On the Predictability of Large Transfer TCP ... - Semantic Scholar

On the Predictability of Large Transfer TCP Throughput Qi He

Constantine Dovrolis

Mostafa Ammar

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

Georgia Tech

Georgia Tech

ABSTRACT
 

     !#"%$&
' ()*+, *-.*/012(3 )4 5,1768 9*(*5:. 9 .*9;8"&.*2 . < .  (*9;-"&^0J.>*(r.*/  /  -01[ 9.*/9M[A k[!O%. ^ C! > )C) <  C s . < )6.A PDT PO&k8 ()«1 >.*1ADvC! K 9293 bn""q C - ]uCO²O%..7 EºÈº°{Å.ºÑ9Ŷ5Ѻ»2ÊÆ°›Ê¸iÉ W B..3o64O-X  ó  ]C! I - j :u!O]?O%9 
ì]ó ; ó  "&tB..3o64ON.*@ n 3o ..´"%$&


 *  ) n t!B.A3o64ON.^. *gC #  %)C 0p.*(*(9* /.*( «1 9.94 /6 µf.*(*1) ?v > m}~Qm„

}…m† ~ J9. < ]"%$&
K   /O%. a`SUŸ01< [f? 6 Q.*(#. Q.*QC!)5 ^62j /9. < .1Ž :.B_9r .01]*(  C23o) z W »Ç¥_>¦%X& . < /.*9R

W=20KB (window-limited) W=1MB (congestion-limited)

RMSRE (log scale)

30

o

10

§ ó ' 1 ê C § p©no«ª § ¨ ¨ o ' 1 o O%  § ó .*j 1 

NB.Jl § *# J < C W 6 3 *(R6TS=UVHKJ+,W:+*X,?U=$'PQHK$'@9SY,Z*-*-@)*X>\[^]`_ba7]N23c3dE$eHKJgfh6h*X$'@9(=>R:=*-,?U=$iPjHO@)*X>Qk l ø0ß"Únm…Í$ø0ß4Ý+ÌÎÍom…Í$ϚÚÎß$ÑV×qpÏ ÷)ÌÎ×5ÏTp÷0Ý+ÚÎÔ5×5̀ÌÎß$Ñ1reÖ Í€ÌÎÍtsvu ×5߬ÚÎÖ+ÍGw+ÌÎß"Ú m…Í$ø0ß4Ý+ÌÎÍo… m Í$Ϛژø)ؓÚÎ̀ÌwÚÎÖ+Í ¢ Ø2÷)ÌRÚÎÖ+ÍDÚÎÖ+ÌÎÍ€Í  ×q0p Ý+ÌÎÍ$ß
+ž Ç«Ð ÉÞџ:ž ǥ͐É-ø0ÏuÐt+ž Ç2ØùÉß4Ö+÷-‹ ßÎøXm l Ô5ÍxÚ4Ìùø0à€Í$ß5er ×ÙÚÎ֚ w Ӽ͘Ð+׏©Ž ̀ÌÎÍ$ÏšÚ l ÌÎÍ$Ð+×5à€ÚÎ÷0ÌÎßO‹¡¥` ¤ Ñ9¡¥¤Šz ÒÕ+ÜwÑ ¢My¦¡¥˜ ¤ ч§5† y Ѭø)ÏuШ§Šygz ÒÕ+Üt¬ x ÊËÖ+͖©«ªLŸ ¬ ø0à€ÌÎ÷0ÏZŒ?m ×5ßfÝ ß4ÍÐ reÖ+Í$ÏnË r Í‰Ý ß4Í ÚÎÖ Í l ÌÎ̀Ó:×5÷0Ý ß Ö Í$Ý:ÌÎ×Zß"ÚÎ×5à$ßFØ2÷0ÌFÚÎÖ ÍRÐ+̀ÚÎ̀à€ÚÎ×5÷Ï ÷0Ø ÒF̀ӼÍ$Ô ÕáÖ ×ÙØqÚÎß`ø)ÏuÐܬÝ:ÚÎÔ5×ZÍÞÌÎßOx  ÷0Ì ÚÎÖ+ÍN¡¥¤ ø)ÏuÐ/¡¥¤Šz ÒÕ+Ü l ÌÎÍÐ:×5à€ÚÎ÷0ÌÎß$Ñ rD͘ß4Ö ÷K r ÌÎ̀ß4Ý ÔÙÚÎßBØq÷0ÌBØ2÷0Ý+̬Ð+׏©Ž ̀ÌÎÍ$ϚÚBÓø)Ô5Ý Í$ße÷0Ø • Ç¥Ï ÷)ÚÎÍxÚÎÖ Í  ×qpjz Ý:ÌÎÍQ­ ßgÔ5ÍOp Í$Ï ÐuÉ®x  ÷)ÌËÚÎÖ Í5¢My¦¡¥ ¤ ø)ÏuÐN§5y l ÌÎÍÐ:×5à€ÚÎ÷0ÌÎß$ÑZË r Íß4Ö ÷Kr ÌÎ̀ß4Ý ÔÙÚÎßBØq÷0ÌÚÎÖ+ÌÎÍ$Í Ó0ø0Ô5Ý Í€ß÷)Ø«¯°x° y Í`÷0È ß4̀ÌÎÓÍÐ8ÚÎÖuøÚÑVøÚÔ5Íø)ß"Ú¬Øq÷0Ì ÷0Ý+ÌwÐ øÚùø0ß4̀ÚÎß$Ñ-ÚÎÖ+ÍE ‡‡ ¡ ÕZ £¢ Ð+÷šÍ€ßwÏ+÷0Ú`ß"Ú4ÌÎ÷Ïhp ԏ Œ Ð:Í l Í$Ï Ð—÷Ï;R ± Ñ  ø0Ï Ð–œŠx²  y Í@Ø2÷Ý+ÏuЋÍOm l ×ÙÌÎ×5àø)ÔZԏK Œ ÚÎÖ ø)Ú? ??>?> MLMLLM

œœœ  ‘ œœ ‘ ‘ ‘‘‘

’’’ ““’’’ “ “ “ ““’“’ “’ “’’  ’“’ “Ÿž “’ ’ žŸžŸ “ “’ ““’“’  ¡  

5

MLMLML

7

0

1

2

3 Trace #

4

5

0.3 0.2

7

0 1

¡¡ ¡ ¡ 

0.8

6

¡ ¡

0.6 0.4 0.2

7

0

ONONON \ ]\]\]\ QP ^_^ \ ONONON \ P ^ \ \ ^_^_^_^ \\]]\]\ QPQPQ ^ 1

R a`a` R SSRR ` ` R R ` RSSSRRR ` `aa``a` 2

7

0

0.3 0.1

7

1

ö÷ö÷ö÷øöøöö   öö÷÷øøøöö   0

3 Trace #

4

1

2

1

úùúùúù    ùúúùù  ú 

2

üûüûüû   

ûü   

4

þýþýþý ÷ÿ÷ÿ÷ÿ ÿÿÿ þþýýþýþý ÿ÷÷ÿ÷ÿ÷ÿ ÿÿÿÿ  

3 Trace #

4

5

6




5

iihhihih ih



  

 

6

0.3 0.2 0.1

6

® ¯ ®¯ ¯ ®¯®®®¯®¯¯®¯®® ¯®¯® ¯¯ ® ¹ ­¬ º»» ¯® ª ®® ª ª«ª«ª«ª ¸¹¸ ­¬ ¯ ¯¯®®¯ ¬ ­¬ º ¯ ­

3 Trace #

üûüüûû

5

kjkjjk x yyxx x kjkjkj x x xyxyxyx

0.4

ZZZ [[ZZZ [ gffgfg [ [ [Z[[Z[Z fg [Z

T UTUT c T XYXXY YXYXX  bbb cbcbb  VV T T Y c V WVWVWWVV dedede  TUUTTUT c XY YYX  b ccb  c V

¨ ©¨©©¨¨ ¨ ¨ ¨ ©¨©¨©¨  ¨ ¨¨ ³ ¥¤¥¤ ² ¶¶¶ ·¶·¶¶ · µ § °  ± ³ ²  ´ µ ´  ¦ § ¦ ° °  ¨ ± ¢££¢ ° ·· °±° ²² ¦¦ ´´ ¨©¨©¨©¨ ·

0.7 0.5

0.2 0.1

6

0

7

2

1

mlmmll z {z{z{z z mlmlml z z z z{z{z{z

n ononon |}| n n | }| n n | nononon | |}}||}|

ÏÎÏÎ ÁÀÁÀÀÁ Î Î Î ÁÀÁÀ Î ÎÏÎÏÎÏÎ

Ð Â ÑÑÐÐÑÐÑÐ ÃÂÃÂÃÂ Ð Ð Â Ð Â ÐÃ  Ð ÂÂ Â Ã  Ð  Â ÂÃÂ ÐÑÐÑÑÐ

0.5 0.4

¼½¼¼ ½½      

Ì ÍÍÌÌ ¾¿¿¾¾ Ì Ì ¿¿¾ Ì ÌÍÌÍÌÍÌ

0.3 0.2 0.1

7

0

0.7

0.3 0.1

7

1



0.5

0

   / 1  +*+*+*    --,,  ! ! /.. ""##"# 100 

    $     ( $%$%$  & &&''&  (())(    

0.3

0.5

0.1

6

6

0.1

0.4

æ çç ææçææççææçæ ç ççæ ñðñððñ åäåä òòóó çæ  ææçæççæçææç ôõôõôõ ä åä ç å 5

0.2

0.4

ÿ
ÿ
ÿÿ         

       úù     ûü   ý
ý
þþýý  ÿ
ÿ  

0.5

T [:X? CIA *-$Qãp* J ãt‘ X&’ $Qã W  Xê T [GèJ‘ X&’ t lo&O&E*(*(015  ^ 1"%$&
Ÿ  ^.*9?*5EH*+ (3o)