Delay-Reliability Tradeoffs in Wireless Networked Control Systems ...

1 downloads 0 Views 403KB Size Report
of both end-to-end (e2e) delay and loss rate when the channel reception prob- ... regulating ability in that the node effective transmit probability depends only.
 "! #%$ !&! '()+*,-./10,/#23/5467!8&9:! ; =@?ABCD=FEG;HCJILKL¥8û! ¦œ5à § ôP«¢û ¦Óú ô  ô  Ö œ5à#" ÊÑõv¹öPKL§‡®Pó«-B@ÇPN© >­ Ò©¡/ׯœQÇ =PCDB6žKfDB¥ K-B“E¤œ^Bk›žIf±JB¸)CD®W¡LB­F¡©¡³D›¡LKL¥ ®ÃÇP¤ M£-±wV]leSfq

pr=0.75

20

7

r V@sRTSc·Vhs/[ShV]lq

8

9

FK; FQ!VLSS@OITEÚCB€ED±Ú

20

·þ¸ /º,» ¸ x ºp ¸

0.1

p =0.8 r

pr=0.7

p =0.75 r

p =0.7 r

0 1

0.04 0.02

r "Is&R)Sc·Vs-okVX\g>V]leSfq 2

3

4

5 node i

xzy2{L|d}7|w$ˆulSgd[UWVefYT_`¼ ¾ g·]¦Y,uQS · tUuWVqZS÷$3R  º c ¸ : ¿ b A@

15

(i)

variance

40

6

r e]sg¼vu

10 D

0.08

60

10 5 node i

5

0.06

20

4

0 1

20

pr=0.75

80

30

3

15

pr=0.8

100

pr=0.7

2

10 D

120

pr=0.8

40

5

gd]¦Y,ulS · ÈUuWVqZSš$3R ã ~Æ]QSfY*)&_X,+%)¢grY,u

60 50

0.2

0 1

20

r V@sRTSc·Vhs/[ShV]lq

0.4

pL

5

0.6

200

20

xzy2{L| w4|w$ˆulSAgd[UWVeLYT_`ec Á º‡¼ g ¸Ã¿À Á

mean

1 0.8

p

variance

mean

40

0 1

{

250

50

0 1

:

6

7

8

9

0 1

ã ~5]QSfY*)&_X,+()¢gdY,u

2

r e]sg¼yux{z=| 3

4 5 node i

6

7

8

· ¸ /º» ¸ x º, ¸

¸)¸®PÌAV]leSfq D

50

0 1

10

r e]sg¼vu 20

D

30

40

50

xzy2{L|}hL|$ˆulS8gd[UWVefY+_`mcgd]Y,ulS8~´µTæ)~“]QSfY*)&_X,+°)¢grY,u ·a¸ /º,» ¸ x º, ¸ÃÁ º‡¼#g ¸Ã¿ À Á

R)Sc·Vs !nScdg·V#"Qgdc·grYts%$FXVkåQSf_#&Pq¶g·]('ËgrX\ScdSqZqTunSfY*)&_X,+pSå.-&_k]^YZX\_c}^sQqÑY\Sf[q 70

30

p =.8 r

pr=.75 pr=.7

0 1

3

4

5 node i

6

7

r V@sRTSc·Vhs/[ShV]lq

8

9

0.1

40 0.05

20

2

pr=.7

60

20 10

pr=.75

0.15

(i)

variance

40

0.2

pr=.8

80

pL

50 mean

100

pr=.8 pr=.75 pr=.7

60

² :

0 1

r "Is&R)Sc·Vs-okVX\g>V]leSfq 2

3

4

5 node i

6

7

8

9

0 1

2

r e]sg¼yux{z=| 3

4 5 node i

6

7

8

xzy2{L|L}I}C|$ˆulS&g·[UlVefY_`Y¼ ¾ gd]AY,uQS3~°´gµTæ)~]QSfY*)&_X,+5)¢grY,u ·a¸ / º,» ¸ xºp à ¸ Á ºc ¸ : ¿ FK½Ò V ÃՈRWf…!‰@VL„ b ƒ‚ y„

LKÊZÇ =Ÿ®PBB¦IKf¹º®PœQÎILB ×3¥¦¹ºÒ©­PCJN M=  >£ŸžÎ B¢ILOl=PBCJ >BBB ILK\@›n=PBBVqZgd]lY\j#gd_ul¢] SZW]Qunj¶_´Fopg St ¶[ vÂ"¤~n¿#SLXh¿ ]WvJåJuTX\ SSh)ªV[«T©Ó_k_c·,X åQ+#qZZ [grY,u r â /@sF'ËgrX\ScdSqZqÝ-&_k[[ t ]Qg·eVY\gd_k]($ XVåQS_&Pq d g

] ) R d g Ñ q Z Y \ X :g " t Y\Sh.å -&_]^YZX\_kc†vWwt¢] ”DwÑa8aÓ a -&_k]D`°Sf¿#X\¿ S]QeS_k] RTSegdqZgd_k]¦V]W3å -&_]JYZX\_—c Z j ´ g t vþ~¶]WåJX\Sh¬V «T_c>åDqZ[gr,Y u r â Yx sv'"gdX\Sfc·SfqZq ã SåQg t [ ~¶eeSqZ÷q -&_]JYZX\_c : ¿ Zäng>V]l#j ulS]Q. d g

] n u f S *)&_X,+pShå%-&_k]^YZX\_kc+}JsDqÑY\S[qvDwt]¢”DwÑa8aÓaŸ¿@¿ ~n[SfX\gdehV]3-&_]JYZX\_c0-&_]Q`°SLX\S]leSZ Y j ´Fg t v(~¶]WåDX\S›V «T_c·åQqZ[gr,Y u r â @{ sv-ÓX\_kqZlq Èc·Vs^SfXR)SfqZg·j]G_`3R)gdqÑYZX\:g " t Y\Shå :: Zäng>V]l#j ulS]Q% -&_]JYZX\_c¤_opSfFX 'ËgrX\ScdSqZquTSfY )3_,X +D“q ZJ}JsDqÑY\S[¿@q8¿ V]lå -&_]^YZX\_k—c ”ž‘l_ t ]WåQVY\gd_k]Qq3V]lå~nUQUlcdBg  ehVY\gd_k]lqv r aÓåvZI$ Z–a3Vq\VX8sLv#aÓgdX,+ ulV t qZSLXZ r wŽ] rbX\~ SfqZZyqps } ul@_ +^X\_c·c·V ulg†vŤR Z[~ Z}DUQgdScd[V] :hâ Z ã Z­«ZE´ t "^s^v ã Z ã gr*Y ¥S]Q[Vpe ulSfXhv ã Z[ r â ¿@¿ : s¶`a ¡egdS]^YnaiXVq t X\šS -&_XZX\SefY\gd]l(j -&_JåDSqvWwt¢] ”DwÑa8a8 a $ XV]lq\VeLY\g·_]lq¶_k]/wŽ]Q`M_X\[]V  \ Y d g k _ .$ˆulS_XZsiZ–Ž8_kc—Z/xf²h”¤{z ˜ { Á xžZ ] S -&_]JYZX\_ci}^sQqÑY\Sf[wq )¢gr,Y u R)Sc·VsD“q Z#ru¢Z ÇR $ˆulSfqZg·qv ´ t ]lå : /žZŒmZluTgdcdqZqZ_k] r : K Á s[nShVBc *$3gd[š t w l ] Ñ q \ Y r g Y t Y\S)_` $+Spe ul]Q_kcd_kjis Z : xmZR¤ZriVX,+PvnæZ «ZrSfXZX\_q r : K â si~nUlUDX\_šQgd[VY\S3~n]lVcrsDqZgdqi_`¤R)gdqZefX\SLY\S ºY\g·[Sˆ$V]låQS[ § t S t Sgd]QjA]QSf*Y )&_,X +Jˆ q )¢gr,Y u3- t qÑY\_[SfzX ´F_kqZ“q ZQwŽ¢] ”JwŽaÓa8®a «5´gµa3Ša -[µ 㠖v Ž8_k—c Z/ž” : { ¿ / [ "¤SfX Z ˜–: { ¿ ²Jv¤RTSeS÷ : {hZæ[ZHrSLXZX\_kqvH©Z°uQSS r : K Á s~¶]“~¶UlUDX\_&šDgd[VY\SA~n]lVcrsDqZgdq_`¢~n]£µTU¤S]£$V]låQS[ § t S t Sgd]Qj7unSf*Y )&_,X +£)¢gr,Y u®r_kU t c·VY\gd_k ] -&_k]QqÑYZXVgd]^YV]lå -&_k]lqÑYV]^Y-}DSfX\oJgdeS $3gd[S“q Z t w ] ¢ ”DwZwÑe a $ XV]Qq\VefY\gd_k]QqYv Ž8_k—c Z3/ ¿ ”–Y²/ ˜ @²JLv µTefY\@_ "¤SfX Z : zžZvZ¶Zr8gdcdc·Vg r â ¿#¿ : sLv2~ R)gdqÑYZX\g:" t Y\Så µTopSfX\cd_kVkå¹-&_]JYZX\_c ~¶c·j_X\grY,ul[ `M_XŸR)Sc·Vs  a&_ t ]låQSh å -3Vc·c }JSfY t U ZpwŽ] ”pwŽaÓa8Oa ¯Ý~ - ã $ XV]Qq\VefY\gd_]lq3_]-unSf*Y )&_,X +Jgd]ljDhv ŽÓ_°c Zh” ² Á@¿ ˜ ² Á DvlR)SeSf¶[ "¤SfX Z : ²hZš-ZF}DV]^Y\gdokV]lS“¥V]Wå wZP}JYVho^XV#+V#+Jgdq r : KYsn}JY t åDs/_`pŽ&VX\gd_ t q°$3R ã ~5}Je8uQS[Sq`°_X 'ËgrX\ScdSqZq+uTSfY )3_,X +Jq g·]),Y uQOS riX\SqZS]QeS8_`QR)ShVkåDcdg·]QSqV]W¨å µTopSL,X ulShVå Zwt¢] ”hwŽaÓa8±a Œk_ t X\]WVc _]6}DScdSeLY\Shå2~¢X\ShVq¢gd>] -&_k[[ t ]Qg·eVY\gd_k]Qqmv Ž8_k—c Z : ²1” :â Á x ˜Y: / ¿ xDyv Œ t cris Z : Á Z~ZžaZma&SuQX\_^_¥gB$+_^_kqZg†vZ [Z nV_ r :  â s&RTSc·Vhs-mnUlU¤SfXea&_ t ]WåQq3`M_X¶V‘g·]QgrY\S)mTqZSfX nV[ t ]l]låQgdeh_kV¬[ Y\gdt_k~¶]le“q eZmSŽ8qZq¢_k—c }^Z2sDxqÑY\S”¤[ {  )¢˜ {gr,Y u¬zDv a ã t X\VqÑX\YŽ8e s2u~¶Z XZX\gdokVcd“q Zlwt¢] ”DwÑa8aÓea $ XV]Qq\VefY\gd_]lq¶_k>] -&_¬[  ¿ : žZŸ Z4Z7$ X\gdopShåDg r â ¿@¿ : sriX\_@"WV"lgdcdgrYŽsGV]låG}^YVY\gdqÑY\gdeq5)¢grY,u£¶Scdg·V#"lgdcdgrYŽs^v¢§ t S t Sgd]Qj2V]Wå â ¿ Z `M-&ã __X ZQ[äTã%U gdt St crY\Y\VSLg:]WulXnå _k}DU(eã gd'ËSZD]QæTgreX\SVScdS~nS]QqZUQjkqTjkUlung cdgdSfehr âY*V)&¿#Y\gd¿ __k#{ X,]QsL+J“q vWq“ZZQR)'"wÑSa8c·g·VaÓcdSf›s aHs^r–v «5ŒkSf#_XZ´g`°ul_µ]¦X\a3[VaŠ]WV]Q-[å eµ }JS_kãC_]Q`i² “q RTZl{hwÑ:gZ &Pm} a&SLX\u S]^¿Y fx ã ² : Ý~ /#-Å/@/x}J:8e uQ²iZS[Sq âi: Z©V]WZUPå ©&-V]Q} j¼ã [~ V]WZF¯å wt¢] $ ”PwÑZ Ža8#} a8Z ¯a rWZ $ © XVt ]l[ q\Vefr Y\â gd¿@_k¿]l/Yqs _R)±] S-&c·V_ksÅ[R)[ gdt qÑ]QYZX\g·ge" Vt Y\gdY\_kgd¿ _k]Q]Qqq¦vv ŽÓ__`-°c ZŸ}Jcd_{ YZ: Y\” Shå: xp~ z ´g˜–µT: æT@{ ²J~ v Á Á n u  _ k o  S ¶"¤SfXZ [ ââ Z c·ã VzX Z™P-&__k*X [¥gW[ Vt ]W]lå©gdehv} VZKY\r g·_t ]lU¤“q _kZ^cdwtgd¢]] ”Jr wŽ: aÓa8fx a sb$ }JXc·_VYZ]QY\q\ShVå|efY\°~ gd_k´g]QµTqæ)_k]~Ž8`°_S X8ulæTgde tgd@j c>uV[Xl-3$+VSfUW8e VuQe]lgr_kYŽs cd_ŽÓjs^_hv g·efŽ8ÝS _k-&—c Z|Scd@x c t /ž Z ” : :K:˜Y: âh: v un_opS[¶"¤SLXZ ¿

¿

â ¿ ã gd] äTgdSV]Wå ã VXZY\gd] æ)VS]ljjkg â /žZ ã-&_gdep[ul[ ScdS£t Q] ™¤gdeh_VX*Y\¥gdg _k]Qr âq¿#v&¿ wtâ]¢s”ÓRwÑa8VaÓYVaï´ $ gd]XV+>]Qriq\VVefepY\+pgd_SfY]lq2RT_X\]9_UlŽ8UQg·S]Qulj gde tã c>V_JXåDS$+cdqSep`Mul_]lX_'Ëcd_kjgrX\siSZPcdSŽ8qZ_kq(c—Z´´ _^{eV: cv un_mZ xDvYŒ t rc sv”² : ¿ ˜ ² : žZ

Suggest Documents