Jan 9, 2003 - egalitarian solution has a recursive structure being related to, what they ... Shapley(1979) showed that two games may have the same core and yet ... and clearly, the coalition i1,2,3j which is assigned a higher value in the.
? |i ti| Lu wLhi?34@ 4@* 4T|@|L?t ? |i ULhi Lu @ M@*@?Ui_ }@4i ai?t wi| OL}@@h_ LTi?@}i? t?itt 5ULL* @?_ N?iht|) Lu LTi?@}i? i3@*i* i*i} Ai OiMhi N?iht|) Lu aiht@*i4 w@ht ALh*?_i|ihti? LTi?@}i? t?itt 5ULL* a@?@h) bc 2ff
,ALMK@BM
Wklv sdshu frqvlghuv wkh vhw ri Oruhq}0pd{lpdo lpsxwdwlrqv lq wkh fruh ri d edodqfhg frrshudwlyh jdph dv d vroxwlrq frqfhsw1 Lw lv vkrzq wkdw wkh Oruhq}0vroxwlrq frqfhsw vdwlvhv d qxpehu ri vxlwdeoh surs0 huwlhv vxfk dv ghvludelolw|/ frqwlqxlw| dqg wkh uhgxfhg jdph surshuw|1 Pruhryhu/ wkh sdshu frqvlghuhv dowhuqdwlyh fkdudfwhul}dwlrqv zkhuh lw lv vkrzq wkdw Oruhq}0idluqhvv lv wdqwdprxqw wr wkh h{lvwhqfh ri dq dgglwlyh/ vwulfwo| lqfuhdvlqj dqg frqfdyh vrfldo zhoiduh ixqfwlrq1 Il0 qdoo| wkh sdshu dovr surylghv d{lrpdwlf fkdudfwhul}dwlrqv dv zhoo dv wzr h{dpsohv ri dssolfdwlrq1 Fruuhvsrqghqfh wr= Mhqv Ohwk Krxjddug/ Lqvwlwxwh ri Hfrqrplfv/ Xqlyhu0 vlw| ri Frshqkdjhq/ Vwxglhvwudhgh 9/ 4788 Frshqkdjhq N1/ Ghqpdun1 H0pdlo= Mhqv1Ohwk1KrxjddugChfrq1nx1gn
ki)Lh_tG @*@?Ui_ }@4itc |i ULhic wLhi?34@ 4@* 4T|@|L?t
2
W?|hL_U|L?
L?t_ih |i ti| Lu ULLTih@|i }@4it | |h@?tuih@M*i |*|) 6L**L?} L? i4@?? @?_ Lh}i?t|ih? wkh Oruhq}0fruh ri frdolwlrqv V zlwk fduglqdolw| n lv wkh vhw ri "
i}@*|@h@? tL*|L? 4@) i t| @?_ ?L| Mi @ 4i4Mih Lu |i ULhi ii? |L} |i ULhi t ?L?i4T|) ? |i U*@tt Lu UL?i }@4it Lh wLhi?3 tL*|L? UL?U_it | |i i}@*|@h@? tL*|L? M| uLh M@*@?Ui_ ?L?UL?i }@4it |i tL*|L?t 4@) U*i@h*) _gih u ULhti #||@ @?_ +@) ?_ | 4Lhi ?@|h@* |L UL?t_ih wLhi?34@ 4@* tL*|L?t | hitTiU| |L |i wLhi?3ULhi @?_ @h}i |@| |ih @TThL@U 4 T*it |@| i}@*|@h@?t4 t |hi@|i_ ? @ UL?tt|i?|< 4@??ih @UhLtt UL@*|L?t OLiihc @t tL? ? #||@ @?_ +@) Ebb |ih @TThL@U t }*) ti?t |i | hitTiU| |L |i i @U| _i?|L? Lu |i wLhi?3ULhic |@| tc i|ih |i ?L|L? Lu M*LU!?} hiuiht |L i@! Lh t|hL?} _L4?@|L? A@| @ hi*@|i*) 4?Lh U@?}i ? |i _i?|L? Lu |i wLhi?3ULhi 4T*it @ h@_U@* U@?}i Lu |i tL*|L? UL?UiT| ?_U@|it |@| |i ?L|L? Lu |i wLhi?3ULhi t *itt hLMt| |@? | @TTi@ht @| ht| t}| Lhi 4TLh|@?|*) |L} t |i u@U| |@| |ihi t @ *@h}i U*@tt Lu }@4it uLh U UL@*|L?@* t|@M*|) t ?_ii_ @ ?@|h@* hit|hU|L? L? |i L|UL4iG |i U*@tt Lu ULt| @?_ thT*t t@h?} }@4it W? u@U|c |t U*@tt Lu }@4it @t |h?i_ L| |L Mi L?i Lu |i 4Lt| tUUitu* @TT*U@|L?t Lu ULLTih@|i }@4i |iLh) Etii i} vL?}EbHD 6LUtt?} L? ULt| t@h?} }@4itc UL@*|L?@* t|@M*|) t i^@*i?| |L |i _i*) @UUiT|i_ t|@?_@*L?i ULt| Th?UT*i t|@|?} |@| ?L UL@*|L? Lu T*@)iht< U@? Mi uLhUi_ |L T@) 4Lhi |@? |ih t|@?_@*L?i ULt| u ULLTih@|L? t@** Mi 4@?|@?i_ Lt| @?_ thT*t t@h?} }@4it @hi Lu|i? 4i4Miht Lu @ *@h}i U*@tt Lu }@4it @ht?} uhL4 UL4M?@|Lh@* LT|43@|L? E+}@4it E tii i} hi* Ebb. ihi |i ULhi @*tL T*@)t @ ?@|h@* hL*i AL 4L|@|i |i ti Lu |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? UL?UiT| L?i 4t|c Lu ULhtic _i4L?t|h@|i |@| | *i@_t |L ?@|h@*< L|UL4it | hitTiU| |L |i LMiU|it t}?@*i_ M) |i _i?|L? U ** Mi _L?i t?} t4T*i i @4T*it ? tiU |L? 2 LhiLihc L?i 4t| _i4L?t|h@|i |@| |i tL*|L? UL?UiT| t@|tit @hLt t|@M*i ThLTih|it EU t _L?i ? tiU|L? @?_ D @?_ ThL_i @? @ L4@|U uL?_@|L? EU t _L?i ? tiU|L? S 6?@**)c |i @|Lht }h@|iu**) @U!?L*i_}i |i L|t|@?_?} hiuihii?} Lu |i T@Tih _L?i M) i|ih 5_L*|ih U ?L| L?*) UL?tt|i_ Lu @ |LhL} hi@_?} | 4@?) @*@M*i t}}it|L?t uLh 4ThLi4i?|t M| @*tL ?U*_i_ |i hit*| Lu AiLhi4 H Lu |i T@Tih ?) hi4@??} ihhLht @hi |i hitTL?
ihdvleoh doorfdwlrqv { # 78 iru zklfk wkhuh lv qr vxefrdolwlrq W zlwk d Oruhq} xqgrpl0 qdwhg doorfdwlrq | zklfk eorfnv {= Khqfh frdolwlrqv fdq rqo| eorfn xvlqj Oruhq}0pd{lpdo doorfdwlrqv zklfk lq wxuq duh xqeorfnhg e| dq| vxefrdolwlrq1 e
tM*|) Lu |i @|Lht
2
L|@|L?
5?Ui |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? t @ ULhi ti*iU|L? UL?UiT| | tii4t ?@|h@* |L 4@!i @ UL4T@htL? | |i i** !?L? ULhi ti*iU|L? UL?UiT| |i ?U*iL*tc M) 5U4i_*ihEbSb Ai ?U*iL*t t M) _i?|L? t?}*i @*i_ uLh @** M@*@?Ui_ }@4it @?_ hi*it L? @ u@h?itt Th?UT*i M@ti_ L? *i UL}h@TU 4?43@|L? Lu |i 4@ 44 i Uitt uLh @** UL@*|L?t L?t_ih |i U*@tt Lu UL?i }@4it Oihi ML| tL*|L? UL?UiT|t @hi t?}*i @*i_ Ai ?U*iL*t t _i|ih4?i_ }iL4i|hU@**) M) |i t@Ti Lu |i ULhi EMiU@ti | UL?U_it | |i !ih?i* ? |t U@ti ihi@t E@t 4i?|L?i_ ? |i ?|hL_U|L? |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? _iTi?_t L?*) L? |i ti| Lu M?_?} UL@*|L?t | hitTiU| |L ULhi AihiuLhic @T@h| uhL4 |ih _gihi?| ?_ih*)?} Th?UT*i Lu u@h?itt |i hi@* _gihi?Ui t i TLti_ uLh ?L?UL?i M@*@?Ui_ }@4it Oihi |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? 4@) Mi ti| @*i_ EUu i @4T*i e ? #||@ @?_ +@) EbHb @?_ |i ?U*iL*t 4@) ?L| Mi _i|ih4?i_ M) |i ULhi +iU@** |@| @tU*ihc i*i} : 5@T*i)Eb.b tLi_ |@| |L }@4it 4@) @i |i t@4i ULhi @?_ )i| _gihi?| ?U*iL* M) |i uL**L?} i @4T*i , @4T*i L?t_ih @ ?L?UL?i uLh T*@)ih }@4i Ec ihi ' ic 2c c ej @?_ E7 t |i Lh| Lu UL@*|L? 7 c _i?i_ M)c E ' 2c Eic 2c j ' Eic 2c ej ' Eic c ej ' Ei2c c ej ' c Eic 2j ' Ei c ej ' Eic ej ' Ei2c j ' c Eic j ' *2c Ei2c ej ' fc Eij ' Ei2j ' Ei j ' Eiej ' E> ' f #i?i ? @__|L? @ }@4i Ec W ihi E7 ' W E7 uLh @** 7 9' ic 2c j @?_ W Eic 2c j ' D*e Lc |i ULhi Lu Ec t _i?|U@* |L |i ULhi Lu Ec W }i? M) |i UL?i ** dE c c c c Ec fc c f o e e e e 5?Ui |i i^@* tT*| @**LU@|L? t ? |i ULhic E 2 c 2 c 2 c 2 t |i wLhi?3 4@ 4@* D
4T|@|L? uLh ML| }@4it @?_ W iih|i*itt |i ?U*iL*t Lu Ec t E 2 c 2 c 2 c 2 ihi@t |i ?U*iL*t Lu Ec W t E DH c H c DH c H Lc ?L UL@*|L? @t @? LMiU|L? |L @?) 4T|@|L? ? |i ULhi Oi?Ui @| _i|ih4?it |i i @U| *LU@|L? ? |i ULhi L}| |L Mi M@ti_ L? UL?t_ ih@|L?t Lu u@h?itt OLiihc UL?t_ih |i 4T|@|L? E 2 c 2 c 2 c 2 @t ti*iU|i_ M) |i ?U*iL*t Lu At 4T|@|L? t t|** ? |i ULhi Lu |i ?i }@4i W @?_ U*i@h*)c |i UL@*|L? ic 2c j U t @tt}?i_ @ }ih @*i ? |i }@4i W @t ?L LMiU|L? |L |t 4T|@|L? Oi?Ui | tii4t ^it|L?@M*i |@| ? |i ?i }@4i UL@*|L? ic 2c j tL*_ Mi @M*i |L i?uLhUi |i LMtihi_ U@?}i U @U|@**) 4@!it T*@)ih 2 Lhti Lg
A@!?} |i @h}4i?| @ M| uh|ih i 4}|c i? @** i Uittit @hi ?L? TLt|ic ^it|L? |i UL44L? LT?L? |@| @ *i UL}h@TU 4?43@|L? Lu |i 4@ 44 i Uitt ^@*it @t @ u@h?itt Th?UT*i AL i*@MLh@|i L? |t TL?| UL?t_ih |i uL**L?} i @4T*i , @4T*i 2 L?t_ih @ |hii T*@)ih }@4i Ec _i?i_ M) Eij ' Ei2j ' Ei j ' fc Eic 2j ' Eic j ' c Ei2c j ' fc Eic 2c j ' 2 *i@h*)c |t t @ M@*@?Ui_ }@4i ihi |i i^@* @**LU@|L? t ? |i ULhi AihiuLhi |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? t E 2 c 2 c 2 Ai ?U*iL*t t |i @**LU@|L? Ec 2 c 2 Wu i UL?t_ih |i }@4i @t @ t@?}t }@4i |ihi t @ h@|ih *@h}i u@4*) Lu E_@* ULt| }@4it EE7 ' M7 SEij SE7 hi*@|i_ |L |t }@4i A@!i uLh i @4T*i |i }@4it S @?_ S _i?i_ @t
S
SEij ' SEi2j ' SEi j ' c SEic 2j ' SEic j ' c SEi2c j ' 2c SEic 2c j ' @?_ S Eij ' D S Ei2j ' c S Ei j ' fDc S Eic 2j ' S Ei2c j ' Dc S Eic j ' c S Eic 2c j ' L|i |@| ? ML| U@tit |i i^@* @**LU@|L? t ? |i ULhi 4T*)?} |@| |i wLhi?3 tL*|L? Lu S @?_ S t E c c S
L?|h@h) |L |t i tii |@| |i ?U*iL*t Lu S t Efc 2 c 2 @?_ Lu S t E 2 c 2 c f 5?Ui ML| S @?_ S @hi _@*t Lu |i t@4i t@?}t }@4i | _Lit ?L| tii4 |L @}hii | @ Th?UT*i Lu u@h?itt |@| ? |i L?i U@ti T*@)ih t |hi@|i_ 4Lt| u@Lh@M*i ihi@t ? |i L|ih U@ti T*@)ih t |hi@|i_ 4Lt| u@Lh@M*i Wuc M) @ Th?UT*i Lu u@h?ittc |i 4T|@|L? Efc 2 c 2 @t ti*iU|i_ uLh |i }@4i S |i? |t 4T|@|L? tL*_ @*tL Mi ti*iU|i_ uLh |i }@4i S t?Ui | t t|** ? |i ULhi @?_ ?L UL@*|L? @t @? LMiU|L? @}@?t| | |c U*i@h*) |i ?U*iL*t _Lit ?L| hitTiU| |t !?_ Lu ?_iTi?_i?Ui Lu hhi*i@?| @*|ih?@|it ' f Wu Ec t @ UL@*|L?@* }@4i |i? t U@**i_ |i UL@*|L? u?U|L? `i? t tTiUi_ i tL4i|4it h|i ?t|i@_ Lu Ec wi| + _i?L|i |i ti| Lu hi@* ?4Miht `i _i?L|i M) + |i ti| Lu @** u?U|L?t uhL4 |L + 4i4Mih % Lu + t U@**i_ @ T@)Lg iU|Lh EuLh Wu % 5 + @?_ 7 |i? i h|i %E7 ' M7 % *i@h*)c %E> ' f wi| Ec Mi @ }@4i Ai ULhi Lu Ec c Ec c t _i?i_ M)
S
Ec ' i% 5 + m%E7 E7 uLh @** 7 @?_ %E ' E j Wu Ec 9' > |i? Ec t M@*@?Ui_ M) |i L?_@hi@5@T*i) AiLhi4 Etii i} i? EbbD
H
6Lh @ UL@*|L? 7 i h|i m7m uLh |i ?4Mih Lu 4i4Miht Lu 7 `i 4@) ?L _i?i @ u?U|L? ) G + $ +? E? ' mm M) |i uL**L?} h*i wi| % 5 + @?_ & ? Ai? )& E% ' 4?i%E7 m7 @?_ m7m ' &j Ai u?U|L? )& t @ TL*)i_h@* UL?U@i u?U|L? uLh & ' c c ? wi| %c + 5 + Lc % wLhi?3 _L4?@|it + u )E% : )E+ c |@| tc )& E% )& E+ uLh & ' c c ?c @?_ )E% 9' )E+ tt4i |@| |i ULhi t ?L?i4T|) T@)Lg iU|Lh % t wLhi?3 4@ 4@* ? Ec u % 5 Ec @?_ |ihi i t|t ?L 5 5 Ec tU |@| 5 wLhi?3 _L4?@|it % W? |t Lh! i ?it|}@|i |i ti| uEc Lu wLhi?3 4@ 4@* 4i4Miht Lu Ec `i? Ec 9' > |i? uEc 9' > MiU@ti Ec t UL4T@U| @?_ ) t UL?|?Lt wi| Ec Mi @? ?TihtL? }@4i tt4i |@| |i ULhi Ec 9' > wi| c 5 c 9' c @?_ % 5 Ec `i _i?i * 7jc r E% ' 4@ iE7 %E7 m 5 7 @?_ 5 % % c r E% jc @?_ 2 _ E% ' 4@ iB E% c fj B E% ' 4?i
+i4@h! Wu % t wLhi?3 4@ 4@* ? Ec c |i? _ E% ' f uLh @** 9' c c 5 hLLuG wi| % 5 Ec c c 5 c 9' c @?_ _ E% : f Ai? % : % @?_ r E% f Oi?Uic u f B B E% c |i? |i iU|Lh + U t }i? M)G +& ' %& uLh & 95 ic jc + ' % n Bc @?_ + ' % Bc t ? Ec *i@h*)c + wLhi?3 _L4?@|it % At % 95 uEc ",# , @4T*i e wi| ' ic 2c c ej @?_ *i| Eic 2j ' Ei2c j ' Ei c ej ' Eic ej ' c E ' 2c @?_ E7 ' f L|ihti Ai? Ec ' iE|c |c |c | mf | j At uEc ' E 2 c 2 c 2 c 2 OLiihc % ' Ec fc c f 5 Ec @?_ _ E% ' f uLh @** c 5 c 9' `i UL?U*_i |@| +i4@h! tc ?_ii_c L?*) @ ?iUitt@h) UL?_|L?
b
wi| Ec Mi @ }@4i `i t@) |@| t @| *i@t| @t _ith@M*i @t | hitTiU| |L Eh| c h||i? c u 7 qic j , E7 ^ ij E7 ^ ij 6ht| i LMtihi |@| u hitTiU|t _ith@M*|) wi44@ Wu % 5 uEc c c 5 c 9' c @?_ c |i? % % hLLuG tt4ic L? |i UL?|h@h)c |@| % : % ) +i4@h! r E% ' f * 7 #i?L|i A ' 7qij Ai? wi| r E% ' E7 %E7 c ihi 5 7 @?_ 5 EA ^ ij %EA % : E7 %EA % ' f 5?Ui % 5 Ec i LM|@? |i _ithi_ UL?|h@_U|L? ",# wi| Ec Mi @ }@4i @?_ *i| % 5 + Ai E#@t@tU*ih hi_Ui_ }@4i A% h| % @?_ A c A 9' >c t }i? M) A%
;A fc 7 ' > ? E7 ' A %EA c 7 ' A = 4@ \ . dE7 ^ - %E- oc 7 Ac 7 9' >c Ac -
A
wi| K Mi @ ti| Lu }@4it tL*|L? L? K t @ u?U|L? j |@| @ttLU@|it | i@U Ec 5 K @ tMti| jEc Lu f W Ec c ihi f W Ec ' i% 5 + m%E E j t |i ti| Lu ui@tM*i T@)Lgt Lu |i }@4i wi| j Mi @ tL*|L? L? K tL*|L? j t@|tit |i hi_Ui_ }@4i ThLTih|) E+B u |i uL**L?} UL?_|L? L*_t Wu Ec 5 Kc 7 c 7 9' >c @?_ % 5 jEc c |i? E7c 7% 5 K @?_ %7 5 jE7c 7% Eihi %7 t |i hit|hU|L? Lu % |L 7 tL*|L? j t@|tit |i t|hL?} +B u j t@|tit |i +B @?_c ? @__|L?c uLh iih) Ec 5 Kc 7 c 7 9' >c % 5 jEc c @?_ +7 5 jE7c 7% c |i T@)Lg iU|Lh E+7 c % .7 5 jEc wi| E Mi |i ti| Lu @** M@*@?Ui_ }@4it Ai ULhi t@|tit |i t|hL?} +B L? E `i t@** ?L ThLi |@| uEc t@|tit |i +B L? E 6ht| i ?ii_ |i uL**L?} hi4@h! +i4@h! 2 wi| Mi @ ?|i ti| Lu T*@)ihtc @?_ *i| 7 c 7 9' > Wu %7 c +7 5 +7 c %7 E7 ' +7 E7 c @?_ 5 .7 5 + .7 c |i? %7 wLhi?3 _L4?@|it +7 g f
E%7 c 5 .7 wLhi?3 _L4?@|it E+7 c 5 .7 EAt hi4@h! uL**Lt uhL4 AiLhi4 fH Lu O@h_) i| @* Eb e Lc i U@? ThLi wi44@ 2 uEc t@|tit |i +B L? E hLLuG wi| Ec Mi @ M@*@?Ui_ }@4ic *i| A c A 9' >c @?_ *i| % 5 uEc Ai }@4i EAc A% t ? E MiU@ti |i ULhi t@|tit |i +B `i U*@4 |@| %A 5 uEAc A% tt4ic L? |i UL?|h@h)c |@| |ihi i t|t +A 5 EAc A% |@| wLhi?3 _L4?@|it %A Ai?c E+A c % .A 5 Ec M) |i t|hL?} +B Lu |i ULhi 6h|ih4Lhic M) +i4@h! 2c E+A c % .A wLhi?3 _L4?@|it % Atc |i _ithi_ UL?|h@_U|L? @t Mii? LM|@?i_ ",# Ai t|hL?} +B 4@) Mi i*Tu* ? ULLt?} |i Rh}| hi_Ui_ }@4i W? Lh U@tic uLh i @4T*ic |i ULhi _Lit ?L| t@|tu) |i t|hL?} +B h| L*?c
Ai hi_Ui_ }@4i ThLTih|) h| L*? @?_ u _ EEfHc f. c EfSDc o 9' > L?|t L? EEfHc f. c Ec *2 o @hi }i? M) % ' EfH n 0c f2 0c fH n 0c f2 0c f. 0c f n 0c f. 0c f n 0c f. 0c f n 0 c f 0 f2 `i UL4T|i )E% ' Ef2 0c fe 20c f. 0c c n 0c 2c 2. 0c e 20c e2 0c D Oi?Ui |ihi t ?L wLhi?3 _L4?@|L? L? dEfHc f. c Ec 2 o L?|t L? dEfHc f. c EfSDc o @hi }i? M) + ' EfH 0c f2 n 0c fH 0c f2 n 0c f. n 20c f 20c f. n 20c f 20c f. n 20c f 20 c f 0 fD `i UL4T|i )E+ uLh f 0 f )E+ ' Ef2 n 0c fe n 20c f.c 20c e0c 2 20c 2.c e n 20c e2 n 0c D Oi?Ui |ihi t ?L wLhi?3_L4?@|L? L?dEfHc f. c EfSDc o *tL ?L TL?| ? dEfHc f. Ec *2 o wLhi?3 _L4?@|it @ TL?| ? dEfHc f. EfH * fc f. n 2* f o EL4T@hi |i ht| UL4TL?i?| Lu ) L?ihti*) ?L TL?| ? dEfHc f. c EfH * fc f. n 2* f o _L4?@|it @ TL?| ? dEfHc f. c Ec *2 o EL4T@hi |i uLh| UL4TL?i?| Lu ) Atc uEc t ?L| UL?i
e
*|ih?@|i U@h@U|ih3@|L?t
wi| Ec Mi @ M@*@?Ui_ }@4i @?_ *i| % 5 f W Ec 6Lh 7 c 7 9' >c i _i?L|i M) 7 |i U@h@U|iht|U iU|Lh Lu 7c |@| tc 7 ' u 5 7c @?_ 7 ' f u 95 7 #i?L|i ?L ~ E% ' i 7 m7 9' >c c E7 %E7 ' fj wi| Mi @ ti| Lu T*@)iht @?_ *i| # G - $ -? Mi |i Lh_ih?} u?U|L? ihi #& E+ ' )& E+ )&3 E+ E)f E+ ' f *i@h*)c # E+ #? E+ 6Lh @ ?4Mih?} Z Lu c |@| t @ MiU|L? Z G $ ic c ?jc *i| Z ' ieZ!Q E c eZ!Q E n eZ!Q E2 c c eZ!Q E n n eZ!Q E?3 j @?_ *i|
E% ' ^iZ mZE% ' #E% j
Ee& t |i !| ?| iU|Lh ? -
wi44@ wi| % 5 Ec @?_ *i| t E% ' t ' i+ 5 - m+E ' f @?_ + 1 f uLh @** 1 5 ~ E% ^ E% j Ai? % 5 uEc g t ' ifj EWu %c + 5 + |i? % + '
S
? '
% +
hLLuG 5Ui?U) wi| t ' ifj tt4ic L? |i UL?|h@h)c |@| |ihi i t|t % 5 Ec tU |@| )E % : )E% E|@| t )E % )E% @?_ )E % 9' )E% wi| + ' % % Ai? + 9' f @?_ +E ' f Wu 1 5 ~ E% |i? 1 ' 7 @?_ E7 %E7 ' f Oi?Ui +1 '% E7 %E7 ' E7 %E7 dE7 % E7 o f Wu Z t @ Tih4|@|L? Lu @?_ ZE% ' #E% c |i? ZE% ' E%Z!Q E c c %Z!Q E?
S
wi| & ? & Z!Q E )& E % )& E% ' ' %
S
& '
%Z!Q E At
% EeZ!Q E n n eZ!QE& % EeZ!Q E n n eZ!Q E& Oi?Ui + EeZ!Q E n n eZ!Q E& f @?_ + 5 t AihiuLhi i LM|@? |i _ithi_ UL?|h@_U|L? iUitt|) wi| % 5 uEc tt4ic L? |i UL?|h@h)c |@| |ihi i t|t + 5 tc + 9' f wi| % '% E| ' % n |+ LLti | : f tUi?|*) t4@** tL |@| E % E| 5 Ec ( @?_ E % % , % E| % E| c c 5 c 9' LLti @ % ' E %Q c c % ? ' #E % *i@h*) Z E% ' #E% Tih4|@|L? Z tU |@| Z E Oi?Ui uLh i@U & ?
[ % ) E % ' &
&
'
[% ' &
'
[+ n| &
'
' )& E% n|+EeZ !QE n neZ !Q E& )& E%
Atc + 9' f 4T*it )E % : )E% c @?_ |i _ithi_ UL?|h@_U|L? @t Mii? LM|@?i_ ",# 5 Ec @?_ ~ E % ~ E% @?_ LhL**@h) wi| % 5 uEc Wu % E % E% c |i? % 5 uEc e
`i ?L Thiti?| @? @__|L?@* U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu uEc wi| Mi @ M@* @?Ui_ }@4i
S
AiLhi4 wi| % 5 Ec @?_ *i| 'E% ' ~ E% ^ E% Ai? % 5 uEc g |ihi i t| TLt|i ?4Miht q1 c 1 5 'E% c tU |@| ' 1M'E% q1 1 Ei 'E% t M@*@?Ui_ hLLuG 5Ui?U) Wu |ihi i t| q1 : f tU |@| ' t E% ' ifj AihiuLhic M) wi44@ c % 5 uEc iUitt|) L?t_ih |i uL**L?} ETh4@* ThLM*i4 E
[
4@
SM 1
'E%
q1 1c |i?
1+
1 M'E%
tMiU| |L +E ' f @?_ E1 + f uLh 1 5 'E% E t ui@tM*i @?_ |t @*i t 3ihL Oi?Ui |i _@* ThLM*i4 t ui@tM*ic |@| tc |ihi i t| 1 fc 1 5 'E% c @?_ q 5 -c tU |@| q Oi?Ui 1M'E% E n 1 1 ' q @?_ |ihiuLhi 1 M'E% 1 1 ' 1 M'E% 1 q : f ",#
S
S
S
S
S
wi| G + $ + Mi t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ t|hU|*) UL?U@ic *i| Ec 5 Ec @?_ *i| % 5 Ec Wu ?' E% ?' E+ uLh @** + 5 Ec c |i?c M) AiLhi4 fH Lu O@h_) i| @* Eb e c % 5 uEc `i t@** ?L ThLi |@| |i UL?ihti U*@4 t @*tL |hiG Wu % 5 uEc |i? |ihi i t|t @ t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ t|hU|*) UL?U@i u?U|L? G + $ + tU |@| ?' E% ? E+ uLh @** + 5 Ec '
S
S
AiLhi4 2 wi| Ec 5 E @?_ *i| % 5 Ec Ai? % 5 uEc g |ihi i t|t @ t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ t|hU|*) UL?U@i u?U|L? G + $ + tU |@| ? E% ?' E+ uLh @** + 5 Ec '
S
S
hLLuG `i L?*) @i |L ThLi ?iUitt|) wi| % 5 uEc `i _i?L|i ~ E% ' ~ E% ^ i c j ' i 7 m7 9' >c c %E7 ' E7 j ^ i c j Ai UL?i Lu ui@tM*i _hiU|L?t @| % t 8 E%c Ec ' i+ 5 + m+E1 f uLh @** 1 5 ~ E% j D
wi| g Mi |i UL?i tT@??i_ M) ~ E% Ai? 8 E%c Ec ' g W c ihi g W t |i _@* Lu g Atc M) _@*|)c |i UL?i Lu E?Lh4@*t Lu tTTLh|?} )TihT*@?it @| % E|L Ec t g Lc M) AiLhi4 c |ihi i t|t q1 : fc 1 5 ~ E% ^ E% c tU |@|
[
'
q1 1 n
1 M~ E%
S
[
q1 1
1 M E%
S
wi| R ' 1M~ E% q1 1 ' 1M E% q1 1 Ai? R 5 g @?_c M) |i _i?|L? Lu E% c E % % , R : R `i ?L ULLti @ t|hU|*) _iUhi@t?} @?_ TiUiti UL?|?Lt u?U|L? G + $ + tU |@| E E| : R u | % c @?_ E| R u | : % c ' c c ?( @?_ E E| : f uLh @** | 5 + EE t TLttM*i MiU@ti Lu E #i?i ?L G + $ + M) E| ' f| E _ Ai? t t|hU|*) ?Uhi@t?} @?_ t|hU|*) UL?U@i 6h|ih4Lhic M) E c
U
[ E+ [ E% n [ R E+ % ?
'
S
S
?
'
?
S
'
uLh @** + 5 + *tLc MiU@ti R 5 gc ?' R E+ % f uLh @** + 5 Ec Oi?Uic ?' E% ?' E+ uLh @** + 5 Ec ",# t @ ULhL**@h) uhL4 |i ThLLu Lu AiLhi4 2 i LM|@? |i uL**L?} RThUi U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu |i 4i4Miht Lu uEc AiLhi4 wi| Ec 5 E @?_ *i| % 5 Ec Ai? % 5 uEc g |ihi i t|t @ t|hU|*) TLt|i iU|Lh R 5 + tU |@| E % % , R : R uLh @** c 5 c 9' c @?_ ? ? E ' R % ' R + uLh @** + 5 Ec
S
S
AiLhi4 t ?L| ?i W| t 4T*i_ M) |i hit*|t Lu AL? @?_ ALh*?_ i|ihti? EbHH L? ThUi U@h@U|ih3@|L? Lu iUi?| h@?_L4 @h@M*it uLh TL*)i_h@* ti|t *tLc |iU?U@**) t4*@h hit*|t @hi LM|@?i_ ? 5_ L*|ih @?_ i*i} EbbH
D
BiL4i|hU@* @?_ |LTL*L}U@* ThLTih|it
`i t@** ?L ThLi |@| uLh i@U 5 Ec uEc t L4iL4LhTU |L |i ti| Lu @hi|L LT|4@* TL?|t Lu tL4i TL*)i_h@* UL?i ti| 6h|ih4Lhic Lh S
L4iL4LhTt4 |ti*u ** Mi TL*)i_h@* At ** i?@M*i t |L UL4T*i|i*) _i|ih4?i |i }iL4i|hU@* @?_ |LTL*L}U@* ThLTih|it Lu uEc wi| Ec 5 E @?_ *i| ) G + $ +? Mi _i?i_ @t ? 5iU|L? wi| ( ' (E +? Mi _i?i_ M) ( ' i+ 5 +? m @?_ ~ ^ t M@*@?Ui_ wi| Ec Mi @ }@4i @?_ *i| % 5 uEc Wu ~ E% ' i7 m%E7 ' E7 c 7 9' >c jc @?_ E% ' iZ 5 7t E mZE% ' #E% jc |i? E~ E% c E% t tUi?| W?_ii_c E% 9' > @?_ ~ E% ^ E% t M@*@?Ui_ Etii AiLhi4 wi| E Mi |i ti| Lu @** M@*@?Ui_ }@4it @?_ *i| j Mi @ tL*|L? L? E `i t@) |@| j t@|tit hit|hU|i_ @__||) E? tLh|G + u Ec c Ec 5 Ec i%j ' jE c i+j ' jE c @?_ E~ E% _ ~ E+ c E% _ E+ t tUi?|c 4T*) |@| % n + 5 jEc n wi44@ e uEc t@|tit + hLLuG wi| Ec c Ec 5 Ec i%j ' uEc c i+j ' uEc c @?_ *i| E~ E% _ ~ E+ c E% _ E+ Mi tUi?| *i@h*)c %n+ 5 En c ~ n E%n + ~ E% _~ E+ c @?_ E%n+ E% _ E+ wi| Z 5 E% _ E+ Ai? Z UL?|@?t ? *?i@h*) ?_iTi?_i?| iU|Lht eZ!QE c c eZ!Q E n neZ!Q E?3 Aiti iU|Lht |L}i|ih | uLh4 @ M@tt Lu - t E~ E% _ ~ E+ ^ E E% _ E+ t M@*@?Ui_c @?) iU|Lh + 5 - |@| t@|tit + E ' f @?_ + 1 f uLh @** 1 5 E~ E% _ ~ E+ ^ E E% _ E+ c 4t| Mi |i 3ihL iU|Lh Oi?Uic M) wi44@ c % n + 5 uEc n ",# `i ?L |h? |L @ L4@|3@|L? Lu uEc h}?@**) i U@h@U|ih3i_ uEc uLh mL m @t |i 4?44 tL*|L? L? E |@| t@|tit ,c W+c +B8c +5c @?_ +c ihi +B8 t @ t*}| @h@|L? Lu +B t @ ULhL**@h) i LM|@?i_ |@| uLh mL m c uEc t |i 4?44 tL*|L? L? E |@| t@|tit ,c W+c +B8 @?_ + hhi?|*)c uEc t @ L4@|3i_ uLh mL m ' 2 M) AiLhi4 . 6Lh mL m e |i hiuihii Lu |t T@Tih @t !?_*) Lgihi_ |i uL**L?} hit*| EAiLhi4 H E6Lh mLm ' @ t*}| 4L_U@|L? Lu |i ThLLu Lu AiLhi4 H tLt |@| u t @ L4@|3i_ M) ,c W+c +B @?_ + 2f
AiLhi4 H wi| mL m e Ai? uEc t |i 4?44 tL*|L? L? E |@| t@|tit ,c +B @?_ + hLLuG wi| j Mi @ tL*|L? L? E |@| t@|tit ,c +B @?_ + `i @i |L tL |@| uEc jEc uLh @** Ec 5 E wi| Ec 5 E | ? ' mm ec @?_ *i| % 5 uEc #i?i }@4it Ec @?_ Ec M) E7 '
+ %E7 c
m7m ? c E7 c m7m ? 2c
@?_ ' *i@h*)c c 5 E ) , |ihi i t|t + 5 jEc @?_ 5 5 jEc `i t@** ht| ThLi |@| + ' % t E ' %E +E |ihi i t|t - tU |@| m-m ' 2 @?_ %E q - +E q - L?t_ih ?L |i hi_Ui_ }@4i E-c +- ) +Bc E-c +- t M@*@?Ui_ *tLc +- E- ' +E- c @?_ +- Eij %EE q - ^ ij +E q - c 5 - At
[
+
M -
-
Eij +- E- %E n %E q - +E +E q - f
t E-c +- t M@*@?Ui_c %E ' +E @?_ %E q- ' +E q- AihiuLhic i @i tL? |@| %E7 +E7 4T*it %E7 ' +E7 c uLh iih) 7 c m7m ' ? 2 Oi?Uic + ' % Lc i t@** ThLi |@| 5 ' f L*_t |hi L|i |@| 5E E ' f t @*_ M) ui@tM*|) wi| 5 tU |@| 5 f @?_ *i| ' ' q ij Ai? |i 5 5 hi_Ui_ }@4i E'c ' t M@*@?Ui_ M) +B *tLc ' E' ' 5E' ' 5E 5 c 5 @?_ ' Eij Eic j 5 ' 5 c uLh @** 5 ' Oi?Uic
[
M'
5 '
5 Eij ' E' 5E E? 2 5 f
5 t M@*@?Ui_c 5 ' f AihiuLhi 5 ' f t E'c ' Lc i t@** ThLi |@| % 5 jE n ' jE W?_ii_
~ E% ' i7 m7 9' >c c %E7 ' E7 j ~ E% *tLc u m7m ? @?_ 7 5 ~ E% c |i? 7 5 ~ Ef ( @?_ u m7m ? 2c |i? E7 ' f @?_ 7 5 ~ Ef Oi?Ui ~ Ef ' i7 m7 9' >c c E7 ' fj ~ E% 2
6h|ihc Ef ' 7t E E% Atc Ef _ E% ' E% @?_ ~ E% _ ~ Ef ~ E% Ai T@h E~ E% c E% t tUi?| MiU@ti % 5 uEc Atc M) +c % ' % n f 5 jE n ' jE W| hi4@?t |L ThLi |@| uEc jEc u Ec 5 E @?_ mm wi| ht| Ec 5 E | mm ' @?_ *i| 5 L q L?t_ih |i }@4i E ^ijc ihi E7 ' E7qij uLh @** 7 ^ij Ai? jE ^ijc uE ^ ijc ' uEc ifj ) +Bc jEc uEc `i U@? ?L UL?|?i ? |i t@4i @) |L LM|@? ?U*tL? uLh ? ' 2c ",# W? Lh_ih |L ThLi ?_iTi?_i?Ui Lu |i @ L4t i UL?t_ih |i uL**L?} i @4T*it , @4T*i 2G jEc ' > uLh iih) Ec 5 E At tL*|L? L?*) L*@|it , , @4T*i G wi| Ec 5 E #i?i jEc ' 7Ec c i |i 5@T*i) @*i Lu Ec At tL*|L? L?*) L*@|it +B , @4T*i eG wi| jEc Mi _i?i_ M) jEc ' @h} 4?
%M Ec
[ %2c ?
'
uLh @** Ec 5 E At tL*|L? L*@|it + , @4T*i DG wi| jEc ' Ec uLh iih) Ec 5 E Ai? j L?*) L*@|it 4?4@*|) wi| 5BV Mi |i ti| Lu @** 4L?L|L?U t4T*i }@4it | i|Liht EWu Ec ` 5 5BVc ihi ` 2 c |i? E > 95 ` @?_ 5 ` ( E u 7 5 ` @?_ 7 A c |i? A 5 `c @?_ E T ' 7 M` 7 9' > T t |i ti| Lu i|Liht `i t@) |@| @ tL*|L? _iTi?_t L?*) L? |i ULhi E? tLh|( # i? uLh @?) |L }@4it | |i t@4i ULhi |i tL*|L? t |i t@4i |LL ? |i U*@tt Lu t4T*i }@4it | i|Liht 5BV i U@? ?L LM|@? |i uL**L?} U@h@U|ih3@|L? ihi @** @ L4t i UiT| uLh # @hi i** !?L? @?_ @i Mii? UL44i?|i_ TL? tiih@* |4it ? |i *|ih@|hi
W
AiLhi4 b wi| mL m Aihi t @ ?^i tL*|L? L? 5BV |@| t@|t it , E?L?i4T|?itt c E@hi|L LT|4@*|) c ,A Ei^@* |hi@|4i?| c 22
E?** T*@)ih ThLTih|) c @?_ # E|i tL*|L? _iTi?_t L?*) L? |i ULhi c @?_ | t uEc
W
hLLuG wi| j Mi @ tL*|L? L? 5BV |@| t@|tit ,c c ,Ac @?_ #c @?_ *i| Ec ` 5 5BV Ai? T ' 7 M` 7 9' > wi| T Mi |i ?@?4|) }@4i L? Tc |@| t T E7 ' u 7 T @?_ T E7 ' f L|ihti ) ,Ac ,c c @?_ jET ' T *mT m ' uEc T Lc Ec T ' Ec ` Oi?Uic M) #c jEc ` ' T *mT m ' uEc ` ",#
.
TT*U@|L?t
L?t_ih @ ThL_U|L? }@4ic i @ }@4i | ? T*@)iht @?} i?_L4i?|t f ^ ^? c E^ ' E^ c c ^? L t@hi @ UL44L? ThL_U|L? u?U|L? s _i?i_ M) ?4Miht : f @?_ ^f : f @t s Eo '
+ fc
o ^f oc o ^f
At s t @ u?U|L? @?} ?Uhi@t?} @ih@}i ThL_U|c 4i@??} |@| s Eo *o t ?L?_iUhi@t?} ? o : f Ai E?L?UL?i ThL_U|L? }@4i ULhhi tTL?_?} |L Esc ^ t _i?i_ M)
+ fc S E7 ' M
7 ^ c
SM SM
^ ^f c 7 ^ ^f
7
S
hLTLt|L? Bi? ^f M ^ c |i? |i 4T|@|L? @ ' ^ 5 Ec 6h|ih4Lhic uEc UL?tt|t Lu @ t?}*i 4T|@|L? %W _i|ih4?i_ M) W
% ' ihi
+
?3& n
^ c
S
? ' &
& ' 4?di 5 m
^ c ' &c c ?c ' c c & c
[ M .t
W? T@h|U*@hc u ^f ^? c |i? %W ' @
2
^ ^f j ^ i? n jo
hLLuG @** @ T*@)ih & 5 M*LU!?} u U*@4t @hi |hi
SM
.t&
^ ^f Ai uL**L?}
E Wu & 5 t ?L| M*LU!?} @?_ % 5 Ec c |i? %& ^& E6L**Lt uhL4 |i _i?|L? Lu |i ULhi Atc u |ihi @hi ?L M*LU!?} T*@)ihtc |i? Ec ' @ E Wu @?_ @hi M*LU!?} @?_ % 5 uEc c |i? % ' % EuL**Lt uhL4 +5 Lc @tt4i L? |i UL?|h@h) |@| % 5 uEc @?_ % 9' %W ) E @?_ E c )E%W : )E% U t |i _ithi_ UL?|h@_U|L? ) ,c uEc ' %W ",# L?t_ih @ ThL_U|L? iUL?L4) | @ *@?_L?ih @?_ Ti@t@?|t E5@T*i) @?_ 5M! EbS. Aihi t L?i *@?_L?ihc T*@)ih c @?_ 6 Ti@t@?|tc T*@)iht 2c c 6 n Ai Ti@t@?|t UL?|hM|i |ih *@MLh @?_ @hi tTTLti_ |L Mi t)44i|hU Ai *@?_L?ih hit Ti@t@?|t |L U*|@|i t *@?_ Wu | Ti@t@?|t @hi hi_c |i? |i 4L?i|@h) @*i Lu |i UhLT t _i?L|i_ M) s E| s G ifc c c 6j $ + t U@**i_ |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L? `i t@** @tt4i E s Ef ' f E*@MLh t itti?|@* uLh ThL_U|L? c E sE| n s E| c | ' fc c 6 wi| ' ic c 6 n j Ai UL@*|L?@* u?U|L? G 2 $ + @ttLU@|i_ | |i uLhi}L?} iUL?L4) t }i? M) E7 '
+ fc
95 7 s Em7m c 5 7
Ai ULhi Ec 9' > MiU@ti Es E6 c fc c f 5 Ec wi| r Ec Mi |i t)44i|hU ULhi Lu Ec c |@| t r Ec ' i% 5 Ec m%2 ' ' %6n j wi| > ' 4?i% m% 5 r Ec j @?_ uEc ' + Ai? + ' 4@ i>c
s E6 j 6n
@?_ +2 ' ' +6n ' 2e
sE6 + 6
At | hi4@?t |L UL4T|i > wi| % 5 r Ec Ai? % n
EsE6 % o s Eo c o ' c c 6 6
Oi?Ui % Lh
sEo s E6 E6 o c 6o o 6
> ' 4@ d $o$6
H
s Eo s E6 6o f o E ' f o 6 6o f
+iuihi?Uit
hi*c W Ebb. G LLTih@|i }@4i |iLh) @?_ @TT*U@|L?tc k*ih EA#w #@tc : @tU*ih EbSD G Ai !ih?i* Lu @ ULLTih@|i }@4ic @@* +iti@hU wL}t|Ut "@h|ih*)c 2c 22 2Db #||@c Ebbf G Ai i}@*|@h@? tL*|L? @?_ hi_Ui_ }@4i ThLTih|it ? UL?i }@4itc W?|ih?@|L?@* aLh?@* Lu B@4i AiLh)c bc D Sb #||@c : # +@) EbHb G UL?UiT| Lu i}@*|@h@?t4 ?_ih T@h|UT@|L? UL?t|h@?|tc ,UL?L4i|hU@c D.c SD S D #||@c : # +@) Ebb G L?t|h@?i_ i}@*|@h@? @**LU@|L?tc B@4it @?_ ,UL?L4U i@Lhc c ef e22 O@h_)c BOc a, w||*iLL_ : B L*)@ Eb e G W?i^@*|itc @4Mh_}i N?iht|) hitt @tU*ihc c i*i} : w 5@T*i) Eb.b G BiL4i|hU ThLTih|it Lu |i !ih?i*c ?U*iL*tc @?_ hi*@|i_ tL*|L? UL?UiT|tc @|i4@|Ut Lu Tih @|L?t +iti@hUc ec f H i?c B Eb.D G Ai ULhi Lu *?i@h ThL_U|L? }@4itc @|i4@|U@* hL }h@44?}c bc DH .f i?c B EbbD G B@4i AiLh) E i_|L? ( U@_i4U hitt i*i}c Eb.2 G ALTL*L}U@* ThLTih|it Lu |i iUi?| TL?| ti|c hLUii_ ?}t Lu |i 4ihU@? @|i4@|U@* 5LUi|)c Dc D D S 2D
5U4i_*ihc # EbSb G Ai ?U*iL*t Lu @ U@h@U|iht|U u?U|L? }@4ic 5W aLh?@* Lu TT*i_ @|i4@|Utc .c S .f 5@T*i)c w Eb. G Lhit Lu UL?i }@4itc W?|ih?@|L?@* aLh?@* Lu B@4i AiLh)c c 2S 5@T*i)c w : 5M! EbS. G ?ihtT @?_ |i ThL_U|L? u?U|L?c "@h|ih*) aLh?@* Lu ,UL?L4Utc Hc HH 5@T*i)c w : 5M! Eb.2 G Ai @tt}?4i?| }@4i WG |i ULhic W?|ih?@ |L?@* aLh?@* Lu B@4i AiLh)c c f 5_L*|ihc : i*i} EbbH G U*iL* @t 4@ 43iht Lu UL**iU|i t@|t u@U|L? u?U|L?tc 5LU@* LUi @?_ `i*u@hi Dc H e A@_i?4@ Ebb2 G +i_Ui_ }@4itc UL?tt|i?U)c @?_ |i ULhic W?|ih?@|L?@* aLh?@* Lu B@4i AiLh)c 2fc 2D e AL?c # : w ALh*?_i|ihti? EbHH G 5|LU@t|U _L4?@?Ui @?_ 6hi_4@? 5@@}i |*|) u?U|L?tc @|i4@|U@* 5LU@* 5Ui?Uitc Sc fD . L? i4@??c a : Lh}i?t|ih? Ebee G AiLh) Lu }@4it @?_ iUL?L4U Mi@Lhc h?Ui|L? N?iht|) hitt vL?}c O EbHD E,_ G Lt| @**LU@|L?c Lh|OL**@?_
2S
