DISCONTINUOUS ENRICHMENT METHODS FOR COMPUTATIONAL


 
  
   !"#%$
 $& '&(
) $ *
 +-, /.102435"37698:37;= 24?A@1= 24?A@1=D^3J_L F F!F F!F!F F!F F!FF F!F!F /FWP7FWP J=X. + ?424? B












































@J?4?4?

F!F F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F !

F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F F!F!F

F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF F!FF

F!F F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F ! F F !

] 

]



]



Q 

Q



Q



Q-S Q7Q P m1m Pm Pm P7P ] P7P Q PlP Pl P m P l














k
$!  # k?Aj70CM< l FWP $ CM=D?A37% ;  & F F!F!F F!F F!FF F!F!F F!F F!F!F F!FF F!F bFWP l H[65
# LN37240b=M?437;bL(Of31Ck"CM3 + F F bFWP m ,  ?A=M^ H[65













































b?W@

Pl] PlQ PlQ PlQ


  

 ^H 8CN3 @J?A_@7
 ! "  # 

% 

F

 $ J  %&! 

  LM^[.KCM8@1.KCM? .Y=D?431;L 31OJ=D^=D^3J_\H-.1;b_c . @J? .1C='.K;_`^3769.1L*$ ]bP%/37; =D^b
 ^b< LM0 + LNVBCN?48b=ML.1CMH ^?42A< .1CNCD. , L .1CN< CM?W=M=M






 

  



  




  '%

4   4 





 

lF  



8  



/?4;VZ<  3  3  ?4L9. L , 6565
8 

65?4; 8



 

 $  


g[;
=D?A37;L   6 . , + < _?4LNVB37;-=D?A;h0370L .KVBCM31LML ?A;h=M











  

      





$

 

 


< CM@J?4 


8CN3 + 24H ^?AVX^ VZ37CMCN
 






/

 4



 3 

37; 

) P   ;

  ?A;bO     



f_?A@ 

^?AVX^?AL




 

#)

 ) 

 

  



1

PS





1

 


1

 

 

        

  

37LN=*31O!=D^b< g;?A=M<
 



1



 P 1



 




 P

 

 







 


 P

 


 P




 P 

1

,.

+, 



             


 1        1     1

 

 







1





PR]



 





 P 

(& =  ( + LM






$2A=M^370j1^  +h,  



N
























1











a37;bLM?4_b
8   





8 " $ $ 8 " $ 8 " $ 8 "  



 b=D^[.Y= ?ALBH

I8

 

&(= .K;_ + < CN
N



l 








 




^
m  



lF l 




 
LN8[.1;    





^ 

    
     m

l







'



  

l F   

a 37;_?W=D?431; l F # ?46582A?4
  



, ?4 +,

 4

,.




4 



     



1

4 



  



   

  





 

  



   



l F 7S  


 


&




;*j1
 

  &

  !  

 & 

^


  

 !

&

LM.K=D?ALNO , H ^b


! '
#

 


'



 





!

  



l F  



 ! ?4L.`g[;?A=M






!

 

 

 

     

 

 



    

lF  

l F -S  






l

^   LN8[.1;   

             8   

LN8[.1; 







    

    



.1;_   H 8c .1CN< 2A3/VB.12h.188CN3 b?A6 .Y=D?431;L(31O  .1;_ 8H1CM
[ 37CM6 0b2 .K=M?437; l F (69. ,!+ =D?431; CN< .1V>=D?431;d 1











3 

  $;31=M^


 







bFWP m 


&


'    % 

 ;< 69. , VB316980/=D< =M^< $ LN37240/=D?431; fO 37C bFWP 
3K=D
 

           &(= 0bL VZ37;LM?A_
  #
  

 

 

$   %
#



 





!LM0VX^*=D^[.K= 

bFWP l  

 
#











'







#    # 


#  



 


 
^< VX^37?AVB





+,,

,,       

 ,,    ,,.

  

!           1 1    !      !    !    !  1 1
    ! 
#  #



 


8    
8   ! 

    

1

P 


#

 


  '

 ! '
#



'




 



 

!

  

 

bFWP 




?A=M^

 





34    

H

  


T








 

 



 

   

   .1L?4; bFAP .1;_   .1L?4; l F


 







  l F -S  H  ?A=M^    





 ^F'^b

+, -

3 4 ,.

 



1



  m ?A;





bFWPRQ 

 m 31;  










$LNLM065  1








1






 1



T
3 4   

l



31=M?4VB










,.

+,

 



 

 



  

1 1








+, ,.




  





  1  

      

  

1





bF l 



















k?4j10CM< /F #& 3JV .K=M?437;d31O
 ^F
;-=M
^ 

 

k?Aj70CM< /FAP m $ 8[.1CN=M?A=M?437;dLM.K=D?ALNO , ?4;jc.KLMLM0b698b=M?437;bL /FAP  bF











(&












 

bF -S  











&


(       









m,

1

1 2

2 −1

−1

h L

||u−u ||

||u−u ||

h L

2

10

2

10

DG SDG DEM

−2

10 −2 10

−2

k?4j10CM< /FAP CNCM37C82A31=DL3KO'"CM3 + F bF bFAP







0

 

J 

+,



−1

10

m ,  H[69



DG SDG DEM h




0.75

0.75 z

1.25

z

1.25

0.25

−0.25 0

0.25

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

−0.25 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

k?4j70bCM< bFWPR] $LM372A0b=D?A37; Of37C"CM3 + F /F bFWP
  2A



−1

10

,  [H 69


4 3







 4   

"  4 1



1



  

 8 

 

 

0=D?A@1=   + < .g[;b?A=D







LN8[.1;   

  

1



3 %



 
    









 

 3 a@7 

 







 



  

LM8.1;



1



3 





 







+ 370;_.1C , F
;

     

FGS  

 ^






8



FUQ  







 

  P



FWP m  

/ ?4;VZ< =D^< =M=)       P     .K;_    P  k?AjF F l  .1;_%      aLM0VX^=D^[.Y=   P     m .1;_%  P  
  P      P   F
T< 





7Q

LM















 

 

VB31;LN=M?A=D0/=D
   

 

 

P  P  

 P  P &  

 

S/P

$          






FWPR]  

2






J 

 )+!  0



J

(& =0L_F
; < /8:37;



8 

 


$ "



P 









 



 

$ )





 $ 

"



 

"

 











P

1

 




S






)  1 

 

1





$ )  $







) 





) 

P




















 




) 

bF#; 




 $ 

l
  l






k?4jF F `VZ37698.1CMO = =D35CM?Aj7^-=   











 





 

m H *%





m,H 

 P m  H










 

  

 

  

 

 

  

  

 

  

 

 

k?Aj70CM< F  b E
m,

h





0



0

10

10 1

1

1

1

−1

−1

h L

||u−u ||

h L

||u−u ||

2

10

2

10

−2

10

−3

−3

10

10 GLS SBO DEM

−4

10 −2 10

−2

10

−4

10 −2 10

−1

h

GLS SBO DEM

10

−1

k?4j10CM< bFAP m CNCM37C82A31=DL3KO'"CM3 + F F /F l H *  



S1]



10




h

m,



,

 

        

  



  

  

 





 

 

 





 

 

    




 

   




k?Aj70CM< FWP7P
 # F 



 P 

y

y

0.5





 P 



 m

 l 

l  Xm ED

0.5

 0.1

x

x

k?4j10CM< bFAP S #J=X.K=M














−1

10

||u−u ||

h L

2

1 1

−2

10

GLS SBO DEM

−3

10 −2 10

−1

10

k?4j10CM< FWPRQCNCM37C82A31=31Ok"CM3 + F bF bF h









=D39.1;*370b=& [3  LM?A_
"      .1; _       aLM0bVX^=D^.K= 









 

 

.1;_












   m

$L ?A; FWP l >H a < _b


    "!

 1 




1

1 



$   "" " 1

    ""

1 


 m ?4;





     37;  

^
]

/




=D^b

(       

N

      % (

&(= 0bL VZ37;LM?A_









N





& 



   NJ

    

$ L*LMH *  m , 




  

, 



m , f24O ==M3

0

0

10

10

1

1 1

1 −1

−1

h L

||u−u ||

h L

||u−u ||

2

10

2

10

−2

10

−3

−2

10

−3

10

10 GLS SBO DEM

−4

10 −2 10

−4

10 −2 10

−1

10

h

k?4j10CM< bF l S CNCM37C82A31=DL3KO'"CM3 + F F bF l 



GLS SBO DEM






−1

m ,  H[69






   
   





 

 




k?Aj70CN< F bE
,, ,,.

1




4 )  463!' '

?4;  m 4? ;  73 ; 



/FAP   



^







 m

  

        

  







7 '

    

  7    

/F   






































l












P l




/FGS  

      2   ) 5        ^


















  
   1 
 




P     
l

 



' ' '






 '

' ' 







'




 '





 '

 ' 








P


















   

 




)






'&

   JN          J       ^
 ,,  '  1 ' ! ,., ,,

  1  !  1

' !  

' !    ' !   !  







 

   !

)



 ) 



1

) ! 1

) !

 1





1



1 1

) ! 


    ! 

 



 

  

      m   !      m

1

 ) 






 m



 m

Q7Q

lF mH 



 

!  )  ) ! % 1

LN0VX^=M^[.K=

   '         !  '  !    !    '   !  ' !  '      '
    





/FUQ 

















" CN
/?4;VZ 





 /

/ /








/

 

/ 1

463!' 



 4

l #



P

P l





1






/

/



/


1

 m /

/



3 4



m 



/


 CN376 f?A@ >H 4? L^3169/ 37j1


 &

 #IH  P  l F   73 C     ?A=D^       +
P 






3K=D< =D^[.Y=  






l 31;*65


;









/FWP S  

 3  Z< @1
F

' 

   &D H   

    HbLM3 '    

45'

  CN376 $ LMLM0b698b=M?437; /F bHa=D^b
/?4;VZ<  

  m





 

   m H





















  %






 3   "   .KCM<
Pm]





   









          ,      



/F l  

    

  ,   



 m

?A;
  








,




1



  


















PmQ




P 1

Q 







  









,




 /F l ]  

^=D?A37;                             + B< 2A37;j7L=D3    F
T< VB.1; ==D^b< 
















OfCN376   & 1. ;b_ LN=D?A242^[. @7<      P   P   P 1 1


+ ?A24?4;b< .1C`=D




























=M^







   " 

^H



5F#[CM316

^Hb$LMLN0658b=D?A37; /F l .1;b_ /F >H  -]    
     -]    
      "    
    "       ^ 



  1   "    












/

 

 F$;.12437j1370LM2 , =D3`& H&(
k?4j10CM< /F $@7O =.1;_








0

CN?4j7^-=

10

1

1 1

||u−u ||

h V

1

h V



0

10

||u−u ||

10

h

−1

10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

−1

10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

−1

10

−1

k?4j10CM< JFU] =D^3J_ ?A;`.65








$ 24265


2

2

−2

−2

10

10 2

1

h L

||u−u ||

||u−u ||

h L

2

1

−3

10

−3

10

GLS SBO DEM

−4

10 −2 10

GLS SBO DEM

−4

10 −2 10

−1

10

−1

10

k?Aj70CM< /FWP l 


 )



31=M?4VB


 ^







  



  

   





 








k?Aj70CN< /F lKm "CM
Pl]








0

0

10

10 1 2

h L

||p−p ||

||p−p ||

h L

2

1

1

−1

1

−1

10

10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

−1

10

−1

10

%?4j70CN< /F l "CM
−1

−1

10

10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

GLS SBO DEM

−2

10 −2 10

−1

10

−1

k?4j10CM< /F l S     
     B >H l P P  WP7P S :P l bH:PRQ7Q /F

$ P% )`F









< k.12A24H  7S/P 1]-S/HIPRQ7Q F

$ l7l %











F !FEaCN3/3 hL5.1;_  F bFF0j7^
:     #">Hb@7372A065
P 1Q 


 # "



$
%

 F F $0;  + 0CNj75cs  # A BRA7 ? K}I O"#$#   0  ^  ¤Y_–b‘X\RY_~`4f@YZ —SA˜© ‘XZ–Z“`–W YW˜L^T\’‘XV{`4f@YZ ^WYZ“deX`$eX . l , (*g m9,  " ƒ  + g ,U/ „^†œ  o •  %"E By ! 7 %"A8E BR&E !C?@! E 7 By ?3 E%" PGME 2Ÿ @8A # 2P% < A8 ?@! E 7K % !CN&O ! E 7 "2@E I # ABR  [SU\^]T_j‘XV ‘X_–bSA˜UeP`–W Œ]*]Z“`4‘@˜ ‘0f0b9YW`4f0e YW˜ [W `–© W€‘0‘XV{`–W € ("h . UK . . k{l , g , m9, gg ƒ ( (9 + ,U/ t ^O† ; 7 ?3 Ÿ)8A8 O 238 J EG 7"E 7"8E 79GME 2QB ! 7"  O %"2 !$#  ? 23 #  # ABRA7 ? K "2@E ! By ?@! E 7 GME 2 ?@  œ