Entity Resolution In Graphs Indrajit Bhattacharya, Lise Getoor Department of Computer Science University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742, USA
indrajit,getoor @cs.umd.edu ABSTRACT
!"# $%! & '( $( # !)* +, '- ( ( ./ 0)# *1 2314 65 !)798:1&5;#9 < )"*( =*>. $? # 2@ 9AB $ ## $C!% , .* DE5F> ) G H- ( #=) , I *)JK9"./ +3 $?* MN 4)% * $ !)C?/MA5 O MP ( 8K*F
* Q# H R ( $ S *( =T ( #4 4)6U 9# , .O0 +J(4 ." R ! # * = 23 *7 *>**) < #V# I- $2W*RMP ( , .E8I*# &! & X#23./ , 9 Y SH S .#3 =, .*23!#*1." 9( Z923#!R Q*" $ #N 4) , .5F# ! "?/#*M[3( # 9H *)= #\#>!* ( (, ]( $*( ! # $* 8 ^C ! &23 #N ( $ # # (#N 9A1 $ ## #>, .* _5F MP ( V 0 +!`9"./ ( #* S. 9 _MP ( 0 + 2' .Q ;*I 23F 9A9D9 0)Q*F #23# ! A323 I?/5 5 >( #* S ]#*( ./ , + ]*& !23# ! 7 _&- *( I < #? \ 0)6D23 #9 S#*
#9D* !23# ! J?/A5 > k +# $* 8l^C7m". ! V5 O)fe 9234 " Q I ! # 0
#23# ! A98in1*7 .. $ (,ED5F#(Mh5 (
# ;T 4)"$c)", # F #2Q< # ! 6U#D\m". !#( `( $23.0 + ;*3#0)"#N"!)"0
K4) J0 =4 (M ( ! SR.* #( #.0 + 1#6D/?*"&# &m"./ * #N R 3( 23.*"$8Fop # ( $23.*", # $*
# q#9 !N$c
* #N c# '234 "!hT * # < ?/ * 9 )h !23# ! 6U#DK5F*#(Mh $ l( $23.* 72>* 0 ( $ !)3 * `- ( B + !? 8C^`7
# )" (#?/O u[3(!7#23.* # 23 9, +! u *)q * 45v0 V* #$ 23 (4
#I , ( P # #35F'#*( #*= #w 1 6I)* , 8
1. INTRODUCTION
xAy2' 9` .*.* ##(4 +! * DH*V + cN #AC I5] " > &M< PM !Q *1 23;**) "#*=4
*KD 5F*K* ) 1 9#3PM *( & 0)V4) F J 23 $*= 9A3- ( D #9 c Oe4-,0+*KD_5F*3 ) J +Q*Q 9# ;* 2Q< #N > *)C4)"$ > ' 23 $*c# 8 #N y B(
# !(# $l - *( ># D5I5 * !)V ##g I $)M23!I&( $
#h c)* , ?0 $D\5V2' 4O0 4N V)"#feM 9g M ; *'./ < V)* , ?0 &2' =* F 9( !
/ ( A*2?/M \5F# !& 30 23 0)h $))" 8hI +,) # DF m ('( $23.* # $ )" 9 ]* ] [Q( 1P ] $ #N#*> 9#3PM *( ]!V *(,V(4 8 xy)* +, ( #4 *#*"DH)4)"*.* ##(4 +! u4"DK + ]# J#23./ , J- ?/ Q ( ( , +F *
" ! D$P Hm 23.* #)"23#*#*F*"2?/ ( S $23 D *)V- F( S #h $)*)"! EDH, g V , .* £8 $8` ! # 0
k #23# ! A#9 q ( ( *948z* Bm 23.* #$D15C `( $23.0 + < #X5 %( * >( ,)" >P 7T |$ $l}R 9 UH 0)hT |$ 0 +0 h}R 9$U#D 5 $* !)l?/723 7 ##g y %2' (,`* 2¤&l + ?/ 2' + #4)7 VT |$4 * J}R 9$U/ 0)'*7?/ 70 4N J)./ 0)" 9 T | 23 ;}R 9$U#D\T|$ $C}R 9$UE *)`T |$*Q}R 9 U!8>xA% ;5 ,) D ; S #*3 #23# k +A7 *J + #?* I# F, g #9 3 ( ( $*94D ?\ 1 9 1! ] !23# ! > /*./ $.* # I5F* $2p]./ $ # F ! 4)e8 >." $? !2v?/ ( $23 I N c23 J!9 S!35F* c5>) > 23Q0 +=Q ! 4)O 9## =0 4N ' 4 $)C?/ C<
#N 4)68x£ (4DF5F* h*B ! +! * 7 X 23 $*C 9## ' ; 23R./ D0)"23#*#*=0 +I5 Q- ( FPI 23B#0)"!N!)*
F2' l#
# # 45@ Q C2' g B )*)# $*
#"P ( 83xO *;5 ,)" DE>
!"# $`." 9( J?/ ( 23 ¥-¦§M¨ © ¦£¥Pª § 8 oI G23 9# $4);4 ##4D$." $?* # 22' ;?/N#5 )=#J23 F , .*O5F*Q* )" ; . 9;*Q 9AX- ( * \ 4)> &?/ $ #N )Q *)=*4) K( ./ 0)= &* ?< MN 4)Q ! # $ ] 23 *R 2B8_^CI5F# # /(4
# 0! H* ¨§P« §M¨§M¬/,§ ® ¨S©M¯° (4 ."#*Q ! +! * 1 23 $Q*J 9AVPM *( 8Rn1" ( * Rm 23. !=# ; * 45F%!OzG#$" $M8=±P Q*# R, .* ( c?/J23#*4)7- 1./ 9!
E.0 M* I IP4 + De&* 4)" I ?/XT ( ! * )6U#8r¢B h ) 3#l*# 3 , .*i +c).* ##(4 3! * J*McPJ Q 23*0)" "! 9A983*Q, gX# c!)" 9#kX5F*#(MOP*( >( ./ $0)% *3 233 9# 0)c* X( *
!!) 2 V(4 +> §M¬¦£¥P¦£² ® ¨ ©,¯° 8=zG# < " ?0& * 45F ;*> 9AX , .*C -M;*- ( J#% MP ( , .h* 4N '?/ y $ #N )68CzG# S4DK* V* > N # # I #23. !;, .ED*; 9AV , .*B# I2*(,V 2'
# #F0 >- ( 3 , .*E8>xAO $))# $X 7>4)"*(# $%#C, .*
#w * ( 23 _5FJ $ #N#*1- ( D$ $ ## $># * ( S< '- I)# ( +N M!>& *1.0 M* #71 9AQ , .B 5 ! £8K&MP ( ; , .* 1 +; -B( $ # # (# * 1 H)# ( **(4) *? , .** 8d³1 ! 'q c $ #N )6DF*c4)"$ V#N $ #N#* *> 23> 9#c5F# ! \?/3)"# ./ 4)X N$J R2' 9B- ( 8 ¢ ) ! =?*# #;k $2´ (MO , .*%5F! # K?/Q#0 (( , +$83xA%* m 23. #$D *F( * (# $ - 2µ*'{A|$4 1}1 9 ~J 9# *3{A| ( ##*I}R 9 ~; 9A>(4 $* ?/] 3#* $ #N 4) 9AV , .*68 , ../ ##N , c?/(4 5c(4 q ' ' S #*C2' (,h" *
k)h23 ( * N #N 98`±30 >*7) 45F4
1 9#J $ ## 3 ! 9 g +m< 0 e !23# ! 7#'*1) (#."! * ] G*& 9## 8Hz Fm 2Q< .* #$DH5F*M* 3 5 %( , # $ QPMQ c*V 23 .* ./ )./ 0)" $V*1 #23# ! AV234 & *(, ]4)I)# S, *( R?/M< A5 h*75 `(#, +# $q S #$ 8rB0 '?/ hm * #N 5 gJ $>) Y *#*I .. 4m"#2' S #1 #23# k +AJ234 D ¡D\$$DE+ G0 +R2' B?/=* 4)B- ;* *./MN"# 4)B
!"< # $68Q J .*. $ (,O# R V* $)* .#N > *./N# 4)%
< $ *23 ]0 +1 #4 +c S !Q #23# k +AB23 Ik $2W ! ?/ #4) )* +, ·$ºD/º"D6+9D/· ¡ b8n1*R *;)"#[Q( * # F# * #3 *./M < N# 4)B23* )VP & $ #"! O# I( $ S *(#7 3 9 )c , #*#* &0 1#*( #0)" R Q ." 9, #N =(
! # (M! O ./ !N$ 0) * #N 7m 23. ! 8hn1*7 .. (Ml5F*#(,h +N$ $!) 7." $?"
C++"G$X0+*GqÇ* Ê4£Å%Æ-XÄE0ÅOÆ-c/kË/qPq4_X Ä6Q0_ÌÍÈAÎHÉ=4E%+"Ê Ç/Æ-Ë/"Ìq"e4-, *KÏ 5F1& ]# F g )3 > ! ?/ e 2?*# * $ m 23. # ?9Q
#4 +*48 2.2 Theoretical Bounds
Ð * '
£8F4½+ e S0)"! K*] #(4 0. ?* # 2Ñ GT 0 +,)"< *#* y -c)* , ?0 $UF0 70 B2' 9( ?/ \ 9 # F!V*; -&)* +, ?0 $8
2.3 Efficiency
#N J* _ $ #N!I\ 9#R
!"# $=. $? # 2 .#2'
# # I( $23., +! 0 ! 7m"./ * #N D0 c!23./ , 9]P 9(* I! I $ [Q< (!*(V# * F#B) , =( #4 !D"5F*R1
6# ] ( 23R*. 5F!m"./ * #N
#$ *23 - Y *)#*O .. 4m"#2'
#< # * > c7." $?* # 2B8%7g$`23 (,0 *# 23 ;P ') !c*# #N
!N$`( $23.#*h*`2' +(M c[3(! *)d 23. ! 4"#* (M*!9* Q( $2323 $ y(4
# #4)iT ? # 9(Mg#*"UK O9*#(Mg Y *)y./ < ! ;).* ##(4 *)r !#23#0 +X* $"2' 4C?/ ?* $) l)"# S 4)l %* Q 2' +(M R(4 * ;?/> .0 *4)X?9B*=5F#0) 45Ñ 0)X *(,O(4 5F# # _ F?/1M !N 4)68HR $ #"! B. ./ $ 4)V# & >2* C 237N
#* 7P 7*O)fe 9 Y !) O( $*)# $*
# r!*) ./0)V !N$ u*%( ! DR i* . ?0 ?*# ### >(4 C?/V S!2' +4)C#y `* *./N# 4)OP *# E8 ^u#*g #F ¸M 0?*# !) *./ >! G5 gJP K( \5F* =*( $0)"< # $*
/#0)" ./ 0)" *(1 *23.# V( * ?/&2' )& 0)3 $*, !#w )=m"./ (M, # $J2' m"#23#w4 # J
#$ #2dP G S#2' + < #*;.* , 23M H 1 .0 +, I2' (,* H *)* .* # 5F *1 !23# ! ?/5 * ]- #$cg$' ! # $ 1 ( $ F* *#, +(M9c5F!(,OX(4 ! H(,*# !)" O 83_ 4N $!)O( $23.0 +< $ ?/A5 B # _.0 I G*. # ]#c > ! # ED"*V. ./ $ J
$.*#*I S , J0 _2' g _* G "*H ! # $*
*#, +(M9 I5 # £8 ÙJ ! *#g +NC
£8y M F ** ( QP4 + F * *?* S ( #V*&)* , =* #*J*&23#*#22µ)"< (M!."# $' # *V."#*( #.* #$8*# #.* K ;( $23. K*F, .* 0)7. 9F( *( .0 E S (R F5 # £8 }1 JG
£8]4·+ m".* # K ]. Y # ?/; $?aS ( 8 *MO 45Ñ* J*!"P*( 3." $?* # 2 # R)" ( !)* ?* #;P R Q ! $=( ! & \* =23 )" # 1 0)B." $./ $ = AaA (# $c 23.* ##*3 ! *2¼- I S#2' #*. $?* ?! ## 8 xAl *Q5 gy R $"3 45F ¹4 LDK570 4N B )* .4)`* Ö_ +< 9'}R#(M #7o& # # 9(4 # $q23 ) ]P B)" 9( *23 Q 0)l $.!( *)qm *)4)l7 `." $./ X `$ , #N c $*.q23 ) FP aS #7 9Al
!"# $E8dxA S4 $)q J./ P 23#*y C.* + #?*I #23# k +AQ . )#(F*R7 ! ?/ 6- &4 (, - ( $8 2.7 Tools
op*2>?/F \-, 235 g R *) 9 $ # R* +N$=?/ X) N$ # $./4)e8
#* ,)* Q
£8#4¹+ F." $./ $ 7 B-, 235 gOP ')( ! , #N )* +, 3( #4 !'? m 0)"#*V¶*ÕRÖ%5F#X ./ (k #!w4)% ./, P R2' +(M!D*( #* S#*V 0)B23 !8F=^i:1xA&ÖO S" S 2 ¡ !9 , > # $ #(4
]9 X ! * 0 $3P Q)" $#*%T -4U_Mm" aS #* J#C) , ?* ;5F%[3( # 9=9* B. 9( #8'ÓG 4U ^u _ ·¸ bD"o&(#N Fo ! I ·$¡+ e *)}1?*#$* # $u .*." (,* 0 4N 3?/ y ..* ##4)y *)C N
#0 +4)C#l B*2>?/; &)" $2' # 8 *4 ## SH ..* ##(4 # Q# $=234)#(4 )* , = ·" b8 Ð * ) , # J O 4 35F*M3)(# $% ])"*. !#(4 + R./ J V # * Y (4 9 (,0
# # $7 0)%^u#*g #V ¸" ]* = *( ( SP ! ` .*. #! )`*# =M< 4 +(M *)q B?* ##* 7 `*# 7) 2' #E8Ño@4 B)4 =5 gu0 ?/ )" $*O2' g#*y C >?*#? !# , .*#(`) , 4¡DE$De$¹D/· D/·$·"De¸ b8Fo& #23 $ SI5F* &m"( .# ED*;P 9( 0 &?/ *;2' +(M!Q G( , # $ 8^` gV#B( - *(
!"# $ 0)r)"! 2?! 0 +!l 9#q23# * V!r* ,
! $0 $7. 9( # ¸"D]· F* ?/ l ..* ##4)` Bm(
./ $ 4)%= c( # S#*X, g/D\5F*'PM *( 0 +Q( ./ $*)y c 237l 9( ! )h5Fh7 237( ! S48lÓG - < 2' *( 323 J* > N
#0 +Q*'90 !# > ]*3( ! S *M, 4)C( $23.0 +4)O V*Q *( #* S > 323 # N 9 #B (M7(4 8]¢ *$= 0) \ #g$ ` + G* J >* # B ( ! S .A%P Q N
#* # $68CH (,l F*3 *M, 4)y( #* SM 2' #&2' (,c *;( # S4D/?/J Q *? & H *;( ! S& #( #0)>P*( ;k $2´23 >0 % $Q( #* SM48'*X 4 + Y S_5 I(4 \ G.*"K( ! S _5F! #H*\*,);(4 J ( ! S # \) 234);!23.$8_*MJ* K*2>?/E 0. 0) #23.( ! S $*, +4) G*N$ !* # $>23 #($8_^C* +N$ ." $./ 4)' '
* #N F N
#0 +# $'23 #(P *# H( #* S# , gq5F*MO5O234 "c*O)#N Ai >4 (,r( $ S *(4) ( ! SR H 9# - ( 1#B23 I \=2?/F HMP < *( = %)fe 9
9# >* #( $9, ! ¸ I 0)C )"# ./ # $C 4 (M% 9Ac +N MR*>"2?/& )feR( #* S< M 8^C * 45¼* ')"! ./M ! (
! # (M! c _.0 ./M]P*( D ./M0 . K( $ # # (4)3?9Q(, 5F ##*;*]5 ?E8\oq5 # C#23./ , 9; $"( QP Ð ¶ 4 (,* D *)C2' g$ > (,*#*cP Q # (M $*#(VN # $ .* ./ 3 #48:1 45 N$' ' 99 $V5F C0 Q* ) Ð +¶
(4 y S4D_*3 +3 k y2 ##. !>P*( J 73 23 .0 ./4D( , # * +&
5] " K
#N 4)' *)3 I*
5 4" I( ( !) Y 4)O · 9D/· · b8 3.1 An Example
*323 SJ( $2323 * X S0)"#4)O?!? #! , .**#(' 9AX
!"< # $, gJ!
#N"#R.0 ./H( , # $ 8 Ð $* !)"\*- $ # # +5F# m 23. #1- 2´ ·$+ bÝ Þ =8oI , 5] bD =8 ¶9!g 948ß © ঩$á ® â ¨M¥P¦-°9ãàe« â ¨ã¥P¬¥P¬ ® © à,ä à â ¥£© ¦£¥ â ¬X¨,åá!§Mà;¥-¬Xá#© ¨ ® §=æ © ¦L© ç© à§Màè xA7éRÖE}R±K)# S, ( 3 ! *35F# # * ;5 ge8':& 45]< N M4D15Bm , (MQ* )fe 9 Y !) Q V #?*" Q &* .0 ./4De5Q2' 0 4N ?/M R #*(,g/8>¶" 23#23 De.0 ./R
!"< # $7(4 B?/R) $R?0 4)7 #23. #' 71 ! 8H^CR(4 * 1 $* \=2' 9 m"# S#*'23 ) FP 1 S #*'2' (,*#*"D/./* .* N *4)7 Q*;, g \ #J2' (,*#*"8]:1 45N 4D*J# $))# $*
/ ! # $*
e#- 2' # ED"#'M23 E*IN * D * "* & *;.0 ./4De 0)7;( , # $ 12' $)"R?97;.0 ./4Z *# ] )*)"## 0
e#- 2' +! 2' Q." +N"!)"&P" * Nk)" *(I *&£ (M&* ]A5 - *( 1 +R*; 23$8
3.2 Issues in Graph-based Entity Resolution 3.2.1 Multi-Type Entity Resolution
xAc ?/ N$m 23. # 0)X!c4 + !#J( * Rm 23. ! D 5&0 )' *IA"./F G $8 8H.* ./ D./ .* #+ 0)Q5I5 "#* $ #N Q*2B83^`Q-J *# = à¥P¬ ® á!§äb¦£²M¯§ §M¬0ä ¦£¥P¦£² $ #"! E8R±1* ;* 15F# !J*> ?/ +N JA5 '( , # $ S #* > +Q* )X 723 #N$ +>.0 ./R
## $`." $? !2BD Q# Q23 7#9 S#*X X 7* >*y." 93 l! # #* S , +< #N 1Mm* 23.* #1 G2>* *R.* ./] #$D*'( , # PM *( I Q * A"./ J ] 9! D5F*#(MO* 23 #N ;2' 4%?/' 2?*# * $ 8VxA .0 + #( * ! 4De S #* 1PMR ©å"¦-° â ¨ 0) ª §M¬*å*§ 9# R# $))# $c ¯"©M¯§M¨ 9! 8R! 1?#* 1*.X 3 ( 0 # '5F* 2 !. #KA"./ _ 0# 4); 1?/K $ #N 4)= !2>* , $ 98 o& 23#*F0 _* S #$ \0 4N K?/ =( (M #=.* 4)J 1 ."< , +J $I*J)"fe 9 Y !) ]í5F#(Mc# & 3)[3( #I." $?* # 2 ?9C Fî* Y S( , +! l S !c23 9# $* QT =8Go&, 45
£U *)T J8&¶#g 94UF *C c 0)T éRÖ6};±K2' 4 * R?/J 9 V)[3( #& 3 $ #N 3T J86¶9!g 94U0 0)OT & 2' g9# < 0 B¶9#g$ 4U#D*T o&, 5]
£U"# F Vm 23 Q( $2323 $'x0)! V ! S 0 23F *)K# H( , ! Q* H $?N! * 0 +T J89oI , 5] £U$- '*= 23> ;X =T & g OoI , 5] £U!8>oI 1P R* N FMP ( D* # *Ig* 45F K* HP A5 ;
#N 4)3.0 +< ./ QN " =2* S>?/'*V 23$DHQ# QN M y)[3(* 4D * 1#23./ !? #$D* Q
#N =RA5 3N *R- ( F5F# $" ./ ( ! !#w )c) $2' # g* 45F #4) $8
3.2.2 Collective Entity Resolution
z B m 23.* #$D&B# B B* ,)i l $? N X*O) ./ "< )" *(7 23 $ *')"#feM 9>
## $l)" ( # # $* ( 2>* < #. !( ! 8=^`>(4 %2' g J*= $ #"! `)" ( # # $* æ §¯§M¬/æ (,q 3#h(4 35F7l ¨§á#© ¦§ æ 8^u* y $ ## $ ) (! # * F &2' $)" â á-á!§¦£¥-ª §á ² D*M3(4 '?/&2*(, #1 2' g $8KxAV*;( , +! %) $2' #7*R !N$ I 9# + ¯"©M¯§M¨,à D © å¦-° â ¨Mà *) ª §M¬*å*§Mà 0)RH # N 9E ! # $ *#.* +Qï ¨M¥P¦§ 0) ¯*å*ç á ¥-à °§æ3¥P¬ D£8 $8Ko&"* Rï ¨,¥P¦§ .0 ./ D"5F*#(M ¯0åç á ¥PàS°*§ æl¥-¬ N 8o&q V# V â äA©å"¦-° â ¨ J < * "* Ke*M=5]F*] 23].0 ./M48G^`](4 3* ]* k +# $* 3 %2' g V $7
## $q) ( # # $ #4 $)y C * *48 ^C12' '?/ !V?93 $ #N#*3T J8*¶#g 94U" *)BT & 2' g9# ** ¶9#g$ 4U#D* 5F*#(,B5= J23 S&( $ Y ) 948*# 12' V #4 $)B 3?/ !# N$3T J8/o&, 5]
£Ue 0)%T & g Bo& , 5
£U6 ;*J 23 4DG #( Q*% + â äA©å"¦-° â ¨Mà 5F%*
#N 4)` * cT¶9!g 94U#8\Ò1 45u5;(4 B Q?0 (Mg3 =*R.* ./I( , # * 5F#(M6D#h $))# $y O* 4N"#%N$ ` #23# ! Q # DK0 4N '* 45 ?/ X)M23!4)7 '?/3ï ¨M¥P¦£¦§M¬`ç² *J 23= * 1# 8 # 2' g * K23 I( $ Y )" 9K* I5 J.0 ./- ( 2' .c V 23>.0 ./; 9A98Jz $ # # +5F#7*> 23=4 )6D 5 3!)#(4 _.* ./ I( , # $ 12>* SF0 4N ;!)" 9!(
_N$ *;( < , +# $* 8>¶ 352' B $ #N > .*.* 9 X)# .* , >N * MP ( 8 3.2.3 Graph-based Evidence for Entity Resolution
xL'# 3* 45W4 #V C B* 45 , .** 3 #.q#. 9#* R)" ./ *) ( # 8H*IP*( R, .7* ) - F4 (M - ( $8ÍxL;*B- *( ( ./ $*)q y2 ##. ! i( ! DR* i5C* +N$%2>* #.* #X* )"%./ 8»H) . 9\*K ! # $ \* \ $ !)?/5 =*MP ( 8^C 2'
# V0 4N ;23 ;* B *;A"./J H4)"$; Q . 9& )"fe 9_./ G " ! # $ G0 +m"# S48*K( MP ( I &*1 23$D5R $ k) # B $ #N 3 9O *JN$ *JP*( ;* Jm (M #%2' +(M 5 7MP ( 83^C(4 ! \*# R./> $ ## $ ® á â ç©$á ¨ §Mà â á 妣¥ â ¬ 8Vz J( , #C 9Ac- ( JJ2' g &*23 S * $DF 0)h(4 ./ 4)h#*$ 3.q #$ Y (4 98q:1 45 N$4D] 2' C* Q
5] " Q?/ .*." $."k +$8`xy*'(4 7 &0 23 >- Mm* 23.* #$D]T =8HoI , 5] bUK2' `-Q OcT & g qoI , 5] bU #Q *](4 $D95F*# #F $23] H#* S, ( F U J8 oI , 5] bU 23# ]MPF 3 Q)"fe 9F 9AXU 1 4aS NBo&, 5]
£U#8H^`1- >*# F k + F $ #"! c S , B á â ,© áE¨§Mà â á 妣¥ â ¬ 8 3.2.5 Additional Sources of Relational Evidence
n&?#?* ## $ , .*!(& ! # $ I( 7
# ./ 9k # #'?/&* 4) 5F l 4N$ # k ?* #$8OÓ ./M + ¥P¦§ æOç² Q.* ./ > *)OA5 .* ./ G â ä¥P¦§ æ *J K( 4)J?1*H 23.* ./G 9#98 xLGA5 Q #23# k +I.0 ./M]P*( & ;( 1 $))# $0 N!) ( ;0 I*M >* 23$8>:1 45 N$4D6 , .2' X
# B?/ ¬e§ ® © ¦£¥-ª § #C 23Q(4 8Vz* JMm* 23.* #$D6A5 .0 ./;- *( 0 +Q + ¥P¦§ æCç² *3 23'.0 ./M 9AC '* ##g C c?/ ).* ##(4 D0 1 +RA5 Q ]- ( F0 & + â äA© å¦-° â ¨Mà R 231.0 ./M&98 3.3 Author Resolution in Graphs
^u*#l*B( $9m3 1 9Ay
!"# $i#h?*#?* ## $, .*#( *) +, "D"5 Y SF ! 9 gB +]*R." $?* # 2¼ G
!N#*' ]- < ( #V , .* ] # N M, $#(
J S #*= #23! ! +#'2' (,'?/A5 3*& "* 0 23 D ?*" - `MP ( B' 23'./ $lN O #$* Y (4 9 98 *I23 $ S( $2323 ')fe ( I! K*FN$ +#A3 E5 K#V5F!(, * Y S* 23' 0)C23!)*)" #30 23' +' ./ ( Y 4)e8Xz* l "< * J 9Au{A|$f/%}; 4N!)%³& ! #2' *~D652' 4B - *( {S|"8*}8³& # !2' *~"DK{A|$fX³& ! #2' *~DH{³1 # #2' ED|8"}8 ~"D0 0)' $68 z* 3*B23 S3.0 + 4D* 7A"./ Q R , SP 2' +# $* '(4 q?/ 0 0)" ! )%?9c ./ (k #!w4)C( )"0 +;(M (,g" &P J( $2323 $c* 23 . 9, # $u , SP 23 8t:1 45 N 4DI5C % S! # ;." 94) 5Fh )"# !232' B 1)23#!c5F*3 Y S0 23' 23!)*)" !>0 23# R*> 233 ; $23Q#*!
£ZG5F# !Q(4 3 2' (,*#{A|8}>8K³& # !2' *~C 0)Ü{S| f/h}8H³1 # #2' ~C 23 9*F $?N# $* D9- ]( $2323 $0 23 K (M' Q{S|8¶23*~R Q{Að=8 ^y * ~*&. $? # 2¼# ]23 ;)"#[Q( * 48Hm# S#* S S23 , g 0 233-49**(O# % ( ( $93 *)C5F# ! $#N V** *
* 23 *# *'2' +(M!O ( 8±"Q*# 3 S# # & #4 4N ' ." $?* # 2 ])23#!V5F*M= V- *(Q q{S|"8¶23#~3P ; {S|$ 23 &¶"23~ V{A|$ #(4 V¶"23*~"8 o& I23 9# $4) ?/- $DE $))# $*
G( 9m1#- 2' +! X(4 ?/ 4)c#X=- 2Ø ( "* R ! # $ *#.* 8=xLH>( "< * ] ;{A|8*¶"23*~JP F* IA5 .0 ./M F 11 23 D" 5c $ k)l, g 7*# 3# C ( ( $*94DF 0)h$#N A5 O- < ( J 7#$*M>2' +(M#*V ( $83±;#O ,)M; B) V*# R5 2 S'0 4N X # $)"i)M23!4)h* '*c *VA5 l "* - *( QPMQ c*V 23V!*)#N!)0 £Z* >#?/ ( 23 Q (,*#(Mg$ B 0)7$3. ?* # 2B8 Ð $ !)E*Hm 23.* # +5FJ#=zG#$ $MD+5F*\5H0 4N P V.0 ./'PM *( D& (,q5Fu C !X 0) '- < ( 8yxh ,)> % $ #N 7 7MP ( DH572' 4C?/ $# ?9lm 23#*#O*B '- *( 3 ` B5F*#(,q * 35 ( * !)& '?/== 23$8&xAB* Y SR S .6D/5=23! 9R)" ( !) 0 +H
# * /*]oI* IP*( \-\ 1* 23F "* \ ?/ (4 * o&* '# ; O" 0 G ! S;* 23$8R*# R( ./ $*) 1
!N#*>
# / E&oI* ;- *( #9 > ; #*
#1 9A98:& 45]< N M4D* .*./ $ J?* 4) B0 23R#- 2' # X
# $$D*5> +J* 9*3 3* J*'³1 # #2' %PM *( Q 3 BV 23' "< * 4D *)5& I( , ! 3* "& ?/ $"K&| $* $3- < ( D #*( 1|$ $* V# ] ;N M Q( 2323 $30 23$8\±"4D)( !)#* 0 +*&o& =MP ( ]( ./ $*)V J*I 23& 9#3$#N * 7 $))# $*
;#- 2' # iP *X³1 # #2' qMP ( 8Ñ^` g* 45Í0 +;*=P*( J * ' 7( $2323 $%( #X*# 1P *# C*9# # 6 _1 9# 0 4N I?/ '
!N$4)68HzG#$";· $K * 45F MP ( J , .*7- I*# ]m 23. #; *) zG#$"J· ?/ +5F ] * #*3 9A', .*68 4.
GRAPH-BASED ENTITY RESOLUTION: PROBLEM FORMULATION
x%Q , .*"= ?EDEBM8&xAB= #$ # 9A7 $ #"! O." $? !2BD 5J +J$#N I - ( < FGD ;)H D"5F*M;4 (, - < ( 8;0 1# 1 #?*" I;= ?=8&*JPM *( R( ./ $0)B 9# K JLD 9)H 1* \4 (MMP ( M ;I0 H I*!)*)" >
! ?/ N ;= A38HH (,' 9AO 91
# * 45F7 #?*" P 9>= ?=D ?* *1 9## I +;* I)" ( V $?* MN 4)68\^u* ]5; $?* MN ; *7 #? Q ;= ?t &!*)#N!)0 PM *( 8`^`V(4 h#2' < #*: ;= ?q >?/I$*, +4)V?93 231)"# S # $V. 9( - $2Ñ* #? J FQ( ./ $0)"#*X 9AR ;= AQ8cn1?N# $ #9DE* 9Ac ! ?/ # ; >- ( J >* ; $? N 4)e8=*." $?"
F9"./ M1 G *; 9# < JO# 9>bhgi9dg 9)f I 45FB#czG#$J¸ ?/MD 5FU9 b = ?jDv{Ao& -4)Vé>8"oI* $~"D 9 d = ?`Dv{ ¶/8 Ð 8*|$ ** *~ 0) 9)f = ?kD¾{A|$f/ }8/³1 # #2' ~8 Ð #4 + #9^ D ;>b4ND ;)l ND ;)mJ *L ) ;)n=( < ./ $0)V y{So& k4)Bé>8*o& $~D Q0 +< ; b = AoDp; l = AqDj; m = AED ;)n = AkDr9>b 8¶"#23# ! 9D ;)f= AoD`;s= AEDp;t= AoDp;>bc= AoDj9dR 0) ; d = AuDv;)w = AxDG9 f 8c' V ! c3"./ bc7( ./ $*)y c ( $*)V 0O ) ;dF 0Q ) ; w ( ./ $*)' ;*]#,)e8:1MI5&* +N$ #9 )( 4)B*=* , # $% *23#*30 +; ! GMP ( R( < ./ 0)c 3*= 23=( ! ; 9! 8;x12' 4 ?/>Mm"0) )c * *) #2>* #.* #>B( ! > 0)c2 !. #=./ 1 K9"./ < )$ ?/5 >P*( 8Hx>*] SK /# K(,0 .4D 5]5F# ! ;*12¼ )$= 1 ?* SR- &9./M * R# R23.* # 494)68&xAX, .*"¥£á#© ¨,¥P¦£² â ã1¯ â ¬e§M¬*¦ , g$ ]# ( ( $*9]R #23! ! +# _1 ! # $ 0 +*IA5 > 9# ] F( ! S ].0 + #( #.0 1!68HK (MV( #* SM # ; 9(k +4)%5FO V M1- *( J *)c" $$c* J- < ( D/*=( #* SMR# ; 9(k +4)%5F% ' R 4)"$ I 7 * - *( 8±KF5F0 +&# F& ?/ $"]* ; *F- ( F0 5H5] _ 1( * !)M3^`H5] 9G I # 9 $gJ* +* + #?* ?*"G +E $ ## )" ( # # $* 60 +_* +N$H?/ R, g ; $;* 2B8 ¶"./( Y (4 ! 9D65Q5 9; # 9 $gO ; 9AX( ! S= ! ?/ # J * 1PM *( D* ]5F*#(M7( #* S ]'( '?/ # *> "8 _ >! # #* S , +;*# ]* #*> $"Fm 23.* #I- $2WzG# =D" .*./ $ 5J* +N$J
4 $)
#N 4) *>T oI* U0 *)XT ³1 # #2' EU"- *( #c( #* S< b 05 ) d ./(#N B 0) 5J = ! 9 g!' I* ( " 9F !23# ! 7 *15 3T| $* $6U F5F*#(,c &9] Q?/
!N$4)B *) S# # _?/ # $ 3 .* , ;7( ! S D0 { f| 0 4N#*~ ;d 01 ) f 0 4N#*~ ; w 8\*5 ;( #* SM +& 9( ! 4) 5F' $*I4)"$I4 (,ED W b *) W l ./(#N 98^`]5] 9 ;£ (< =#9 7Q #23! ! +#%234 " ¬ â ¦I¦-°*§3¬/© ã3§Mà *Q * - *( 1#B*;5 34)"$ De?F*;£ (1* I?/ c \* 2 R 9( ! )75F7*& 23I $ #N 4)V 9A'( #* SMM b 0) (d D"5F*#(,B# ]5F0 I2' g *2t #23! ! +48 o&y# V* Q# >? $$9Q >?9C*V ?/ N$ )"! (* # $h# *B)""0 23!(70 +c 1*B, .*"5F# # ]* ?/'( $ k)"4) #23# k +F * * E8H±"]* ], .*"*5 ; 9A=( #* SM *)>*MQ +I ##* Q( 2?!4)=5FQ5 #$9 % 0)7 O8_xA *R- $ # # 45F!3A5 3 ?* (M! * D5=)# ( FRA5 Q #23! ! +# ( 23./ $* ]#c)", # £8
5.1 Attribute Similarity
^`I *23]*Fm"# S *(I 6 $23F?0 !(I #23# k +A3234 0 +1, g 15 'P*( #?*" ; *)B R 'N$ !>?/M
*+O"e4-4k Ê H4EO++"G$"ÊQ4_q$Ç0++Ê \Ç/_ÌrÇy*+CÆ-PÊ "Ì K0GÌi4EOK !Ê'+ e6H( "Ì_0"Ê$Ï 5 Q½1 0)3* #0)"#(4 G]) 0 #23# ! A=?/5 2B8cot#$*MN
#*3#*)#(4 !23# ! `?/5 ' #?*" 8'^`3 +3* >2' g!B % *> 23.# $ ?/ $"=Q + !?Q #23# ! AO234 $8Qo&9X234 "0 + +# Y V* % 23.# $ '(4 u?/c 4)68p*# 7# V.0 + !(
(Mc #23# ! AB234 " 1 +> - c*4) - ./ ( Y (V) 2' #* > *)C2' C?/V 4N # ! ?* #7 = #!?", OP*(< # * 87}R ./ *)#*7 $C3) 2' #ED_#=# =./ $ #?* #3 c $) ."= )"fe 9& #?*";234 "; *)7#;#I# 5FB &
#$ *2 23 # 98 :& 45 N M4D"5R*4) h
( K ) Y *&1 #23# ! AV < #? &?/A5 XA5 ' 9AB( #* S 8JH (,X 9Ac( # SR# 7( $ # # (# $y - *( ;5F#%* = 45F` + !? 8'¶" 75 4)Q J* F*I #23! ! +#3234 F0 H, g$ K5 > #?*" X)" Y *3 #23# ! AC?/A5 C5 B( ! S = I #? 8 # # 7 #23# ! 7 Y 0)"#*CO $ +`)# S, *( X?/5 5 c( # S > #N y .* 5F# )"# S, *(V23 8B¢B 9` .< ." (M ##g à¥P¬ ® á!§&á ¥-¬ \D ©ª §M¨ © ® §Rá ¥P¬ \] 0) â ã&¯/á!§M¦§1á ¥P¬ \* +N$ ?/ '. $./ 4)c + /5F*M1 $23I $ # B $./, +# $V! K* 4) ;( $2?#*.0 # ?/7 5 B# B. ?
0 23 8X¶ BP A5 c( #* S 8hH& 0)7D\( $23.*"#*c + < #?*" #23# k +AX#N $ #N Q ¢ £
¤|
¥ ¤ H h ¢^¦¢ £
§¤§
¥ ¤ ¢0 #2Q< # ! Al( 23.*", # $ DK, +*Q* r ¢ hHi¢Z¢ | ¢G( 23.*", # $ D 5F*M £
¤|
¥ ¤ 6# _K*2>?/6 *k9H- ( + !? N
#* _!=( #* SMa 8\zG#0 # #9D *50 4N K $23H5] J Y 0)"#*& U 4N , $U #?*"KN
#H- \4 (MJ "*H( #* SM D K." $?* # 2 # F2*(,V !23. #48 *# F ! S&./ $#9I
# Q $(M F $ R# *J _*; 2' #( \J #?*"; !23# ! B#B*;(4 =5F;5= =( #* SM < #*c#` ,)J B./ - 2¾ 9AX
!"# $E8B±KC) #$6D4 (M ( #* SM ( ./ $*) V y $*c
#N 4)u 9AZ 998Í*# 7 2' c0 4N =?/ X- 4)c 7 !72' 9X)fe 9R #?*" D ># Q N!) 9J- 2Ú*V + !? 8 ;= ?t F'MP ( Q?/M
# ; #?*"> ?/3 #*
!3N
#4)6DE* %*
# `# J $*Q QN
#*Q ]* 9A% + !?1 9= ?J8Qz* J#* S, ( $D6*=P*( 3 + #?* 2' `* +N$V?/ T o=8\oI* U#DT o& - )lé=8\o& U#DT o=8 éWo& U\ 0) V $EDe?I*; *= 9AB #?*"># JT oI #k4)Xé>8eoI* U#8I^` 2' c)" Y =! ¨§¯0¨ §Mà§M¬*¦L© ¦£¥Pª §V á åà,¦§M¨3© ¦£¦£¨M¥£çå"¦§ 1*=23 $ S
##g *; !N$ *&P*( = #? F# 0 +I( #* S48¶" "D 5F*y( $23.#*B7 + #?*' #23# ! Ay F*'A5 c ( #* SM D2' g K23 F & J # 9 $g' *F #23! ! +#' 6* A5 O ." 9, #N B #?*" QP 3* ( ! S D, +*3* ( * !)#Q
# 6 E*R + #?* #74 (M7( #* S48H# ]2' g J)fe ( I!' 0 +# $* H5F*I5I0 4N I)M (4)3)"#feM *( 5F*#(,y2' O?/V)"*Q BA"./ , .*#(4 #C- *( + < #?*" I5F!X c 9A7( #* S1?*I* +N$; S! # G?/ X ? !;
!N$V 2¾( (M #98X^u y( 23.*#B #23! ! +#yN
#* P J*# J 9#%( #* S;53./ $ #?* C) B ;5] 9= Q $# S - *(> + #?* Q.* ! B = $ #$8 5.2 Graph-based Similarity
Ò1Mm"4D5> $))" F*J , .*"P $"=.0 ./M R5]# ?9XToI* "U!8I> )$J I (d= Y´P JT ³1 # #2' EU*# 1!) 9#(4 _5F*# # * FP RT| $* $6U0#S f = Y_D )W b g W l 8 ^C1)" Y I J #23# ! AQ234 "F- F ;.* ] 64)"$ D" ;0 + #N X*# 1.* C4) $D_53( $ k)"=*Q2>* #Rm".* ##( #B( $ k)" ; N M B4)"$Q 9( ! 4)%5F# (,C 9Ac( ! S48Qn1?* N J0 +;( 23.*#V #23# k +A ?/MA5 BA5 V )$ &# 1 ##* &!B= +N$, >*2>?/F MP < *( !7 '4)"$$D5F! #&( $23.#*;*I4)"$R)", # e #23# k +A \A5 '( # S 1# R9* $)", +#(=#c*= 4N , $=*2?/MF H4) 9( ! 4)y5Fy4 (,l( #* S48co&`# *'5Fy* #* B¡ l V $ +# $-*(# $l# >0 +Q c! y #23! ! +#y?/5 ' #*
!>.0 #R K4) 12' B R
5] " ;?/ 3 S *V Nk)" *( - J)"23#*#')*. #!( &!%)" $2' # &5F*M== )$ R(4 ?/; $# Sc ]5 # £8x7*J ?* ( J \ $# ;* 45N 4D0I# &N$
##g V0 +I5 3 ]5FB #23! ! +1* 23 F +>)"*. !#(4 + F ?/ V 1 ?* N$4)Q =5]KaA* S $*&.0 ./5F'*F 23& ](
! ! ?/ , #X 8Qo&* *; $)N * Q ] #* B¡ _D 1( 23.0 +4)75Fc FP*(# $ & ##g C B¡³>´/D*# &* IR # ! 45F ( ! SB #23# ! # 7 y?/X.e)* )q[3( # 9 q5F i ! ) ( ! S I23$$8 5.2.2 Neighborhood Similarity
Ð #4 + 9D* 7# &5F7 )$1), # 6 #23# ! A'# &( $23.*"< , +# $0 G( 23.* #m"A98]J $ ## $ R)"! (* 4)B#B*;( $9m 0 + #?*K #23! ! +#;(4 ** ?/Hm 0)"4)1P 4) 8xLG# G* #N!
\ #*(M 23 9,
# X*.e) )$Q), ! H #23# k +AX5F* ( ! S 123M$$8&o& # "D0*;4)"*(# $X)"*; 3 ./4 +!' 9# .* &#c4)"$ &# 1* 1Mm./(4)7 '?/= & ! * Y ( 9R &- + #?* 8 o ( $*)Q *)23 ./ #* 9H# *F# \5F*MK]), # ! ) .* ] )$ 9( ! 4)`5F`48B 5&(4 3- 2'
# ')" Y F& #$?/ 9 )V2>* * 14)"$J)M, # e !23# ! 7# ] I .. .! ; 9 23 R 0)7* #$?/ * 9 ) #23# ! A7# I "[3( # 948 5.3 Negative Evidence from Graphs
¶" '£ +4DE5* +N$( * !) )%, .*% S *(MQ J $))# $0 N!) ( JP &A5 * &MP ( ; (0 # #cMP #*' 3* 23V**) "#*% "* 3 9A98O:1 45 N$4D, .
# ;#2' $#] S $* H , .*MP ( ;( ./ $*)% 7)# S#*(; ;# 8;^C * 4N F *(,3( $ S , #9 KP N$ )$F0 +* H23 ]0 3 $ MP ( $8p*# 7( i?/B, g q#9 y ( ( $97?9l*c, .< ?* 4)B #23# ! AB234 "$8F*J #23# ! A ?/A5 BA5 '( #* S< M].0 # ! Kw =_23 #*J* 2ÑN!
! ] 9Q ! # $*
e( < S , #48 6.
GRAPH-BASED CLUSTERING FOR ENTITY RESOLUTION
#N *R #23# ! A7234 1- 1 .0 #I \ 9#V( #* S D 5F(4 Q I 1 )" $
# $23, +!N$&( # S#*J
# *2Í0 + Y 0)" *R( # S1( ! SI.0 #& +& (,B S .B 0)V23$ ] 2B8 :&O5C)"# ( * B N ,
J#23.* # 23, +# $r *)u./ P 2' *( # +,)#*& , .( ! S 0)X*3 ! *2¾, +!N$ C # 9 $g J Y 0)%Q( # $ S>.* J( #* S 8³&* # Q*X) , V c 2'
# £DF'# V#23.", (< (
E 3( $* !)"R # _./ $ #? !J.* 1 &./ 9!
_( 0)"!)* I- 23M$#*"8QoId .0 1- $2Ø (4 #!B# *$D_23 $ S;.* ;(,* (,g 4) ?9% } À ¥ 1 .. (M%5F# ! K?/AaA (4)% !( 3* *
# O ?/ $" 4Ût \ ! E.0 # & R J).* ##(4 8± # 9(,g"#Q (M*!9* F + 0 ! % 23. ! 49 )X V* # J.0 J5F#(MO 3( M , #O 7?/ $"?*#$ $ >- < ( ; J- ( ;5FC( 2323 $X ! S=0 23 ; 3 ;?/ 9 < S , ../4)Q#Q*I ? *(& 6 k +# $0 / N!) ( F!3F- 2Ñ ( P
# ! 45F#* S .* 8Jo14 (,O S.ED6;!) 9 Y *V( " 9 #C( # $ SQ.0 I( #* S hH|g Jk $2¾*V(4 "< )!) M= 0)c23 1 2v V(4 +3 75Í( #* SMU hH 8=x 23 +N k $2¼*;( 0)"!)* J & ! E.0 # F0 +I!N
#N R *M hH& Q |B *)`! > !N$ .0 # =P Q hH 8%xLQ ! %*.e) *V #23# k +Ay234 =P Q* T ! 4)eUH( #* S.0 8`o& # H* =, g" &* ) V?/=./ - 234)B[Q( # 9 # V2' g ;*
# *2W (4 k ?* #$8 z* [3( # 9Mm" , (# $> *( # S\.0 # \ 0)J*.e) #*I *I #23# k +! D0 7#0)"m"4)Q2' mÚ Û'ÒhÔ
ØÒhÙUÎÐÛ Ü
Ë>ÒhÙUÊi×
6.4 Evaluation Measures
¢ S .*. $ (,* 6 ] 9AI $ ## >* +N$N"#54)1*\." $?<
# 2µ ;.0 5F# 1( k Y (4 +! V, g/8\:1 45 N$4D *I)"*.* ##(4 + k +# $X 2' 9#(4 ! ) Y * I B49*#N
# *(;.0 # $#*3 $ RPM *( 1 0) & .. (M ! F Y 0)7( ! S I H).* #< ( Q- *( 87z $2@# =./M ./ (#N $DE=5 $ k)O?/Q.- < ?* # & N$ #0 H*K( #* S \)"#( J! S4 $)= 0 = N$ #0 # *R#23. !#4)V?*#0 + 7)*. #!( ;. )#(# $ 8 #N *= "* & ! ?/ ª H ¨@ÝP 14 (MBMP ( =! 7N$ !* # $6DH#I*'
!"# $h! >./ P(4DK y4 (Ml$< M, 4)c( #* SMR5F# ! Mm* ( c( ./ $*)c ' *> 1 9#98 ^i* h*# '! ' 3* (4 $DF5B2' #2' $#* 5 y)"fe 9 ( 0 +! Q #V O( ! S3#*( !*) QMP ( Q* 3* +N$ )"fe 9V 9#h k ?/ # DI 7#'P # # V y(4 ."X
# &- ( * I0 4N R .0 + !(* ! I 9AV ! ?/ £8 Y SG23 # _) Y *4)1 +N M_ *, +4);( #* S hHa¨@Þ>8 xA)4 # #9D 4 (M=( #* S\ $ k)J?/ $23 $ * $* 6
# "- ( #V '( # S $* !)30 4N F*F 23& 9A ! ?/ £8K*I 4 + *2>?/G 0PM *( H 1)fe 9\ 9# #3 &( # S4D$ 5 119*
#A3 _*I( #* SM48\1 +*K0 '* #N '( *9 < #7*Q)fe 9; 9AX ! ?/ # =#C 7( #* SM4D_5(4 O234 " 9 .B Q)"! S #?# $% +N ; 9AB k ?/ # ;#C V( #* S< M481# &5J(4 # á å"ধM¨æ ¥Pª §M¨,à¥P¦£² 81o& & cMm* 23.* #$D/ .*./ B +7 y- ( 3#h % *, +4)l 9#`( # S4Z Y N ]* 2@( ./ 0)O $*39DE" Q c ( $0)O 9# 0)Q*F 2' !#*;A5 = > R*,)3 9#98\*'&." $?* ?*# < C)"# S !?# $C N$J 9AX ! ?/ # JP =- *( J!O*# ( ! S'#@ ßb*½ = ¡¹ g,¡½ = *· g,*½ = àM8ixAh$*, bD#&*# 3)"! S #?# $?/ ßÐá b gá d gh==h=hgá àMD$ >] 9 $.9J# )" Y 4) â aá H # à á H 8 Ò& * \*] 9 .=# K½15F* 3 # - *( * +N$*] 23
_7 ! ?/ _ 0)7R ! ?/ _)# S #?*"! B#C ßS = >½ àM8K*;< .9 # I*#$ SFP 1 Q*P 2W)"# S !?# $68]oI ! "D/ *P 2 )"# S !?# $X +N ~ ãr> k ?/ # R0 1! *R 9 $.9 * B0 + +N MS ãV ! ?/ # 815! 94) 4N , $R _R)#N M #' _( #* S< M ' 3( * !) ) Q* Y S'90 !l234 "$DK5F .9B K4 (MX( #* SM;# &5! 94)%?97*="2?/I HMP < *( ]#V48H_ >?/&23 &. ( # $D1( 2?*#4)')#N AQ N$ >( #* S#*µ Þp# Ý ä
³
Þ;Dæå ç
¢ hHi¢ ¸
¯|è>é
£
³
H
5F90 ##%! §M¬*¦£¥-¦£²%æ ¥Pàb¯§M¨Mॠ⠬ ) Y *4)% N$ (,h` ! ?/ ª HS8%:1'P Q4 (Ml 9A9DG57( $* !)" )"# S !?# $ N$I)fe 9F( # SI k ?/ # 1 #$* ) >*RM-< M *( I- I0 I 9A98o& ]- &( #* S1)#N 9D; 9 $.9 # &234 "4)7P 1J)# S #?*# c N$1( ! SR ! ?/ # &P R4 (M 987^C3 ! 9 g` +>Q5 #$94)y 4N M, $' ]*3 9AC)# S< ./M ! * D/5F;*;5 # & K c 9# ! ?/ G# IJ"2?/ PM *( I* F0 4N &0 I ! ?/ bÝ ¢ª H ¢ ä
á Þ;aDêå £
á ª Hbg ë ¯|èì
¸
5FI£
á ª H H# 9 . 6*F( #* SM ! ?/ e)"# S !?# $3- RPM *( I* 4N"#Q 9AV ! ?/ ª H 8 Ò& * V # 45VN
#* V +c.- 4)h- )# ./ # $i 0)
)#N M #98Goy./ - (\( # S#*F5F! # 0 4N Hw I( #* SM\)#N *)>w M R 9A>)# ./ # $68\*# H# ., (M!(
# Q* H (,*# N ? ! #l23 $ SQ( 3 0)y %) (M4 7!l *'5F! # ] 0
# y234 h #*( 3#% *48=^`>(4 O.* # R3)# ./ # 7( * !)M
# K.0 D\.* #( * ! + #OP :1KÓGDE X XT ?* # 9(Mg#*"U\ .. $ (,`# 23. ! 49 )J RMm" , (*./ 9!
).* ##(4 8*# H .*." (M , !: í ¡$¡$Û» *& *;)"*.* ##(4 + ]P &?/ )* +, 8K* *2>?/6 "./ 9!
)"*. !#(4 +\.0 G EP*( G -M ?* # 9(,g!Q# ;4·"D º º P Ð +¶ & *)O$D ¹ ·¸D º$º>- I:RHÓG8 o& 3 '?* ##* 0U448¿VMD5c( $23.* 5FB9"?!) î â «M ¦ ï ß ä ðñ ß234 %# F0 +30 Q?/ l +5Fl % $./M < P 2× *7* *./N# 4)i .*." (,* 7P 7Mm" Õ(Ê3 9
XΠŧÊÊ Ê Ô "5 9
Ö Ì "! Ì $#% Ì ) Ì % "5 Ì $# 9 Ì & ;:
Ì $#& Ì %* Ì 76 Ì &
4ÎÆ-Z .6 ½ "Ê X¿;Ál*GÌÍ$Ç0++"Ê \Ç/GÌGPEpG+" PÊ4-Ç/Ü0_Ì +"$*ÆPÆ]Ç0{0U448¿L·0U44¿@÷ 0GÌ ¼{½O¾ ÃI¿©ú3-4u_"-0 Î\Ç0_ÇeÇ6Ìi0_Ìh"Ì_0 Ì_ 0-ÆKÊ4£ÅOPÆ-*-,hÇ0 ¾ - Èû6Q0_Ì 6
Ì ? Ì $#@6 Ì 76
(' Ì &? Ì Ì 76 +-,(.0/21>Ô43 Ì ? Ì 76BC;"5 +-,(.8 ÃÑ>Õ(Ê3 Ì $#A Ì D C; 9
2 =>6 Ì $#A Ì %* Ì $#% Ì $#%? Ì %* Ì $#@6 Ì ? Ì $#&?C; Ì &? Ì $#FE C; ;:
_ ?* #V> ( ,) RzQ (M!N 4)c?9 *JP J #$ 23 R5F#
N # * S #= #23# ! AQ234 " K( $*. #4)Q5F#7¶ -,]z_*>(4
# H!( #0)" ? # 9(Mg#*"D c0 +V#$* S (4 # & (M# N$ ?* #V! *½ = ¡$¡ ·%- Ð +¶ 1 *) *½ = ¡ ¡"JP &:1KÓG8 >?/ S1?* ##*>./ P 2' *(># &5F%| + 7 R ( 0) S #& #23# ! A;- Ð +¶"\ *)=¶"(4 ! )>Ö6 N S #J- \:1KÓG8 xL#
# %5 y #*c0 +Q c?* ##*'5F* $"Q#*!
0) ) $.B." $?* ?*# ## & ( I?/ # 45p¡½ = ¹>zJ* #*3|$ ' *) | + < ^i!g !MRP J?/ O)* , 8>xR# ;! *15F#`¶"(4 #4)OÖ6 N "< S! *½ = $?*"] S# # E #$ Y (4 7?/ # 45; $23 94)'?0
*7) (! # h" *
k)eD #*( RV( $ !)I0 23 F
# *$8 zG#$" ;¹' *)cº' 45p* 45d./ P 2' *(>N # IP ¼{½O¾ Ã ¿ÑP K*]A5 =)* , K5F3N "#*;( 2?!* # $Q5 #$9P I P K #?*" *)>, .*" . , +#N B .*. $ (,yP 3
# ] ( 0)* + #23# k +A'234 8H&( "N ?/( $23I!) 9#(4
0- ]#$*M N
#* H B5F ' #? \2' MK # 8Ho !23# ! H *)>5] $? N 4)'P 1:1KÓ ]5 # £8 zG#$"'V +5F ;./M P 2' *( ¼µ½O¾ : Ã ¿¾5F $R* #*
*ÎGÆ-q66ÂÍÃ&Ä6$À_4-Ç/W4£Å%pÇ0 ¼{½Q¾ Ã:¿@Q0U484¿ 0GÌ ¾ ù^] 0U448¿L÷@P Ê "$Ç/GÌ_ʵLÇ0 ¾ - Èû6t0_Ì_ I#$>) #! ?*# #A * #*Q )$R), ! E #23! ! +#B # $* 8 zG# =Q * 45F F*;.( # ! c (4
# G(,0 +, (M! S#( IP & - $"J
#$ *23 &5FO| 7 & ( 0)* + X #23! ! +#98RÓ\ # $ 45F 0 +3
# I
# *23 Q./M P 2¤5 # - Ð +¶ 48lÓ\ # ?0( $( 9 , I $BR $# c H)fe*( J?/5 7*=
< *23 8¶9! # e*R(N ]- I4) J), # G *)7 #$?/ 9 ) #23# ! Ai %
#23 S7!)" 9!(
£D& V! '* (4 XP :1KÓÑ! . # (4M8H±H*( $ # S 9 # 2' #3 +N K*F?0 #! - ?/ u)* +, 8Ün1?* N B* { 0U448¿L÷l)" $23#0 + µ 0U484¿ - Ð #4¶" K?*"\* $ # H N ]- :1KÓG8 Ò1 F* ¼{½Q¾ Ã ¿Ô S, + ?/ +N c¡$½$Ûj (4
# £8d*# '! V?9lN# c ;, .< : ?* 4)y?/ 9 S , .*.#*8y*V( ./ 0)"!O." ( # # $h# Q*#$ 5 # eN
#!)* #=&fe(#N * ] E $ , .0 )# ./ # ?/F H( #* SM 8Fo&$ #ED ?* N$;* 45 , .*(, # 45R)# ./ # $68F*J#*!
G2?/] H( #* S< M ># # 45M4)`?9` · Û@P Q:RHÓp 0)C?9`¹ Û@- Ð +¶ 48 * 77# 7 ( (, X(4 i?/c#- 4)q- 2 *B #$ Y (4
# 45MR)"!N$ A7 ]R 23R2?/] ( #* SM I( $23.0 +4)V 0U44¿@÷*8qB*2>?/Q 14 1 * 3 9# QP 7:1KÓÍ# ¡$º$DI5F*#(Mu# ' * 45Fu !l CN #(4 1 ##*X#i.* # ?"?/e " 9A1( #* S< M \ 0)J0 +\4) ]), # "./M P 23 ?/M 0 > #$?/ 9 ) #23# ! A98 zG#*
# 9D5R # 9 $gV ]1m" ( "# $7#23 _;
# *23 8 oI # *m"./#23 9 G5MFQ $Q >$8# :&w&}1 # 0ÓG 45,H) &$¹ ½ ½ ÓG#2@x x xF N 48;G ? !·'( ,)" R*=m" ( # %#23 &! Ð Ó\³l ( 0) E *\?* ##* G 0);)"fe 9_N$ # $* E ¼{½Q¾ Ã ¿v B* Ð +¶"; 0) :1KÓi) , 8 ¼{½O¾ I : Ã ¿@Mm./( < ) 3, g 23 I#23I* 3*I?0 #! 8K±## FIP S - Ð +¶"3, g#*O $* lA5F#( B '2(M`#23B µ 0U484¿L÷08 xLQ, g$ # $$3- ':1KÓ]ZH ?/ VB#23 Q 3 ! *%( $23.* 4) V*>?0 !#$8^u# !* #*74) 3), # H# ;23 m"./ !N$
800 600 400 200 0
0
10 20 30 40 50 Number of References (in Thousands)
60
¿F-/À_+BÁ;c6ÂRÃIÄE" À_ -Ç/O £ÅO3LÇ0C0U484¿L÷*GÌ ¼µ½O¾ Ã:¿ 3- t_"-/eÎ\Ç0_ÇeÇEÌt*G̵"Ì_*uÌ_ 0-ÆQÊ4£ÅCPÆk*-,»Ç"Ë/" Ë"*+_-_y6ÀÅXÎ\3Ç0I+"L+_$"ÊQPiÊ E6 _4PBÌ_ 0Ê 4Ê$Ï ú
_ & ]* 45y*
#$ #23 (4
#5FQ#*(M4 #*1"2?/_ - *( 1#B*=) , M4D05J* )c Q S9#(= *M, &P 2>?*#$ $ F)* , 8\^`R." N 4)'P4 + I _*14 G) , M 5F*M N H./ $ #? ! D !#g F 4N , F"2?/G /- *( 0) 4)"$ ]./F9D9*;)" 1 G #$?/ 9 )7P I4 (,7 *)7*J 4N M, $J*2>?/] P*( &./I4) $8];m" ( "
5 $ k)O !#g > S ;0 +;*QMm( # $ #23c)" ./ *) 3 $ '£ (M 7 35 # & !#g 7*B*2>?/3 ./ 9!
;)"*.* ##(4 +O.* #i*%) , "DI5F*#(,i5X5%* ?* #B C( $9 $ &) ( 98u¶" O B*2>?/ $ k)h* '?/ ( $23.0 +4)35F#'*Im" ( "# $'!23 $'*F4 E) , ]?*" # S4 $)Q $* !)Q N$I * - R( $23.* , +!N$I S*)"> /&)"-< - 9] #$ 23 8H*I( N K( Y 2Ñ* ¼{½O¾ I Ã ¿», g$
# *$MR0 X>?* ##*>?*"&c ! V * 45p* &*; 0) # ] $$ #' ##* I#7*&*2?/M EPM *( F- &
# eN # * R48l .* # 3
# C 45t*7 ! * Y ( 93 ./ 4)"*.y0 +Q# (M# N 4)35F7, .*"?9' ! 9 g!Q +]*1( 9] 9AQ k ?/ # F _ k +4)7# 8 ^C1." 94)3A5 >)fe , .
# #C #23# ! Al23 D4)"$7), # I# 3 ?* #7 O (,*# N$7! q (< (, (Mu#)"23#*#)"*. !#(4 + 8txi£ (4D;#r $*% > $" ) , D\ N %5F* $"=* #*c + #?* > +>
# £D)" 9 J?/ < M&* X #? #?=) (! # * * 3# ' .*. .! 7P 'y $ ## E8q*# 3234 " # Mm./(4)c ?/( $23.*", # $*
# %!9 #N Q 0)c*- 5 ." $./ = #M0 #N K234 "H* _( $ S *( 6*\ . < , +#N B + !?'P '4 (,`( #* SMV 0)` l234 " #23# ! # c?/5 r* % ." 9, #N B $ #98»:1 45N 4D Jm"./#23 9 & * 45Ü0 1* #$ #3 #!g$ $Q23 >./ < - 23 \?/ \#>., (M!($8Ho& # D$* ! \ ." 9, #N \ +
( 23.*"4)c9*#(Mg X R( #* S 1m".0 *)6D/! 1 .. (MO) 9 * ( $2335Fy ! * Y ( 9Q#23. +N 23 9 ;!yMm( # $`#23 *M48 ^`X N
#* O ` , .4)( *1!< !
\*2>?/1 ( ! S ;?9X$·$Û O ; ! =)* +, ;5F"< $"R #$ Y (4 c( $23. 23# !3 $c." ( # # $E8I^`= * 450 , .*"23 F( S #>0 Q./ P 23#*J #?] #23# k + < A98]:& 45 N M4D/ $"1m"./#23 9 F $c S"9*M!(=) , Q * 450 ?/ C , . ;./ - 234)QN$ J-49* *)*]#*( 4) ( 23.*, +# $B#23J! &* 1m"./ (M4) '?/J 9 V(#(4
£81* 2' = e( F?/] 0 # * \5F*! K .. $ (,Q# K H #!g$ 1." +N )N 9, $ D$P \m 23. !H5F*)# S#*(#N ( !!9* ) %* 3m"# S3P 3*V 9## 3 '1- *( QP '4 (, )$ ../4 =, *) 23 #9873*3* M>* J*3(,* !(V ]£ ! ##* ?0 (Mg; > , )# $0 " #?*" #23# k +A= \ #I & #$
# 45I5 # ]- & , .r ê g__ ë g â ¬4«4§M¨ §M¬/,§ â 5 ¬ ñR¥ ® ¥P¦L©$)á i\¥£ç¨ © ¨,¥L§Mà D â «R¦-°*{ .0 $ &$¡ ¡ "DeÓ\ ?* ED*Óeo=D|$*J · "ºc ¡$¡ "8 4+ =ÖH8 , 4N$ * "D0ÓG8xA./ # D*Ò>8"Ù; $*)* D* *) }80¶#N S, 4N$ 8_m\aS $# F- 1)* +, ( #4 #*' *) #9 , +! c#B 7,)?*23 8"x p7 ¦-µ ° ð4 2pð,¬¦§M¨M¬0© ¦£¥ â ¬0©$á g â ¬ «4§M¨§M¬0M§ â L ¬ ñ=© ¦Lj © ]¬ ® ¥P¬e§§M¨,¥P¬ ® D/ ½ ½$·"8 >¢O8*o=8:1O 0)" w; 0)B¶/80|"8/¶9 $ P "8/*;23M$++.* . ?* # 2t- I ! $=) , ?* 8*xA~ d ¨ â M§§ æ ¥P¬ ® à â «R¦-°*§ p7b7Qrê g_ë î ðQsK ë yñqð,¬*¦§M¨,¬/© ¦£¥ â ¬/©$ á g â ¬4« §M¨§M¬/,§ â ¬ ëO© ¬0© ® §Mã'§M¬¦ â : « ñ=©¦L© G î ðQsK ë yñJUä bFK D0.* ;+$ 0 ·$"D
¶ |$ $ D Ð o=D0¢B O ¡$¡$¹8 4¡+ =|80oJ8*:I" # E8"xS)" 9-"#*Q 0) 23M$#*= ! 4) ?*#?* ## $, .*#(J( ,)" 8e¢B SM4U F* ! D}R .* 23 9] H # ( #(4 G\* ! #*' 0) Ð $23.*"&¶"(!*( $D0¢ xS1D 4¡$¡ º"8 ½+ JxM8*|$ $994DÖ\80±&8*:1
k)"4D* 0)V}8*|8 Ð 9 g/8 , .8ÖE£D/ÓG8*¢ #$D/ 0)V}8& E8*¶" 2' 9!(1!9 , # $ ! m4ÝHz $2W 2?*# * $ ]0 23 Q!) 9 Y ?* #R 9# 8 ê ðIëO© ® © V¥P¬/§4è î ¯§ ¥b©$á ð,ààå*§ â ¬ î §Mã3© ¬¦£¥bC : ð,¬¦§ ® ¨S© ¦£¥ â ¬ D ½$½$¹8 3 ../4 48 ¸ =o=8*¢ ( Ð
# #*2v *) ±&8"^` ! #48 Ð 0)# $*
E23 ) # ] k)" 9AV*( , #9A35Fc .*. !#(4 +# $B Q $* ( - ( $80x }8 ¶/8 Ð * I±"4 6D^` *# $6D } Ð D0 ½ ½ 8
Varying alpha: Jaro for CiteSeer w/ Cl. Rep. 0.996
0.994
0.994
0.992
0.992
0.99
best F1
best F1
Varying alpha: Jaro for CiteSeer 0.996
0.988 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.986 0.984 0.982 0.98
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
0.99 0.988 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.986 0.984 0.982 0.98
1
0
0.2
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
best F1
best F1 1
0.996 0.994 0.992 0.99 0.988 0.986 0.984 0.982 0.98 0.978
GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0
0.2
(4
0.994
0.994
0.992
0.992
0.99 0.988 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.982 0.98
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
4
0.8
1
Varying alpha: Scaled Lev. for CiteSeer w/ Cl. Rep. 0.996
best F1
best F1
Varying alpha: Scaled Levenstein for CiteSeer
0.984
0.4 0.6 alpha
)*
0.996
0.986
1
Varying alpha: Jaro Winkler for CiteSeer w/ Cl. Rep.
GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0
0.8
?0
Varying alpha: Jaro Winkler for CiteSeer 0.996 0.994 0.992 0.99 0.988 0.986 0.984 0.982 0.98 0.978
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
0.99 0.988 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.986 0.984 0.982
1
0.98
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
1
,
¿F-0À_+6 ½ "Ê R¿RÁQÅO0Ê4À_+"Ê&* Gk"Ë/"ÌcÎ6 ¼{½O¾ ÃI¿ ú3-4O_"-/eÎ\Ç0_ÇeÇEÌy*GÌ%"Ì_*3Ì_ 0-ÆGÊ4£ÅCPÆk*-4-"Ê;Ç"Ë/"1ËEP_ ÇeÅXÎGP_* -Ç/eú>"-/ePcLÇ0 ¾ - Èû69ÏIù;ÆkÇ04Ê=ÈA! #*ÉKÀ_Ê >Ê4-_/Æ-ÆPPSVÇ0I* -ÎÀ_ QÊ4£ÅCPÆ--M5ú3-45ÿ6*+Çà ÿ6*+ÇÈWPS6Æ- *GÌ ûE 0Æ-"E Ì þHË/_Ê "P+"Ê \"$4-Ë/"Æ-0ÊBÊ "$Ç0GÌ_*+Ê4£ÅC-Æ-*-,Eú3_PÆ-lÆ-Ç0 ÊyÈAÎ!Ì# É7À_Ê `+"_"Ê "e *4kË/y* -ÎGÀ_ "Ê LÇ0V ÆPÀ_Ê O Ê ú3k4i4_XÊ 0ÅOc4_+XÊ "$Ç/GÌ_+qÊ4£ÅOPÆ-*-,uÅ%"*Ê4À_+"Ê$Ï
Varying alpha: Jaro Winkler for HEP
Varying alpha: Scaled Levenstein for HEP 0.985
0.98
0.98
0.98
0.975 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.97
best F1
0.985
best F1
best F1
Varying alpha: Jaro for HEP 0.985
0.975 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.97
0.965
0.965 0
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
1
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
0.975 GBC-ER (Nbr) GBC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*
0.97 0.965 1
0
0.2
?/
0.4 0.6 alpha
0.8
1
(+
¿F-0À_+
6L  4=_OÎH"Ê ¿;Á`ÅO0Ê4ÀE"Ê'0G-Ë/"ÌuÎE ¼{½Q¾ Ã:¿»ú3-4_"-/eÎHÇ* EÇ6Ç6Ìp*GÌ"Ì_0CÌ_ 0-ÆRÊ4£ÅCPÆk*-4-"ÊcÇ"Ë/" Ë"*+EP_r$Ç/ÅXÎ-_*4kÇ/qú>"-/e@pLÇ0 
