  B (C @ %D'*@ ,@   

 H

  (  0: B//'C 5  G $ 0 (!

  E2!  @ (!@ !

2 ..2

@ ! @ !   $  $ B C @

'*&D'+' 0!4! > @ ,%@ :4

  H

  ( ( !   0    !    E 2!

$@ (!@ ! 2   #  9#5 E!4 2! !

! !   

     

*

! !   B  C ! J  ! " 2 # (5L 9#5 @ ,D%-  ! # @ ,&@ 2 4  9 E $ M P  # B///C #! $ 2 #   !  ! ! (!  " 2 (#(@ (!@ ! 2 *2 @ ! @ ! ! !    ! !  # @ ,'@ 0 9: ! ( B.--,C 6 $    @ !@ !

2 #

&.BCI'&D'+@ ,*@ 0 (A :  H    > B//C  $ 2  $2 #  ! 

!  ! ( @ (!@ !

  $ 

2 ,2 #  9: ! @ !

: !"$  !    # $ B:C @ %D&. ! !   @ ,+@ 0J  : !)!4  # !  B//.C  $ 5)J   3 !  

! ! ! $ ! @ ! !    *B,C@ ,,@ 02!!!  ! G$2! ) # B//.C          ! 2 

$ !   E2! @  

 ! 

$   # $  !

 E2!   @ >!   ! !!  @  @ ./B%CI--D%*@ ,-@  > B.--+C  )  A$ 2  

!  !  ! ! !

)    !   !   !     ! "! @ 02 !  >!   /BCI.&.D.&+@ -/@ H

  ( ! G$2! ) #  6  B.---C 0!"   5    E2!  $   !  ! @ (!@ !

2 ..2

@ ! @ !  

! !    $  $ B C @ .*&D.+- F )$ 9 @ -.@ H

  ( H$  P 4 !! !  :  A B///C :05I  0!! !   $   0 ! !  E2!    !   @    $@  @ %B&CI&D&+@ -@ H

  (   

 9!$  ( 0!  # B//%C  "!4 ! 2 

$ ! 0   ! @ (!@ ! 2 .'2 @ ! @ !   !  !    $  $ B C @ '/D'%' :$    @ -%@ H

  ( B///C  E2!  #! $     

 @ (2 2

 02  

 ! 2  9@ -&@ E $  :! F # 4  B.--%C         

  #! $@ (!@ !

2 -2

@ ! @ !   $  $ B C @

*+/D*++ H     @ -'@ E $  ! H  2  B.--'C  "!4 !  

!      2@

 0  ! ! : !"$     $  $ B0:C

+B&CI*+/D*++@ -*@ E $  B.--,C  (!  (   ! 0!     # $ @ !@ ! 2 # &.BCI',D*'@ -+@ E $  B//C >!   !    @ H!@ % !

  ) 

   : "   (

 ! !  # @ -,@ E # A   B//&C  $    5)J K# !   @ (!@ !

2 . 

@ #  9#5 E!4 2! !

! !   

! !   B  C ! J  ! " 2 # (5L 9#5 @ ./D.- (   @ --@ E 4 E 02 )  M B.--.C    ! ! 2 $   #! !

!  4$ ! 2 .--/ @@    @     2

!   -.L/- @@   ! 2   E 2 $!   @ .//@ E 4 E B//&C #2! !   $    $    @ !  !    -B+C@

    !   " 

 # $ ./.@ PS

  5 F > P2 F B///C # $   

+

 #    " 2

(!$

  !  ! 3  @ (!@ ! 2 .*2

@ ! @ !   

$  $ B C @&*.D&+*   $!  @ ./@ P2 M 2 2  B//C I    #! ! $ ! 02!   !    0 @ (!@ ! 2 ./2 @ ! @ ! H $    BHC @ %',D%*- F! $:! $ 2 @