Personal pdf file for
Andrea Dall’Asta, Noortje van Oostrum, Sheikh Nigel Basheer, Gowrishankar Paramasivam, Tullio Ghi, Letizia Galli, Irene AL Groenenberg, Amanda Tangi, Patrizia Accorsi, Monica Echevarria, et al. With compliments of Georg Thieme Verlag
www.thieme.de
Etiology and Prognosis of Severe Ventriculomegaly Diagnosed at Late Gestation
DOI http://dx.doi.org/10.1055/a0627-7173 For personal use only. No commercial use, no depositing in repositories.
Publisher and Copyright © 2018 by Georg Thieme Verlag KG Rüdigerstraße 14 70469 Stuttgart ISSN 0172-4614 Reprint with the permission by the publisher only
Original Article
b
Etiology and Prognosis of Severe Ventriculomegaly Diagnosed at Late Gestation
Ätiologie und Prognose einer schweren Ventrikulomegalie bei Diagnose in der Spätschwangerschaft
Authors Andrea Dall’Asta1, 2, Noortje HM van Oostrum3, Sheikh Nigel Basheer1, 4, Gowrishankar Paramasivam1, Tullio Ghi2, Letizia Galli2, Irene AL Groenenberg3, Amanda Tangi5, Patrizia Accorsi6, Monica Echevarria7, Maria Angeles Rodríguez Perez7, Gerard Albaiges Baiget7, Federico Prefumo5, Tiziana Frusca2, Attie TJI Go3, Christoph C Lees1, 8, 9
Affiliations 1 Centre for Fetal Care, Queen Charlotte’s and Chelsea Hospital, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London, United Kingdom 2 Obstetrics and Gynaecology Unit, University of Parma, Parma, Italy 3 Department of Obstetrics, Gynaecology and Prenatal Diagnosis, Erasmus Medical Centre, Rotterdam, the Netherlands 4 Department of Paediatrics and Neonatal Medicine, Hammersmith Hospital, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, London, United Kingdom 5 Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, University of Brescia, Brescia, Italy 6 Department of Child Neurology and Psychiatry, ASST Spedali Civili, Brescia, Italy 7 Fetal Medicine Section, Department of Obstetrics, Gynecology and Reproductive Medicine, University Hospital Quiron Dexeus, Barcelona, Spain 8 Department of Surgery and Cancer, Imperial College London, United Kingdom 9 Department of Development and Regeneration, KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium Key words fetal neurosonography, central nervous system, antenatal ultrasound, third-trimester scan received 11.09.2017 accepted 16.04.2018
Bibliography DOI https://doi.org/10.1055/a-0627-7173 Published online: July 5, 2018 Ultraschall in Med © Georg Thieme Verlag KG, Stuttgart · New York ISSN 0172-4614
Correspondence Dr Christoph C. Lees, MD, MRCOG Centre for Fetal Care, Queen Charlotte’s and Chelsea Hospital, Imperial College Healthcare NHS Trust, Du Cane Road, London, W12 0HS, United Kingdom
[email protected]
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
ABSTR AC T
Objectives We sought to assess the causes and outcomes of
severe VM diagnosed de novo after 24 weeks of gestation where a mid-trimester anomaly scan was described as normal. Methods Multicenter retrospective study of five European fetal medicine centers. The inclusion criteria were normal anatomy at the mid-trimester scan, uni/bilateral finding of posterior ventricle measuring ≥ 15 mm after 24 weeks with neonatal and postnatal pediatric and/or neurological assessment data. Results Of 74 potentially eligible cases, 10 underwent termination, the outcome was missing in 19 cases and there was 1 neonatal death. Therefore, 44 formed the study cohort with a median gestation at diagnosis of 32 + 0 weeks (25 + 6 – 40 + 5). VM was unilateral in five cases. Agenesis of the corpus callosum (ACC) and grade III/IV intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) accounted for 14 cases each. ACC was isolated in 9 fetuses. Obstructive abnormalities included 5 arachnoid and 1 cavum velum interpositum cyst. Four fetuses had an associated suspected or confirmed genetic condition, 2 congenital infections, 1 abnormal cortical development and the etiology was unknown in 3/44. Postnatal assessment at median 20 months (3 – 96) showed 22/44 (50 %) normal, 7 (16 %) mildly abnormal and 15 (34 %) severely abnormal neurodevelopmental outcomes. Conclusion One half of babies with severe VM diagnosed after 24 weeks have normal infant outcome with ACC and IVH representing the most common causes. Etiology is the most important factor affecting the prognosis of fetuses with severe VM diagnosed at late gestation. Z US A M M E N FA SS U N G
Ziel Bestimmung der Ursachen und Folgen einer schweren Ventrikulomegalie (VM) mit de-novo Diagnose nach 24 Schwangerschaftswochen (SSW) bei unauffälligem Basisultraschall im 2. Trimenon. Methoden Multizentrische retrospektive Studie in 5 europäischen Pränatalzentren. Die Einschlusskriterien waren eine normale Fetoanatomie beim Screening im 2. Trimenon, ein nach der 24. SSW auftretender uni-/bilateraler Befund im Hinterhorn von > 15 mm sowie neonatale und postnatale pädiatrische und / oder neurologische Befunde.
Original Article
b
Ergebnisse Von 74 potentiell geeigneten Fällen wurde bei 10
die Schwangerschaft beendet, in 19 Fällen fehlte der Ausgang und in einem Fall verstarb das Neugeborene. Folglich bildeten 44 Fälle die Studienkohorte, die bei Diagnosestellung eine mediane SSW von 32 + 0 (25 + 6 bis 40 + 5) aufwies. In 5 Fällen war die VM einseitig. Eine Agenesie des Corpus Callosum (ACC) sowie eine intraventrikuläre Hämorrhagie (IVH) Grad III / IV bestand bei jeweils 14 Fällen. Eine isolierte ACC wurde bei 9 Feten festgestellt. Zu den obstruktiven Anomalien gehörten 5 arachnoidale Zysten und 1 Zyste des Cavum velum interpositum. Bei vier Feten war dies mit einer vermuteten oder bestätigten Erbkrankheit assoziiert, zwei hatten kongenitale
Introduction
Fetal cerebral ventriculomegaly (VM) is defined by the enlargement of the posterior horns (atria) of the lateral ventricles and accounts for approximately 0.1 – 1 % of all antenatally detected abnormalities [1]. VM has been considered a sign of abnormal development of the fetal central nervous system (CNS), but its prognosis varies depending upon the underlying condition, including structural and obstructive pathologies, infections, intracranial bleeding and genetic syndromes [2]. Severe VM is defined by measurement of the posterior horns of the lateral ventricles at or above 15 mm. This is reported to be suggestive of major brain abnormalities, associated with a high likelihood of progression of the ventricular enlargement and coexistence of additional CNS structural abnormalities [3]. In the largest reported case series of antenatally diagnosed severe VM, approximately 45 % had additional abnormalities [4] with higher proportions reported in other cohorts [3, 5, 6]. Although limited data are available regarding postnatal outcomes in survivors, very poor neurodevelopmental and motor prognosis and a high risk of neonatal death is reported even in cases where the severe VM is isolated. As a consequence, a high rate of termination of pregnancy (TOP) has been associated with the antenatal diagnosis of severe VM [4, 7, 8]. However, in most studies fetal outcomes have been aggregated irrespective of gestational age at diagnosis, which is usually performed at the second-trimester anomaly scan [3 – 5]. For this study we collected the data of a predefined cohort of fetuses diagnosed with severe VM after 24 weeks and with known postnatal follow-up aiming to evaluate whether late gestational age at the time of VM detection may influence the prognosis and to investigate outcomes where severe VM is detected after a midtrimester scan was described as normal.
Methods
This was a retrospective multicenter study involving five tertiary referral centers in Europe (Queen Charlotte’s and Chelsea Hospital, London, United Kingdom; University Hospitals of Parma and Brescia, Italy; Erasmus Medical Centre, Rotterdam, the Netherlands; University Hospital Quiron Dexeus, Barcelona, Spain). Since
Infektionen, bei einem lag eine abnormale Entwicklung des Cortex vor und in 3/44 Fällen war die Ätiologie nicht bekannt. Die postnatale Bewertung nach median 20 Monaten (3 – 96) ergab bei 22/44 (50 %) eine normale, in 7 (16 %) eine leicht auffällige und in 15 (34 %) schwer auffällige neurologische Entwicklung. Schlussfolgerung Die Hälfte der Babys mit einer nach 24 SSW diagnostizierten schweren VM hatte ein normales pädiatrisches Outcome, wobei ACC und IVH die häufigsten Ursachen waren. Die Ätiologie ist der wichtigste Einflussfaktor auf die Prognose von Feten mit Diagnose einer schweren VM in der Spätschwangerschaft.
2007 in all of these countries, a mid-trimester anomaly scan has been routinely offered to all pregnant women in accordance with national screening programmes. Cases of severe VM were identified by searching fetal medicine databases (Astraia GmbH, Munich, Germany), Viewpoint (GE Healthcare GmbH, Solingen, Germany) and a non-proprietary Electronic Database for the terms VM and hydrocephalus. Obstetric notes and scan reports and images were then reviewed. The criteria for inclusion of cases were a routine mid-trimester anomaly scan with normal findings performed according to relevant national or international standards [9 – 13] before 24 weeks and ultrasound (US) findings of either unilateral or bilateral severe VM, defined by measurement of the posterior horn of the lateral ventricle of 15 mm or greater on a standard transventricular axial plane as described by Cardoza et al. [14] at or after 24 weeks of gestation. We excluded cases in which an additional major structural anomaly which should have been diagnosed according to the National and/or International Guidelines, such as spina bifida or encephalocele, was identified at the time of the diagnosis of severe VM. In all cases full US overview of the fetal anatomy was performed, including two-dimensional neurosonography with or without three-dimensional mutiplanar imaging, and the diagnosis of severe VM was made or confirmed by fetal medicine experts from the centers involved in the study. Once severe VM was confirmed, detailed US inspection of the fetus for other structural anomalies was also performed. Additional investigations such as karyotype, SNP-array or CGH-array, “TORCH” (Toxoplasma, Rubella, Cytomegalovirus (CMV) and Parvovirus B19) and, where hemorrhage was noted, feto-neonatal alloimmune thrombocytopenia (FNAIT) screen were undertaken. We defined the severity of intraventricular hemorrhage (IVH) based on the classification proposed by Volpe [15]. In all cases the option of karyotyping or array testing was discussed antenatally and performed either antenatally or postnatally. COL4A1/2 testing was not performed antenatally but only postnatally at the discretion of the physician in cases of suspected IVH. In all cases the option of fetal magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) was discussed antenatally and performed either antenatally or postnatally in all surviving children.
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
b
Collected antenatal data included information on antenatal US findings, gestational age at diagnosis, width of the largest ventricle and mean ventricular width, laterality of the severe VM (unilateral vs. bilateral), MRI findings, results of the additional tests performed and delivery outcomes. Hydrocephalus was defined as VM and head circumference measurement on or above the 95th percentile for gestation. Details of the perinatal and postnatal outcome and subsequent follow-up were obtained and included US or MRI imaging, need for further treatment (ventriculo-peritoneal shunting or other surgery), final diagnosis and age of the children up to November 30, 2016. TOP after 24 weeks is legally precluded in Italy (L. 22 Maggio 1978, n. 194), permitted under specified circumstances in the United Kingdom (Clause E [Section l (l)(d)] of the 1967 UK Abortion Act, on the basis of “a substantial risk of severe handicap” if the babies were to be born alive) and in Spain (Ley Orgánica 2/ 2010, de salud sexual y reproductiva y de la interrupción voluntaria del embarazo), only on the basis of severe malformations incompatible with life or with expected severe sequelae, while in the Netherlands (Wet Afbreking Zwangerschap) TOP can only be performed on the basis of severe malformations incompatible with life after consultation. Surviving infants were referred to pediatric neurology clinics for further follow-up and outcomes were collected to the latest examination. No common neurodevelopmental scoring system was used. Neurodevelopmental outcome was defined as normal, mildly abnormal and severely abnormal. Mildly abnormal outcome comprised conditions not impacting the motor, mental and cognitive functions such as visual impairment, muscular stiffness or reduced tone, mild cerebral palsy or motor asymmetry, whereas severely abnormal outcomes included any condition where mental or motor dysfunction was impacting ability such as motor or developmental delay and cerebral palsy. All cases with unknown outcome were excluded from the analysis. Due to the design of this retrospective study and the inclusion of fully anonymized clinical data where no intervention was undertaken, it did not fulfill the criteria for requiring ethical committee consideration in any centers. Statistical analysis was performed using Statistical Package for Social Sciences (SPSS) v. 19.0 (IBM Inc., Armonk, NY, USA). Data were shown as median (range) or as number (percentage). The Chi-square test was used to compare categorical variables and p-values < 0.05 were considered statistically significant. This case series was reported according to the Strengthening the Reporting of Observational Studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) guidelines [16].
Results
Over the study period, 74 cases were identified with severe VM first diagnosed after 24 weeks. Among these, 10 underwent termination of pregnancy due to suspected genetic syndrome (1 case), grade 3 IVH (3 cases), grade 4 IVH (3 cases), agenesis of the corpus callosum (ACC) (2 cases) and severe fetal anemia secondary to anti-D antibodies (1 case). Postmortem examination was performed in all of these fetuses and in all cases the antenatal diagnosis was confirmed. Of live-born fetuses, 1 died neonatally
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
▶ Fig. 1 Flow chart (according to STROBE guidelines) [16] for inclusion of cases. TOP: termination of pregnancy; NND: neonatal death. *Mildly abnormal outcome included conditions not impacting motor, mental and cognitive functions such as visual impairment, muscular stiffness or reduced tone, mild cerebral palsy or motor asymmetry. #Severely abnormal outcomes included any condition in which mental or motor dysfunction was impacting ability such as motor or developmental delay, and cerebral palsy.
(IVH secondary to COL4A1/2 mutation – HANAC Syndrome) and 19 infants had an unknown outcome, leaving 44 fetuses eligible for analysis (▶ Fig. 1). The antenatal characteristics of the included cases are summarized in ▶ Table 1. Severe VM was diagnosed at a median gestational age of 32 + 0 weeks (25 + 6 –40 + 5 ). At diagnosis, the mean width of the wider ventricle was 22.6 + 7.9 mm. Severe VM was bilateral in 39 fetuses and progressive in 20 out of the 39 fetuses who had at least two serial scans (51.3 %), while hydrocephalus was concomitant in 15 cases. Male gender was recorded in 26 of the 44 included cases (60.5 %).
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
case N
gestation at diagnosis of severe VM
Vp worst
Vp mean
progressive ventricular enlargement
hydrocephalus
antenatal US/MRI diagnosis
final postnatal diagnosis
case 1
33 + 4
22
17
Y
N
ACC, bilateral severe VM with colpocephaly
ACC
case 2
33 + 2
18
15
1 scan
N
ACC, bilateral severe VM
ACC
case 3
33 + 6
18
18
N
N
ACC, bilateral severe VM with colpocephaly
ACC
case 4
40 + 5
49
48
1 scan
Y
bilateral severe VM with hydrocephalus, posterior fossa cyst, distal aqueduct stenosis, hydrocephalus
congenital posterior fossa cyst with aqueduct stenosis and hydrocephalus
case 5
33 + 2
15
15
N
N
ACC, bilateral severe VM with colpocephaly
ACC
case 6
35 + 3
20
16.5
N
N
ACC, interhemispheric cyst
ACC, interhemispheric cyst
case 7
34 + 0
22
21
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM with hydrocephalus, dilated 3 rd ventricle, cavum velum interpositum cyst
cavum velum interpositum cyst
case 8
34 + 2
30
28
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM with hydrocephalus, grade IV IVH and ventriculitis
grade IV IVH and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus
case 9
25 + 6
18
13.7
N
N
left unilateral severe ventriculomegaly of unknown cause
unilateral severe VM, unknown etiology
case 10
36 + 6
15.8
12.4
Y
N
left unilateral severe VM, right unilateral moderate VM
unilateral severe VM, unknown etiology
case 11
29 + 1
16
15
Y
N
right unilateral severe VM, grade 3 IVH with ventriculitis
grade III IVH
case 12
37
21
19
1 scan
N
bilateral severe VM with enlarged 3 rd ventricle, grade III IVH
bilateral severe VM, grade III IVH
case 13
38 + 6
31.9
–
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM with progressive hydrocephalus secondary to Grade IV IVH
grade IV IVH and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus
case 14
35 + 4
36
29.5
Y
Y
grade IV IVH, porencephalic cyst
grade IV IVH and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus, porencephalic cyst
case 15
36 + 3
20
18.5
Y
N
bilateral severe VM, ACC, IUGR
ACC
case 16
32 + 4
17.7
–
Y
N
bilateral severe VM, ACC
ACC, 17q21.31 microdeletion (Koolen-de Vries syndrome)
case 17
35 + 1
27.7
28.3
1 scan
N
bilateral severe VM, ACC
ACC, porencephalic cyst
case 18
31 + 0
24.5
23.9
Y
N
bilateral severe VM, dilated 3 rd ventricle, suspected aqueductal stenosis
grade III IVH
case 19
31 + 2
17.7
17.5
N
N
bilateral severe VM, ACC
bilateral severe VM, ACC, Pierre-Robin sequence, suspected genetic etiology but testing declined by the parents
Original Article
▶ Table 1 Features of the included cases: antenatal findings and final postnatal diagnosis.
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
▶ Table 1 case N
gestation at diagnosis of severe VM
Vp worst
Vp mean
progressive ventricular enlargement
hydrocephalus
antenatal US/MRI diagnosis
final postnatal diagnosis
case 20
35 + 6
45
40
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, hydrocephalus, congenital toxoplasmosis
congenital toxoplasmosis
case 21
31 + 5
21.5
20.7
1 scan
N
bilateral severe VM; partial ACC
partial ACC
case 22
31 + 6
17.7
16.8
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, ACC, hydrocephalus
bilateral severe VM, ACC, hydrocephalus
case 23
31 + 3
15.3
15.1
N
N
right unilateral severe VM, left unilateral moderate VM, ACC
bilateral VM, ACC, dysmorphic features, Mowat-Wilson Syndrome
case 24
34 + 3
17
17
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, posterior fossa arachnoid cyst
bilateral VM, posterior fossa arachnoid cyst, hypoplastic cerebellum
case 25
30 + 6
28
23.5
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, dilated 3 rd ventricle, ventriculitis, grade III IVH
bilateral IVH and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus
case 26
37 + 5
36
–
Y
Y
aqueduct stenosis of unknown cause, hydrocephalus
aqueduct stenosis secondary to IVH, and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus
case 27
31 + 1
31
29.5
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, dilated 3 rd ventricle, ACC, hydrocephalus, grade III/IV IVH grade
grade IV IVH, confirmed COL4A1 mutation
case 28
39 + 0
18
16.5
N
Y
bilateral severe VM, posterior fossa arachnoid cyst
posterior fossa arachnoid cyst
case 29
29 + 4
32
32
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, arachnoid cyst, non-communicating hydrocephalus
Arachnoid cyst
case 30
32 + 6
22
20
N
N
bilateral severe VM, grade III IVH
grade III IVH, Chiari 1 malformation
case 31
27 + 4
18
16.3
N
N
bilateral severe VM, grade III IVH
post-hemorrhagic ventriculomegaly
case 32
36 + 0
20
14
Y
Y
bilateral severe VM, grade III IVH
post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus
case 33
36 + 0
16
16
N
N
bilateral severe VM, partial ACC
partial ACC
case 34
30 + 1
15.5
15
N
N
undetermined encephalopathy
CMV encephalopathy
case 35
32 + 0
20
18
N
N
bilateral severe VM, abnormal cortical development
bilateral severe VM, abnormal cortical development
case 36
35 + 0
18
17
N
N
bilateral severe VM, grade III IVH
grade III IVH
case 37
31 + 0
23.6
22.3
N
N
bilateral severe VM, suspected callosal hypoplasia
post-hemorrhagic ventriculomegaly (grade III IVH)
case 38
31 + 0
30
26.5
Y
Y
post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus, periventricular leukomalacia, vein of Galen aneurysm
grade IV IVH, and post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus, and vein of Galen aneurysm
case 39
26 + 4
16.5
13.2
N
N
right unilateral severe VM
right unilateral severe VM, unknown etiology
Original Article
HC = head circumference; IVH = intraventricular hemorrhage; VM = ventriculomegaly; TCD = transcerebellar diameter; ACC = agenesis of the corpus callosum; CC = corpus callosum; CSP = cavum septum pellucidum.
ACC bilateral severe VM, ACC N N 16 34 case 44
16
ACC bilateral severe VM, ACC N N 17 31 + 4 case 43
17
arachnoid cyst
ACC bilateral severe VM, ACC
bilateral asymmetrical ventriculomegaly, suspect intraventricular cyst near Monro foramen N
N N
N 19.5
18
31 case 42
21
33 + 0 case 41
19
bilateral severe VM, callosal hypoplasia, vermian hypoplasia bilateral severe VM, thin corpus callosum N Y 18 33 + 2 case 40
21
gestation at diagnosis of severe VM case N
▶ Table 1
(Continuation)
Vp worst
Vp mean
progressive ventricular enlargement
hydrocephalus
antenatal US/MRI diagnosis
final postnatal diagnosis
b
Antenatal MRI was performed in 38/44 cases, yielding additional information compared to expert neurosonography in 4 (9.1 %); all cases underwent postnatal MRI. TORCH screening was performed in all cases and was positive in 2. FNAIT screening was performed in all women and a positive result for anti-platelet alloimmune antibodies was found in 1. All cases had either antenatal or postnatal karyotyping with or without CGH-array and infants were assessed by a geneticist whenever a genetic syndrome was either suspected or confirmed. IVH and ACC represented the most common diagnosis, accounting for 14 cases (31.8 %) each. Specifically, there were 9 cases classified as grade 3 IVH and 5 cases as grade 4 IVH. Isolated complete and partial ACC accounted for 9 and 2 cases, respectively; additionally, there was 1 case of partial agenesis of the ACC associated with vermian hypoplasia of the cerebellum and 2 cases of complete ACC associated with interhemispheric cyst and porencephalic cyst, respectively. Intracranial cysts leading to an obstructive pathology were diagnosed in 6 cases: 5 arachnoid cysts, of which 3 were infratentorial, and 1 cavum velum interpositum cyst. Genetic abnormalities responsible for VM were either diagnosed or suspected in 4 fetuses. Among these, intracranial bleeding related to COL4A1/2 mutation was confirmed in one case. Other genetic conditions were Koolen de-Vires and Mowat-Wilson Syndromes, while in one fetuses a genetic etiology appeared highly likely but could not be confirmed (case 19). Congenital infections were diagnosed in two fetuses (one each of Toxoplasma and CMV), while in 1 case VM was associated with abnormal cortical development. In the remaining 3 fetuses, no apparent cause for the severe VM was identified. The perinatal and postnatal outcomes are shown in ▶ Table 2. The 44 fetuses were delivered at a median gestation of 38 + 0 (33+ 1–41+ 2) weeks. Caesarean section was scheduled in 10 of the 15 fetuses diagnosed with severe VM and hydrocephalus (67 %) and in 10/29 fetuses (35 %) with normal head size. Pediatric neurology assessment was performed at a median age of 20 months (3 – 96). Normal neurodevelopmental and cognitive outcome at the last evaluation by a pediatric neurologist was recorded in 22 of the 44 surviving children (50 %). A mildly abnormal outcome was reported in 7 cases (16 %). 15 children (34 %) showed severe abnormalities in neurodevelopment and/or in motor functions, with or without epilepsy. The poorest postnatal outcomes were reported in the 4 children suspected or diagnosed with a genetic syndrome or COL4A1/2 mutation, in all but one case of grade IV IVH and two cases of grade III IVH, in one case each of isolated complete and partial ACC, in one case with ACC associated with porencephalic cyst, in one case of posterior fossa arachnoid cyst (case 4) and in both cases of congenital infection. Ventriculo-peritoneal shunting was required in 13 infants; in 8/14 cases of IVH, in 4/6 cases of VM secondary to an obstructive pathology and in the only case of congenital toxoplasmosis. Normal neurodevelopmental outcome was noted in only 4/13 fetuses (31 %) who underwent shunting procedures, including 1/4 (25 %) with obstructive etiology and 2/8 (25 %) with IVH. Normal outcome was reported in 9/14 cases of ACC (6 cases of isolated complete ACC, 1 case of isolated partial ACC, 1 of complete ACC associated with interhemispheric cyst and 1 of partial
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
▶ Table 2 Perinatal and long-term outcomes. The included cases are re-ordered non-consecutively so that they are grouped as “normal”, “mildly abnormal” and “severely abnormal” outcome. case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 2
40 + 5
SVD
3000
male
normal outcome
normal neonatal condition
MRI: ACC, radial orientation of the cingulate gyrus, bilateral VM with colpocephaly, opened 4th ventricle, Rathke cleft cyst
N
12
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 3
39 + 3
SVD
2900
male
normal outcome
normal neonatal condition
confirmed antenatal findings
N
32
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 5
–
SVD
unknown
female
normal outcome
normal early outcome
confirmed antenatal findings
N
4
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 6
41 + 1
SVD
5013
male
normal outcome
normal early outcome
confirmed antenatal findings
N
30
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 7
–
ElLSCS
unknown
male
normal outcome
macrocephaly (HC 99th percentile), asymptomatic
confirmed antenatal findings
N
8
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination; under neurosurgical surveillance but no surgery indicated at this time
NORMAL
case 9
34 + 6
SVD
2160
male
spontaneous preterm delivery
normal examination, HC on 50th percentile
neonatal cranial ultrasound scan shows left-sided ventriculomegaly (left ventricular index > 97th percentile)
N
10
asymptomatic macrocephaly (head circumference > 99th percentile), normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 10
–
SVD
unknown
female
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
neonatal cranial US scan normal; mild asymmetry of ventricle (left more prominent), normal bilateral ventricular index (50 – 75th percentiles)
N
3
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination, no further follow-up arranged
NORMAL
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 12
–
SVD
unknown
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
neonatal cranial US: bilateral ventriculomegaly (bilateral ventricular index > 97th percentile, dilated 3 rd ventricle), right IVH
N
22
normal neurological examination and neurodevelopment using Bayley Scales of Infant DevelopmentIII; normal motor and non-motor parameters including communication
NORMAL
case 15
37 + 4
SVD
2050
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
confirmed antenatal findings
N
24
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 18
39 + 5
SVD
3840
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
bilateral severe VM, normal CC, features suggesting grade III IVH
N
18
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 25
37 + 0
ElLSCS
2970
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
cranial US: grade III IVH, hydrocephalus confirmed
N
13
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 28
39 + 6
ElLSCS
3200
male
normal outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
normal examination
confirmed antenatal US findings
Y
59
surgery for cyst resection; normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 29
37 + 0
ElLSCS
2780
female
normal early outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
normal examination
confirmed antenatal US findings
Y
36
endoscopic fenestration of the cyst and VP shunt at 1 month; repeated shunt at 17 months; normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 31
37 + 4
CS
3270
female
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
post-hemorrhagic ventriculomegaly
N
4
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 32
36 + 5
SVD
2300
female
normal neonatal condition
suction difficulties
post-hemorrhagic triventricular non-communicating hydrocephalus
Y
24
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 33
39 + 1
CS
3650
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
partial ACC
N
57
normal neurodevelopment; febrile convulsions
NORMAL
Original Article
▶ Table 2
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
▶ Table 2 case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 36
37 + 0
CS
–
female
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
post-hemorrhagic ventriculomegaly
N
39
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 37
37 + 5
CS
2970
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
post-hemorrhagic ventriculomegaly
Y
32
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 40
39 + 0
SVD
3350
female
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
bilateral severe VM, callosal hypoplasia, vermian hypoplasia
N
–
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 42
33 + 1
SVD
2790
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
left ventricular obstructive hydrocephalus due to arachnoid cyst
N
19
surgery for septostomy and marsupialization of the arachnoid cyst; normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 43
40 + 6
OVD
3200
female
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
bilateral severe VM, ACC, colpocephaly, acute left frontal intraparenchymal hematoma
N
50
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 44
40 + 0
SVD
3240
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
bilateral severe VM, colpocephaly, ACC
N
38
normal neurodevelopmental and neurological examination
NORMAL
case 1
41 + 2
SVD
3550
male
normal outcome
normal neonatal condition
MRI declined by parents because of need for sedation
N
12
seen by ophthalmologist: bilateral optic nerve hypoplasia; no other abnormal neurological findings
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 22
38 + 2
SVD
2740
male
normal neonatal condition
mild left hemiparesis
severe VM and ACC confirmed
N
16
mild left unilateral cerebral palsy
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 24
38 + 4
vacuum delivery (FTP)
2800
female
normal neonatal outcome, transfer to NICU until shunting
normal examination
MRI: bilateral VM, big arachnoid cyst behind cerebellum, hypoplastic cerebellum, prominent choroid plexus cyst
Y
11
normal neurodevelopment, mild bilateral cerebral palsy
MILDLY ABNORMAL
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 26
38 + 6
EmLSCS (FTP)
3100
female
normal neonatal outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
mild left hemiparesis
hydrocephalus, IVH
Y
3
left unilateral mild hemiparesis
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 35
39 + 2
SVD
3660
male
Transient tachypnea
normal examination
unknown cause
N
3
mild left ocular strabismus, mild reduction of muscle tone
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 38
38 + 0
CS
3580
female
prolonged intubation, embolization of vein of Galen aneurysm at 40 days
upper limb motor asymmetry
triventricular hydrocephalus, vein of Galen aneurysm, right hemisphere malacic lesions, right ponto-mesencephalic atrophy
N
5
upper limb motor asymmetry
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 39
34 + 0
SVD
1943
male
transient tachypnea
normal examination
mild ventricular enlargement (right>left), colpocephaly, small right subependymal cyst
N
28
alternating divergent strabismus (right>left)
MILDLY ABNORMAL
case 4
41 + 1
ElLSCS
4600
male
normal outcome
severe ventriculomegaly and macrocephaly (HC > 99th percentile); asymptomatic
MRI: posterior fossa arachnoid cyst, distortion of the brainstem with superior transtentorial herniation, aqueduct stenosis with hydrocephalus, bilateral PCA infarcts
Y
16
substantial speech and language delay
SEVERLY ABNORMAL
case 8
37 + 1
ElLSCS
unknown
female
normal neonatal condition
severe ventriculomegaly, and macrocephaly (HC > 99th percentile), asymptomatic
MRI: bilateral post-hemorrhagic hydrocephalus, right thalamic injury
Y (required revisions)
9
developmental delay and cerebral impairment
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
Original Article
▶ Table 2
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
▶ Table 2 case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 11
37 + 2
ElLSCS
3570
female
neonatal hypotonia and transient need for nasal oxygen and NG tube feeding
asymptomatic, macrocephaly (HC on 99th percentile)
MRI: residual evidence of a right germinal matrix hemorrhage, right thalamic abnormality, bilateral ventriculomegaly with some reduction in the periventricular white matter volume
N
11
developmental delay, severely delayed cognitive skills and significant cerebral visual impairment with abnormal visual evoked
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 13
38 + 6
ElLSCS
4135
female
normal neonatal condition
asymptomatic, macrocephaly
MRI: right frontal cerebral infarction, hydrocephalus
Y
84
triventricular hydrocephalus; left unilateral cerebral palsy, spastic due to cerebral infarction right frontal and hydrocephalus due to prenatal intraventricular bleeding
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 14
36 + 4
SVD
2830
female
normal neonatal outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
early information not available
porencephalic cyst, severe VM, most likely secondary to IVH
Y
72
cerebral palsy, spastic unilateral right side, refractory epilepsy
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 16
40 + 4
EmLSCS (obstruction)
3040
male
normal neonatal condition
abnormal sucking and swallowing
confirmed antenatal findings
N
48
delayed neurodevelopment, dysmorphic features diagnosis of Koolen-de Vries syndrome
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 17
39 + 3
SVD
4470
male
normal neonatal condition
normal physical and neurological examination
postnatal US: right hemisphere porencephalic cyst (not seen antenatally), bilateral severe VM
N
54
right unilateral cerebral palsy, epilepsy, delayed neurodevelopment, IQ55
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 19
41 + 1
SVD
3260
male
normal neonatal condition
normal examination
ACC
N
14
delayed neurodevelopment, Pierre-Robin sequence suspected genetic cause but genetic testing declined by the parents
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
(Continuation)
b
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
case N
gestation at delivery
mode of delivery
birth weight
gender
neonatal outcome
early neurological observations and examination
postnatal imaging (US/MRI)
shunt
age (months) at last neurological follow-up
postnatal outcome
case 20
37 + 4
SVD
3100
female
Normal neonatal condition
normal examination, left-sided microphthalmia
MRI: hydrocephalus confirmed, microphthalmia left eye
Y
24
delayed motor development and language, hydrocephalus, microphthalmia
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 21
36 + 1
EmLSCS (abruption)
1900
male
normal neonatal outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
normal examination
–
21
delayed neurodevelopment, bilateral cerebral palsy; PHVD after IVH, suspicion of brain atrophy
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 23
37 + 6
SVD
3815
male
normal neonatal condition
neonatal seizures
US and MRI confirmed antenatal US findings
N
15
delayed neurodevelopment, epilepsy; diagnosis of Mowat-Wilson syndrome
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 27
35 + 1
EmLSCS (FTP)
2920
female
normal outcome, transfer to NICU for observation
CNS infection after drain
grade III/IV IVH, hydrocephalus
Y (repeated)
4
first drain infected after few days, CNS infection, second drain cerebral palsy COL4A1 mutation confirmed
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 30
38
CS
3380
male
transfer to NICU, intubated
respiratory depression, suction difficulties
Chiari 1 malformation, choroid plexus hemorrhage, ventriculomegaly,
Y
96
delayed neurodevelopment
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 34
36 + 0
CS
1850
male
normal neonatal condition
normal suction and swallowing
CMV encephalopathy: diffuse leukomalacia, ventriculomegaly, abnormal cortical development, bilateral germinolytic cysts
N
–
delayed neurodevelopment
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
case 41
39 + 4
CS
2810
male
normal neonatal condition
reduced spontaneous motility, upper limb tremors
bilateral severe VM, ACC
N
40
delayed neurodevelopment
SEVERELY ABNORMAL
HC = head circumference; IVH = intraventricular hemorrhage; VM = ventriculomegaly; TCD = transcerebellar diameter; ACC = agenesis of the corpus callosum; CC = corpus callosum; PHVD = posthemorrhagic ventricular dilatation; PCA = posterior cerebral artery; FTP = failure to progress.
Original Article
▶ Table 2
b
ACC associated with vermian hypoplasia), in 7/14 cases of IVH (all were grade 3), in 4/6 cases in which an obstructive cause was considered responsible for the severe VM and in 2 cases in which the etiology was unknown. There was no relationship between postnatal outcome and progression of the ventricular enlargement (abnormal outcome in 12/19, 63.2 %, vs. 8/20, 40 %, p 0.15) and fetal gender (abnormal outcome in 12/26 male fetuses, 46.2 %, vs. 9/17 female fetuses, 52.9 %, p 0.66). Regarding the relationship between etiology and outcome, good prognosis was noted in cases of isolated partial or complete ACC (6/7 cases, 86 %), grade 3 IVH (6/9 cases, 67 %), obstruction of the ventricular system (4/6 cases, 67 %) and idiopathic causes (2/3 cases, 67 %). On the other hand, grade 4 IVH and genetic causes were invariably associated with a severely abnormal outcome.
Discussion
To our knowledge this is the first study specifically focused on severe ventriculomegaly diagnosed de novo after 24 weeks. We show considerably better infant neurodevelopmental and motor outcome among live-born fetuses compared to formerly reported data [3 – 6]. Within our cohort, half of fetuses survived with no impairment and those remaining with either a mildly or severely abnormal outcome. There was one neonatal death. Former data on severe VM reported the pathology and the outcomes associated with severe VM regardless of the gestational age at diagnosis. In the largest case series published to date [4], antenatally diagnosed severe VM was concomitant with structural or genetic abnormalities or other complications in nearly twothirds of all cases (100/157, 64 %), among whom CNS malformations (65/100, 65 %) and particularly neural tube defects represented the most common diagnosis (29/100, 29 %). Such findings are consistent with those reported in other case series [3, 5, 6]. It is important to note, however, that in all but one study [6] the median gestational age at diagnosis was lower than we report [3 – 5]. Furthermore, only one study [5] provides information on the neurodevelopmental outcome of the surviving 8 fetuses with severe VM. Otherwise, outcomes are described only in relation to intrauterine death (IUD) or TOP, live births and neonatal deaths [3, 4, 6]. Our data show that the most frequent pathologies in late onset severe VM were complete or partial ACC and IVH, accounting for over half of the cases. One-third of the fetuses diagnosed with late onset severe VM after a mid-trimester anomaly scan was described as normal had major structural intracranial abnormalities. Although these were potentially diagnosable at an earlier scan, it is important to note that the degree of detail of CNS examination on ultrasound varies considerably with the setting of the ultrasound scan and the experience of the operator. Isolated ACC, either complete or partial, is more likely to be associated with normal neurodevelopmental outcome [17, 18]. Severe disability has been reported in 10 % and 30 % of complete and partial ACC, respectively [19]. With expert neurosonographic examination, ACC should be diagnosed earlier in most cases. However, in many national and international guidelines [9 – 13], visualization of the corpus callosum is not required at the routine mid-trimester anomaly scan. In such cases, ACC may be suspected
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
from indirect findings, including ventriculomegaly or failure to visualize the cavum septum pellucidum [20, 21]. Nevertheless, nonvisualization of the cavum septum pellucidum is not a reliable sign in the diagnosis of ACC [22]. Furthermore, ACC may coexist with additional CNS findings and with a variety of chromosomal abnormalities or genetic conditions [18] which may negatively impact the prognosis. In our cohort, ACC was diagnosed in 1 case of arachnoid cyst, 1 porencephalic cyst, 1 vermian hypoplasia and in the fetus that had a final diagnosis of Koolen-de Vries Syndrome. Although ventriculomegaly may reflect primary abnormality in neuronal migration and cerebral development such as cortical dysplasias, polymicrogyria, or lissencephaly [2, 23 – 25], there was only one case of abnormal cortical development in our cohort, which is in contrast with previous reports [3 – 6]. This leads us to speculate that complex abnormalities such as cortical dysplasias are unlikely to be overlooked at the mid-trimester scan, regardless of the presence or absence of the corpus callosum. Severe VM developing after 24 weeks seems more likely to represent the consequence of acquired conditions. Furthermore, given the number of cases of severe VM associated with ACC from our cohort not identified at the mid-trimester anomaly scan, the midsagittal view might usefully be included in the routine assessment of the fetal brain. IVH may cause ventriculomegaly which may be complicated by obstruction of the cerebrospinal fluid circulation, usually at the level of the aqueduct of Silvius, but possibly at the foramina of Monro [26]. In utero IVH has been linked to maternal trauma and fetal coagulation disorders [26]. IVH may represent a similar pathophysiological process as seen in preterm newborns of similar gestation, i. e. subependymal germinal matrix hemorrhage with spread within the ventricular system following a variety of possible insults including perfusion abnormalities [15]. Within our cohort, one woman out of 14 with IVH screened positive for alloimmune anti-platelet antibodies. A mutation of the COL4A1 gene was identified in 1 child. This has been reported in conjunction with intracranial bleeding thought to be related to abnormal collagen development and small vessel vasculopathy [27]. Previously reported data suggested a 50 % chance of poor neurodevelopmental outcome in fetuses with IVH associated with VM, high in utero and perinatal mortality rates and also high rates of termination of pregnancy [26]. Consistent with these observations, in our cohort neurodevelopmental outcome was normal in 50 % of the surviving fetuses. The involvement of the cerebral parenchyma, which defines grade IV IVH, was invariably associated with a severely abnormal outcome, while normal neurodevelopment was reported in most children with grade III IVH, i. e. without parenchymal injury. A very poor prognosis was also reported in the two cases of ventriculomegaly secondary to congenital infection, consistent with previous reports [28, 29]. Obstructive causes of VM other than IVH, represented predominantly by arachnoid cysts in our cohort, and idiopathic causes of severe VM were more often associated with a normal or a near-normal outcome. Features of obstructive pathology include increased head circumference, partial or complete destruction of the cavum septi pellucidi, decrease or absence of pericerebral spaces and, in some cases, if the obstruction is below the third ventricle, at the level of the Sylvian aqueduct, the presence of dilated third ventricle and suprapineal recess [2]. Depending on their position within the brain
Original Article
b
parenchyma, which can be infratentorial or supratentorial, intracranial cysts may be associated with abnormalities of the corpus callosum in addition to fetal ventriculomegaly. Postnatal neurology examination was normal in two-thirds of cases of intracranial cysts. Such figures are consistent with those recently reported for second and third trimester fetuses by Youssef et al. [30] and suggest that severe VM secondary to benign cystic lesions is not associated with a worse prognosis than that of intracranial cysts themselves. Similarly, normal neurodevelopment and motor function were noted in fetuses showing apparently isolated severe VM. According to our data, this diagnosis of exclusion after 24 weeks, though uncommon, is associated with a better outcome than reported, both in terms of survival and survival with intact neurodevelopment [3 – 6]. Strict inclusion criteria and completeness of the outcome data, particularly those concerning the postnatal neurodevelopment, are among the main strengths of our work. The retrospective design of the study and the lack of a standardized scale for neurodevelopmental evaluation are limitations. Nevertheless, in all cases the information regarding postnatal follow-up was complete and collected from case notes or correspondence from dedicated pediatric clinics even though the length of infant follow-up was variable. One half of the included cases had a follow-up of less than 24 months, and a quarter of less than 12 months. Finally, in the standard transventricular plane, only the hemisphere on the far side of the transducer is clearly visualized, as the hemisphere close to the transducer is usually obscured by a reverberation artifact, so we cannot exclude that some of our cases of unilateral VM were overlooked at screening ultrasound because of fetal position. In conclusion, we describe the pathologies responsible for severe VM diagnosed after 24 weeks and childhood neurodevelopment in a cohort of fetuses with normal assessment at the mid-trimester anomaly scan. Within a selected cohort of fetuses in which severe VM was diagnosed at late gestation, we find a higher rate of normal neurodevelopmental outcome than previously reported and no association with progression of ventricular enlargement and fetal gender. The detection of severe VM should prompt a careful examination of the fetal brain. Depending on the differential diagnosis of the potential causes of VM, additional investigations including genetic testing should be offered, as outcome is strongly dependent on the underlying etiology. These data can be useful in the counseling of the prospective parents.
AB BRE VI ATIONS
VM CNS TOP US CMV FNAIT MRI IVH ACC
ventriculomegaly central nervous system termination of pregnancy ultrasound cytomegalovirus feto-neonatal alloimmune thrombocytopenia magnetic resonance imaging intraventricular hemorrhage agenesis of the corpus callosum
Conflict of Interest
The authors declare that they have no conflict of interest.
References
[1] European Surveillance of Congenital Anomalies EUROCAT. Prevelance Tables for Nervous system anomalies (per 10000 births). EUROCAT Available via 2012 http://www.eurocat-network.eu/accessprevalencedata/prevalencetables. [29 November 2016] [2] Guibaud L, Lacalm A. Etiological diagnostic tools to elucidate “isolated” ventriculomegaly. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2015; 46: 1 – 11
[3] Lam SJ, Kumar S. Evolution of fetal ventricular dilatation in relation to severity at first presentation. J Clin Ultrasound 2014; 42: 193 – 198
[4] Hannon T, Tennant PW, Rankin J et al. Epidemiology, natural history, progression, and postnatal outcome of severe fetal ventriculomegaly. Obstet Gynecol 2012; 120: 1345 – 1353 [5] Gaglioti P, Danelon D, Bontempo S et al. Fetal cerebral ventriculomegaly: outcome in 176 cases. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2005; 25: 372 – 377 [6] Breeze AC, Alexander PM, Murdoch EM et al. Obstetric and neonatal outcomes in severe fetal ventriculomegaly. Prenat Diagn 2007; 27: 124 – 129
[7] Graham E, Duhl A, Ural S et al. The degree of antenatal ventriculomegaly is related to pediatric neurological morbidity. J Matern Fetal Med 2001; 10: 258 – 263 [8] Pilu G, Falco P, Gabrielli S et al. The clinical significance of fetal isolated cerebral borderline ventriculomegaly: report of 31 cases and review of the literature. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 1999; 14: 320 – 326 [9] International Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics & Gynecology Education Committee. Sonographic examination of the fetal central nervous system: guidelines for performing the “basic examination” and the “fetal neurosonogram”. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2007; 29: 109 – 116
[10] Italian Society of Ultrasound in Obstetrics and Gynecology (Società Italiana di Ecografia Ostetrico Ginecologica, SIEOG). SIEOG guidelines. 2015 http://www.sigo.it/wp-content/uploads/2015/12/LineeGuidaSieog_2015.pdf [11] Fetal anomaly screening programme: programme handbook June 2015. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/fetal-anomaly-screening-programme-handbook [12] Spanish Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology (SEGO). Guidelines for antenatal ultrasound screening. http://www.gapsego.com/categoriaguia-asistencia/ecografia/ [13] Dutch Society of Obstetrics and Gynecology (Nederlandse Vereniging voor Obstetrie en Gynaecologie, NVOG). Structureel echoscopisch onderzoek (SEO) Versie 2.0. http://www.rivm.nl/dsresource?objectid=c05e9286-9198-47a4-88fc-99abfec96553&type=org&disposition=inline [14] Cardoza JD, Goldstein RB, Filly RA. Exclusion of fetal ventriculomegaly with a single measurement: the width of the lateral ventricular atrium. Radiology 1988; 169: 711 – 714 [15] Volpe JJ. Intracranial Hemorrhage: Germinal Matrix Intraventricular Hemorrhage of the Preterm Infant (Neuropathology and Pathogenesis). In: Volpe JJ, editor Neurology of the Newborn. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders; 2001: 428 – 447 [16] von Elm E, Altman DG, Egger M et al. The strengthening the reporting of the observational studies in Epidemiology (STROBE) statement: guidelines for reporting observational studies. Lancet 2007; 370: 1453 – 1457
[17] D’Antonio F, Pagani G, Familiari A et al. Outcomes Associated With Isolated Agenesis of the Corpus Callosum: A Meta-analysis. Pediatrics 2016; 138: doi:10.1542/peds.2016-0445
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
b
[18] Santo S, D’Antonio F, Homfray T et al. Counseling in fetal medicine: agenesis of the corpus callosum. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2012; 40: 513 – 521
[19] Sotiriadis A, Makrydimas G. Neurodevelopment after prenatal diagnosis of isolated agenesis of the corpus callosum: an integrative review. Am J Obstet Gynecol 2012; 206: 337.e1 – 337.e5 [20] Barkovich AJ, Norman D. Absence of the septum pellucidum: a useful sign in the diagnosis of congenital brain malformations. Am J Roentgenol 1989; 152: 353 – 360
[21] Malinger G, Lev D, Kidron D et al. Differential diagnosis in fetuses with absent septum pellucidum. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2005; 25: 42 – 49 [22] Ghi T, Carletti A, Contro E et al. Prenatal diagnosis and outcome of partial agenesis and hypoplasia of the corpus callosum. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2010; 35: 35 – 41
[23] Malinger G, Lev D, Lerman-Sagie T. Abnormal sulcation as an early sign for migration disorders. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2004; 24: 704 – 705 [24] Malinger G, Kidron D, Schreiber L et al. Prenatal diagnosis of malformations of cortical development by dedicated neurosonography. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2007; 29: 178 – 191
Dall’Asta A et al. Etiology and Prognosis… Ultraschall in Med
[25] Guibaud L, Selleret L, Larroche JC et al. Abnormal Sylvian fissure development on prenatal cerebral imaging. Significance and correlation with neuropathological and postnatal data. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2008; 32: 50 – 60 [26] Ghi T, Simonazzi G, Perolo A et al. Outcome of antenatally diagnosed intracranial hemorrhage: case series and review of the literature. Ultrasound Obstet Gynecol 2003; 22: 121 – 130 [27] Kutuk MS, Balta B, Kodera H et al. Is there relation between COL4A1 / A2 mutations and antenatally detected fetal intraventricular hemorrhage? Childs Nerv Syst 2014; 30: 419 – 424 [28] Malinger G, Lev D, Zahalka N et al. Fetal cytomegalovirus infection of the brain: the spectrum of sonographic findings. Am J Neuroradiol 2003; 24: 28 – 32 [29] Malinger G, Werner H, Rodriguez Leonel JC et al. Prenatal brain imaging in congenital toxoplasmosis. Prenat Diagn 2011; 31: 881 – 886 [30] Youssef A, D’Antonio F, Khalil A et al. Outcome of fetuses with supratentorial extra-axial intracranial cysts: a systematic review. Fetal Diagn Ther 2016; 40: 1 – 12