DELPHI collaboration. DELPHI 2001-062 CONF 490. June 18, 2001. A study of the energy evolution of event shape distributions and their means.
!#"%$'&)(+*,*.-0/1*,23(54768'9;:,.?@A-CB.D(+*,*-
E FHGIKJML N OPGQSR RTSRUV5L RXWYNAZ[IMG\[NYT N O RXWYRT]G^F_QS`bacR JKC\ FHGU%\CdKIMG_\[NYTKF^`bTKJ GQSRe\CUgf Re`hTKF k mporqtsuJSRXG_RevwGxNAUy`Ggmpkzo i \0GQ G_QSR jln {S|}{]~##+
_K|7c~3~,0
_|c~,
|XC[ _K|}~ ¢¡[£+¤¦¥§¤¦¨©¢¡'ª¡C«C¬¨®+¯°±¤²¥³ ¨®¬§¢¡¤_´#µ¨®¶0¤²¥§¬¨¸·º¹ ·»½¼_¾M¿bÀÁÁ+¤¦¥·§Â ¼_0Àà ¬·¥¢Ã ¤xÄůÇÆ[Ä0Å0È[É¿ÀÁÁʤ²¥·¢Â˯+¼x¤²¥Ì7µC« Ä7ͱÎÏ#Ð%¯+ͱ¾#»§ºÄÇ _¼x¤²µ¤¦¶7ÄѯÒCÓÔ¨¸·§Õ¦¤²¥Â©µÖ ×bØÙÚ0Û ÜÝÇÚ Þ§ßàâá¦ãCá¦äåæãÇßå;çºèé}é}êß3äãCá ë1ãCàËäìäíÇäßîïë1ðãCñäìåê}ë1îòá¦êôóõ3î1ê}èßëöãÇßå;î1ð3äêôáY÷äãÇß;í[ãÇé}õäë ãCá1ä å3äîòäá¦÷øêß3äåhãCî%çºäßîòá1äºùèÇàâù÷øãÇë1ëäß3äá1úêôäë_óäîûHääß5üýXîòèöþCÿþ ä ñð3äß3è÷øäß3èéôèÇúê}çãÇé ãÇßãÇ é ,ë1ê}ëxê}ßbí+ê}äûæèÇàñè0ûxäá%çºèÇá1á1äçºî1êôèß5÷øè+å3äéëxêßçé}õåêß3ú ðãÇå3á¦èßb÷öãÇë1ë_ä .äçºî1ë%àâèÇáóèÇî1 ð åê äá1äßÊî1ê}ãÇéåê}ë1îòá¦êôóõ3î1ê}èßëãÇßå'÷øäãÇß íCãÇé}õ3äëê}ëñá¦äëòäßîòäå ë1ê}ß3úñ.è ûHäá çºèÇá1á1äçºî1ê}èßë ±ê}ë ä+îòá²ãÇçºîòäåàâá¦è÷ ÷äãÇßeíCãÇé}õ3äë±ãÇßåeë1ðãCñäë ë±ãÇßeãÇéôîòäá²ßãCî1êôíÇäãCññá1èãÇç²ðXá1äß3èÇá¦÷øãÇéê}ë1ãCî1êôèß úÇá1èõ3ñ êßíCãCá¦ê}ãÇßçº ä )Þøê}ëøõëòäåãÇëöãÇß ä +ñéê}çêôîøçºèßëòîòá²ãÇê}ßî éôäãÇåê}ß3úîòè ãçºèßë1ê}ëòîòäßÊî å3äë1çºá¦ê}ñî1êôèß èÇàH÷äãÇßïí[ãÇé}õäëûê}î1ð3èõ3îßääåYàËèÇá7ë1 ê äãCóéôä'ñè0ûxäá)çºèÇá¦á1äçºî1êôèßë "!%ðä #%$'& ( ùà õßçºî1êôèßê}ë)ñá1äçê}ëòä é A÷äãÇë1õ3á1äåõë1ê}ß3úbî1ðê}ë7ãCññá1èãÇç¦ð *)3á1è÷rî1ð3* ä &,+.-0/21Þ)åãCî1ã5èß 3 ù !%ð3á¦õëòîê}ßçé}õåê}ß3ú'åãCî1ãèÇàÔéôè0û;äßäá14ú hä +ñäá¦ê}÷øäßî1ë_èß3ä èÇóî1ãÇê}ßë (6587:9=4?A@ ÿ ;>B þ àâèÇá î1ð3äeèß3äeéôè+èÇñïçºè+ä CöçêôäßÊîèÇàî1ð3ä ( ùàËõßçºî1êôèßYèÇDá ãÇë¦ë1õ÷øê}ßEú #%$'& àâèÇá)î1ð3äeßÊõ÷ óäáèÇà ãÇçºî1êôíÇGä FãíÇèõ3á¦ë ü HJI 7 ü ;K9 ý @ ÿ ; üÇL !%ð3äëòä7íCãÇé}õ3äëãCúÇá1ääwûxäé}éûêôî1M ð #G$'& ä +ñäçºî1ãCî1êôè ß (6587N9?O9 ãÇßå HJI 7 Pý 4RQ,?TSUWVYX>ZS @\[ "]P^@\U"_`QaUw%"8b $'%"(+*,*.-Lcd >J[ ]P^@\efShg"]+?J[ !#"%*.-Lcji%QakA@lg
#s TG_UNìJKIKvwG_\[NYT @ [@ U @\]Pe @EQJ^ VË?.D D %V S Vâ?\U²@l]PeWVË?Y@[?@ U+DYD QaUGkLQakY@[?TS >Jk SU ]+?Je1/ _@\U D , D ]ÊJ? [:S@ U @ ] kr 4 JU QakMQ6[ ? ]PkMV\e Dø4)hDPS@ T]Ê>,@,S.@\QaU! QP_eWSUWQ,? VË?TSº@ U]DSV Q,?Je" d @ e VY[.\@ eLS @ kYl@ ] U²\@ kY@[T? S QP_ S@ eWS U Q,? #\Q,Z> ^ YVâ? V Se²@ _1D8S@ ^JU @\V e @kY@l]JU²@\kY@[?TS Q.?J? VË? MV e,S@ U D@ _`QaU @ ]+?%@ $ ^\@ U V kA@ T? S] S]Pe QZ? [ ]PkY@[?TS] VYkM^QaUfS]+?[@" @ eWS J> [ Q.@[? @ V e7%@ $ ^@ S \@ [ SQ6& U XJ] UWX ] e VYQ+? Q U X ] SV0&+@ \QPU U @ S VYQ,J? e%VâR ? +@[?@ U] %V0 U²\@ [> [*@ S*@ e V0S[@ QP_.S*@ ^0Q, @ U%S \@ UWkLe" ." Q, \@ UT\QaUWU @ DSV Q,? kLQ6[@ e]PU² @ \Q,J? eWVY[@ U @ [A@ eWS] ]+T? S V SVâ\@ e _`QaUX JV0CN^Q, \@ U>\QPU U @ S VYQ,J? eE]PU @ kMVËZ? VYkMVS[@ [ eJQ,> [ X@Y@ kL^ ]Pe V e @ ["MY QaU²\@ Q,&,@ U S.@ U l@ ] \@ eWeEQP_A^Q, \@ UZ\QaUWU @ SV Q,J? e ]+J? [ S\@ V U U l@ ]/
%@ $6S @[J? [LVYe_J? Q 0 0>J? [@ U efSQ6Q [\[ô- ]^"_=`\U V SV0l] 6U %@ & V e V Q,M ? ] YeWQ QP_Q \@ e eGQP_SZVYeAS \@ efS%VYkM^ YVâ\@ e S ].J? [:_`QPUES@ ^Q, \@ UM\QaUWU @ SV Q,N ? kLQ6[@ Ye VË? monpl]+? X@ ^JU²\@ [JV0 Sº@ [ Z> e VË? ic& ^\@ UWS J> U XJ] ^ SQM(+*3K( c^@ uhD _`U Qak S@ @[?@ UaVâ\@ e ]PU Q+>J? [ S.H @ v ^0QQ Ë"@ ]ZkLkL]PU V e @ Ê] ?J\ [ ,Q ? Ë>J[ @*âV ? b @DSVY+Q ?a"
j RXG_RevwGxNAU
SJS`Gx` `bTKJ JS`Gx` `bTS`hZ LFx\CF wes yIt {}| VYeL]#@ U kY@ S V [@ S @ S QaU %V S ] e QQ â@[?JQPVY[ ] "kL],?.@ SV06@ [ QP_ -Q"®(/4" @S U]C Vâ? [@DSº@DSQaUWe[JD eWV S > ] ! % ! # c @ kL]PeWe5@3 @ S eMS@A Q ]P^J^ZU QT]C. @\e ]PU @*]P^Z^Y Vâ@\[~ &ò? }[ -CJU1/kMQakY@[?TSº>Jk VË? S@*efS]+?J[J]PU [ _`QaU kb> ]~ g V c ! ! g c / eC @ kA@lg c¦-Ç*ag 5 c! E g V cI H E g cNø / eC @ kA@lg c¦-,-4g 5 c! E
V SJ % H X@\Vâ? S @ø>?JV SF,& @ S QaU Vâ? [JVYU²@ S VYQ,? QJU @Xl~w4RQPU U @ S VYQ,?Je [>@ SQ kL]Pe e @3@DSe~D.@ _> } VË?@*eZQ; %e S@ U @ Y]?TSO" n Z VË @ S @ Q,+& @\U]/ _
@%±3 @ S*VYe QP_ S @ QaUW[@\U Q ]ZS U @ ]ZS VYQ,?Je_`QaU: D2,2D+2 ]+?J[J^Z^@ UBC ]J,Q ? U] / [JVY] â@l]P[ S Q ]*X ]P[ 0U ,Q ?TSUWQQ â@\ [ @%$aC +] ?,@ QP_0S .@ %V [ @G+] ?JY [ ? ]PUWU ,Q @%&,@[?T S @\kMVYeW^ @\²U @ [ô-ÇJe Vâ?] U XJ] ]PUWV S VË\@ eG_`Q,>J? [ Q,? S.M@ U²l@ ] ']j$ VYe" 9 QaU e²@ &+\@ U]/ 8[ZV03\@ U @ T? SV]/ '[JVYefSUWVYXZ> S VYQ,Z? e ]+J? [ VË? S@ e V kL^ Ë\@ efSA]P^J^JUWQ,$ V k ] Se8VËM? eJV _ SVâ? SG@ [JVYefSU V XZ> S VYQ,? c"gQP_S@ QPXJe @ U&JUWe"VË? S@ ?JQ,?/^@\UWS >JU XJ]
2
>
-
- (
.
Ë?8 c1-
@
- Tg
. @
g - ([ ¦c - - ( e g ¦c - - e g ] ! c" . $g # -
1- - ( e g ¦- - ( e - ec Tg g
*-, . ' 8c
8c
" 5
)
(' .0/ (.c&
eg
%V S 5 aV8&,@ ? X2 S.@ ^0QaeWV SV Q,? PQ _.S@ö!]+?J[J]+>".QQ â@ Q Y] S Q+?@ ,D@ Se~ c¦- - S]+? ( g / ö 4 8 a g!) . *-9;: 4< ,>= . .@? = 36A c¦- ;( (0g c¦-C:Tg 5 c g 9 5 c S]+? 3 \QaeAa : ( 5 ( -
1/N dσ/dBsum*scale
ß}è1êºîç1ä1áÇáºè ç áxä0ûèñ ä31ðîÇàèß}è1êºîÇç¦ãòáî3ó1õ_ëáòäËîCà#ãôîé1õë1äá3ä1ð#îë û3è1ðë3ä}ßêøéå3ä1ðÇëãå3ä%ð!4Çä3úÇߦã+áÇé}ã1ê}îê}ßê3ä1ðøîåßÇèäøóßôè1êCî}ãéèCñ¦ãòá,îä Çßãë0û3è¦ðhëä}ß}êc é åòäòîÇî3èYå3ä1ðhîôä}éêð_û4 Çä3úÇߦãáîä1ðøî}ëÇéã+õhä3ä}ß}ê_é}ééËõ àä%ð! )ä.þCÿþ åÇßì ã ýü ßäxäûîäó ëôäê¦úá3äß#äÇáËèÔàë3ú}ßêßäÇåã1èxáîÇää1ðîÇàè1ëîßôäêçCÊäºèçÇäôí1êCîã¦ó3á1õ1îáäñ,ùß3èßä1ðîÇàèß}è1êCîã}ßøê¦÷áòäîä & a~ @ JU,>0V9
Ç2-
10 16
DELPHI 202 GeV
10 14
200 GeV
196 GeV
10 13 196 GeV
10 12 192 GeV
10 12 192 GeV
10 11 189 GeV
10 11 189 GeV
10 10 183 GeV
10 10 183 GeV
10 9 172 GeV
10 9 172 GeV
10 8 161 GeV
10 8 161 GeV
10 7 133 GeV
10 7 133 GeV
10 6 93 GeV
10 5 91.2 GeV
10 4 89 GeV
10 3 76 GeV
10 5
10 4
10 3
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 0.35 Bsum
–
10 15
202 GeV
10 14
200 GeV
10 13
10 2 45 GeV
1/N dσ/dBmax*scale 10 15
10 6
√s 10 16
10 10
1 1
DELPHI
93 GeV
91.2 GeV
89 GeV
76 GeV
10 2
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25 0.3 Bmax
√s
–
66 GeV 66 GeV
45 GeV
EEC*scale
DELPHI
–
√s
10 7
202 GeV
10
6 200 GeV 196 GeV
10
5 192 GeV 189 GeV
10 4
183 GeV 172 GeV
10 3
161 GeV 133 GeV
10 2
93 GeV 91.2 GeV 89 GeV
10
76 GeV 66 GeV
1 45 GeV
90
100 110 120 130 140 150 160 170 180 χ
9 V0,J> U @bB ~ & äîòäá¦÷öê}ßãCî1êôèß]èÇàHî1ð3äXßèß,ùñäá1î1õ3á1óãCî1ê}íÇäXçºè+äCöçêôäßÊî1ë)èÇàî1ð3ä +.+$pàâèÇá)äß3äá¦úêôäë)óäîûxääß üýeãÇßå þCÿþ2)ä!%ð3ä)à õé}é.é}ê}ß3ääÊõãÇéë_î1ð3ä î_á¦ãÇß3úÇä4 3ûðêéôäî1ð3äwåèÇîòîòäå é}ê}ß3ä ë1ð3è ûëãÇßhä+îòá²ãCñ.èéãCî1êôèß óä Çèßåæî1ð3äìêßêôî1ê}ãÇéá¦ãÇß3úÇ4ä !ð3äìåãÇë1ð3äåæéê}ß3äë1ð3è ûë5î1ð3äá1äë¦õéôî5ãCàâîòäáïë1õ3óîòá²ãÇçºî1êôèßæèÇàXî1ð3äñè0ûxäá çºèÇá1á1äçºî1ê}è ß
-
n @ U @*S@*^@\UWS >JU XJ]JU XJ]JUWX ] ]P[JU ] Ë? ø - [ [ c g [ # c g@] [ c g [ # c g c¦-Ç2ag 5 ( (
@
@ SU @\]JU X ] SV0+& @%^ ]PU]JV8P& ]/Ë @[?TS S QNS @ ?JQ,?/ ^@ UWS >JU X ] SV0+& @ ^ ]PU ]PkA@DSº@ U QP_ S @ QPS @\U QaXJ e²@\U! P& ] ]L_`QPU S @ %4 V e ]x ]JU @ kA@ ?TSe]J[@ [VË? S@(JSO"'@PJU eWSX@\UWU QaUGVYe%S@ eWS]@[?[@ QP_ZJ]P[JU Q+? k ] S Q ],@\efSËV ? V ] \,Q ?JefS+] ?TS e JV _ S ,Q &+@\U S.@Z ZQQ Ë@ZlHE²@ S%²U @aV ,Q ? ËV ??l]P²e @*QP_.S @4 ^ ] e*e ]P^@ kA@\]+?Je ]PU²@ _> 0 0 VË? Ë>JeWV0&+@ d > ]+T? SV SVâ\@ e8[\@ ^@[J? [ZVË? Q,? ] eWVË? Ë@w@[?@ UMel] â@ Q,? 0> JV0C ]PU @ \@ eW^@\VY] 8U @ 0e >JV Sº@ [L_`QaUT YQ, eWS] e VË? ] 0 @%&,@ ? S e"*JQ+>Q S@ C ]PU ] S \@ UWVYeWS V eQP_S@)%@ &,@ ? SAeJ]P^" @ QPXJe @ U& c§(+*ag i >5 D 5 ( j#m - @ ( @
%V Sx= ]Ê?J[ d X@\Vâ?P ?JQ,w
??\ Q@rqM\ Vâ@[?TSe4[ ( D(+BD(Ê?2 @ VQTS @\[kY@l]Ê? *"¸2: l.- ø* " *+:3B ø* "¸Q* l,< 5c
5
c^mg *"-(Ê:- ø*" *,*.- ø*a"®*,*l.*"-(,(,(ø*" *,*3(+*ø *a®" *,*,l * *"-,- ø *" *,*Q,l *ø *a®" *,*-ÇB *"-,-ÇB ø *" *.-Ç*+: ø *a®" *,* *" -,-Ç< ø *" *.-Ç* ø *a®" *,* B *" -,lQl ø *" *.-,-ÇBø *a®" *,* Ê: *" -(+B,B ø *" *.-Ç*+: ø *a®" *,*+2 *" -,,l *+:+ø *" *.-Ç* ø *a®" *,*+2,< *" -,-Ç2 ø *" *,*.-ÇBø *a®" *,*+* *" -,- Ê:+ø *" *,*3(-ø *a®" *,*,(+* *" -(+* ø *" *,*+:3Bø *a®" *,*,(+2 *" -(- ø *" *,*+:32ø *a®" *,*,l *
a#%: (+2a" :-,-®" 2 Ê(l -C:â" - Ê( -Ç*aâ" - - @ 5 ^ ]PVâ? VË? .9 V,J> U²@]-Ç* cUWVQTSg%"(@ e6eWS \@ kL]JU @ø-Ç*a~!Ô@ _ SO~KY @l]Pe²>JU @ [ kA@\]+? &@\e8QP_ 1- D ^mP :' ) D " D ' m A]+?Z[ ' m 8]Pe ] _>.? S VYQ,L ? QP_S.H@ [@ T? SU @/ QP_ / k ] SeAQP_S.@BJS ek %V S Kd e"c¦-Ç< (O- g0TD S@ [JQJU X ] SV0&+@ ^ ]