May 19, 2006 - when every free name appearing in pe is defined in. P . The clocking rules defining the predicate. P, H ⣠e : ct are now given in figure 6 and are.
Synchronizing Periodic Clocks in Kahn Networks Albert Cohen, Marc Duranton, Christine Eisenbeis, Claire Pagetti, Florence Plateau, Marc Pouzet
To cite this version: Albert Cohen, Marc Duranton, Christine Eisenbeis, Claire Pagetti, Florence Plateau, et al.. Synchronizing Periodic Clocks in Kahn Networks. [Research Report] RR-5603, 2005, pp.38.
HAL Id: inria-00070404 https://hal.inria.fr/inria-00070404 Submitted on 19 May 2006
HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access archive for the deposit and dissemination of scientific research documents, whether they are published or not. The documents may come from teaching and research institutions in France or abroad, or from public or private research centers.
L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est destin´ee au d´epˆot et `a la diffusion de documents scientifiques de niveau recherche, publi´es ou non, ´emanant des ´etablissements d’enseignement et de recherche fran¸cais ou ´etrangers, des laboratoires publics ou priv´es.
INSTITUT NATIONAL DE RECHERCHE EN INFORMATIQUE ET EN AUTOMATIQUE
Synchronizing Periodic Clocks in Kahn Networks Albert Cohen, Marc Duranton1 , Christine Eisenbeis, Claire Pagetti, Florence Plateau2 and Marc Pouzet2
N° 5603 2005
N 0249-6399
ISRN INRIA/RR--5603--FR+ENG
Thème COM
apport de recherche
! #"%$'&()+* , -.0/214365798;:14A@+36BDCE3F@G !ACBED 7 $$F > 7 )+ 7 ! @- ) 7 !4 H G" ck 1 ck ! ck_ 2 ck ! _ ) *.% !7I J< A 1 2 K AG_$7 ) _ L !4 ) _ %) 7 -NM
OQP ^O6R
ÌÍ+Î|ÏZÐtÑÍ Í Ð ÃÑ ÃÎÑ6ÎË
uvqu|»qp6³ mqe6u¼rUyv4x 8 yzpv4wc~d{yxÔuv_xPrt~Uywqrtyv_x HRyrºeÇZrUexcprtacyzpºu{_uwcwp9rtv·uv_dyxceRpsrt~Ue6{_dp i´ yrta n°psoZxu|a~tv4xcyÅI{ceuvqu|»qp6³ mZe6urtyv_x qe6pUu~Uy+e6puvqqe¾¥_exe~|{rtyv_x psrt~|{rte6¥_ye6p¾Â ±²v4~º{xZo n° ptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcyÅ6{_ceºc~Uv_¥_~|{dºÄG{_pte6½v4x·rt~|{xGpsz{rUyv4x rtv {Ncwc~Ueo·ptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGpZo½{wqrUv_d{rUyu6{o yxpte~trtyxc¥Dwq¿+e6~Up9´iyrtaÔdyxcyd{iptyÅ6e_³·ie6{rte6É´2v4~t»qpg{~UeqyzptuwpUpseI·yxÔmZeIu¼rtyv_xÔq?+e±²v4~te´2e uv_xuwGqeyxNmZeIu¼rtyv_x A ³ )µ S$)µ hXw~Xd{yxDdv_rtyF{rtyxc¥¾{ccyzu{rUyv4xp
{_~tegZyqe6vpsrt~Ue6{_d c~tvque6pUpsyxc¥±²v4~Say¥4aq°Yce¶xcyrtyv_x `¸ &%' !(L³ `ae6pte{_¥4v_~UyrUacdp9ce6{´iyrtaÔcyzu¼rtw~teRpUu{yxc¥yurtwc~UeRuv_d+v4ptyrUyv4x]ÂÃcyurtwc~Ue°Yyxq°Lyurtwc~UeIÄ2{xG ÀPw{_yro,exa{xuedexPr²yxuwcyxc¥,yurtwc~Ue~U{rtewcq°uv4xP4e~|psyv_xGpuv4xZ_e~trtyxc¥
rtace±²~|{de~U{rtev±+rtace cyptcz{Fo_e6NPyzqe6vÆqe°Yyx4rUe~U{4uyxc¥±²v4~Xc~Uv_¥4~teIptpty_epUu~Ueex pswu|a¹{_p
ÓG{r{_xceWqyzps{Foqp6+pta{~UcxceIptp ydc~Uv_ede6x4rIiuv_v_~excaG{xuedexPr6ierUu_³ ij}~Uvque6pUptyxc¥É~teIÀ4wy~Ue6pºuv_xptyzqe~|{ceR~Ue6ptv_wc~|ueIpi{xG yxZ_v44e6p{F{_~tyerov_±y+eyxe6¾{¥_v4~tyrtacdpv_x¾dgwcrUycydexGpsyv_x{_HprU~teI{dp6³ }ayyGp pDyxceÉv_±av_de·exPrUe~trU{yxcdexPrDe6xc¥_yxceIpRyp cwcyr v_xÖdeIqy{c~tvque6pUpsv4~Up±²v4~Nacy¥_aq° +e~t±²v_~Ud{xueº{x ay¥4aq°YÀPw{_yroDdgwcrtyd9eIqyz{D{cyzu{rtyv_xp6³Rcv4~yxpr|{xue_rtae eÇZ+e~Uyz{Nâv4d9e ±Ã{_dyoDv_±u|acypºÂ0pswGu|a¹{4prtace}2 X¤P__4Ä & ¡_G (2u6{x¹Geº±²v_wcx¹v4x `¸
°YuexPrt~Uyzug~tvqqwurUpptwu|a½{_p {_x{v_¥G4{_x{v_¥ "qy¥_yrU{_0P{xºcy¥4yr|{Æ`¸Apter|p2{_xº~Ue6uey_e6~Up64uv_xcxceIu¼rUe6 cy¥4yr|{;`¸pqacv4de
dw° rUydeIqy{pte~U_e6~Up6Z{xacv_de,e6x4rUe~trU{_yxcde6x4ruexPrte6~Up6³
+ ,
"! )# %&*
"! $#% &'(
y¥_wc~Ue ' HW`aceqv´ixpUu{_e6~ `aceIpse{_ccyu6{rUyv4xpÆyxP4v__eW{ipterHv±cpUu{_e6~Up;~Ue6ptyÅ6eyd{¥4e6pÆyx,~Ue6{°Lrtyd9e4³hXwc~Æ~Uwcxcxcyxc¥ieÇq{_dce yzpi{9uz{_pUpsyzu{_;cv´ixptu6{e~ &' B(Yqeyurte6yx¾y¥_wc~Ue ' ³WYr
uv4xP4e~trUp{9acy¥4ace¶xcyrtyv_x ÂÃâX×SÄZyzqev pty¥_x{_0 cyÇZe6p+e~±²~U{_d9e4qyxPrUvº{9psrU{_xc{_~Uqe¶GxcyrUyv4x½Â0mq×Äv_wcrtcwqri±²v4~
`¸ pUu~UeexO × 1080 rUa{ryzp 1920 H720 × 480 ' ³i acv4~tyÅv4xPrU{;¶GrUe~i/ k .10kn~teIqwue6prUacexZwcdgGe6~v±WcyÇqezpyxN{yxce,±²~Uv_d 1920 qv´ixrtv Z º o y P x t r e U ~ + _ v z { t r y c x ¥9{_u|»4er|pv±9cyÇqezp³ 720 ¡q³i\~te6v_~|qe~Uyxc¥gdvqqwceX3 k 2(46572 89492Hkpsrtv_~Ue6pi9yxe6pv± 720 cyÇqezp³ c³i 4e~trtyzu{_¶rte6~; k :"0k ~Ue6qwue6p?rtaceSxZwcd+e~v_±Hyxce6pyx{±²~U{_d9eX±²~Uv_d 1080 qv´ixPrtv 480 Zo yx4rUe~UGv4{rtyxc¥9{_u|»4erUpv_±9cyÇqezp³ `ace,~tvqueIptptyxc¥gv_±{9¥_y_e6x ±²~|{deyxP4v__eIp{uv_xpsrU{_x4rixZwcdgGe6~iv±µv4Ge6~U{rtyv_xpv4xrUacyzp±²~U{_d9e v4xco_³Ù(qeIpsy¥_xrtvZv_Syp rtaZwpeÇZ+e6urteI rtvÔ{wqrUv_d{rUyu6{oÔc~Uvqqwue¹{xeÁºuyexPr¾uvqqeN±²v4~{_x e6d+e6cce6Ô{~|u|acyrUe6urtwc~Ue_rUv¹u|aceIu|» rta{r9~Ue6{_°Lrtydeuv_xpsrt~|{yxPrUp9{~UepU{rUyps¶e6H?{xÉrtv¹v_crtyd9yÅe =
G K) _> A?7 ) _ - !7I ?' % @8 > ( )+ R BADC )+BEFA6GH / E!>
^3^`_!ab c d e
=
/ IH I9 _ ) _ @!_ ! M
Ñ6Ï ÍÒqÐ Í Y) ÑÍ zË Í # EzË $ )+)* )
Ò Í YiÑÒ$G E)
rUacededv4~to ±²vPv_rtc~Uyx4rv_±WyxPrte6~tdeIqy{rtec{rU{{_x¾v±rtaeuv4x4rU~tv4Huvqqe4³`aceed+e6qe6RptoqprUed ce6pty¥4xce~yzpgvZv_»Zyxc¥¾±²v_~9{Rc~Uv_¥4~U{_d9dyxc¥Rz{xc¥4w{¥4egrUa{r9v¿;e~|pc~Ue6uypteo rtaceIpserUac~Ueeº±²eI{rUwc~teIp {_xd9v4~tec~Ue6uypteo_q´iayu|a Ë ) )*ÃÎ KÌ ¥_w{_~U{_xPrteeIp2±²v_wc~iydGv4~sr|{xPric~tv4Ge6~srUyeIp H ' ³i{c~UvZv±rta{r6;{_uuv_~|qyxc¥9rtvº´v_~|prt°Yu6{_pteeÇqe6uwqrtyv_x¾rUydeaZoZGv_rtaceIpseIprtace±²~U{_d9eg{x¾cyÇqe ~U{rte´iyH+eptwpr|{yxce6% ¡q³i{xºe6{w{rUyv4xv±;rtaceSqez{Fo9yxPrt~Uvqqwue6Zo9rtaceSqv´ixpUu{e~WyxrUace
Zyzqev~tvqueIptptyxc¥u|a{yxH y0³ e_³qrUaceqez{Foº+e±²v4~teSrtae,v_wqrUcwqrc~Uvque6pUppr|{~trUp~Ue6ueyPyxc¥9cyÇZe6p c³i{9c~tvZv_±OrtaG{rirtaepsoqpsrted a{_p+v_wxqe6dedv_~Uoº~Ue6ÀPwcy~te6dexPrUp 8 ³i{x e6F{_wG{rtyv_x v_±de6d9v4~to ~teIÀPwcy~Uede6x4r|p2rtv prUv_~Ue¾{rU{·´iyrUacyx rUaceNc~UvqueIptpte6p6{_xÔrtv cwq¿;e~irUacepsrt~Ue6{d!c~tvqqwGue6Zortae,_e~trtyzu{_;¶rte~iyx±²~tv4xPrv_±µrUacev_wqrUcwqr
~tvqueIptp6³ xNrtace6v_~Uo_;psoZxu|ac~Uv_xv_wpiz{x¥_w{_¥_e6pX{~Ue´eptwcyrte6RrtvºrUace9ydcedexPr|{rtyv_xDv±Wrtae9qv´ixGptu6{e~I {_v´iyxc¥9rtvº+v_wcxGR~teIpsv4wc~|ue~teIÀPwcy~Uede6x4r|p{xGR{_pUpseIptp~Ue6{_°LrtydeeÇqe6uwqrtyv_xO³ er6+´2e´iyµptacv´ rUa{reÇqyzprUyx¥gptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGpW{_xc¥_wG{¥_eIpd{»4eXptwu|a {_x yd9e6d9e6xPrU{rUyv4xrteIqyv_wp{xGe~U~tv4~s°Yc~Uv_xce4³
!"#$&%('$)+*
`µe6u|axcyu6{o4Irtaceptu6{yxc¥X{¥_v_~UyrtacdAc~UvZcwueIpHyrUp °0rUav_wqrUcwqri ÄOPoSyx4rUe~UGv4{rtyxc¥
Xuv_xGpseIuwqrUy4e yÇqezp
 p Ä´ey¥_aPrUe6Zo9uvZeÁºuyexPrUp?¥_y_e6x9yx {,t~teIqerUe~Ud9yxceIotd{rt~UyǾ²eÇq{_dce
v±O{, 8 ca{_pte6p °0r|{p+v_j oZca{_pteS¶rte~ &' B( ÄEH ot =
5 X
pt×1920/720+k ×
uvZe± (k, t dvq
64).
k=0
y¥_wc~UeD¡¹psacv´p{¹¶G~Upsrº_e6~Uptyv4xÉv_±XrUaceNacv4~tyÅv4x4r|{¶rte6~6yd9e6d9e6xPrte6 yx {½prU~tyzu¼rUoÔpsoZxq° |u a~tv4xcv_wpz{x¥_w{_¥_eptwu|aº{_p = (0) {_x ⊥ = (1) psyxue ±²v_~X{ ³?cv4~{x¾yxq¶xcyrtepter S Í$# (S) = w ´iae~Ue [w] = Ë¼Ò {[w0 ] | w0 ∈ S} [(0)]p = ∞ p p ±²v4~ie4e~Uo p ∈ N ³ p > 0 4exPrtwG{o4rtace2±²v_v´iyxc¥X~te6d{~U»{_v´pµd9vPprv_+e~|{rUyv4xpµv_xyxq¶xyrUe+e~UyvZcyu2cyx{~Uo´2v4~Ucp rUvGeuv_dcwqrUe6v_x¶xcyrte,´v_~|cp6³ Û ·«q&ª % C LXÍÌ ÐÑ # Í ?Í K) Ð ÃÑ ÃÎ # Í Ð¼Ì Z?ÑÐ FËÎ Í # 9[Ð [Ð Ë Í ) Z K)²Ï [Ð Q ¼Ë /Í Ð ÃÑ Ë ZµÏcÑFË Í :)²ÏPËË )+z'Ë #|ÌNËÑ ¾Î|Ñ Í !K)+ÃÑÍ ÑÍc Ë , $ Ð )*Z?Ñ Í Í K) Ð ÃGÑ !ÃÎ # Í Ð¼Ì Z?Ñ[Ð Ë / ) (
ºÎ Í )LÐ Í*Ë #ÑÐ )²FÏ Q [Ð ¼Ë| Ë ÃÑÍË Ñ # w / Í w0 Í )Ñ F Ð )*ÃÎRÒ Ð w = u(v) Í w0 = u0 (v 0 ) Q Ð [Ð ¼Ë Í ) )+KUB Ë a(b) / Í 0 0) ZµÏ ÃÎ|Ï Ë ,ËÑ 9ÎUÑ RÒ ) )*ÃÑÍcË ( NÎ Í]Î|ÏcÑIÑFË +#ÑÐ Íca Ë (b ) Í+Î a a0 b / Í b0 ˼ÒÎUÏ )²Ï ) |a| = |a0| = max(|u|, |u0|) /Í Ï [Ð Î Ë ) Í F,Ë #ÑÐ e6{4pruv_ddv_x dgwcrtyc-e /. Í : Ë¼Ò : ÑFË
|b| = |b0 | = Î (|v|, |v 0 |) ZµF Ï ¹!Ñ )²FÏ ÐDÎ Ë zË Ë )LÐ FÏ ) #Ñ Ð Z [Ð p = |u0| − |u| /Í n = Î (|v|, |v0 |) ) Ï Í |u| ≤ |u0 | +)²F Í Í w = u.v[1] · · · v[p]. (v[p + 1] · · · v[p + |v|])n/|v| / w0 = u0 .(v 0n/|v | ) 010(001100) / # |Î|Ñ
Í 10001(10) M : Z zË +SÑ/ Í T01000(110000) Ì $Í #ÑÐUÎ T) Ï ) [Ð 10001(101010) Q ¼Ë /Í Ë¼1Ò 0 Q ËÏ U! T)²FÏ 9Ë ! ÍGÒ # Ð9Ñ # Ë w = Í a(b) Í w0 = a0 (b0 ) Z K)²Ï |a|1 = |a0 |1 = max(|u|1 , |u0 |1 ) / |b|1 = |b0 |1 = Î (|v|1 , |v 0 |1 ) . / $ Í $ C+Ë¼Ò ÑEË |u|1 ≤ |u0|1 Í |v|1 ≤ |v0 |1 p = |u0|1 −|u|1 r = [v]p Í n = Î (|v|1 , |v0 |1) 0
^3^`_!ab c d e
'
Ñ6Ï ÍÒqÐ Í Y) ÑÍ zË Í # EzË $ )+)* )
Ò Í YiÑÒ$G E)
)²ÏF Í w = u.v[1] · · · v[r]. (v[r+1] · · · v[r+|v|])n/|v|1 Í w0 = u0 .(v 0n/|v0 |1 ) 010(001100) Í/ # UÎ|Ñ
010001(100001) Í/ 10001(101010) ! 10001(10) ÏF Ë ) Í) Ð[ ¼Ë )+ Í Î Ë zË w = a(b) Í/ w0 = a0(b0) Z K)²Ï |a|1 = |a0| Í |b|1 = |b0| . Í/ $ C2Ë¼Ò : ÑFË
|u|1 ≤ |u0 | Í |v|1 ≤ |v 0 | p = |u0 |1 − |u| r = [v]p Í n = Î (|v|1 , |v 0 |) ²) ÏF Í w = u.v[1] · · · v[r]. (v[r + 1] · · · v[r + |v|])n/|v|1 Í/ w0 = u0.(v0n/|v0 |) 010(001100) Í/ # 10001(10) U Î|Ñ 0100011000011(000011) Í 10001(10)
v_~XrtacepU{»_ev±2ptydcyzuyro_Æ´e´iyW{_pUptwcdertae~Ue6{± rUe~Xrta{rSe6_e6~to¾yxq¶xcyrte9Ge6~tyvqqyzucyx{_~to ´v_~|ºaG{_pi{x¾yxq¶xcyrte,xZwcdgGe6~iv± ' p6qy0³ e_³qyzpiGe6~tyvq av_zcpi{re6{4priv_xe ' ³
? $ * $ ? $
uvqu|»,±²v4~Wyxc¶xcyrtepsrt~Ue6{dpWu6{x9Ge{_x9yxq¶xyrUeicyxG{~Uo´2v4~Ugv_~W{,uv_dGvPpsyrtyv_x9v±+yxc¶xcyrtecyx{_~to ´v_~|cp6q{_piqe¶xce6ZorUace±²v_v´iyxc¥9¥_~|{dd{~GH clk ::= w | clk on w w ∈ (0 + 1)ω
Y± ck ypg{Ruvqu|»D{x w yzp{_x¹yxq¶xyrUeºcyx{~UoD´v_~|ÆHrUacex ÎÑIÎ v_± ck q´iace~Ue w ypyrUpte±pterv4xuvqu|» ck ³ ³ ¥³ (01) 5 !_ 7 >! @@ 7!>8/ _ !> L !4 ) _ - F > ) ( G" 7 * F - 7 / _ ! > L !4 ) _ _? K _ ?$) _ *. _' M ) ? ! - ! < > G" 7 #) _ ) ! %%& ! ( -K
^3^`_!ab c d e
'
Ñ6Ï ÍÒqÐ Í Y) ÑÍ zË Í # EzË $ )+)* )
Ò Í YiÑÒ$G E)
O` vptydcy±²oºrtacec~Ue6ptexPrU{rtyv_xHZ´eX´iyH{_pUpswcdeSyxd{xZw{Æuv_dcwqr|{rtyv_xGp?rUa{rrUacewcxcyrv_± uv4d9wqrU{rtyv_xDv_±Wrtace4e~trtyzu{O¶rte~yzpX{yxce{xGRxcvr,{ºyÇqeLÆace6xue9~te6cz{_ue A ¡_Zo ' yx rtace,~te6Pyv_wGpipsy¥_x{rtwc~Ue_ZoZyezqyx¥H γ → γ 5 ! ) _ + M
OQP ^O6R
ÌÍ+Î|ÏZÐtÑÍ Í Ð ÃÑ ÃÎÑ6ÎË
'GP
tp e6ÀPwce6xueIpZyL³ e4³ x v y y± x yzpi{g~te¶cǺv± y ³`aeSv4~Uce~Ue6ºpter D = (T ∞, v) yzpi{guGvG³WY± D {xG {~Ue9uGvGÆrtaex yp,{u+v´iyrta rtaeuvZv_~|qyxG{rte°L´iyzptev_~|qe6~6³ {_pXrta1epter D2 v_±?uv4x4rUyxZwcv4wpi±²wxu¼DrUy1v4x×pXD±²~tv42 d D rtv D yp{zptv { uGvPor|{»Zyx¥rtace9+v_[Dyx41r´i→yzpteDv_2~|]qe6~6³Y± f yp 1 {uv_xPrtyxZwcv_wpd{_ccyxc¥9±²~tv4d rtv c2´epta{Æ´i~tyrte Q f = lim f n() ±²v4~rtaceptd{eIpr n→∞ ¶Ç Gv4yxPrv_± f  á eexeXrUacev4~te6Ddº1ļ³ D2 ® eSce¶xceXrtaeSpter Ñ6Î : )L[Ð ! v_± EÎ Ñ6Î : 9Ë Ò Í;Î Ë {_p?rtacepter2v_±H¶xcyrte{xGyxc¶xcyrte pte6ÀPwce6xueIpv±eedexPrUpv4e~rtaÊ epser T (T=) T + {⊥} ³ 7!5@5
ÑIÎ$
⊥
= {0, 1} = T + {⊥} ) [ (T ) = (T )∞ ⊥
Ê 0Ð Auvqu|»_eIºpseIÀPwcexue
yzp?d{4qeXv_±Oc~Ue6ptexPr2v4~{_ptexPr2{wceIp³ ® eSqe¶xceXrtaceuvqu|»v±O{9pseIÀ4wexue s {4p{+vZv_e6{xNpte6ÀPwce6xueºÂôiyrUacv_wcrS{Gpse6x4rXF{_we6p|ÄyxGqyu6{rUyxc¥ ´iacexN{{_wceyp
c~teIpse6xPr6³icv4~rtayp wc~t+v4pte_q´e,u{_xqe¶xcerUace±²wcxurtyv_x clock ±²~tv4d!uvqu|»_e6pseIÀPwcexue6prUv9+vZv_e6{_xpte6ÀPwce6xueIpH T⊥
clock () clock (⊥.s) clock (x.s)
= = false.clock (s) = true.clock (s)
® e,psaG{ÆwpseSrUaceersrte6~ ±²v_~c~Ue6ptexPri{wce6p6³W`aZwp qexcv_rteIpi{gpsrt~Ue6{_d¯´iacv4pteX¶~UpsrieedexPr yzpXc~teIpse6xPrS{xGR´iacv4pte~Ue6vpsrXyzp s ´iace6~teI{_p ⊥.s qexvrteIpXv.s{prU~teI{dÕ´iacv4pte¶G~UpsrXe6e6d9e6xPrXyzpX{_pse6xPr6³ `aegyxPrte~Uc~Uer|{rtyv_xRv_±?{4psyzuc~Uyd9yrty_eIp
v_±rtae9uv_~Uez{xc¥4w{¥4ev_e6~Xuvqu|»_eIRpseIÀ4wexue6pXypS¥_y_e6x yx¹¶¥_w~te A ³ ® eºwptertaceºd{_~t» # rtvNcypsrtyxc¥_wypta¹rtace ptoZxPrU{_urtyzuuv4xprU~twGu¼r ²e4³ ¥G³ 7R±²~tv4d£yrUp yxPrte6~tc~Uer|{rUyv4x{_pi{psrt~Ue6{_dØrt~|{xps±²v_~Ude~¼Ä¼³ `ace I #- ( ! 7> ) 7 7 ) _ ! _' *.%&)+@ < AH $#%) / ! *.*. D -F > ?* !A _ 7I- > A?> ! ) K _ - ) _ ) (! GA _7 -) _ L 4! ) _ < F$ 5 /+/ - _$/1 ) -F > +M
^3^`_!ab c d e
Ñ6Ï ÍÒqÐ Í Y) ÑÍ zË Í # EzË $ )+)* ) 8
Ò Í YiÑÒ$G E)
_{ x ~UwceIp{~Ue9qeIpsy¥_xe6Drtvd9yxcydyÅ6eºqez{FoRyxGpse6~srUyv4xHÆacexGue9rtvR{F_v4yDpscw~tyv_wp cez{FoÔ{4uuwdwcz{rUyv4xH³ ® e {_~teDrtaZwpuv_xc¶GqexPr¾{+v_wqrrtace¹uvZu|» u6{zuwcwp p{cyyroÔrtvÔ{_uueqr dvPpr,c~Uv_¥4~U{_dpg²´iyrta +e~UyvqqyzuuvZu|»qp|ÄirUa{ru6{x GerU~U{_xpsz{rUe6NrtvR{¾prU~tyzu¼rUo·Â0°ÄptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGp ±²~|{de6´2v4~t» Po_er
{g±²v4~td{Huv_dcerUxce6pUp~teIpswriyzpxcvr
{F{yz{ce_³ () $$$
A
i$)µi
µ
* ? * + #+ $ @
` aexvrtyv_xÔv±S~te6{Çqe6ÔpsoZxu|ac~Uv_xZo½u{_x +eR~Ue6u{4pryxÔ{_x eIÀ4wy{exPrº{c~tvP{_u|a {_pte6 v_x psoZxq° u|a~tv4xcv_wpjRe6{_o d{_u|acyxceIp & ¡ ' (Y³ ® e~te±²e~ae~Ueºrtv¹{xÉ{_cc~Uv4{4u|a¹wGpseI ±²v_~9dvZceyxc¥¹{Dpty¥4x{ ~tvqueIptptyxc¥guv_dGv4xcexPrqeIpsy¥_xceIºv4x{9u|acy & ¡B(Y³xrUacyzp{+e~IPrtace{_wqrtacv4~Up2´{xPrrtv9c~tv4e
rUa{r r´vgmZvquXqe6pty¥4xp?{_~te
e6ÀPwcyF{_e6xPr{xGrtaZwp2wpteX{,dyxcydyÅ6{rtyv_xºv4x {wqrUv_d{r|{,yxºv_~|qe~?rtv¶xº{_x v4qrtydyÅ6e6¾uv4d{~Uyptv_xO³ ® eXuv_xptyce~WrUace¶xyrUeX{ca{_Ger Σ = {i/o, i/¯o, ¯i/o, ¯i, /¯o} ³`acedeI{xcyxc¥v_± Σ yzpWrUace±²v4v´° yxc¥ H ÝrtaepsoZd+v_ i pr|{xcpi±²v_~{xyxccwqrvquuwc~|p Ýrtae9ptoZd+v_ o pr|{xp±²v4~S{_xNv_wqrUcwqrvquuw~Up6+ptvºrUa{rS±²v_~Syxpr|{xuerUacege6_e6x4r i/o de6{xGprUa{r {x¾yxccwqr
{_x{_x¾v_wqrUcwqrvquuwc~psydwr|{xce6v_wpto4 Ý ¯i psrU{_xcp±²v4~ixcvyxcwqrvquuw~Upi{_xºrUaceptoPdgGv4 o¯ psrU{_xcp±²v_~ixvv_wqrUcwqrvquuwc~Up6³ v_~
dvqqe6yxc¥rUaceptoZpsrte6d¾G´eqeyurXe6{4u|aRuv_d+v_xce6xPr
Zo{_xRy "v°{wqrUv_d{rUv_x¾{xrUacypXu{_x +e¾{wqrUv_d{rUyu6{o ~Ue6{yÅe6·Po½qeIptu~tycyxc¥NrUace¾qe+excexuo ±²wcxu¼rUyv4x ¥4y4ex·Zo¹rtae~tvqueIptptyxc¥ {_¥4v_~UyrUacd¾³ ® e,~Uec~Ue6ptexPrrtace,yxccwcr
{x rtace,av_~UyÅ6v_xPrU{_G¶GrUe~ZorUacey~iy "v°{wqrUv_d{rUv_xH³ ¯i/o
6
i/¯ o
6
i/o
5
i/¯ o 0
A0 = input
0
4
i/¯ o i/¯ o
i/o
1
i/¯ o
2
i/o
3
A1 = horizontal f ilter
Y rypXe6{4psorUvpteerUa{rXrtace9z{xc¥4w{¥4e~teIuv4¥_xcyÅeIZoR{x¹{wqrUv_d{rUv_x L ⊆ Σ∗ u6{xN+e9ptee6xD{_p ´iyrUa l ↔ 1 {_x ¯l ↔ 0 ´iyrUa l = i, o ³`aexº´eXxvrtyzue
rta{r L × L L1 × L2 ⊆ {0, 1}∗ × {0, 1}∗ 1 2 uv_~U~teIps+v_xGcprUvrtacepty¥_x{rtwc~Ue L → qe¶xceI yxrtace,c~UeZyv_wpipte6urtyv_xH³ L1 on L2 1 `aceptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcyÅ6{rtyv_xNv_±2y "Fv°{wcrtv_d{rU{ºyzp,qe¶xce6¹{_pS±²v4v´p H
y±2r´vuv_d+v_xce6x4r|p,{~Ue9uv_xq° xe6u¼rUe6ÆZy±OrUace
¶G~Upsr2e6d9yrUp{_x v_wcrtcwqrrtaZwp2rUaceSpte6uv_x xceeIcp?rtv9~teI{_yr6qv_rtace6~t´iyzpse
´2eSexPrte6~2yx{ ce6{_cvqu|»pr|{rUe_³WY±OrUaceS¶~|priqvZe6pxcv_re6dyr{xv_wcrtcwqrIZrtaZwprUace,pseIuv_xGºdwGpr~teIÀPwcy~Ue{x yxccwcr6³ Oer a, c = i v_~ ¯i {_x b, d = o v4~ o¯ZrUaceptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcyÅ6{rUyv4x yzp~te6c~Ue6ptexPrteI ZoH OQP ^O6R
P
ÌÍ+Î|ÏZÐtÑÍ Í Ð ÃÑ ÃÎÑ6ÎË a/o
q
a/¯ o
q0
k
s
i/b
s0
=
(q, s)
a/b
(q 0 , s0 )
¯
a/b i/b (q, s) (q 0 , s0 ) s0 = k s `ace6~teyzpW{¥P{yxg{prU~tv4xc¥S{~|{e64´iyrta9rUaceqe¶GxcyrUyv4xgv_±G+e~Uyvqqyzuuvqu|»Zp6³µOerwpWuv_xptyzqe~r´v y "Fv_°Y{_wqrtv4d{rU{ A {xG A ´iyrUa L(A ) ≡ L1 × L1 {x L(A ) ≡ L2 × L2 ³`ace6x A = A k A ~Ue6uv_¥4xcyÅ6e6p L(A)1≡ L ×2L ³ ® eaG{F1_e L 1→ L 2 on L = 2L1 → 1 L1 on2 L1 on  L2 on1 L2 Ätļ2³ 1 1 2 1 2 `aypde6{_xprtaG{r L =1 L1 {_2x L = L1 on  L2 1on L2 Ä2³ 1 1 2 1 2 1 2 cwq¿;e~v±HpsyÅe yp2{x °{wqrUv_d{rUv_x´iacyzu|aºu{xºpsrtv4~teX{c{r|{,y±Hyryp?xcvr2±²wc;{xG´iacyu|a u6{x¾qey_e~{c{rU{9yn±yrypxnvr+e1dqro4³r
{xZorUyde_yr
u6{xcwpta¾{_xGv4¾ptydwcrU{_xcev4wpso_³ `aceNuv_dcwqr|{rUyv4xÔv_±XrUaceDqe6{Fo {x rtaeNpsyÅeR+v_yp qv´ixÉrUv½~teI{_u|a{_cyyroÉ{xG{oZptyzp³]hXwc~ {_cc~Uv4{4u|aX´iyrta{uvqu|»Su{zuwwpOv_xyxq¶xcyrte2cyxG{~Uo
´v_~|cpÆyzpOqy~teIu¼rUoS{ccyzu{eWrUv{ptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGp z{x¥_w{_¥_e{xyNp Ð ÃÑÐ ptydce~I³ q
q0
# $!
` ae~Ue{_~te{DxZwcdgGe6~v±X{_cc~Uv4{_u|ae6p,±²v4~9rtaceRptGeIuy¶Gu{rtyv_x {x qe6pty¥4xÉv_±
a{~|q´{~Ue "psv_± r´{_~te ptoqprUedp6³ jRvPpr9v±irtaed{~Ueºv4x·¥_~|{cayu6{rUvZv_zp{4pseI v_x·~tvqueIptpxcer´v_~U»qp³ á {acx½~tvqueIptp xer´v_~U»Zp¾Â á }?XÄ &%' ¤(
yzpº{¹±²wcxc{_dexPrU{_v_xce4cwqr yrºdvZcezpv_xco·±²wxu¼rUyv4x{Xc~tv4Ge6~srUyeIp{_p v4c+v4pte6¾rUvpsrt~Uwu¼rUwc~|{c~tv4Ge6~srUyeIp³ á }?Ù{_~tegwpseINyx { xPwd+e~v±rUvZv_zpSptwu|aD{4p ?{cy &%' G (Wv_~ rUaceXf2v4ptoc~UveIu¼r & B ( _rUaceiwpteiv±Æpswu|a9rUvPv4pWpsrty~Ue6ÀPwcy~teIpµay¥4a9eÇqGe6~srUypte±²~tv4d qy¿;e~UexPr?qv_d{_yxp {_xgrtace6~teiyzpxv,~teI{owxcy4e~|pt{_q{_xc¥_wG{¥_erUa{r2uv_dgcyxe6pyxº{,psyxc¥_e±²~|{de´v_~U»,±²wcxurtyv_x{_{xG psrt~Uwurtwc~|{+±²e6{rtwc~Ue6p6³ }WrUv_edgo &SA (yzp{~Uyu|acz{rt±²v_~Ud ´iyrUaºpsydw{rtyv_x{x{_x{oqpsyzpµrtvZv_zp±²v_~rtaceqeIpsy¥_xv_±+e6d+e6Z° ce6psrt~Ue6{dyxc¥ptoZpsrte6dp Hµyrc~tvZyzqe6prUaceXptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wpWc{rU{°LÓv´AÂ0mq×SWÄWdvqqeGv±Huv4d9wqrU{rtyv_xH³
xcy»4eXptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGpz{xc¥4w{¥4e6p6Pmq×S ¥_~|{caGp2{_~texvreÇqcyuyrUoºuvqu|»_eI5 HpsoZxu|ac~Uv_xZogyp{uv_xpte° ÀPwce6xuev_±µvZu6{Æ{_{_xueSe6ÀPw{rtyv_xpv4x+e~UyvZcyuSeÇqeIuwqrUyv4xpUu|acedeIp³W`acemq×S·dvqqeÆyzpuv_xZ_e° xye6x4rS±²v_~Xrtae9{_wqrtv4d{rtyzuqe6~ty{rUyv4xNv±rUydyxc¥c~tv4Ge6~srUyeIp & ¡_B¡ (wqrXrUace9{4u|»v_±2uvqu|»qp
´e6{_»_exGp yrUp
{dex{_cyyroº±²v4~i±²v_~Ud{H~Ue6{4psv4xcyx¥9{_xRuv4~t~Ue6urs°YPoP°uv4xprU~twGu¼rtyv_x ¥_exe~|{rtyv_xv±WptoPxGu|ac~tv4xcv_wGp uvqqe_q´iyrta¾~Ue6ptGeIu¼rirtvptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wp?z{x¥_w{_¥_e6p &%'BA GB (L³ mPrUeprUv´{_~UpHrUaceipsoZxu|ac~Uv_xv_wpµuv_xPrU~tv44v_±+{_ptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wpOptoqprUedp{~Ue{_ptvXuv_xcwu¼rUe6gyxgrtace cv_d{yxRv±?ptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wpc~Uv_¥_~|{ddyxc¥{_xc¥_wG{¥_eIpGpswu|aN{4pirUace´v_~U»v_±H"e OSwe~UxcyuerS{_0³ &%'P ( v4x +v_oqu|ac~Uv_xZo_³Ô`acyp´v_~U»¹rU{_~t¥4erUpgrUaceN{wqrUv_d{rUyu{xG uv_~U~teIu¼rPo uv_xGprU~twurtyv_x ~te¶xcede6x4r v_±c~Uv_¥_~|{dp6Oyx½rtaepU{de ptcy~tyr9{4pv_w~guvqu|»¹uv_d+v4ptyrUyv4xHcwqryrqvZe6pgxcvruv_xGpsyzqe~9ÀPw{xq° rUyr|{rUy4e c~Uv_+e~trtye6pgv±
uvqu|»qp³½mPrU~teI{dYr & ¡B (yzp9{D{_xc¥_wG{¥_eº±²v_~ay¥4aÉ+e~t±²v_~Ud{_xueprU~teI{dyx¥ uv_dcwqr|{rUyv4xprta{rirU{4u|»Pe6pd{yxco psrt~Ue6{d9°Ye6_e6;{_x¾{¥_e6c~U{_yu
v_qrUydyÅ6{rtyv_xypUpswe6p6³
^3^`_!ab c d e
4
Ñ6Ï ÍÒqÐ Í Y) ÑÍ zË Í # EzË $ )+)* )
Ò Í YiÑÒ$G E)
2 O #$' i?)µ i ® ec~Uv_+v4pte6 {ptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wpXc~tv4¥_~|{ddyx¥ z{xc¥4w{¥4erUvydcedexPruv4~t~Ue6urs°YZo4°uv4xpsrt~Uwu¼rUyv4xH ay¥4aq°L+e~t±²v_~Ud{xuepsrt~Ue6{dyxc¥ {_ccyu6{rtyv_xGp³hXwc~Sd9vqqe6{4cq~Ue6pUpseIpirUace9{_wqrtv4d{rtyzuptoZxPrtaceIpsyzp
v_± uv_ddwxcyu6{rUyv4xpO+er´ee6xc~UvqueIptpte6pHrta{r{_~te2xcvrWprU~tyzu¼rUoptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wp6³ÆxrUacypdvqqeL´eptacv´ rUa{rz{rUexuyeIpi{xcwq¿;e~
~teIÀ4wy~UedexPr|pu6{xGe,yxq±²e6~t~Ue6{wqrUv_d{rUyu6{o4³ v_~rtacyzp wc~t+v4pte_i´eDyzqe6x4rUy¶Ge6{ uz{_pUpv±+e~UyvqqyzuDuvqu|»qpº´iayu|a~tv4e6Ôwpte±²wcSyx rtace uv_xPrteÇZrv_±Zyzqev~tvqueIptptyxc¥9{_¥4v_~UyrUacdp³ ® eeÇPrUex¾{uv_~Ue{rU{°0ÓGv´dvZceH´iyrta¾rUacypxcvrUyv4x v_±+e~UyvZcyu,uvqu|»qp{xG´iyrtaN{~Uez{ÇqeIuvqu|»u6{zuwcwprUvºuv4d9+v4pte,psoZxu|a~tv4xcv_wp~tvqueIptpte6p6³x ydcedexPrU{rtyv_xyxrtace
ptoZxu|ac~Uv_xcv4wpz{xc¥4w{¥4eOwuyzºmZoZxu|ac~Uv_xeyzpwxqe~?´{Fo9{x9´{_p{_ccyeI rUv{9u{4ptptyzu{;Zyzqevºqv´ixGptu6{e~eÇc{dce_³ `acyzp´2v4~t»{F4e6prtace´{Fo±²v4~xZwcde6~tv4wp?eÇZrtexGpsyv_xp6³x {_~srUyuwc{_~6P´eX´v_wczy»4e
rUv9ce¶xce {_x9{_¥4ec~|{yzu?±²~U{_d9e6´2v4~t»±²v4~ n°psoZxu|ac~Uv_xv_wpuvqu|»ZpG{_pte6gv_xqyz{_qyzuxZwcd+e~|p_yx{_~srrtv,+exe¶cr ±²~Uv_dÖeÁºuyexPr{_¥4v_~UyrUacdpOv4x~|{rUyv4x{4xPwd+e~|p³ ® e{zptv
´iyzpsartvprUwqo,rUaceuv_xcxe6u¼rUyv4x+er´ee6x ~UerUydyxc¥ {_xÉcez{Fo¹yxpte~trtyv_xH{4pg{ de6{_xprUv eÇqc~teIptp9{~|u|acyrteIu¼rtw~te°Y{F´{~Uev_qrUydyÅ6{rUyv4xp6³ xZwcdgGe6~µv_±G{cyzu{rtyv_xpµqe6{_4´iyrta # yrsrUe~Uyx¥ % v_~ #scwc~|pro % prU~teI{dpOrta{r{_~texvrWprU~tyzu¼rUo+e~Uyvqqyzu {_xeÇZrtexGpsyv_xrtv´{~|cpdv_~UeXeÇZ~teIptpty4eSuvqu|»qp´v_wcz +e,+exce¶Guyz{L³
ii !"!"#%$ '&(*)+' ,.-/0$1 23-23.$541#6 74%$849(*)+: .;9A@ BDC+EFHGHIC+J3K LNM I%O M JPQP'G9¦.B¹P'G9VX@ L»º ¼7½¾[LnM IoE=T%T1WG\$10.) 3at. 4%2#%$aNÀ @[gagx2/,0.!" i332;RgT1EFHB M T à IF\T=U"G9¸XICooT M T=C+E6 T _T1E%I M WI5Fw`T NT=C.F UT T=CFw` ] CCB.J3K ] XSÀ DV L R ]_à *V ] Xq VP[Z*IU%G\ ¨D©jFw`ª:T=U%G,OC ] B*FIVP"JFHGIVC²XICoT M T=CbE6T=a+2$_c/$a
na£90.i}}3}* +
k»rt#%$1$
,V"¢? 3[272$1$1$a.' 3r#6V3V$1ya. p jx#oa3b': 3rg 3 #6V£5 .>974%#%-23.-4Vb'!"!"2#1(2#%c3. ,¤V4% 23
z
N$s;9 j#% [0.#%!" Ha [.*0·&yD0.a230. >9$123y2*anVb·_¶*/n74%$1-6yaso. 4%2#%$a6CF\T M E%ICC+T%EF %XsT=CF M GEª:T=U%G,OCI M ] W VJCbE=T1W +I.XJC+W Ã I.Xta-6ybV).4%#oDa.)bc$d3h3hoe7fid* ¢/07n=#oab_).#% /i}3}Vf.
,o°j": 7^V/~Dn-6y$a*rg .
n$1). Harg 7p(*!"23ba7Vb"±Q Dr /³V0b t&ny_$5(*-6y.#%2230.$n.V46 2o ).#%2c#6!"!" .c /,Vc30c:/0.$541#%3 LnM IoE6T6T1WGwCDOU'I5^Fw`T1sNa°h*h=od}oeod3i}*agz*).4%!'~+#^ohh*
,Vl' ¢Vy :&ny.?$1! VD4% -$[2;l$1 !")/Q/,.c30c3?;w2#)V#6///).#%2c#6!"!" .c. :>98. p_23$1*;=@?2AB#CEDFA#0EBGH; 932/?'I1?J3K; 9+A'B>=K6>3EGEB'DFA#0;'6#CH