Robust, applied morphological generation - Computer Science ...

39 downloads 0 Views 181KB Size Report
(version 1.5; Miller et al., 1993). In addi- tion, we ..... George Miller, Richard Beckwith, Christiane. Fellbaum, Derek Gross, Katherine Miller, and. Randee Tengi.
              !!"" # !! $ !% &'()*+*,- .)/ &'012+*)( 34*-)4-5 6)*,-75*+8 '9 3255-: ;7*(*81 61, +0/.84: 8.3 89 5 0 /> 2*99 61*+8/.7= 2* ?

202

~ˆ‚

@A BC DEC E F D @G HIJ GK LKM N OG P Q OGR LS TDH E DU U VB

…of cflajo_\m hbmf gl aof ^dcf bh _ ^fedc_^ fz]^fhj hbg\q …of t^_`fh hbe\bli fz_`aci g\f g``d^^f\`f gl _\ fcfkf\a gl aof `o_^_`af^ hfa _tt^fnb_afm ti aof hiktgc A  pf _hhdkf of^f ao_a A _tt^fj nb_afh aof d]]f^ _\m cgpf^ `_hf cfaaf^h gl aof _cj ]o_tfaq …of \fza hiktgc C h]f`bvfh ao_a aof^f kdha tf _ hfwdf\`f gl g\f g^ kg^f `o_^_`af^hx f_`o tfcg\eb\e ag aof `o_^_`af^ hfa _tt^fnb_afm ti A q W gdtcf wdgafh b\mb`_af cbaf^_c `o_^_`af^ hiktgchq …of ^beoajo_\m hbmf gl aof ^dcf ebnfh aof  `gmf ag tf fzf`dafm pof\ _\ b\]da ha^b\e k_a`ofh aof ^fedc_^ fz]^fhhbg\q rof\ aof cfz ^dcf k_a`ofh aof b\]da X  ' x lg^ fz_kj ]cfx aof  ld\`abg\ KM N OG P Q OGR ~mfv\fm fchfj pof^f b\ aof ef\f^_ag^ ‚ bh `_ccfm ag mfaf^kb\f aof pg^m lg^k `g^^fh]g\mb\e ag aof b\]das aof ld\`abg\ mfcfafh aof b\yf`abg\ ai]f _\m  g ‡ c_j tfc h]f`bv`_abg\h _\m aof mfcbkbaf^hx ^fkgnfh aof c_ha `o_^_`af^ gl aof cfkk_x _\m v\_cci _aj a_`ofh aof `o_^_`af^h   aof pg^m lg^k ef\f^j _afm bh aodh X  q  l `gd^hf \ga _cc ]cd^_c \gd\ b\yf`abg\h _^f `g^^f`aci ef\f^_afm ti aof ^dcf b\ ~ ˆ‚ hb\`f aof^f _^f k_\i b^^fedc_^babfh _\m hdt^fedc_^j babfhq …ofhf _^f mf_ca pbao dhb\e _mmbabg\_cx kg^f h]f`bv`x ^dcfhq …of g^mf^ b\ pob`o aofhf ^dcfh _^f _]]cbfm ag aof b\]da lgccgph fz_`aci aof g^mf^ b\ pob`o aof ^dcfh _]]f_^ b\ aof cfz mfh`^b]abg\q …obh k_Œfh lg^ _ nf^i hbk]cf _\m ]f^h]b`dgdh p_i ag fz]^fhh ef\f^_cbY _abg\h _\m fz`f]abg\hq g^ b\ha_\`fx aof ^dcf b\ ~• ‚ ef\f^j _afh aof ]cd^_c lg^k gl k_\i u\ecbho \gd\h ao_a g^beb\_af l^gk € _ab\x hd`o _h # Z Z q ~• ‚ @A BC DJ EC E F D @G HIJ GK LKM N OG P Q OGR L[ TD\ DUU VB

rbao aof b\]da  # Z Z  ' x aof gda]da bh # Z  ^_aof^ ao_\ aof b\`g^^f`a ] # Z Z  ao_a pgdcm lgccgp l^gk aof _]]cb`_abg\ gl aof kg^f ef\f^_c ^dcf b\ ~ˆ‚ q  i f\hd^b\e ao_a aobh ^dcf ]^f`fmfh aof ^dcf b\ ~ ˆ‚ b\ aof mfh`^b]abg\x \gd\h hd`o _h  # Z Z efa aof `g^^f`a ]cd^_c lg^k b\yf`abg\q ‡ gkf gaof^ pg^mh b\ aobh `c_hhx aogdeox mg \ga o_nf aof € _ab\_af ]cd^_c lg^k ~fqeq ] %$  _h _ ]cd^_c lg^k gl %$ Z ‚  b\ aofhf `_hfh aof ef\f^_ag^ `g\a_b\h ^dcfh h]f`blib\e aof `g^^f`a lg^kh _h fz`f]abg\hq

 

         

…of ^dcfh `g\habadab\e aof ef\f^_ag^ mg \ga \f`j fhh_^bci o_nf ag tf kdad_cci fz`cdhbnfx hg aofi `_\ tf dhfm ag `_]ad^f aof b\yf`abg\_c kg^]ogcj gei gl cfkk_a_ ao_a o_nf kg^f ao_\ g\f ]ghj hbtcf b\yf`afm lg^k ebnf\ _ h]f`bv`  g ‡ c_tfc _\m b\yf`abg\_c ai]fq ‹\ fz_k]cf gl aobh bh aof kdcab]cf b\yf`abg\h gl aof \gd\ " "#Z x pob`o o_h \ga g\ci aof € _ab\_af ]cd^_c lg^k ""# tda _chg aof u\ecbho ]cd^_c lg^k " "#Z   q [\ _mmbj abg\x b\yf`abg\h gl hgkf pg^mh mbŽf^ _``g^mb\e ag mb_cf`aq g^ fz_k]cfx aof ]_ha ]_^ab`b]cf lg^k gl aof nf^t #$ %X bh %$X  b\  ^babho u\ecbhox pof^f_h b\ ‹kf^b`_\ u\ecbho aof ]^flf^^fm pg^m lg^k bh %$X q [\ `_hfh pof^f aof^f bh kg^f ao_\ g\f ]ghhbj tcf b\yf`abg\ lg^ _ ]_^ab`dc_^ b\]da cfkk_x aof g^mf^ gl aof ^dcfh b\ aof cfz mfh`^b]abg\ mfj af^kb\fh aof b\yf`abg\_c ]^flf^f\`fq g^ fz_kj ]cfx pbao aof \gd\ " "#Z  x aof l_`a ao_a aof ^dcf b\ ~• ‚ ]^f`fmfh aof g\f b\ ~ˆ‚ `_dhfh aof ef\f^j _ag^ ag gda]da aof pg^m lg^k " "# ^_aof^ ao_\ " "#Z   fnf\ aogdeo tgao ^dcfh _^f _]]cb`_tcfq [a bh bk]g^a_\a ag \gafx aogdeox ao_a aof ef\j f^_ag^ pbcc _cp_ih `ogghf tfapff\ kdcab]cf b\j yf`abg\hs aof^f bh \g p_i lg^ ba ag gda]da _cc ]ghhbtcf pg^m lg^kh lg^ _ ]_^ab`dc_^ b\]daq

lgccgpfm ti g\f `g\hg\_\a _\m aof c_ha ]_^a gl aof pg^m bh ha^fhhfmx b\ ef\f^_c aof `g\hg\_\a bh mgdtcfm ~ ^g`af^x ˆ‰‰– ‚ q gpfnf^ aof^f _^f fz`f]abg\h ag aobhx _\m b\ _\i `_hf aof b\]da ag aof kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_ag^ mgfh \ga `g\a_b\ b\lg^k_abg\ _tgda ha^fhhq  g\hbmf^ aof cfz ^dcf b\ ~ ‚ x pof^f aof hikj tgch _\m _tt^fnb_af aof `o_^_`af^ hfah `g\j hbhab\e gl ~d]]f^ _\m cgpf^ `_hf ‚ `g\hg\_\ah _\m ngpfchx ^fh]f`abnfciq ~ ‚ @A B @ B@ B DI C HP D !

"

#

$ "

#

#

@G HIJ GK L%& N OG PQ OGR L' TDI D TDHP DU U VB

 bnf\ aof b\]da Z % #  aobh ^dcf `g^^f`aci ef\f^_afh Z % ## q gpfnf^x aof nf^t #$  %# mgfh \ga d\mf^eg `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\e hg aobh ^dcf pbcc ef\f^_afx b\`g^^f`acix aof pg^m lg^k  %## q [\ g^mf^ ag f\hd^f ao_a aof `g^^f`a b\yf`abg\ gl _ nf^t bh ef\f^_afmx aof kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^j _ag^ dhfh _ cbha gl ~_^gd\m ˆxˆŠŠ ‚ cfkk_a_ ao_a _ccgp `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\ex fza^_`afm _dagk_abj `_cci l^gk aof  ^babho  _abg\_c  g^]dh ~     d^\_^mx ˆ‰‰– ‚ q …of cbha bh `of`Œfm tflg^f b\j yf`ab\e nf^thq  bnf\ aof l_`a ao_a aof^f _^f k_\i kg^f nf^th ao_a mg \ga _ccgp `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\ex cbhab\e aof nf^th ao_a mg bh aof kgha f`g\gkb` hgcdabg\q ‹\ _mmfm tf\fva bh ao_a bl _ cfkk_ $ _ccgp `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\e tda bh \ga      b\ aof cbha aof\ aof pg^m lg^k ef\f^j ‹\ bk]g^a_\a bhhdf `g\`f^\b\e kg^]ogcgeb`_c b\`cdmfm _afm pbcc habcc tf `g^^f`a pbao ^fh]f`a ag ‹kf^bj ef\f^_abg\ ao_a bh `cghfci ^fc_afm ag ao_a gl `_\ u\ecbhoq b\yf`abg\_c ]^flf^f\`f bh `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\eq …obh ]of\gkf\g\x g``d^^b\e k_b\ci b\  ^babho      u\ecbhox b\ngcnfh aof mgdtcb\e gl _ `g\hg\_\a …of kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_ag^ `gk]^bhfh _ hfa gl _a aof f\m gl _ cfkk_ pof\ aof cfkk_ bh b\j _]]^gzbk_afci ˆx –Š ^dcfh fz]^fhhb\e kg^j yf`afmq g^ fz_k]cfx aof ]_ha af\hf†]_^ab`b]cf gl]ogcgeb`_c hdt^fedc_^babfhx _\m fzj b\yf`abg\ gl aof nf^t #$ #X  bh #X   b\ `f]abg\h lg^^fedc_^babfhx h]f`bv` pg^mh  _chg _^gd\m –Š cb\fh  ^babho u\ecbhox pof^f aof v\_c `g\hg\_\a gl aof gl  †cfz `gmf lg^ ]^ge^_k b\bab_cbh_abg\ _\m cfkk_ bh mgdtcfm tflg^f aof hd“z bh _aa_`ofmq aof ld\`abg\h `_ccfm ti aof ^dcf _`abg\hq [\ ‹kf^b`_\ u\ecbho aof ]_ha af\hf†]_^ab`b]cf mfv\b\e ^dcf hfa bh b\ l_`a gta_b\fm ti _dagk_abj b\yf`abg\ gl aof nf^t #$ #X  bh dhd_cci h]fca …of `_cci ^fnf^hb\e _ kg^]ogcgeb`_c    X q …obh #X  q  g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\e bh a^beef^fm g\ bh _ kd`o f\o_\`fm nf^hbg\ gl aof _\_cihf^ g^bej aof t_hbh gl tgao g^aoge^_]ob` _\m ]og\gcgebj b\_cci mfnfcg]fm  ‹…u hihafk ~ d\j `_c b\lg^k_abg\s pof\ _ pg^m f\mh b\ g\f ngpfc \b\eo_k fa _cqx ˆ‰‰lg^ ‚ qaof}b\\f\ _\m  _^^gcc ~’\j ‚ mf^ ^fnbfp mfh`^btf b\ mfa_bc ogp aof ^fnf^h_c bh 0 2* /> ,8/* = 79*+ ,- ,1+*18- 8- .> * +*9/186.8,- /7]f^lg^kfmq …of ef\f^_ag^ fzf`da_tcf g``d]bfh 8- ;7/. = * ,4*118+ +*- =3 7117- 8- ;,1 .> * 9*/,- + ,1 90=: 9* 0 *-. 5 7./> ., /,4*1 7 271 *1 6 71. ,; .>* 8-60. 9, .>7. _^gd\m & ŠŠ t g\ mbh`q .> * 2,- *9. 5 7./> >*0189.8/ 76 628*9 *48- * *. 72 ? ? …of _\_cihf^‘ _\m aof^flg^f aof ef\f^_ag^‘ 0. -,.* .> 7. .>* 102*9 87- + 822 72 739 5 7./> b\`cdmfh fz`f]abg\ cbhah mf^bnfm l^gk rg^m  fa .> * 975 * 8- 60. 96 7- ? ~nf^hbg\ ˆq–  }bccf^ fa _cqx ˆ‰‰ ‚ q [\ _mmbj 2* +, *9 - ,. 722, .> * 0 9* ,; 102*9 .> 7. > 74* 8+*-: .8/72 2*;.:> 7- + 98+* 1* 0271 * 61*998,-9 ? abg\x pf o_nf b\`g^]g^_afm m_a_ _`wdb^fm hfkbj (

!

)*

+

)+













  

,





-  





.



















 

  



  

 

203

/

_dagk_ab`_cci l^gk aof lgccgpb\e `g^]g^_ _\m k_`ob\f ^f_m_tcf mb`abg\_^bfhs aof €   `g^j ]dh ~ _^hbmf fa _cqx ˆ‰  & ‚ x aof  f\\ …^ffj t_\Œ ~}_^`dh fa _cqx ˆ‰‰ ‚ x aof ‡ ’ ‡ ‹  u `g^j ]dh ~‡ _k]hg\x ˆ‰‰– ‚ x aof ‡ ]gŒf\ u\ecbho  g^j ]dh ~…_icg^ _\m \gpcfhx ˆ‰   ‚ x aof  zlg^m  hi`ogcb\edbhab` W _a_t_hf ~ db\c_\x ˆ‰‰• ‚ x _\m aof  gk]daf^j’h_tcf  nf^hbg\ gl aof  zlg^m ‹mn_\`fm € f_^\f^„h W b`abg\_^i gl  d^^f\a u\j ecbho ~ ‹ € W  u  }baag\x ˆ‰‰• ‚ q /

 

 -    

}b\\f\ _\m  _^^gcc ~’\mf^ ^fnbfp ‚ ^f]g^a _\ fn_cd_abg\ gl aof _``d^_`i gl aof kg^]ogcgebj `_c ef\f^_ag^ pbao ^fh]f`a ag aof  u € u  cfzbj `_c m_a_t_hf ~nf^hbg\ •q–   __if\ fa _cqx ˆ‰‰ ‚ q …obh ao^fp d] _ hk_cc \dktf^ gl f^^g^h pob`o pf o_nf \gp vzfmq rf o_nf ^f^d\ aof  u € u  j t_hfm fn_cd_abg\s _e_b\ha aof ]_ha af\hfx ]_ha _\m ]^fhf\a ]_^ab`b]cfx _\m aob^m ]f^hg\ hb\edj c_^ ]^fhf\a af\hf b\yf`abg\h gl nf^thx _\m _cc ]cdj ^_c \gd\hq ‹laf^ fz`cdmb\e kdcabjpg^m f\a^bfh ~]o^_h_c nf^thx fa`q‚ pf pf^f cfla pbao   x • gda gl aof g^beb\_c ˆ Šx–‰– pg^m lg^khq g^ f_`o gl aofhf pg^m lg^kh pf lfm aof `g^^fh]g\mb\e b\]da ~mf^bnfm _dagk_ab`_cci l^gk aof cfkk_j abh_abg\ _\m b\yf`abg\ h]f`bv`_abg\ ]^gnbmfm ti  u € u  ‚ ag aof ef\f^_ag^q rf `gk]_^fm aof ef\f^_ag^ gda]da pbao aof g^beb\_c  u € u  pg^m lg^khx ]^gmd`b\e _ cbha gl kbha_Œfh _]]_^f\aci k_mf ti aof ef\f^_ag^x pob`o pf aof\ `of`Œfm ti o_\mq [\ _ \dktf^ gl `_hfh fbaof^ aof  u € u  cfkk_abh_abg\ p_h p^g\e b\ ao_a ba mbh_e^ffm pbao aof ^fcfn_\a f\j a^i b\ aof   %X    #X #$   "#$ X $   ~ ^g`af^x ˆ‰‰– ‚ x g^ aof gda]da gl aof ef\f^_ag^ p_h `g^^f`a fnf\ aogdeo ba p_h \ga bmf\ab`_c ag aof pg^m lg^k ebnf\ b\  u € u  q rf mbm \ga `gd\a aofhf `_hfh _h kbha_Œfhq rf _chg lgd\m ao_a  u € u  bh b\`g\hbhaf\a pbao ^fj h]f`a ag `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\eq g^ fz_k]cfx ba b\`cdmfh aof pg^m lg^k ## $   x pof^f_h ba gkbah k_\i `g\hg\_\a mgdtcfm pg^mh ao_a _^f kd`o kg^f `gkkg\ ~_``g^mb\e ag `gd\ah l^gk aof    ‚ q g^ fz_k]cfx aof    `g\j a_b\h _^gd\m  –Š g``d^^f\`fh gl aof pg^m lg^k X$ X   a_eefm _h _ nf^tx tda aobh lg^k bh \ga ]^fhf\a b\  u € u  q …of lg^k X$ X  mgfh g``d^ b\  u € u  x tda mgfh \ga b\ aof    q .

+



171*  ,1+  5 *7- 8-  ., = * ,4*123 /,-/*1-*+  8.> 95 722  0 - 85 6 ,1.7-. +*.7829 ?

204

rf mbm \ga `gd\a aofhf `_hfh _h kbha_Œfh fbaof^q  l aof ^fk_b\b\e –‰ kbha_Œfhx   `g\`f^\fm pg^m lg^kh ao_a mg \ga g``d^ _a _cc b\ aof ˆŠŠ} pg^mh gl aof    q rf `_afeg^bhfm aofhf _h b^^fcj fn_\a lg^ ]^_`ab`_c _]]cb`_abg\h _\m hg mbh`_^mfm aofkq …odh aof #  _``d^_`i gl aof kg^]ogj cgeb`_c _\_cihf^ pbao ^fh]f`a ag aof  u € u  cfzj b`_c m_a_t_hf bh ‰‰q‰ &  q …of #$   _``d^_`i bh ‰‰q‰   pbao ^fh]f`a ag aof ˆ x •–x ˆ ^fcfn_\a agŒf\h b\ aof    ~bqfq _ ^_af gl apg f^^g^h ]f^ af\ aogdh_\m pg^mh ‚ q rf afhafm aof ]^g`fhhb\e h]ffm gl aof ef\f^j _ag^ g\ _ ‡ d\ ’ca^_ ˆŠ pg^Œha_abg\q [\ g^mf^ ag mbh`gd\a ]^ge^_k ha_^ad] abkfh ~pob`o _^f _\ip_i g\ci gl aof g^mf^ gl ŠqŠ– hf`g\mh ‚ pf dhfm b\]da vcfh gl ŠŠ _\m  ŠŠ agŒf\h _\m ^f`g^mfm aof mbŽf^f\`f b\ abkb\eh  pf aggŒ aof _nf^_efh gl ˆŠ ^d\hq W fh]baf bah pbmf `gnf^_ef aof kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_ag^ bh nf^i l_has ba ef\j f^_afh _a _ ^_af gl kg^f ao_\  ŠxŠŠŠ pg^mh ]f^ hf`g\mq    ! Z!   W   "  YZ  .

/



  

/

       

…of kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_ag^ lg^kh ]_^a gl _ ]^gagai]f hihafk lg^ _dagk_ab` hbk]cbv`_abg\ gl u\ecbho \fph]_]f^ afza ~ _^^gcc fa _cqx ˆ‰‰‰ ‚ q …of eg_c bh ag ofc] ]fg]cf pbao _]o_hb_ ~_ c_\j ed_ef bk]_b^kf\a ai]b`_cci g``d^^b\e _h _ ^fj hdca gl _ ha^gŒf g^ of_m b\ d^i ‚ ag tfaaf^ d\j mf^ha_\m u\ecbho \fph]_]f^ afzaq …of hihafk `gk]^bhfh apg k_b\ `gk]g\f\ahs _\ _\_cihbh kgmdcf pob`o mgp\cg_mh aof hgd^`f \fph]_]f^ afzah l^gk aof pft _\m `gk]dafh hi\a_`ab` _\_cj ihfh lg^ aof hf\af\`fh b\ aofkx _\m _ hbk]cbj v`_abg\ kgmdcf pob`o g]f^_afh g\ aof gda]da gl aof _\_cihf^ ag bk]^gnf aof `gk]^fof\hbtbcj bai gl aof afzaq ‡ i\a_`ab` hbk]cbv`_abg\ ~ _\j \b\e _\m …_bax ˆ‰‰‰ ‚ g]f^_afh g\ aof hi\a_z a^ffh ]^gmd`fm b\ aof _\_cihbh ]o_hfx lg^ fz_kj ]cf `g\nf^ab\e hf\af\`fh b\ aof ]_hhbnf ngb`f ag _`abnfx _\m h]cbaab\e cg\e hf\af\`fh _a _]]^g]^bj _af ]gb\ahq ‹ hdthfwdf\a cfzb`_c hbk]cbv`_abg\ ha_ef ~W fncb\ _\m …_bax ˆ‰‰  ‚ ^f]c_`fh mb“`dca g^ ^_^f `g\af\a pg^mh pbao hbk]cf^ hi\g\ikhq …of _\_cihbh `gk]g\f\a `g\a_b\h _ kg^]ogj cgeb`_c _\_cihf^x _\m ba bh aof t_hf lg^kh gl . 89 28 *23 .> 7. 7 5 , +*9. 8-/1*79* 8- 96 **+ /,02+ = * ,=.78-*+ =3 96 */8;3 8-  ,6.85 897.8,- 2*4*29 8-  2* 7-+  // .> 7. 71* >8  >*1 .> 7- .>* +*;702.9 ?

pg^mh ao_a _^f ]_hhfm ao^gdeo aof hihafk  aobh f_hfh aof a_hŒ gl aof cfzb`_c hbk]cbv`_abg\ kgmj dcfq …of v\_c ]^g`fhhb\e ha_ef b\ aof hihafk bh aof^flg^f kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_abg\x dhb\e aof ef\f^_ag^ mfh`^btfm b\ aof ]^fnbgdh hf`abg\q



            

  

rf _^f `d^^f\aci afhab\e aof `gk]g\f\ah gl aof hbk]cbv`_abg\ hihafk g\ _ `g^]dh gl ˆŠŠŠ \fph hag^bfh mgp\cg_mfm l^gk aof  Z   X  " $ ~_ cg`_c \fph]_]f^ b\  g^aoju_ha u\ec_\m ‚ q [\ gd^ afhab\e pf o_nf lgd\m ao_a \fpci f\`gd\j af^fm ng`_tdc_^i g\ci ^_^fci \f`fhhba_afh _\i kgmbv`_abg\ ag aof ef\f^_ag^ ~g^ ^_aof^ aof _\_cihf^ ‚ hgd^`f  bl aof pg^m o_h ^fedc_^ kg^j ]ogcgei aof\ ba bh o_\mcfm ti aof ^dcfh fz]^fhhj b\e ef\f^_cbh_abg\hq ‹chgx _ hbmfjfŽf`a gl aof l_`a ao_a aof ef\f^_ag^ bh mf^bnfm l^gk aof _\_cihf^ bh ao_a aof apg kgmdcfh o_nf fz_`aci aof h_kf `gnf^_ef _\m _^f ed_^_\affm ag ha_i b\ haf] pbao f_`o gaof^q …obh bh bk]g^a_\a b\ aof `g\afza gl _\ _]]cbfm hihafk q …of _``d^_`i gl aof ef\f^j _ag^ bh wdbaf hd“`bf\a lg^ aobh _]]cb`_abg\  gd^ fz]f^bf\`f bh ao_a ai]ge^_]ob`_c kbha_Œfh b\ aof g^beb\_c \fph]_]f^ afza _^f kd`o kg^f `gkkg\ ao_\ f^^g^h b\ kg^]ogcgeb`_c ]^g`fhhb\eq +



       



         

‡ gkf g^aoge^_]ob` ]of\gkf\_ h]_\ kg^f ao_\ g\f pg^mq …ofhf `_\\ga tf mf_ca pbao b\ kg^j ]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_abg\ hb\`f aobh pg^Œh ha^b`aci _ pg^m _a _ abkfq rf o_nf aof^flg^f bk]cfkf\afm _ v\_c g^aoge^_]ob` ]gha]^g`fhhb\e ha_efq  g\j hbmf^ aof hf\af\`fs ~ ‚ ]  X  $$    #  ##X "#$ # +

#+    $X

   $  #Z X  .   % % "  $  Z    .        $ 

  + #   + #

 "#$%&'()$% *+,-

>89 9*-.*- /* 89 .7  *- ;1,5 .> * 9.,13 >* +*5 89* ,; 0 - +*127- + 9 70  1*  *18*9 89  848-  2, /72 5 098/87-9 7 /79* ,; .>* = 20 *9 60 =289>*+ 8- .> * ,-   0  09.   ?



!

+

.

+

+

!

/

…obh bh b\`g^^f`a g^aoge^_]ob`_cci tf`_dhf aof mfaf^kb\f^ b\ aof v\_c \gd\ ]o^_hf hogdcm tf  x _h b\   "$Z  #"     $ q [\ l_`a  kdha tf dhfm bl aof lgccgpb\e pg^m ha_^ah pbao _ ngpfc hgd\mx _\m  gaof^pbhfq rf _`obfnf aobhx _e_b\ dhb\e _ vcaf^ bk]cfkf\afm b\ cfzx pbao _ hfa gl ef\f^_c ^dcfh Œfib\e gŽ aof \fza pg^m„h v^ha cfaaf^ ~o_nb\e hŒb]]fm _\i b\af^j nf\b\e hf\af\`fjb\af^\_c ]d\`ad_abg\ ‚ x agefaof^   .

pbao _ cbha gl fz`f]abg\h ~fqeq X x Z    $Z ‚ `gccf`afm dhb\e aof ]^g\d\`b_abg\ b\lg^k_abg\ b\ aof  ‹ € W  ux hd]]cfkf\afm ti ld^aof^ `_hfh ~fqeq Z   $  ‚ lgd\m b\ aof    q [\ aof `_hf gl _tt^fnb_abg\h g^ _`^g\ikh ~^f`ge\bhfm ti aof g``d^^f\`f gl \g\jpg^mjb\bab_c `_]ba_c cfaj af^h _\m a^_bcb\e ldccjhag]h ‚ pf Œfi gŽ aof ]^gj \d\`b_abg\ gl aof v^ha cfaaf^ `g\hbmf^fm b\ bhgc_j abg\q ‡ bkbc_^cix aof g^aoge^_]oi gl aof ef\babnf k_^Œf^ `_\\ga tf mfaf^kb\fm pbaogda a_Œb\e `g\afza b\ag _``gd\ax hb\`f ba mf]f\mh g\ aof bmf\abai gl aof c_ha cfaaf^ gl aof ]^f`fmb\e pg^mq [\ aof hf\af\`f b\ ~ ‚ pf \ffm g\ci fcbkb\_af aof h]_`f tflg^f aof ef\babnf k_^Œb\ex gta_b\j b\e /  0 1 X  q  dax lgccgpb\e aof \fph]_]f^ haicf edbmfx bl aof ]^f`fmb\e pg^m f\mh b\  g^ 2 pf o_nf ag ƒ^fmd`f„ aof k_^Œf^ _h b\x lg^ fz_kj ]cfx  #"  3 X 0    Z  4  X q …of ef\f^_abg\ gl `g\a^_`abg\h ]^fhf\ah kg^f gl _ ]^gtcfkq g^ fz_k]cfx `o_\eb\e  3   ag  0  pgdcm k_Œf ~ ‚ kg^f bmbgk_ab`q  da aof^f _^f `_hfh pof^f aobh ai]f gl `g\a^_`abg\ bh \ga ]f^kbhhbtcfq ‡ b\`f aofhf `_hfh hffk ag tf mf]f\mf\a g\ hi\a_`ab` `g\afza ~hff ‡ f`abg\ tfcgp ‚ x _\m pf o_nf hi\a_`ab` ha^d`ad^f l^gk aof _\_cihbh ]o_hfx pf _^f b\ _ eggm ]ghbabg\ ag k_Œf aof `g^^f`a `ogb`fq gpfnf^x pf o_nf \ga ifa a_`Œcfm aobh bhhdf _\m `d^^f\aci a_Œf aof `g\hf^n_abnf _]]^g_`o gl \ga `g\a^_`ab\e b\ _\i `b^`dkha_\`fhq 5 6 " Z 7 ! 8 rf _^f lgccgpb\e _ pfccjfha_tcbhofm cb\f gl ^fj hf_^`o b\ag aof dhf gl v\bafjha_af af`o\bwdfh lg^ cfzb`_c _\m ho_ccgp hi\a_`ab` € a_hŒh ~fqeq _^aad\f\ fa _cq ~ ˆ‰‰  ‚‚ q € fzb`_c a^_\hmd`j f^h o_nf tff\ dhfm fzaf\hbnfci lg^ kg^]ogcgeb`_c _\_cihbhx _\m b\ aofg^i _ v\bafjha_af a^_\hmd`f^ bk]cfkf\ab\e _\ _\_cihf^ `_\ tf ^fnf^hfm ag ]^gmd`f _ ef\f^_ag^q gpfnf^x pf _^f \ga _p_^f gl ]dtcbhofm ^fhf_^`o g\ v\bafjha_af kg^]ogj cgeb`_c ef\f^_ag^h ~ ˆ‚ fha_tcbhob\e pofaof^ b\ ]^_`ab`f aofi ]f^lg^k pbao hbkbc_^ f“`bf\`i ag kg^]ogcgeb`_c _\_cihf^hx ~• ‚ wd_\ablib\e aofb^ ai]f†agŒf\ _``d^_`i pbao ^fh]f`a ag _\ b\mfj ]f\mf\ax fzaf\hbnf ƒegcm ha_\m_^m„x _\m ~ ‚ b\j mb`_ab\e ogp f_hbci aofi `_\ tf b\afe^_afm b\ag c_^ef^ hihafkhq d^aof^kg^fx _caogdeo _ \dktf^ gl v\bafjha_af `gk]bc_abg\ aggcŒbah ~fqeq _^aad\f\ ~ ˆ‰‰ ‚‚ _^f ]dtcb`ci _n_bc_tcf g^ `_\

205

!

/

tf cb`f\hfm lg^ ^fhf_^`o dhfx _hhg`b_afm c_^efj h`_cf cb\edbhab` mfh`^b]abg\h‘ lg^ fz_k]cf u\j ecbho kg^]ogcgeb`_c cfzb`g\h‘ _^f dhd_cci `gkj kf^`b_c ]^gmd`ah _\m _^f aof^flg^f \ga l^ffci _n_bc_tcf ag aof € ^fhf_^`o `gkkd\baiq …of pg^Œ ^f]g^afm of^f bh _chg ^fc_afm ag pg^Œ g\ cfzb`g\ ^f]^fhf\a_abg\ _\m kg^]ogj cgeb`_c ]^g`fhhb\e dhb\e aof W ‹… ^f]^fhf\a_j abg\ c_\ed_ef ~ _obccx ˆ‰‰  un_\h _\m  _ Y m_^x ˆ‰‰  ‚ q gpfnf^x pf _mg]a cfhh gl _ aofg^fabj `_c _\m kg^f gl _\ f\eb\ff^b\e ]f^h]f`abnfx lgj `dhb\e g\ kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_abg\ b\ aof `g\j afza gl pbmfj`gnf^_ef ]^_`ab`_c € _]]cb`_j abg\hq …of^f _^f _chg ]_^_ccfch ag ^fhf_^`o b\ aof apgjcfnfc kg^]ogcgei l^_kfpg^Œ ~ ghŒf\j \bfkbx ˆ‰   ‚ x _caogdeo b\ `g\a^_ha ag gd^ _]j ]^g_`o aobh l^_kfpg^Œ o_h ^fwdb^fm fzo_dhabnf cfzb`_ _\m o_\mj`^_lafm kg^]ogcgeb`_c ~d\bvj `_abg\ ‚ e^_kk_^h b\ _mmbabg\ ag g^aoge^_]ob` mfh`^b]abg\h ~n_\  gg^mx ˆ‰‰ˆ  ba`obf fa _cqx ˆ‰‰• ‚ q …of ‡ [  g^f € _\ed_ef u\eb\f ~‹cj ho_pbx ˆ‰‰• ‚ dhfh _ hfa gl mf`c_^_abnf hfekf\j a_abg\ ^dcfh pob`o _^f hbkbc_^ b\ `g\af\a ag gd^ ^dcfh _\m _^f dhfm b\ ^fnf^hf ag ef\f^_af pg^m lg^khq …of hihafk x ogpfnf^x bh \ga l^ffci _n_bcj _tcfx _e_b\ ^fwdb^fh _\ fzo_dhabnf hafk cfzb`g\x _\m aof ^dcfh _^f \ga `gk]bcfm b\ag _\ f“`bf\aci fzf`da_tcf v\bafjha_af k_`ob\f tda _^f g\ci b\j af^]^fafmq …of pg^Œ ao_a bh ]f^o_]h aof kgha hbkbc_^ b\ h]b^ba ag gd^h bh ao_a gl aof € ‹ W € e^gd]x b\ aofb^ `gk]bc_abg\ gl c_^ef cfzb`g\h gl b\yf`afm pg^m lg^kh b\ag v\bafjha_af a^_\hmd`f^h ~}go^bx ˆ‰‰  ‚ q …of ^fhdcab\e _\_cihf^h ^d\ _a _ `gkj ]_^_tcf h]ffm ag gd^ ef\f^_ag^ _\m aof ~`gkj ]_`afm ‚ fzf`da_tcfh _^f gl hbkbc_^ hbY fq gpj fnf^x _ ldcc lg^k cfzb`g\ bh d\pbfcmi _\m b\`g\j nf\bf\a ag d]m_afx _\m _ hihafk mf^bnfm l^gk ba `_\\ga `g]f e^_`fldcci pbao d\Œ\gp\ pg^mh tfj `_dhf ba mgfh \ga `g\a_b\ ef\f^_cbh_abg\h _tgda ^fedc_^ g^ hdt^fedc_^ kg^]ogcgeb`_c tfo_nbgd^q …of kg^]ogcgeb`_c `gk]g\f\ah gl `d^^f\a pbmfcijdhfm € hihafkh af\m ag `g\hbha gl o_^mjpb^fm ]^g`fmd^_c `gmf ao_a bh abeoaci tgd\m ag aof pg^Œb\eh gl aof ^fha gl aof hihafkq g^ b\ha_\`fx aof  befc e^_kk_^ ~}_aaobfhhf\x ˆ‰  ‚ `g\a_b\h € bh] `gmf ao_a `c_hhbvfh nf^tx \gd\ _\m _m f`abnf f\mb\ehx _\m aofhf `c_hhfh _^f ]b`Œfm d] ti ld^aof^ `gmf b\hbmf aof  } € hihafk ~ _afk_\x •ŠŠŠ ‚ bahfcl pob`o ]f^lg^kh b\yf`abg\_c ef\f^_abg\ ti ha^b]]b\e gŽ n_^b_tcf !

/

!

/

206

cf\eao a^_bcb\e ha^b\eh _\m `g\`_af\_ab\e hdlj vzfhq ‹cc kg^]ogcgeb`_cci hdt^fedc_^ lg^kh kdha tf f\af^fm fz]cb`baci b\ aof cfzb`g\x _h pfcc _h b^^fedc_^ g\fhq …of hbad_abg\ bh hbkbc_^ b\ ’† ‡ ’  ux kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_abg\ b\ aof ‡ ’  u e^_kk_^ ~uco_m_m _\m gtb\x ˆ‰‰  ‚ tfb\e ]f^lg^kfm ti ]^g`fmd^fh pob`o b\h]f`a cfkk_ f\mb\ehx ha^b] gŽ a^_bcb\e ha^b\eh pof\ _]]^g]^b_afx _\m `g\`_af\_af hd“zfhq [\ `d^^f\a € hihafkhx g^aoge^_]ob` b\lg^j k_abg\ bh mbha^btdafm ao^gdeogda aof cfzb`g\ _\m bh _]]cbfm nb_ aof e^_kk_^ g^ ti o_^mjpb^fm `gmfq …obh k_Œfh g^aoge^_]ob` ]^g`fhhb\e mblj v`dca ag mf`gd]cf l^gk aof ^fha gl aof hihafkx `gk]^gkbhb\e k_b\a_b\_tbcbai _\m f_hf gl ^fdhfq g^ fz_k]cfx b\ ‡ ’  ux k_^Œf^h lg^   dhj _ef `_\ tf _mmfm ag cfzb`_c f\a^bfh lg^ \gd\h ag b\mb`_af ao_a aofb^ b\bab_c hgd\m bh `g\hg\_\aj g^ ngpfcjcbŒfx _\m bh `g\a^_^i ag po_a aofb^ g^j aoge^_]oi pgdcm hdeefhaq ~…obh bh g\ci _ ]_^ab_c hgcdabg\ hb\`f _m f`abnfhx _mnf^th‘ _\m kg^f ^_^fci gaof^ ]_^ah gl h]ff`o‘ `_\ lgccgp aof b\j mfv\baf _^ab`cf _\m aodh \ffm aof h_kf a^f_aj kf\a ‚ q …of _]]^g]^b_af b\mfv\baf _^ab`cf bh b\j hf^afm ti ]^g`fmd^fh _hhg`b_afm pbao aof e^_kj k_^q [\ W ‹…u j• ~ gpf^ fa _cqx ˆ‰‰  ‚ x _\   lf_ad^f `_\ tf _hhg`b_afm pbao _\i cfzj b`_c f\a^ix _\m bah n_cdf bh ]^g]_e_afm d] ag aof  cfnfc ao^gdeo cflakgha ^dcf m_deoaf^h b\ aof e^_kk_^ ~ gpf^x ]f^hg\_c `gkkd\b`_abg\ ‚ q  gao gl aofhf hihafkh b\af^cf_nf g^aoge^_]ob` ]^g`fhhb\e pbao gaof^ ]^g`fhhfh b\ ^f_cbh_abg\q [\ _mmbabg\x \fbaof^ o_h _ kf`o_\bhk lg^ ha_aj b\e fz`f]abg\h lg^ pogcf hdt`c_hhfh gl pg^mhx lg^ fz_k]cf aoghf ha_^ab\e Z lgccgpfm ti _ ngpfc‘ hd`o _h Z  _\m ZZ  ‘pob`o kdha tf ]^f`fmfm ti  q  } € _]]f_^h \ga ag ]f^lg^k aobh ai]f gl ]^g`fhhb\e _a _ccq rf _^f \ga _p_^f gl _\i cbaf^_ad^f mfh`^btb\e ~]^_`ab`_c ‚ € hihafkh ao_a ef\f^_af `g\a^_`j abg\hq gpfnf^x b\af^fhab\e cb\edbhab` ^fhf_^`o b\ aobh mb^f`abg\ bh ^f]g^afm ti  dccdk _\m  pb`Œi ~[\ ]^f]_^_abg\ ‚ q …obh pg^Œ b\nfhabe_afh aof d\j mf^cib\e hi\a_`ab` ha^d`ad^f gl hf\af\`fh ao_a tcg`Œ _dzbcb_^i ^fmd`abg\hx lg^ fz_k]cf aoghf pbao   fccb]hbh _h b\ ~– ‚ q ~– ‚ ]   0 ZZ   $  3   0  /

!

+

. +

+

+

%"YY rf o_nf mfh`^btfm _ ef\f^_ag^ lg^ u\ecbho b\j yf`abg\_c kg^]ogcgeiq …of k_b\ lf_ad^fh gl aof ef\f^_ag^ _^fs [a b\j        `g^]g^_afh m_a_ l^gk hfnf^_c c_^ef `g^]g^_ _\m k_`ob\f ^f_m_tcf mb`abg\_^bfhq ‹\ fn_cd_abg\ o_h hogp\ aof f^^g^ ^_af ag tf nf^i cgpq …of ef\f^_ag^ mgfh \ga `g\a_b\   _\ fz]cb`ba cfzb`g\ g^ pg^mjcbhax tda b\haf_m `gk]^bhfh _ hfa gl kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^_cbj h_abg\h agefaof^ pbao _ cbha gl fz`f]abg\h lg^ h]f`bv` ~b^^fedc_^ ‚ pg^mhq ’\Œ\gp\ pg^mh _^f nf^i glaf\ o_\mcfm `g^^f`aci ti aof ef\j f^_cbh_abg\hq      …of g^j e_\bh_abg\ b\ag ef\f^_cbh_abg\h _\m fz`f]j abg\h `_\ h_nf mfnfcg]kf\a abkf hb\`f _mj mbabg\ gl \fp ng`_tdc_^i ao_a o_h ^fedc_^ kg^]ogcgei mgfh \ga ^fwdb^f _\i `o_\efh ag tf k_mfq …of ef\f^_ag^ bh ]_`Œ_efm d] _h _ ’\bz vcaf^x k_Œb\e ba f_hi ag b\afe^_af b\ag _]]cb`_abg\hq         …of ef\f^_ag^ bh t_hfm g\ f“`bf\a v\bafjha_af af`o\bwdfhx _\m bk]cfkf\afm dhb\e aof pbmfci _n_bc_tcf ’\bz cfz dabcbaiq …of kg^]ogcgeb`_c ef\f^j  _ag^ _\m aof g^aoge^_]ob` ]gha]^g`fhj hg^ _^f l^ffci _n_bc_tcf ag aof € ^fj hf_^`o `gkkd\baiq ‡ ff  oaa]s††pppq`gehq hdhzq_`qdŒ†c_t†\c]†`_^^gcc†kg^]oqoakc  q [\ ldad^f pg^Œ pf b\af\m ag b\nfhabe_af aof dhf gl ]og\gcgeb`_c b\lg^k_abg\ b\ k_`ob\f ^f_m_tcf mb`abg\_^bfh lg^ _ kg^f ]^b\`b]cfm hgj cdabg\ ag aof `g\hg\_\a mgdtcb\e ]^gtcfkq rf _chg ]c_\ ag ld^aof^ b\`^f_hf aof yfzbtbcbai gl aof ef\f^_ag^ ti b\`cdmb\e _\ g]abg\ ao_a _cj cgph aof dhf^ ag `ogghf pofaof^ ba o_h _ ]^flf^j f\`f lg^ ef\f^_ab\e  ^babho g^ ‹kf^b`_\ u\ecbho h]fccb\eq W%8   "    ZY …obh pg^Œ p_h ld\mfm ti ’ u ‡  ]^g  f`a  † € –ˆ& – ƒ‡ u…s  ^_`ab`_c ‡ bk]cbv`_abg\ gl u\ecbho …fza„x _\m ti _\ u ‡  ‹mn_\`fm fcj cgphob] ag aof hf`g\m _daog^q …of g^beb\_c nf^j hbg\ gl aof kg^]ogcgeb`_c _\_cihf^ p_h Œb\mci 

 -

 













 









 

 



-   

/

207

]^gnbmfm ag dh ti aof ’\bnf^hbai gl ‡ of“fcm  ‹…u ]^g  f`aq  o^bh  ^fpx W _cf  f^mfk_\\x ‹m_k bce_^^bŽ _\m uodm fbaf^ o_nf hdej efhafm bk]^gnfkf\ah ag aof _\_cihf^†ef\f^_ag^q …o_\Œh _chg ag aof _\g\ikgdh ^fnbfpf^h lg^ b\j hbeoaldc `gkkf\ahq 6   !%Y ‹cl^fm ‹ogx _nb ‡ faobx _\m  fŽ^fi ’cck_\q ˆ‰  q  $ X  X "  "   Z    $$ q ‹mmbhg\jrfhcfiq bi_\ ‹cho_pbx fmbag^q ˆ‰‰•q   $X   Z      q }[…  ^fhhx  _kt^bmefx }‹q _^_cm  __if\x b`o_^m  bf]f\t^g`Œx _\m fmj mf^bŒ n_\ b \q ˆ‰‰q      "  # %       q € b\edbhab` W _a_  g\hg^abdk x ’\bnf^hbai gl  f\\hicn_\b_x  obc_mfc]ob_x ‹x ’ ‡ ‹q  go\  _afk_\q •ŠŠŠq /   X$     X"   q ’\bnf^hbai gl  ^fkf\x  f^k_\ix  oaa]s††pppqltˆŠqd\bjt^fkf\qmf†_\ecbhabŒ† c_\e]^g†Œ]kc† u‹ W }uqoakc  q € gd  d^\_^mq ˆ‰‰–q ’hf^h ^flf^f\`f edbmf lg^ aof  ^babho  _abg\_c  g^]dhq …f`o\b`_c ^fj ]g^ax  zlg^m ’\bnf^hbai  gk]dab\e ‡ f^nb`fhq € i\\f  _obccq ˆ‰‰q }g^]og\gcgei b\ aof cfzj b`g\q [\ X$"  $ #   #  $ X " $ #  ZX$    #X $ #  1  $"#$ $X  $ Z ##$   Z #" x ]_efh  & ‰  x ’a^f`oax …of  faof^c_\mhq  ng\\f  _\\b\e _\m  go\ …_baq ˆ‰‰‰q ‡ i\a_`j ab` hbk]cbv`_abg\ gl \fph]_]f^ afza lg^ _]o_j hb` ^f_mf^hq [\ X$"  $ #  1       $X   $ $  Z #$     $X #$   X x  f^Œfcfix  ‹x ’ ‡ ‹q  go\  _^^gccx  dbmg }b\\f\x W _^^f\  f_^`fx  ng\\f  _\\b\ex ‡ bgto_\ W fncb\x _\m  go\ …_baq ˆ‰‰‰q ‡ bk]cblib\e u\ecbho afza lg^ c_\j ed_ef bk]_b^fm ^f_mf^hq [\ X$"  $ #  /

+

+

!

*

!

!

+

) *

*

(

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

+

*

.

+

 $ X " $ #+  Z X$  +  #X $ # +  1  $"#$ $X  $ Z ##$   Z  * #"  1   x  f^ef\x  g^p_iq  #+

_kbho  d\\b\eo_kx g^b`Œ rbcŒhx _\m gtf^a  _bY _dhŒ_hq ˆ‰‰  q  ‹…u‘ _  f\f^_c ‹^`obj af`ad^f lg^ …fza u\eb\ff^b\eq [\ X$"   $ #   #  $ X " $  $ Z ##$ 

 Z  #" x  g]f\o_ef\x W f\k_^Œq ‡ bgto_\ W fncb\ _\m  go\ …_baq ˆ‰‰  q …of dhf gl _ ]hi`ogcb\edbhab` m_a_t_hf b\ aof hbk]cbj v`_abg\ gl afza lg^ _]o_hb` ^f_mf^hq [\ ~ f^j tg\\fx ˆ‰‰  ‚ q

!

*

+

+

}b`o_fc uco_m_m _\m  _`wdfh gtb\q ˆ‰‰  q ‹\ gnf^nbfp gl ‡ ’  us ‹ ^fdh_tcf `gk]^fof\j hbnf hi\a_`ab` ^f_cbY _abg\ `gk]g\f\aq …f`oj \b`_c f]g^a ‰  jŠx W f]a gl }_aofk_ab`h _\m  gk]daf^ ‡ `bf\`fx  f\  d^bg\ ’\bnf^hbaix [hj ^_fcq gef^ un_\h _\m  f^_cm  _ Y m_^q ˆ‰‰  q W ‹… s _ c_\ed_ef lg^ cfzb`_c Œ\gpcfmef ^f]^fhf\a_j abg\q  $ Z ##$   Z  #" x ••q gef^  _^hbmfx  fgŽ^fi € ff`ox _\m  fgŽ^fi ‡ _k]hg\q ˆ‰  & q  "$ Z ##$     $     "$X Z  %   X$ " q € g\ej k_\x € g\mg\q € _d^b _^aad\f\x  f_\j  bf^^f  o_\gmx  ^feg^i  ^flf\hafaafx _\m ‹\\f ‡ `obccf^q ˆ‰‰  q fedj c_^ fz]^fhhbg\h lg^ c_\ed_ef f\eb\ff^b\eq ' # Z X  Z     X x • ~ ‚ sŠ–  •‰q € _d^b _^aad\f\q ˆ‰‰ q  g\ha^d`ab\e cfzb`_c a^_\hmd`f^hq [\ X$"  $ #   #  $ X " $  $ Z # #$   Z  #" x ]_efh Š  ˆˆx igagx  _]_\q bkkg ghŒf\\bfkbq ˆ‰  q …pgjcfnfc kgmfc lg^ kg^]ogcgeb`_c _\_cihbhq [\  #   #X  #$   $ #  $ X " $ 1 X #4 "   #    " x ]_efh       –x _^ch^dofx  f^k_\iq  go\ € fnb\fx …g\i }_hg\x _\m W gde  ^gp\q ˆ‰‰•q    "" q  „ fbcci _\m ‹hhg`b_afhx hf`g\m fmbabg\q }ba`o }_^`dhx  f_a^b`f ‡ _\ag^b\bx _\m }_^i ‹\\ }_^`b\Œbfpb` Y q ˆ‰‰q  dbcmj b\e _ c_^ef _\\ga_afm `g^]dh gl u\ecbhos aof  f\\ …^fft_\Œq  $ Z ##$   Z  #" x ˆ‰ ~• ‚ sˆ Šq  o^bhab_\ }_aaobfhhf\q ˆ‰  q ‡ ihafkb`  ^_kj k_^ b\ `gk]da_abg\s …of  befc `_hfq [\ X$

}fo^i_^ }go^bq ˆ‰‰  q  \ hgkf _]]cb`_abg\h gl v\bafjha_af _dagk_a_ aofg^i ag \_ad^_c c_\j ed_ef ]^g`fhhb\eq ' #Z X  Z      X x • ~ ˆ ‚ s ˆ  Šq  go\  f^tg\\fx fmbag^q ˆ‰‰  q  Z #"  # %  q € f`ad^f  gafhq  ‡€ [  dtcb`_j abg\hx ‡ a_\lg^mx ’ ‡ ‹q b`o_^m  gpf^x W g\b_ ‡ `gaax _\m gef^ un_\hq ˆ‰‰  q r o_a  gd ‡ ff [h ro_a  gd }f_\as mbj ^f`a Œ\gpcfmef fmbab\e pbao \_ad^_c c_\ed_ef lffmt_`Œq [\ X$"  $ #   #     Z X$   $ X " $ 1 X#4 "   #   "  1    x  ^beoag\x ’ q  _dc  ^g`af^q ˆ‰‰–q   %X    #X #$   "#$ X $   q  _kt^bmef ’\bnf^hbai  ^fhhq  fgŽ^fi  dccdk _\m ‹^\gcm  pb`Œiq [\ ]^f]_j ^_abg\q € b`f\hb\e gl ]^ghgmb` lf_ad^fh ti hi\a_`ab` ^dcfhs aof Œfi ag _dzbcb_^i ^fmd`j abg\q b^ha nf^hbg\ ]^fhf\afm ag aof ‹\\d_c }ffab\e gl aof € b\edbhab` ‡ g`bfai gl ‹kf^b`_x  ob`_egx [ccb\gbhx  _\d_^i ˆ‰‰ & q ‹n_bc_tcf _a  oaa]s††pppqch_m`qg^e†pft•†‰‰kgm_tlg^k qoak  q  obcb] db\c_\q ˆ‰‰•q   $X  " $  Z#"  # %  q  zlg^m ’\bnf^hbai  ^fhhq  ^_fkf ba`obfx  ^_o_k dhhfccx ‹c_\  c_`Œx _\m ‡ af]of\  dck_\q ˆ‰‰•q  $ Z ##$   $X $$  X"#"  "    $X # 

   "$ q }[…  ^fhhq  fgŽ^fi ‡ _k]hg\q ˆ‰‰–q   $X #  "$ Z #X q  zlg^m ’\bnf^hbai  ^fhhq ‡ ad_^a ‡ obftf^x  f^a _\ n_\  gg^mx gtf^a }gg^fx _\m f^\_\mg  f^fb^_q ˆ‰‰Šq ‡ fk_\j ab` of_mjm^bnf\ ef\f^_abg\q  $ Z ##$ 

 Z  #" x ˆ  ~ ˆ ‚ s&  ˆ & q € ba_ …_icg^ _\m  f^^i \gpcfhq ˆ‰  q }_\j "  $ #    #  $ X " $ #  Z X$  d_c gl b\lg^k_abg\ ag _``gk]_\i aof ‡ u    #X $ #  1  $" #$ $X  $ Z ##$   g^]dhs aof k_`ob\fj^f_m_tcf `g^]dh gl h]gj

 Z  #" x ]_efh ˆ––  ˆ  x  bh_x [a_ciq Œf\ u\ecbhoq }_\dh`^b]ax ’\bnf^hbai gl € _\j  fg^ef }bccf^x b`o_^m  f`Œpbaox  o^bhab_\f `_haf^x ’ q fcct_dk x W f^fŒ  ^ghhx _aof^b\f }bccf^x _\m  f^a _\ n_\  gg^mq ˆ‰‰ˆq }g^]ogcgei b\ _\mff …f\ebq ˆ‰‰q     X $  $X }b}g•q }_\dh`^b]ax ’\bnf^hbai gl ’a^f`oax ' # q  ^b\`fag\ ’\bnf^hbaix  ^b\`fag\x  q q  dbmg }b\\f\ _\m  go\  _^^gccq ’\mf^ ^fnbfpq …of  faof^c_\mhq   #   X$ %Z  #  $X $$ " X$" #$$ $X X "#" '  " #$  q gef^ }baag\q ˆ‰‰•q ‹ mfh`^b]abg\ gl _ `gk]daf^jdh_tcf mb`abg\_^i vcf t_hfm g\ aof  zlg^m ‹mn_\`fm € f_^\f^„h W b`abgj \_^i gl  d^^f\a u\ecbhoq ‹n_bc_tcf _a  la]s††ga_qgzq_`qdŒ†]dt†ga_†]dtcb`†mb`ah† & ˆŠ† afza & ˆŠqmg`  q +

+

*

+

.

+

*

*

+

*

/

/

.

+

*

/

+

+

*

/

/

/

+

*

+

*

. +

)

*

/

)

+

.

+

+

+

/

+

+

/

/



*

+

208

+

)

*

+

+

+

*

Suggest Documents