Problem solving in biochemistry - asbmb

0 downloads 0 Views 7MB Size Report
Apr 23, 2013 - American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (2012) Degree certification program, ... ASBMB Core Concept ... Connections.
PROBLEM SOLVING IN BIOCHEMISTRY:! ASSESSMENT, LEARNING STRATEGIES, AND PRECONCEPTIONS!

*+,-&.$%'/$

!"#$%&'()&$

!"&$(0)&$

Cheryl A. Sensibaugh! University of New Mexico! April 23, 2013!

PROBLEM SOLVING IN BIOCHEMISTRY:! ASSESSMENT, LEARNING STRATEGIES, AND PRECONCEPTIONS!

OBJECTIVES:! 1.  Summarize a DBER dissertation.! 2.  Identify its implications for the community.!

STEM DISCIPLINE-BASED EDUCATION RESEARCH (DBER)!

g of hin ce ac ien Te Sc g & nin ar Le

Le a in rnin th g & eD T isc eac ipl hin ine g

Discipline-Based Education Research

DBER

Expert! Novice!

cs a ti em g th n Ma eeri gin gy En olo n ch Te ics e ys c Ph ien c os Ge istry em Ch y g y olo istr Bi m he y oc Bi nom tro

As

STEM Discipline

Adapted from National Research Council (2012) Discipline-Based Education Research, National Academies Press, Washington, D.C.!

COLLECTIVE VISION FOR CHANGE! V&C Core Competency! Apply the process of science!

Discovery requires:! •  objective measurement! •  quantitative analysis! •  clear communication!

g of hin ce ac ien Te Sc g & nin ar Le

ASBMB Core Concept!

Le a in rnin th g & eD T isc eac ipl hin ine g

Discipline-Based Education Research

DBER

Expert! Novice!

cs a ti em g th n Ma eeri gin gy En olo n ch Te ics e ys c Ph ien c os Ge istry em Ch y g y olo istr Bi m he y oc Bi nom tro

As

STEM Discipline

American Association for the Advancement of Science (2011) Vision and change in undergraduate biology education, http://www.visionandchange.org/.! American Society for Biochemistry and Molecular Biology (2012) Degree certification program, http://www.asbmb.org/accreditation/.!

DEFINING SCIENTIFIC PROBLEM SOLVING! *+,-&.$%'/$

!"#$%&'()&$

!"&$(0)&$

W.L. Anderson, C.A. Sensibaugh, M.P. Osgood, S.M. Mitchell (2011) Int. J. So. Teaching and Learning, 5(1).!

INDIVIDUAL PROBLEM SOLVING ASSESSMENT (IPSA)! •  Electronic, computer-based! •  Progressive reveal format! •  1 Short essay per domain! •  45-75 minutes total! Scoring rubrics!

+,-.

W.L. Anderson, C.A. Sensibaugh, M.P. Osgood, S.M. Mitchell (2011) Int. J. So. Teaching and Learning, 5(1).!

"! * ) ( ' & % $ # " !

@.A=.B3

"! * ) ( ' & % $ # " !

783.:?;3.

"! * ) ( ' & % $ # " !

;3.

"! * ) ( ' & % $ # " !

789.53,:;3.

/01234.5,6.

"! * ) ( ' & % $ # " !

Exemplary! Satisfactory! Unsatisfactory!

DIVERSE DBER PERSPECTIVES! IPSA!

CAT!

CLASS-Bio!

!"#$%&'( )#%*+,-

  

Learning Attitudes about Science

./0#12&3+4&

   

Real World Connection

5,*&31+-61&

  

Enjoyment

7*6%861&

   

Conceptual Connections

5,1&-"61&

  

Problem Solving Reasoning Synthesis & Application ● Strategies ● Effort ●

9&:&;1

W.L. Anderson, C.A. Sensibaugh, M.P. Osgood, S.M. Mitchell (2011) Int. J. So. Teaching and Learning, 5(1).! B. Stein, A. Haynes, M. Redding (2007) Proceedings of the National STEM Assessment Conference, 290- 299.! K. Semsar, J.K. Knight, G. Birol, M.K. Smith (2011) CBE – Life Sciences Education 10: 268-278.!



DIVERSE DBER PERSPECTIVES! IPSA!

CAT!

CLASS-Bio!

!"#$%&'( )#%*+,-

  

Learning Attitudes about Science

./0#12&3+4&

   

Real World Connection

5,*&31+-61&

  

Enjoyment

7*6%861&

   

Conceptual Connections

5,1&-"61&

  

Problem Solving Reasoning Synthesis & Application ● Strategies ● Effort ●

9&:&;1

W.L. Anderson, C.A. Sensibaugh, M.P. Osgood, S.M. Mitchell (2011) Int. J. So. Teaching and Learning, 5(1).! B. Stein, A. Haynes, M. Redding (2007) Proceedings of the National STEM Assessment Conference, 290- 299.! K. Semsar, J.K. Knight, G. Birol, M.K. Smith (2011) CBE – Life Sciences Education 10: 268-278.!



DIVERSE DBER PERSPECTIVES! IPSA!

CAT!

CLASS-Bio!

!"#$%&'( )#%*+,-

  

Learning Attitudes about Science

./0#12&3+4&

   

Real World Connection

5,*&31+-61&

  

Enjoyment

7*6%861&

   

Conceptual Connections

5,1&-"61&

  

Problem Solving Reasoning Synthesis & Application ● Strategies ● Effort ●

9&:&;1

W.L. Anderson, C.A. Sensibaugh, M.P. Osgood, S.M. Mitchell (2011) Int. J. So. Teaching and Learning, 5(1).! B. Stein, A. Haynes, M. Redding (2007) Proceedings of the National STEM Assessment Conference, 290- 299.! K. Semsar, J.K. Knight, G. Birol, M.K. Smith (2011) CBE – Life Sciences Education 10: 268-278.!



A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

A DBER DISSERTATION!

'( ! !/ !+      

,

-%

+

+

,

-%

.

 

  # &4+

 

 

01

  

 

2-1

,  56

LONGITUDINAL IPSA PERFORMANCE! .6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . -

.6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . -

!"#

%$&'()*'

&'()*''

!"#

%$!+,#

&'()*'

&'()*''

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#,

7$89$:;;:#, .6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . -

!D:EF:#>

'"D>B#,9:#>

?%@8#A>B,C>

.6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . -

!"#

%$&'()*'

&'()*''

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#, J*K*.1

&'()*'

&'()*''

42#A*@>$"#,E> 2-#A*@>$"#,E> /2#A*@>$"#,E> I,",;F;*B !"#

%$&'()*'

&'()*''

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#,

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#,

I:+,;F;*B

G>HE>B#,9:#>

?%@8#A>B,C>

.6 5 4 3 2 1 0 / . -

!"#

%$&'()*'

&'()*''

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#, J*K*.1

&'()*'

&'()*''

42#A*@>$"#,E> 2-#A*@>$"#,E> /2#A*@>$"#,E> I,",;F;*B !"#

%$&'()*'

&'()*''

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#,

!+,#

7$89$:;;:#,

I:+,;F;*B

G>HE>