Counting the Number of Equivalent Binary Resolution Proofs Joseph


   
   "!$#%&$'  #$ ( )*,+
% &
.-/

0+ 01 20354&6879:520?0@ a[b APÉ\2i?825784”=54&35½8¼x> 2SË$=54&3520¼xÏ5784”Â&¼|ºS½8354&3ºS>>57846hºS=54&? ?825784$Ê8¹x?hºS=5»=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?>5=54&4 Ò|Ê8=5>"Ó\2SË,¾x¿Ô8ÐPÕÁL¹x3½8354&Ä>52=54&68=54&354&?$35½8Â"7”68=5254&Äi=54ºS3520?84&=53 Â&20?835>5=5½8Â&> 68=5257hºS>ºS?mÊh44"È[4&Â&>5¹xÏ04&¼x» =54&68=54&354&?54&ÄÊ53: ¸\¹x?hºS=5»=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?3520à 4&>5¹xà 4&3L¹x3\ºS353525¹xÏ040ÐS¹x?>57hºS> ËH20= 3520à 4Â&¼|ºS½8354&3 Ñ ÐS¸ºS?8Ä 9ÐLÒ|Ø ÙÚÛÓÙSÜÝ*ÞœØ ÙÚÒHÛ/ÙSÜÝÓ&:Lß4&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?”20?ºS?iºS>520Ãà6¹x3$Ä84&?820>54&ÄÊ5784 206h4&="ºS>5¹x20?_Ù"áh:LÇ7¹x36h203535¹xÊ8¼x4>52”Â"7hºS?8Æ04>5784 20=5Ä84&=2SË>5784 =54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?83¹x?i>5784 â,ã O"YPO"B&Q5CPŽ YHD0N0N8I&Q5FPO"gŠ0GB$&Q5B&U0F JxQ5IM/ZRSj ã KiI&J K B&UºS?8Äi68=525782¹x>,¹x3 ?820>\ºS¼x¼x4&Ä>57hºS>¹x? >578203546hºS6h4&=53: ¸\¹x?hºS=5»_=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?m7hºS3      ”ºS¼x352hÐÉ78¹xÂ"7m¹x3ý8Â"7_4ºS35¹x4&= >52i7hºS?8Ä8¼x40:¸\4&ºS½8354i؜ÙÚ,Û ÞÛ ÙÚØàËH20=ºS¼x¼Â&¼|ºS½8354&3Ø ºS?8ÄÛ É78¹xÂ"7ºS?Êh4 =54&3520¼xÏ04&ÄLÐ8=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?”68=525784&354=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?83: ,?844ºS35» ɺ»>52ºÏ020¹xÄ >5784Ä8½868¼x¹xºS>5¹x20?¹x3>52 20=5Ä84&=,>5784Â&¼|ºS½8354&3$¹x?52º 5ɺS¹x>5¹x?8 Æ !¼x¹x35>Ð8354&¼x4&Â&> 4ºSÂ"720?84ºS>,º>5¹xà 4,ºS3$º 5Æ0¹xÏ04&? !Â&¼|ºS½83540Ð8=54&3520¼xÏ04>5784Æ0¹xÏ04&? Â&¼|ºS½8354ɹx>57ºS?578¹x3Lɺ»5784Â"7820354&?Â&¼|ºS½83540Ð0ºS?8Ä?820> É784&? Û ¹x3 >5784Â"7820354&? Â&¼|ºS½83540: "HËLº,=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?68=52578¹x3$Â&20à ý8>"ºS>5¹xÏS4,=54&Ä8½8?8ÄhºS?8Â&»5784&?4ºSÂ"7Ê8=5>$ɹx>57 &=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?83 Â&20½8¼xÄiÊh4Â&20?835>5=5½8Â&>54&Ĺx?mÔ 'iÄ8¹ È[4&=54&?ɺ»5¹x?8ƹxÄ84&?5¹xºS¼Â&¼|ºS½8354&3½835¹x?8Æ ËH20=5ɺS=5Äm35½8Ê835½8à 68>5¹x20?LÐ 35½8Â"7/º68=525¹xÏS4,=54"× Ä8½8?8ÄhºS?8Â&»ÃºS¹x?8¼x»Êh4&ºS½8354=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?ºS¼xɺ»54&3\Ê8½8>,Ä82$ºS¼xɺ»5784$=54&3520¼xÏ04&Ä ¼x¹x>54&="ºS¼x3Ð0>5784&?”¹x? 20?84$20=5Ä84&=2SË>5784$=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?83¹x>\ºS?Êh4à 4&=5Æ04&ĺS?8Ä >5784&?”=54&3520¼xÏ04&Ä ºÉº»É¹x>57>578420>5784&=20=5Ä84&=,¹x>\¹x3¼x4"ËH>¹x? >5784$=54&35½8¼x>: )820=\4 *8ºSà 68¼x 4 + Þ ,/1

Ò ,-.Ù0Ú / -.ÓLÙS0Ü 1 .,2 Ê8½8> ,-.\ÙÚ\ Ò / -.\ÙS0Ü 1 .Ó3 Þ ,/1. Ç784$ºS6868¼x¹xºS>5¹x20?2SË ºS353525¹xÏP»=54&ÅPÉ\2ºSÄÍ&ºSÂ&4&??8252Êh4,=520>"ºS>54&Ĺx? º,Ê8=5>Ð5784,20=5Ä84&=\2SË[>5784,=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?83Ð5¹x¼x¼h68=525784,3"ºSà 4\=54&35½8¼x>5¹x?8Æ Â&¼|ºS½8354ºS>>5784¼x2SÉ\4&= ?82"ºS>5¹x20?¹x3 35¹xà ¹x¼|ºS=>52_>5784=520>"ºS>5¹x20?6h4&=PËH20=5à 4&Ä ¹x? 5Ñ 476 ×P>5=54&4&3”É784&?=54&ÊhºS¼|ºS?8Â&¹x?8ƾx¿"Á5: Ñ Æ04&?84&="ºS¼$4 *8ºSà 68¼x4 ¹x335782SÉ?¹x2? )L¹xÆ0½8=54i¿0: ÇÉ\2Ê8=5>53$ºS=543"ºS¹xÄ>52 Êh84     9 9:; 9:L¹ Ë20?84ºS?”Êh420Ê8>"ºS¹x?84&ÄËH=520Ãà>5784 20>5784&=Ê"ºS>5¹x20?83: ß20>"ºS>5¹x20?4&Å5½8=54&368=54&Â&¹x354&¼x» >5784ºS353525¹xÏ04$=54&Ä8½8?8ÄhºS?8Â&»2SË Ê8¹x?hºS=5» =54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?L: Ñ ?”ºS½8>520úS>54&Ä Ê8¹x?hºS=5» =54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?68=525¹x20?hºS¼x¼x»$4&Å524ºSÂ"720>5784&=: ,?8Â&4$68=525784,4 *5="º$Ê8=5>53ºS=54 >P»57hºS>20=5Ä84&= >5784¼x¹x>54&="ºS¼x3ɹx>57mºÂ&¼|ºS½83540Ð35½8Â"7ºS320=5Ä84&=54&Ä=54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?/¾ =8?Ð >SÁ,20=¼x25=5¹xÂ&>5¹x20? ºÏ020¹xÄ8368=54&Â&¹x354&¼x»>5784ºS353525¹xÏ04$=54&Ä8½8?8ÄhºS?8Â&»2SË =54&3520¼x½8>5¹x20?L: ;,2SɜÊ8¹xƔºS=54>57844&Å"ºS>5¹x20?hºS¼x¼x»4&Å53 @8"P?>578¹x3 6hºS6h4&= ¹x>¹x335782SÉ?m>57hºS>˺Ê8=5> Â&20?"ºS¹x?883 & ¹x?54&=5?hºS¼,?8254&="ºS¼x3Ð0>5784&?>5784$?53=520>"ºS>5¹x20?hºS¼x¼x»4&Å52ºÆ0¹xÏ04&? Ê8=5>\¹xB3 -S Ò C,EÓ D Ô

h‰ 0‰8niŠ0T U"ºS>54&Äm>52>5784=522SË,>5784Ê8=5>:0"P?mÂ&¼|ºS½8354 >5=54&4”>54&=5à 3ÐL>578¹x3 ¹x3$>5784?520Ã?82520= 2SË8Êh4&>PÉ\4&4&? ºSÊh20½8E> > ºS?8Ä &20?>5784$?5¹x20?836h4&=PËH20=5à 4&ÄL: Ñ 320?8¼x»”>5784 35>5=5½8Â&>5½8=54”2SË,>5784 68=52"ºS?$¹x?i>578¹x36hºS6h4&=Ð ¹x>ºS?_Êh4 ºS3535½8à 4&ÄËH20=>5784 à 2035>6hºS=5>>57hºS>ºS¼x¼ºS>520à 3ºS=54 Æ0=520½8?8Ä_ºS>520à 3 : i4ºS?_¹xÄ84&?5¹ ËH» >5784 ?825784Ê8=5>Ê5784 ¼x¹x>54&="ºS¼ËH=520à >5784¹x?835>"ºS?8Â&4&32SË,>5784¼x¹x>54&="ºS¼x3$ËH=520à >5784 ¹x?868½8>\Â&¼|ºS½8354&3,=54&3520¼xÏ04&ĺS>\>5784?8254ºSÄ2SË>5784$Â&¼|ºS½835468=525¹x20?2SË ¹xà 68=52SÏ04&Ã4&?53h>52,>5784\68=52520=5¹x?8Æ206h4&="ºS>5¹x20?83Ð20=LÄ8¹ È[4&=54&? à 4&=5Æ04&3: "P?8Ä84&4&ÄËPºSÂ&>520=53$ºS=542SËH>54&?ºS¼x¼x4&Äà 4&=5Æ04&3>578=5½820½8>>578¹x3,6hºS6h4&=:8;,2SÉ\4&Ï04&=,>5784 =54&35½8¼x>53$2SË>578¹x3,6hºS6h4&=ºS6868¼x» >52Ìh=535>,20=5Ä84&=$¼x20Æ0¹xÂ$ɹx7520½8>,>5784&354=54&35>5=5¹xÂ&>5¹x20?83Í"½835>$ºS3 É\4&¼x¼LºS3>5268=5206h2035¹x>5¹x20?hºS¼[¼x20Æ0¹xÂ0: Ç784354&Â&20?8Äm354&Â&>5¹x20?mÆ0¹xÏ04&3ÊhºSÂ"Î53 ºS?8Ä_Â&¼|ºS½8354>5=54&4&3¾ Á5: ¼|ºS½8354 >5=54&4&3ºS=54”ºS?820>5784&=à 4&>57825¹x20?m68=52"ºS?8Ä8¹x?8Æm>5784”=54&35½8¼x>53¹x?>578¹x36hºS6h4&=:  4&Â&>5¹x20"? !Â&20?835¹xÄ84&=53 >57844 *5=54&à 4ºS354&3$ËH20=,>5784?5784&=54 ºS=54?82à 4&=5Æ04&3 2S˼x¹x>54&="ºS¼x3$¹x?>5784 68=525¹x20? >”Æ0¹xÏ04&3º Ä8»