Solving a Possibilistic Linear Program qhrough ... - UPCommons

5 downloads 5230 Views 537KB Size Report
lution of the problem depends critically on this degree of feasibility, which is ... bi-objective problem that we will solve through a Compromise Programming.
sYbs„‚ m 7BP ]B8}Z$t  w1(((D dxTdM;

7Bj%$t s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$t‚s„ _„B„s8 qY„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t F$8?‚t‚9 N?B}‚9 @  iBI„?Z‚9 =„?s z V„‚tsR  $jAsB V @ *}B e{BtB8?s V}j${sIs y =t$%‚„R$IsI I‚j _s?R zsR{B 7}s$t ‚Z}`$jB8oR‚‚YZ‚R  *}B e{BtB8?s ]Zst$s$%s =t$%‚„R$IsI I‚ !%$‚IB 7}s$t 8s„$s8s„oR{${}IZt$B%$‚R

VAR„s{ yt Y$R }s}‚„ b‚ }„B}BR‚ s 8‚YBI B RBj%‚ s j$t‚s„ }„B„s88$t }„BAj‚8 $t%Bj%$t PZ99k }s„s8‚‚„R bYBR‚ }BRR$A$j$k I$R„$AZ$BtR s„‚ $%‚t Ak PZ99k tZ8A‚„R qB sII„‚RR Y‚ sAB%‚ }„BAj‚8 b‚ Ys%‚ ZR‚I s }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ „‚js$BtT RY$} BP PZ99k tZ8A‚„R Ys j‚sIR ZR B s RBj%$t 8‚YBI Ys }„BIZ{‚R Y‚ RBT{sjj‚I

TI‚„‚‚ P‚sR$Aj‚ RBjZ$BtR

y 8ZR A‚ }B$t‚I BZ Ys Y‚ htsj RBT

jZ$Bt BP Y‚ }„BAj‚8 I‚}‚tIR {„$${sjjk Bt Y$R I‚„‚‚ BP P‚sR$A$j$k bY${Y $R $t {Bt4${ b$Y Y‚ B}$8sj %sjZ‚ BP Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt qY‚t * Ps{‚R s A$TBA`‚{$%‚ }„BAj‚8 Ys b‚ b$jj RBj%‚ Y„BZY s ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t s}}„Bs{Y bYBR‚ RBjZ$Bt j‚R Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ ‚-}„‚RR Y$R Bbt }„‚P‚„‚t{‚R sABZ P‚sR$A$j$k %‚„RZR B}$8sj$k !Z„ }„B}BR‚I 8‚YBI b$jj A‚ $jjZR„s‚I Ak s tZ8‚„${sj ‚-s8}j‚

€‚kbB„IRU

N$t‚s„ _„B„s88$t 3Z99k WZ8A‚„ ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s8T

8$t _BRR$A$j$k *$R„$AZ$Bt e-}‚{‚I $t‚„%sj e-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚

3Z99k

tZ8A‚„R „st,$t

V7 ]NV77y3y]Vqy!W wddDU (g (, (g 13 d

yt„BIZ{$Bt

N$t‚s„ }„B„s88$t wN_D $R Y‚ B}$8$Rs$Bt ‚{Yt$JZ‚ 8BR P„‚JZ‚tjk s}}j$‚I $t „‚sjTbB„jI }„BAj‚8R stI Y‚„‚PB„‚ $ $R %‚„k $8}B„st B $t„BIZ{‚ $t Y‚ s}}„Bs{Y t‚b sR}‚{R Ys sjjBb Y‚ 8BI‚j B h $tB Y‚ „‚sj bB„jI sR 8Z{Y sR }BRR$Aj‚ Vtk j$t‚s„ }„B„s88$t 8BI‚j „‚}„‚R‚t$t „‚sjTbB„jI R$Zs$BtR $t%Bj%‚R s jB BP }s„s8‚‚„R bYBR‚ %sjZ‚R s„‚ sRR$t‚I Ak Y‚ ‚-}‚„R stI $t Y‚ {Bt%‚t$Btsj s}}„Bs{Y Y‚k s„‚ „‚JZ$„‚I B h- st ‚-s{ %sjZ‚ B Y‚ sPB„‚8‚t$Bt‚I }s„s8‚‚„R d1HD stI „st,$t 8‚YBIR IB tB sjbskR s„‚‚ b$Y ‚s{Y BY‚„ *$&‚„‚t }„B}‚„$‚R Ys%‚ A‚‚t s}}j$‚I B `ZR$Pk „st,$t 8‚YBIR RZ{Y sRU I$R$tZ$RYsA$j$k w B„Bjst stI *‚st$ >1HD „s$Btsj$k wWs,s8Z„s >MHD PZ99k B„ j$tZ$R${ }„‚R‚ts$Bt w*‚jsIB z‚„I‚sk stI z$js >;H stI qBt stI Bt$RBt‚ >ddHD stI „BAZRt‚RR wOZst >d;HD yt Y$R }s}‚„ b‚ ZR‚ s 8‚YBI wF$8t‚9 >HD Ys %‚„$h‚R sjj Y‚ sAB%‚ }„B}‚„$‚R stI Ys A‚R$I‚R $R {B8}Zs$Btsjjk ‚^{$‚t B RBj%‚ st N_ }„BAj‚8 A‚{sZR‚ $ }„‚R‚„%‚R $R j$t‚s„$k NBB,$t s Y‚ }„B}‚„k BP „‚}„‚R‚t$t Y‚ }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ „‚js$BtRY$} $t j$tZ$R${ B„ PZ99k ‚„8R „st,$t 8‚YBIR {st A‚ {jsRR$h‚I $t bB s}}„Bs{Y‚R !t‚ BP Y‚8 sRRB{$s‚R Ak 8‚stR BP I$&‚„‚t PZt{$BtR ‚s{Y PZ99k tZ8A‚„ B s R$tj‚ }B$t BP Y‚ „‚sj j$t‚ stI Y‚t s Bsj {„$R} B„I‚„ „‚js$BtRY$} A‚b‚‚t PZ99k tZ8A‚„R $R ‚RsAj$RY‚I qY‚ BY‚„ s}}„Bs{Y „st,R PZ99k tZ8A‚„R Ak 8‚stR BP s PZ99k „‚js$BtRY$} y sjjBbR I‚{$R$Bt 8s,‚„R B }„‚R‚t Y‚$„ }„‚P‚„‚t{‚R $t s „sIZsj bsk bY${Y $t st N_ }„B„s8 }‚„8$R ZR B YstIj‚ b$Y I$&‚„‚t I‚„‚‚R BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR stI b$Y „‚s„I B BA`‚{$%‚ %sjZ‚ $ sjjBbR ZR B jBB, PB„ s tBt IB8$ts‚I Rs$RPk$t RBjZ$Bt !A%$BZRjk $P Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ ‚RsAj$RY‚R s Y$Y I‚„‚‚ BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR PB„ s RBjZ$Bt Y‚ P‚sR$Aj‚ RBjZ$BtR R‚ A‚{B8‚R j‚RR stI {BtR‚JZ‚tjk Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ B}$8sj %sjZ‚ $R bB„R‚ 7B Y‚ * YsR B htI s Asjst{‚I RBjZ$Bt A‚b‚‚t bB BA`‚{$%‚R $t {Bt4${U B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt %sjZ‚ stI B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR yt B„I‚„ B sII„‚RR Y‚ sAB%‚ }„BAj‚8 $ YsR A‚‚t RZ‚R‚I PB„8Zjs$t st sZ-$j$s„k A$TBA`‚{$%‚ }„B„s8 Ys b‚ b$jj RBj%‚ Y„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s8T 8$t qY‚ }s}‚„ {Bt{jZI‚R b$Y s tZ8‚„${sj ‚-s8}j‚ B {js„$Pk Y‚ }„B}BR‚I 8‚YBIBjB${sj s}}„Bs{Y 1

_BRR$A$j$R${ j$t‚s„ }„B„s8

yt s }„‚%$BZR }s}‚„ >dH b‚ }„B}BR‚I B RBj%‚ Y‚ PBjjBb$t }BRR$A$j$R${ j$t‚s„ }„BT „s8U $t$8$9‚ FK ) K ?  + wdD K  KK, ?  ( RZA`‚{ B ? ;  w\,K KKD ) ? ; {p b \? bY‚„‚ K ) wK@, K, 3 3 3 , K D \K ) >Ky H  KK ) wKK@, KK , 3 3 3 , KK D „‚}„‚R‚t PZ99k }s„sT 8‚‚„R bYBR‚ }BRR$A$j$k I$R„$AZ$BtR s„‚ $%‚t Ak PZ99k tZ8A‚„R 0

z

z

7i E?z

E

7Bj%$t s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$t‚s„ _„B„s8 qY„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t d

!Z„ s}}„Bs{Y $t Y‚ }„‚%$BZR }s}‚„ sjjBb‚I ZR B BAs$t s PZ99k B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt $t Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ R}s{‚ PB„ }„BAj‚8 wdD yt Y‚ }„‚R‚t bB„, b‚ }„B}BR‚ BAs$t$t s tBt PZ99k B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt $t Y‚ I‚{$R$Bt %s„$sAj‚R R}s{‚ B Y‚ Rs8‚ }„BAj‚8 qB IB Ys Y‚ PBjjBb$t JZ‚R$BtR >H s„$R‚U BP s I‚{$R$Bt %‚{B„ - bY‚t Y‚ }s„s8‚‚„R dD H !Y‚„R Ak ZR$t RB8‚ „‚js$BtRY$} BP {B8}s„$RBt BP PZ99k tZ8A‚„R $‚ ]sI‚tsR stI z‚„I‚sk >nH 7s,sbs >H !Z„ s}}„Bs{Y A‚jBtR B Y‚ R‚{BtI „BZ} G‚ ZR‚ s PZ99k „‚js$BtRY$} B {B8}s„‚ PZ99k tZ8A‚„R I‚%‚jB}‚I Ak F$8t‚9 >H Ys %‚„$Pk BBI }„B}‚„$‚R RZ{YU I$R$tZ$RYsA$j$k „s$Btsj$k PZ99k }„‚R‚ts$Bt stI „BAZRt‚RR qY$R 8‚YBI $R {B8}Zs$Btsjjk ‚^{$‚t B RBj%‚ st N_ }„BAj‚8 A‚{sZR‚ $ }„‚R‚„%‚R Y‚ j$t‚s„$k BP Y‚ }„BAj‚8 ‚PB„‚ }„‚R‚t$t Y‚ }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ „‚js$BtRY$} BP PZ99k tZ8A‚„R Ys b‚ b$jj ZR‚ b‚ RYBZjI „‚{sjj Y‚ tB$BtR BP Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I $t‚„%sj stI Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚ BP s PZ99k tZ8A‚„ xH I‚ht‚R Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I $t‚„%sj BP s PZ99k tZ8A‚„ yK bY${Y b$jj A‚ tB‚I o{ wKyD sRU P‚sR$A$j$k

B}$8sj$k

wKD ) >o@ , o H ) y

o{ y bY‚„‚

Wy w_D

stI

/y w_D

y

@

W d w_D Q_,

8

y



d

(

]

/ d w_D Q_ y

w1D

s„‚ Y‚ j‚P stI Y‚ „$Y YstI R$I‚ BP Y‚ 8‚8A‚„RY$}

PZt{$Bt BP Y‚ PZ99k tZ8A‚„ y K bY${Y b$jj A‚ tB‚I

}8

o~ wKyD sRU

VtI Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚ BP s PZ99k tZ8A‚„ y K

o~ wKyD )

ody L o1y

wnD

1

yP y K ) wyd , y1 , yn , y; D $R s „s}‚9B$Isj PZ99k tZ8A‚„ $R ‚-}‚{‚I $t‚„%sj stI $R ‚-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚ {st A‚ {sj{Zjs‚I %‚„k ‚sR$jkU

o{ wKyD )

}

yd L y1 yn L y; , 1

1

]



o~ wKyD )

yd L y1 L yn L y; ;

w;D

*‚ht$$Bt d PZ99k

3B„ stk }s$„ BP PZ99k tZ8A‚„R y K k K K b‚ I‚ht‚ Y‚ „‚js$BtRY$} BP K }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ - wK y, KD Y„BZY Y‚ PBjjBb$t 8‚8A‚„RY$} PZt{$Bt >HU

y, KKD ) - wK

T € z € Z

(

o!y oAK o!y oAK woAy o!K D

d

o1y  odK c ( o J R$ ( ; ody  o1K , o1y  odK R$ ody  o1K k ( R$

wxD

p Q K, K K $R Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ BP yK B%‚„ KK  bY‚„‚ - y p Q yP - y K, K K   b‚ I‚tB‚ $ Ak yK  KK stI b‚ Rsk Ys yK $R „‚s‚„ Yst KK s p Q K, K K ) d1  b‚ Rsk Ys yK stI KK s„‚ $tI$&‚„‚t j‚sR $t s I‚„‚‚  GY‚t - y

dM

 F$8?‚t‚9 N?B}‚9 z iBI„?Z‚9 =„?s  V„‚tsR  m V $jAsB

*‚ht$$Bt 1 V I‚{$R$Bt %‚{B„ ? ; {pz $R Rs$I B A‚ TP‚sR$Aj‚ B }„BAj‚8 wdD $PU - wyi ?, Ki Di )

wED

yKi ?  KKi ,  i ) d, 3 3 3 , E

wD

8$t \

i @,333,E

Ys $R B Rsk $P

qY‚„‚PB„‚ sP‚„ wxD b‚ b„$‚ Y‚ PBjjBb$t ‚-}„‚RR$BtU J

o

wd  DoyE L o@yE ?  oKE L wd  Do@KE wMD qY‚ R‚ BP sjj TP‚sR$Aj‚ I‚{$R$Bt %‚{B„R $R I‚tB‚I Ak  w D 3„B8 I‚ht$$Bt 1 Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„B}‚„k $88‚I$s‚jk PBjjBbRU wD

@ c  p  w @ D V  w  D k 8‚stR BP I‚ht$$Bt 1 b‚ Ys%‚ stRb‚„‚I Y‚ h„R JZ‚R$BtU YBb B I‚ht‚ P‚sR$A$j$k bY‚t Y‚ {BtR„s$tR $t%Bj%‚ PZ99k tZ8A‚„R 7$t{‚ $tI${s‚R Y‚ P‚sR$A$j$k I‚„‚‚ BP ‚s{Y {BtR„s$t d  {st A‚ $t‚„T }„‚‚I sR Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP ZtP‚sR$A$j$k $‚ d  $%‚R ZR s 8‚sRZ„‚ BP „$R, BP %$Bjs$Bt BP RZ{Y {BtR„s$t qB stRb‚„ Y‚ R‚{BtI JZ‚R$BtU YBb B I‚ht‚ Y‚ B}$8sj$k PB„ st BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt b$Y PZ99k }s„s8‚‚„R b‚ {BtR$I‚„ Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„BAj‚8U $t$8$9‚ FK ) K? wd(D RZA`‚{ B U ? ;  w\, KD ) \? ; {pz b \?  K, ?  (i bY‚„‚ Y‚ PZ99k }s„s8‚‚„R s„‚ Btjk $t Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt V{{B„I$t B Y‚ „st,$t 8‚YBI $%‚t $t I‚ht$$Bt d b‚ {st Rsk YsU *‚ht$$Bt n ?L ;  w\, KD $R Rs$I B A‚ st s{{‚}sAj‚ B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wd(D $P $ $R %‚„$h‚I YsU wddD K? @b K?L , ? ;  w\, KD 3„B8 I‚ht$$Bt d Y‚ sAB%‚ ‚-}„‚RR$Bt {st A‚ b„$‚t sR PBjjBbRU  o ?  o@ ? d wd1D o ?  o@ ? L o ?  o@ ? 1 RB Ys o@ ? L o ?  o@ ? L o ? wdnD 1 1 qY‚„‚PB„‚ P„B8 ‚JZs$Bt wnD stI I‚ht$$Bt n Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„B}BR$$Bt {st A‚ Rs‚IU _„B}BR$$Bt d ?L ; {pz $R st s{{‚}sAj‚ B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wd(D $P stI 0 L

0

0

0

0 L

0

0 L

0 L

0 L

Btjk $P $ $R st B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B Y‚ PBjjBb$t {„$R} j$t‚s„ }„B„s8U

$t$8$9‚ o~ wKD? RZA`‚{ B U ? ;  w\, KD

wd;D

7Bj%$t s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$t‚s„ _„B„s8 qY„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t

d

bY‚„‚ o~ wKD ) wo~ wK@ D, o~ wK D, 3 3 3 , o~ wKz DD V{{B„I$t B Y$R „‚RZj b‚ 8sk ‚RsAj$RY Y‚ PBjjBb$t I‚ht$$Bt „‚js‚I B Y‚ $t$$sj PZ99k 8BI‚j wdD *‚ht$$Bt ; ?L ; {pz $R Rs$I B A‚ st B }„BAj‚8 wdD $P $ $R st B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„BAj‚8U $t$8$9‚ o~ wKD? wdxD RZA`‚{ B U ? ; w D qY„BZY Y$R 8BI‚j b‚ Ys%‚ RZAR$Z‚I Y‚ $t$$sj PZ99k }„B„s8 wdD PB„ s {„$R}

T}s„s8‚„${ j$t‚s„ }„B„s8 3„B8 wD Y‚ BAs$t$t BP s A‚‚„ %sjZ‚ B Y‚ B}$8sj BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt $8}j$‚R s j‚RR‚„ I‚„‚‚ BP P‚sR$A$j$k BP Y‚ {BtR„s$tR qY‚t Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ „ZtR $tB bB {Bt4${$t BA`‚{$%‚RU B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt %sjZ‚ stI B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR qB BAs$t s Asjst{‚I RBjZ$Bt B Y$R }„BAj‚8 b$Y bB BA`‚{$%‚R $t {Bt4${ b‚ Ys%‚ I„sbt Z} st sZ-$j$s„k A$BA`‚{$%‚ }„B„s8 sR RYBbt $t Y‚ PBjjBb$t R‚{$Bt TB}$8sj RBjZ$Bt

n

V A$BA`‚{$%‚ }„BAj‚8U Y‚ }sk B& 8s„$- stI Y‚ $I‚sj }B$t

V{{B„I$t B Y‚ sAB%‚ {BtR$I‚„s$BtR b‚ }„B}BR‚ „s$R$t Y‚ }„BAj‚8 wdD ss$t Y„BZY Y‚ PBjjBb$t tBtTj$t‚s„ A$BA`‚{$%‚ }„BAj‚8U $t$8$9‚ FKw?D ) K? s-$8$9‚ RZA`‚{ B U wdED J o wd  Doy L o@y ?  oK L wd  Do@K ,  i ?  (, (   d qY‚ R‚ BP P‚sR$Aj‚ RBjZ$BtR BP 8BI‚j wdED $R I‚tB‚I Ak   *‚ht$$Bt x w? , D ;  $R Rs$I B A‚ s _s„‚B B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B wdED $P Y‚„‚ IB‚R tB ‚-$R stBY‚„ w?, D ;  RZ{Y Ys K? @b K? wdD stI wdMD

 bY‚„‚ s j‚sR Bt‚ BP Y‚R‚ $t‚JZsj$$‚R $R R„${ 3„B8 I‚ht$$BtR ; stI x b‚ I‚IZ{‚ Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„B}BR$$BtU _„B}BR$$Bt 1 Vjj _s„‚B B}$8sj RBjZ$BtR w? , D B }„BAj‚8 wdED s„‚ T i

i

E

E

RBjZ$BtR B }„BAj‚8 wdD stI „‚{$}„B{sjjk

_„BBP N‚ w? , D A‚ st TRBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdD AZ tB s _s„‚B !}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdED Y‚t Y‚„‚ ‚-$RR stBY‚„ w?, D %‚„$hk$t wdD stI wdMD bY‚„‚ s j‚sR Bt‚ BP Y‚R‚ $t‚JZsj$$‚R $R R„${

 F$8?‚t‚9 N?B}‚9 z iBI„?Z‚9 =„?s  V„‚tsR  m V $jAsB

dM(

3„B8 wdD stI Y‚ }„B}BR$$Bt d b‚ Ys%‚U o~ wKD?  o~ wKD? stI P„B8 wdMD ? ; w D Y‚t ? $R tB st B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdxD stI w? , D $R tB st TRBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdD VtI „‚{$}„B{sjjk j‚ w? , D A‚ s _s„‚B !}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdED AZ tB st TB}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdD 3„B8 I‚ht$$Bt ; Y‚„‚ $R stBY‚„ ? ; w D RZ{Y Ys o~ wKD?  o~ wKD? P„B8 wnD b‚ Ys%‚ Ys K? k@b K? stI w? , D $R tB s _s„‚B RBjZ$Bt B }„BAj‚8 wdED " 78sjj I‚„‚‚R BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR {st tB A‚ s{{‚}‚I Ak Y‚ *‚{$R$BtT s,‚„ yP  $R Y‚ 8$t$8Z8 I‚„‚‚ BP P‚sR$A$j$k BP {BtR„s$tR Ys Y‚ I‚{$R$Bt 8s,‚„ $R b$jj$t B sI8$ Y‚ P‚sR$A$j$k $t‚„%sj BP $t  $R „‚IZ{‚I B    d G‚ „‚P‚„ B Y$R t‚b }„BAj‚8 sR wdETA$RDU

BI‚j wdED b$YU    d qB RBj%‚ Y‚ }„BAj‚8 wdETA$RD Y„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t $ $R t‚{‚RRs„k B BAs$t Y‚ }skTB& 8s„$- qB IB Ys b‚ B}$8$R‚ ‚s{Y BA`‚{$%‚ R‚}s„s‚jk {sjT {Zjs$t Y‚ %sjZ‚ „‚s{Y‚I Ak Y‚ BY‚„ BA`‚{$%‚ Bt Y‚ B}$8sj I‚{$R$Bt %s„$sAj‚ qY$R 8s„$- sjjBbR ZR B JZst$Pk Y‚ {Bt4${ j‚%‚j A‚b‚‚t Y‚ bB BA`‚{$%‚R yt BZ„ {sR‚ b‚ {st BAs$t Y‚ bB „BbR BP Y‚ 8s„$- Rs„$t P„B8 Y‚ 8$tB„ stI „‚s‚„ P‚sR$A$j$k I‚„‚‚RU

)



stI

) d

V{{B„I$t B I‚ht$$Bt ; Ys

8‚stR RBj%$t Y‚ PBjjBb$t bB {„$R} 8BtBTBA`‚{$%‚ }„B„s8RU

)   bYBR‚ B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt ? w  D $%‚R Y‚ PZ99k tZ8A‚„ F K w  D )  K? w  D sR }BRR$A$j$k I$R„$AZ$Bt BP Y‚ {B„„‚R}BtI$t B}$8sj sD _„BAj‚8 wdxD b$Y

BA`‚{$%‚ %sjZ‚

) d bYBR‚ B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt ? wdD $%‚R Y‚ PZ99k K? wdD sR }BRR$A$j$k I$R„$AZ$Bt BP Y‚ {B„„‚R}BtI$t B}$8sj tZ8A‚„ F K wdD )  AD _„BAj‚8 wdxD b$Y

BA`‚{$%‚ %sjZ‚ qY‚„‚PB„‚ Y‚ }sk B& 8s„$- $R Y‚ PBjjBb$t

!A`‚$%‚ 3Zt{$Bt !A`‚$%‚ 3Zt{$Bt 3‚sR$A$j$k *‚„‚‚

FK w  D FK wdD

3‚sR$A$j$k *‚„‚‚

 d

F ,

qY‚ ‚j‚8‚tR BP }„$t{$}sj I$sBtsj wK w  D dD PB„8 Y‚ $I‚sj }B$t bY${Y B}$T 8$R‚R Y‚ bB BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$BtR R$8Zjst‚BZRjk !A%$BZRjk Y‚ $I‚sj }B$t $R Ztss$tsAj‚

F

!t Y‚ BY‚„ YstI Y‚ R‚{ZtIs„k I$sBtsj PB„8R Y‚ st$T$I‚sj

,  D

}B$t wK wdD

;

]B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$BtR

qY‚ ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t s}}„Bs{Y B RBj%‚ s 8Zj$BA`‚{$%‚ B}$8$9s$Bt }„BAj‚8 $R AsR‚I Bt Y‚ $I‚s Ys s „s$Btsj *‚{$R$Bt s,‚„ RYBZjI {YBBR‚ Y‚

7Bj%$t s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$t‚s„ _„B„s8 qY„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t

dMd

_s„‚B B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt B„ st s„‚s BP _s„‚B B}$8sj R‚ Ys $R t‚s„‚R B Y‚ $I‚sj }B$t qY‚ }B$tR Ys %‚„$h‚I Y‚ }„‚%$BZR }„B}‚„k s„‚ {sjj‚I {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$BtR yt BZ„ {sR‚ w}„BAj‚8 wdETA$RDD Y‚ }B$tR BP Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ R}s{‚ Ys%‚ Y‚ PB„8

F ? , D b$Y FKw?D ) K? Ys $R B Rsk Y‚ h„R {B8}Bt‚t $R s PZ99k tZ8A‚„

wKw D



Rsk Ys Y‚k s„‚ PZ99k }B$tR qB htI Y‚ {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$BtR $ $R t‚{‚RRs„k B I‚ht‚ Y‚ I$Rst{‚ A‚b‚‚t ‚s{Y BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt

WE

stI $R $I‚sj %sjZ‚

I$Rst{‚ A‚b‚‚t PZ99k tZ8A‚„R >EHU

WE 

G‚ bB„, b$Y Y‚

QwKy, KKD ) /o~ wKyD  o~ wKKD/

QE 

8‚st wdD

3„B8 wdD b‚ {st ‚RsAj$RY Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„B}BR$$BtU

_„B}BR$$Bt n Vtk {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$Bt B Y‚ PBjjBb$t {„$R} }„B„s8U

$t$8$9‚ o~ >FKw?DH ) o~ wKD? s-$8$9‚ RZA`‚{ B U J y o K

 DoO L o@ ?  o L wd  Do@K ,  i ?  (,    d wd

E

E

E

E

$R sjRB s {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$Bt B PZ99k }„B„s8 wdETA$RD stI „‚{$}„B{sjjk

w1(D

yt BZ„ {sR‚ b‚ {st I‚ht‚ Y‚ I$Rst{‚ A‚b‚‚t ‚s{Y BA`‚{$%‚ %sjZ‚ stI Y‚ {B„„‚R}BtI$t $I‚sj %sjZ‚ sR PBjjBbRU Q@ wKF w?D, FK w  DD ) /o~ wKFw?DD  o~ wKF w  DD/ w1dD Q w , dD ) d  VR Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚R s„‚ 8‚sRZ„‚I $t I$&‚„‚t Zt$R $ $R t‚{‚RRs„k B YB8B‚t$R‚ Y‚ I$Rst{‚RU o~ wKD?  o~ wKF w  DD Q@ )  Q ) dd

w11D o~ wKF wdDD  o~ wKF w  DD  qB I‚‚„8$t‚ sjj }BRR$Aj‚ {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$BtR b‚ {BtR$I‚„ Y‚ PBjjBb$t I$RT st{‚ 8‚sRZ„‚RU F € € @b€ PB„ d  € c w1nD U€ ) >wP@ Q@ D L wP Q D H PB„ € ) 8s- wP@ Q@ , P Q D GY‚„‚ P@ stI P s„‚ Y‚ b‚$Y Ys „‚}„‚R‚t Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„:R }„‚P‚T „‚t{‚R b$Y „‚s„I B Y‚ I$%‚„‚t{‚ A‚b‚‚t ‚s{Y BA`‚{$%‚ %sjZ‚ stI $R $I‚sj %sjZ‚ V {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$Bt $R Y‚ Bt‚ bY${Y 8$t$8$R‚R U€  qY‚„‚PB„‚ b‚ b$jj RBj%‚ Y‚ PBjjBb$t {„$R} 8BtBBA`‚{$%‚ }„B„s8U $t$8$9‚ U€ RZA`‚{ B U J o w1;D wd  Doy L o@y ?  oK L wd  Do@K ,  i ?  (,    d E

E

E

E

dM1

 F$8?‚t‚9 N?B}‚9 z iBI„?Z‚9 =„?s  V„‚tsR  m V $jAsB

!A%$BZRjk Y‚ RBjZ$Bt I‚}‚tIR Bt Y‚ {YBR‚t 8‚„${ k %s„k$t } P„B8 d B  Y‚ R‚ BP {B8}„B8$R‚ RBjZ$BtR {st A‚ I‚‚„8$t‚I qB $jjZR„s‚ Y‚ }„B}BR‚I 8‚YBIBjBk s }BRR$A$j$R${ j$t‚s„ }„B„s8 $R }„B%$I‚I sR s tZ8‚„${sj ‚-s8}j‚ x

WZ8‚„${sj ‚-s8}j‚

N‚ A‚ Y‚ PBjjBb$t s }BRR$A$j$R${ j$t‚s„ }„B„s8UU $t$8$9‚ wd, 1(, 1dD?d L w1, n(, ndD?1 RZA`‚{ B U w;3x, x, x3xD?d L w13x, n, ;D?1  wd;, 1((, 1(ED wn, ;, xD?d L wE3x, , 3xD?1  w1n(, 1;(, 1x(D ?d  (, ?1  (

w1xD

3B„ R$8}j${$k b‚ Ys%‚ RZ}}BR‚I Ys sjj $8}„‚{$R‚ }s„s8‚‚„R s„‚ „$stZjs„ PZ99k tZ8A‚„R AZ stk BY‚„ PZ99k tZ8A‚„R {BZjI A‚ $8}j‚8‚t‚I N‚ ZR sRRZ8‚ Ys Y‚ 8$t$8Z8 I‚„‚‚ BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR Ys * $R b$jj$t B s{{‚} $R ( ) (3; V{{B„I$t B ‚-}„‚RR$Bt wdETA$RD b‚ b$jj RBj%‚ Y‚ }„BAj‚8U $t$8$9‚ wd, 1(, 1dD?d L w1, n(, ndD?1 s-$8$9‚ w1ED RZA`‚{ B U ? ;  w D, (3;   d qB BAs$t Y‚ }sk B& 8s„$- $ $R t‚{‚RRs„k B RBj%‚ Y‚ sAB%‚ }„BAj‚8 PB„

) (3; stI PB„ ) d Y‚t s{{B„I$t B ‚}$„s}Y 1 b‚ b$jj RBj%‚ }„B„s8 wdxD b$Y ) (3; stI PB„ ) dU

!3 3*

!3 3* K w(3;D ) wd(;n31, d(M, ddn;3MD (3; F K wdD ) wdd;3M, d11E, d131D d

F

qY‚ }„$t{$}sj I$sBtsj $R Y‚ $I‚sj }B$tU wKF w(3;D, dD qY‚ {B8}„B8$R‚ R‚ $R BAs$t‚I RBj%$t Y‚ PBjjBb$t }„B„s8R b$Y 8‚„${R U€ B Y‚ {„$R} }„B„s8 w1;D N‚ Pd ) (3x stI P1 ) (3xDU sD b$Y 8‚„${ Ud  b‚ Ys%‚ Y‚ }„BAj‚8U 3 F , E A Ln(?! d(n3x L (3x d $t$8$9‚ Ud ) (3x 1(?d11E d(n3x (3E RZA`‚{ B U >wd  Dx31x L ;3xDH ?d L >wd  Dn3x L 13xDH ?1  w1D  1(n L wd  Dd >wd  D;3x L n3xDH ?d L >wd  D31x L E3xDH ?1   1;x L wd  D1nx (3;   d, ?d  (, ?1  (

7Bj%$t s _BRR$A$j$R${ N$t‚s„ _„B„s8 qY„BZY ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t

dMn

qY‚ RBjZ$Bt $RU ) (3xM ?dd ) 13n ?d1 ) dM31KFd ) wd(M131, dd13E, dd3(ED stI Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚ BP FKd $R dd13E AD b$Y 8‚„${ U Y‚ }„BAj‚8 $RU $t$8$9‚ U ) Q RZA`‚{ B U BI‚j 3 R‚ F w1D {BtR„s$tR A Ln(?! d(n3x  Q (3x 1(?d11E , E d(n3x (3x d( 3E  Q

w1MD

 qY‚ RBjZ$Bt $RU ) (3d ? d ) 13n ?1 ) dM3E  F K ) wdd(3d;, ddx3E;, d1(E3d;D stI Y‚ ‚-}‚{‚I %sjZ‚ BP FK $R ddx3E; ]B8}s„$t Y‚R‚ RBjZ$BtR b$Y Y‚ $I‚sj }B$t b‚ b$jj BAR‚„%‚ Ys Y‚ Bt‚ {B„„‚R}BtI$t B U $R 8B„‚ Asjst{‚I Yst Y‚ BY‚„ stI $ bBZjI A‚ B&‚„‚I B Y‚ I‚{$R$BtT{‚t„‚ sR s RBjZ$Bt yP Y‚ I‚{$R$BtT8s,‚„ IB‚R tB {BtR$I‚„ Y‚ sAB%‚ RBjZ$Bt s{{‚}sAj‚ $ 8sk A‚ Y‚ Rs„$t }B$t BP st $t‚„s{$%‚ }„B{‚RR

E

]Bt{jZR$BtR

yt Y$R }s}‚„ b‚ Ys%‚ }„B}BR‚I s 8‚YBI B RBj%‚ s j$t‚s„ }„B„s88$t }„BAj‚8 $t%Bj%$t PZ99k }s„s8‚‚„R bYBR‚ }BRR$A$j$k I$R„$AZ$BtR s„‚ $%‚t Ak PZ99k tZ8T A‚„R yt s }„‚%$BZR bB„, >dH b‚ YsI RBj%‚I Y‚ Rs8‚ }„BAj‚8 BAs$t$t s PZ99k RBjZ$Bt $t Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ R}s{‚ AZ tBb b‚ Ys%‚ {BtR„Z{‚I s RBj%$t 8‚YBI Ys }„BIZ{‚R {„$R} B}$8sj RBjZ$BtR $t I‚{$R$Bt R}s{‚ qB {BtR„Z{ Y‚ sAB%‚ 8‚YBI s }„‚P‚„‚t{‚ „‚js$BtRY$} BP PZ99k tZ8A‚„R $ YsR A‚‚t ZR‚I qY$R j‚sIR ZR B Y‚ RBT{sjj‚I TI‚„‚‚ P‚sR$Aj‚ RBjZ$BtR stI Y‚t B Y‚ s{{‚}sAjk B}$8sj RBjZ$Bt G‚ Ys%‚ RYBbt Ys Y‚ BAs$t$t BP s A‚‚„ %sjZ‚ B Y‚ B}$8sj BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt $8}j$‚R s j‚RR‚„ I‚„‚‚ BP P‚sR$A$j$k BP Y‚ {BtR„s$tR stI Y‚„‚PB„‚ Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ Ps{‚R s }„BAj‚8 $t%Bj%$t bB {Bt4${$t BA`‚{$%‚RU B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ BA`‚{$%‚ PZt{$Bt %sjZ‚ stI B $8}„B%‚ Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP Rs$RPs{$Bt BP {BtR„s$tR yt Y$R }„BAj‚8 Y‚ I‚„‚‚ BP P‚sR$A$j$k BP {BtR„s$tR A‚{B8‚R s t‚b I‚{$R$Bt %s„$sAj‚ qB BAs$t s Asjst{‚I RBjZ$Bt B Y$R }„BAj‚8 b‚ Ys%‚ RBj%‚I s ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t }„BAj‚8 bY${Y sjjBbR Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ B ‚RsAj$RY I$%‚„R‚ „‚T JZ$„‚8‚tR sABZ P‚sR$A$j$k %‚„RZR B}$8sj$k qY$R R{Y‚8‚ „‚JZ$„‚R s {‚„s$t $tT ‚„s{$Bt b$Y Y‚ *‚{$R$BtTs,‚„ $t B„I‚„ B sI`ZR Y$R R„Z{Z„‚ BP }„‚P‚„‚t{‚R AZ $ $R 8Z{Y 8B„‚ 4‚-$Aj‚ Yst Y‚ ZRZsj PB„8Zjs$BtR qB RBj%‚ Y‚ sAB%‚ ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t }„B„s8 $ YsR A‚‚t t‚{‚RRs„k B ‚-‚tI B _BRR$A$j$R${ _„B„s88$t Y‚ 8s$t „‚RZjR Bt {jsRR${sj ]B8}„B8$R‚ _„B„s88$t

dM;

 F$8?‚t‚9 N?B}‚9 z iBI„?Z‚9 =„?s  V„‚tsR  m V $jAsB

i‚P‚„‚t{‚R >dH  V„‚tsR V $jAsB  z iBI„?Z‚9 stI  F$8?‚t‚9 XV PZ99k RBjZ$Bt s}}„Bs{Y B s PZ99k j$t‚s„ Bsj }„B„s88$t }„BAj‚8" $t Zj$}j‚ ]„$‚„$s

*‚{$R$Bt s,$t

 eIR p 3stI‚j stI q psj 7}„$t‚„ W‚b OB„, }} 1xxT1E;

dx >1H p

B„Bjst stI i *‚st$ XV „‚%$‚b BP RB8‚ 8‚YBIR PB„ „st,$t PZ99k

RZAR‚R"

3Z99k 7‚R stI 7kR‚8R dx

 }} dTd dMx

>nH F  ]sI‚tsR stI FN z‚„I‚sk X=R$t PZ99k tZ8A‚„R $t j$t‚s„ }„B„s8T

yeee q„stR 7kR‚8R st ]kA‚„t‚ T _s„ U ]kA‚„t‚${ zBj 1

8$t"

WB E

 }} d(dETd(11 wI‚{‚8A‚„ dD

>;H  *‚jsIB FN z‚„I‚sk stI V z$js XV }„B{‚IZ„‚ PB„ „st,$t PZ99k „‚js$BtR"

3Z99k 7‚R stI 7kR‚8R 1E

 }} ;TE1 dMM

>xH 7 H  F$8? ‚t‚9 Xist,$t PZ99k tZ8A‚„R Y„BZY Y‚ {B8}s„$RBt BP $R ‚-}‚{‚I

yt‚„ts$Btsj FBZ„tsj BP =t{‚„s$tk 3Z99$t‚RR stI €tBbj‚I‚T sR‚I 7kR‚8R

$t‚„%sjR"

zBj; WB; }} nTnMM dE

>MH € Ws,s8Z„s X_„‚P‚„‚t{‚ „‚js$Bt Bt s R‚R BP PZ99k Z$$‚R sR s AsR$R PB„

3Z99k 7‚R stI 7kR‚8R 1( 3Z99k R‚R stI $t‚„s{$%‚ 8Zj$BA`‚{$%‚ B}$8$9s$Bt

I‚{$R$Bt 8s,$t" >H  7s,sbs

 }} d;TdE1 dME

 _j‚tZt

_„‚RR W‚b OB„,TNBtIBt dn >d(H d1H  Gst stI e €‚„„‚ X!t Y‚ {jsRR$h{s$Bt stI Y‚ I‚}‚tI‚t{$‚R BP Y‚

3Z99k jB${ 3BZtIs$Bt stI $tIZR„$sj V}}j${s$BtR yt‚„ts$Btsj R‚„$‚R $t yt‚jj$‚t q‚{YtBjB$‚R B„I‚„$t 8‚YBIR" $tU * iZst weID

 €jZb‚„ *B„T

I„‚{Y }} nT( dE >dnH _ N OZ XV {jsRR BP RBjZ$BtR PB„ „BZ} I‚{$R$Bt }„BAj‚8R"

7{$‚t{‚

sts‚8‚t

 zBjd }} nET;E dn

>d;H O OZst X]„$‚„$s PB„ ‚%sjZs$t PZ99k „st,$t 8‚YBIR

‚8R ;;

 _? sdnTdx dd

3Z99k 7‚R stI 7kRT