Benchmarking Database - Saferider

SAFERIDER ADVANCED TELEMATICS FOR ENHANCING THE SAFETY AND COMFORT OF MOTORCYCLE RIDERS FP7-ICT1-216355

BENCHMARKING DATABASE Deliverable No.

1.1

Workpackage 1 No.

Workpackage Title

User Needs and Use Cases

Activity No

Activity Title

Benchmarking database

A1.3

Authors

Annie Pauzié INRETS / LESCOT Laure Guillot INRETS / LESCOT

Dissemination Level 1

PU

Status 2

F

File Name

SAFERIDER_INRETS_WP1_V1_D1.1_BenchmarkingDatabase.doc

Project start and 1st January 2008, 36 Months duration Issue date

1st June 2008

Project Coordinator: Evangelos Bekiaris Centre for Research & Technology Hellas (CERTH) Hellenic Institute of Transport (HIT) 6th km Charilaou-Thermi Rd 57001, Thermi, Thessaloniki, Greece Tel: +30-2310-498453, Email: [email protected]

1

PU: Public; RE: Restricted; CO: Confidential

2

F: Final; D: Draft; RD: Revised Draft

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

Table of Contents TABLE OF CONTENTS...................................................................................................................................... 2 LIST OF FIGURES .............................................................................................................................................. 2 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY................................................................................................................................... 3 1

INTRODUCTION........................................................................................................................................ 4

2

BENCHMARKING DATABASE............................................................................................................... 4 2.1 2.2 2.3

OBJECTIVES ............................................................................................................................................ 4 METHOD AND PROCESS .......................................................................................................................... 5 CD-ROM PRESENTATION ........................................................................................................................ 6

3

CONCLUSION........................................................................................................................................... 10

4

ANNEX 1 - PTW’S IDENTIFIED FUNCTIONS.................................................................................... 11

5

ANNEX 2 - TEMPLATE ABOUT DESCRIPTION FORM .................................................................. 12

6

ANNEX 3 – TEMPLATE ABOUT OVERVIEW TABLE ..................................................................... 13

List of Figures FIGURE 1 : BENCHMARKING FUNCTIONALITIES ........................................................................................................ 5 FIGURE 2 : CD-ROM HOME PAGE ............................................................................................................................. 6 FIGURE 3 : EXAMPLE OF A FUNCTIONALITY PAGE .................................................................................................... 7 FIGURE 4 : EXAMPLE OF A PRODUCT PAGE ............................................................................................................... 8 FIGURE 5 : EXAMPLE OF TABLE TO COMPARE PRODUCTS ......................................................................................... 9

July, 2008

Page 2/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

Executive Summary The Del 1.1 “Benchmarking Database” is a public deliverable of the A 1.3 of Saferider Project. This deliverable is composed by an interactive CD Rom (available at [email protected] & [email protected] with a simple request) and this additional paper report. It gives a state-of-the-art analysis of existing and under development (prototypes) Advanced Driver Assistance System (ADAS) and In-Vehicle Information System (IVIS) applications for Powered Two Wheels (PTW), presenting interfaces with pictures, some technical specificities, names of the product, and references such as web site address where it is possible to get some additional up-to-date information about the product. The content of the “Benchmarking Database” has been set up by a compilation of information coming from Saferider partner’s inputs and from the net.

July, 2008

Page 3/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

1 Introduction The SAFERIDER project, funded within the 7th Framework-Programme of the DG Information Society & Media, aims to study the potential of ADAS/IVIS integration on motorcycles for the most crucial functionalities and develop efficient and rider-friendly interfaces and interaction elements for riders comfort and safety. This document is a part of the first Work Package untitled “User Needs & Use Cases”, including “A1.1: accident analysis”, “A1.2: Riders’ identified needs and want for information and communication technology”, run in parallel with “A 1.3: benchmarking database and ergonomic inspection of existing applications for riders”. The task “A1.4: use cases” will finalise this Work Package1. This document corresponds to the deliverable of the A 1.3 of Saferider Project. It gives a state-of-the-art analysis of existing and under development (prototypes) Advanced Driver Assistance System (ADAS) and In-Vehicle Information System (IVIS) applications for Powered Two Wheels (PTW) (note: the ADAS and IVIS acronyms have been created in the automotive context and are commonly used since then, identifying assistive functions from informative functions for the driver; it appears that they should be revised in the rider context: ADAS becoming ARAS for “Advanced Rider Assistance Systems” and IVIS becoming BIS for “Bike Information Systems”. For practical reasons, we will keep the ADAS and IVIS vocabulary all along this report and the CD Rom). The Del 1.1 “Benchmarking Database” is a public deliverable, and is mainly composed by an interactive CD Rom and an additional paper report. It is a compilation of information coming from partners input and from the net. This report presents context of the project in chapter 1, objectives, methods and results in chapter 2, whereas a conclusion is proposed in chapter 3.

2 Benchmarking Database 2.1 Objectives The objectives for setting up the Benchmarking Database are:

ƒ

To have an overview of available or under prototyping functions of PTW’s systems, in order to be able to evaluate the diversity and the characteristics of ergonomic design concerning existing functions and HMI.

ƒ

To develop a benchmarking database giving detailed information on each function, system by system, according to functionality, technical characteristics, producer, HMI elements used,…, including description and photos

ƒ

To make this benchmarking database available for the project partners and for any interested stakeholders through the development of an interactive CD Rom with an additional report.

July, 2008

Page 4/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

2.2 Method and process Following several conference calls between INRETS & UNIMORE, a common template (see annex 2) has been developed allowing to categorize and to describe PTW’s systems according to their technology, their functions and the specificity of their HMI. A template “overview table” (see annex 3) allowed each partner to be able to identify in which category he was able to bring information, and to organise then the inputs made inside the project (see Overview table and Description Template in annex of this report). The templates were sent to Saferider partners to be fulfilled according to their knowledge. Others information were collected from the net. To structure the database, INRETS proposed a classification of functionalities with five categories (cf. Figure 1 : Benchmarking functionalities). Pink categories cover functions related to safety and yellow categories cover functions related to comfort or entertainment. Green category is related to helmet HMI.

Navigation Traffic information

Comfort through general information

Weather information Safety camera Speed limit

Intersection warning : distance to the stop line Intersection warning : approaching vehicles Collision warning system

Safety through information assistance

On-coming vehicle information assistance Warning curve overshooting detection

Automatic stability control

Warning speed alert Safety through partial control

Brake assistant system

Adaptive light control

Automatic stability control

Rear view camera information assistance

Hands free call Radio MP3 player Picture viewer

NZI Entertainment Motorola helmet HS380 Helmet

Audio book player

Motion research HARD

Share ride BMW Motorrad Wireless communication helmet

Figure 1 : Benchmarking functionalities

July, 2008

Page 5/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

2.3 CD-Rom presentation INRETS chosed CD-ROM as a support of the interactive database because it allows presenting a great deal of information without overloading the reader. The CD Rom allows also interactivity and direct access to internet web sites, these features being an important quality made possible through this type of media. Home page presents eight categories (cf. Figure 2 : CD-Rom home page):

ƒ

four on the left related to ITS for safety,

ƒ

one about ITS for comfort,

ƒ

one about ITS for entertainment.

And the two latest categories present,

ƒ

for the one the particular type of HMI which is the helmet,

ƒ

and the other category presents sensors.

Finally, there is a bibliography page to reference all website used in this CD-Rom and visit them to bring a complement of information.

Figure 2 : CD-Rom home page

July, 2008

Page 6/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

Each category refers to several functionalities presented in special page. Each functionality page proposes a short description of the functionality on the top and an access to products page clicking on pictures (cf. Figure 3 : Example of a functionality page)

Figure 3 : Example of a functionality page

July, 2008

Page 7/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

Each product page of a same functionality is built with the same template. For instance, for navigation functionality: the description of general HMI, the specific subfunction HMI, pictures of HMI, and finally the additional features are presented (cf. Figure 4 : Example of a product page).

Figure 4 : Example of a product page

July, 2008

Page 8/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

When it was possible or when products have lots of functionalities, a table is added to compare products. For instance, for navigation function there is a summary presenting what function and what HMI for what product (cf. Figure 5 : Example of table to compare products).

Figure 5 : Example of table to compare products

July, 2008

Page 9/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

3 Conclusion

This overview allowed identifying the following important points: -

the systems covering assistive functions are at a very prototyping state. None of them are available on the market in Europe today. Some examples such as warning about on-coming vehicles are today available only in Japan. This review allowed to point out that this type of “ADAS functions” are under construction nowadays in several European projects (watchover, Pisa,…).

-

several “IVIS functions” functions are nowadays available for riders on the market: o

Entertainment such as music listening, audio book player, pictures viewing are functions made available for riders. Nothing on the literature indicates that riders are really using these functions.

o

Navigation, giving instructions to the user for directions to follow to reach a pre-defined destination. It has been showed in previous studies in the automotive context that the concept can have positive impact on road safety, as long as the interface and interaction do not interfere with the activity. From this point of view, the modalities of optimised navigation HMI for riders are not well known at this stage, very few studies have been conducted on this topic. The products available on the market have diversified HMI. For the dialogue between rider and system, the access for the user can be more or less direct according to the choice of the product manufacturer (for example, possibility of hardware buttons in addition to tactile screen inputs for some expansive product). The way to communicate auditory inputs to the rider is also quite diversified: some product relied on the mobile phone with blue tooth connection to transmit information to the rider, some other have just plain wired earphones connected to the system.

The ergonomic inspection planned as a next step of the A 1.3 will allow identifying which manufacturers choices regarding “IVIS functions” would be the more relevant in terms of usability and safety for the riders, according to expertise process.

July, 2008

Page 10/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

4

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

Annex 1 - PTW’s IDENTIFIED FUNCTIONS – Saferider Meeting in Lyon, Safety through partial control

Comfort through general information

¥Automatic stability control ¥Brake assistant system ¥Adaptative suspension ¥Intersection control ¥Traction control

Safety through information assistance ¥Intersection warning : distance to the stop line ¥Intersection warning: approaching vehicle ¥Collision warning system ¥Warning curve overshooting detection ¥Warning speed alert ¥Adaptative light control ¥Rear view camera information assistance ¥Blackspot warning ¥Blind spot assistante system

¥Navigation ¥Traffic information ¥Weather information ¥Safety camera

Entertainment ¥Hands free call ¥Radio ¥MP3 player ¥Audio book player ¥Picture viewer

Helmet ¥HUD on helmet ¥Wireless communication helmet ¥NZI

Safety through teleservices ¥E-call services ¥Telediagnostic services

Safety through integrated functions

Sensors ¥Ibeo ¥É

¥Piaggio ¥BMW K1200LT

July, 2008

31 March-1st April 2008

Page 11/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

5 Annex 2 - Template about description form Benchmarking Database of ICT for motorbike DESCRITPTION FORM

Template for the description of each function 28/02/2008 – version 2

This template allows to gather detailed information for each function/ each product in terms of Manufacturer, General description, HMI description, Status, Vehicle and Pictures.

Functions : (e.g. Comfort through general information or e.g. Safety through Information assistance, refer to the OVERVIEW TABLE) Name

Manufacturer General Description HMI description Status Vehicles Additional features Pictures

July, 2008

(e.g. Navigation or e.g. Intersection stop & go assistance system) (e.g. AvMap or e.g.HONDA ASV3) Description as detailed as possible concerning the technical features and the functionalities Description as detailed as possible concerning the Human Machine Interface and Interaction / mode of dialogue (e.g. Prototype or product) (e.g. Motorcycle, Mofa, Moped)

Size and weight, case, antenna, memory card accessories…)

Page 12/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

6 Annex 3 – Template about Overview Table Benchmarking Database of ICT for motorbike OVERVIEW TABLE

Template about overview of ICT identified functions 28/02/2008 – version 2

This table allows to have an overview of identified ICT functions for Motorbike. Each SAFERIDER partner is requested to complete it and to send the corresponding documents (HMI, Functions, Technical features, pictures,…) to INRETS.

Functions : Comfort through general information Navigation

HIT

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

TomTom RIDER BMW Motorrad Navigator I BMW Motorrad Navigator II BMW Motorrad Navigator III Garmin Quest GPS GARMIN Quest 2 GPS GARMIN StreetPilot 2820 GARMIN ZUMO 450 GARMIN ZUMO 550 AvMap

Traffic information

HIT

Unimore

Percro

GARMIN StreetPilot 2820 GARMIN ZUMO 450 GARMIN ZUMO

July, 2008

Page 13/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

550 BMW Motorrad Navigator III TomTom RIDER Other ???

Weather information

HIT

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

GARMIN StreetPilot 2820 GARMIN ZUMO 550 TomTom RIDER Other ???

Functions : Safety through information assistance On-coming HIT vehicle information assistance Honda ASV-3 motorcycle YAMAHA ASV-3 Research Motorcycle

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

HIT Intersection warning : distance to the stop line Honda ASV-3 motorcycle YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle Model 2 Other ???

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

HIT

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Other ???

Intersection warning : approaching vehicles July, 2008

Page 14/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle Model 2 Other ??? Right turn HIT warning : approaching vehicles YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle Model 2 Other ???

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

HIT Warning : approaching pedestrians YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle Model 2 Other ???

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

HIT Warning : obstacle detection YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle, model 2 Other ???

Unimore Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Warning : curve HIT overshooting detection YAMAHA ASV-2 Research Motorcycle, model 2 Other ???

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Warning : speed HIT alert Which product?

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Adapatative light HIT

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

July, 2008

Page 15/16

INRETS/LESCOT

DELIVERABLE 1.1 BENCHMARKING DATABASE

SAFERIDER PROJECT FP7-216355

control ALC Other ???

Rear view HIT camera information assistance Honda ASV-3 motorcycle Other ???

Unimore

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Percro

Piaggio

MetaSystem IBEO

INRETS

Functions : Safety through partial control Automatic stability control BMW Other ??? Brake assistant system YAMAHA ASV-3 Research Motorcycle Other ???

HIT

HIT

Unimore

Unimore

Percro

Human Machine Interaction HUD on HIT helmet VR2 NZI Other ???

Unimore

Wireless communication HIT helmet BMW WCS-1 helmet Motorola Wireless Helmet Headset HS830 NZI Tech Com 1.0 Headset/Handsfree/Intercom

July, 2008

Unimore Percro Piaggio MetaSystem IBEO

Page 16/16

INRETS

INRETS/LESCOT