Exploring Variable Partitioning for Dual Data ... - Semantic Scholar

Exploring Variable Partitioning for Dual Data-Memory Bank Processors Qingfeng Zhuge

Bin Xiao

Edwin H.-M. Sha

Department of Computer Science University of Texas at Dallas Richardson, Texas 75083

Department of Computer Science University of Texas at Dallas Richardson, Texas 75083

Department of Computer Science University of Texas at Dallas Richardson, Texas 75083

[email protected]

[email protected]

[email protected]

ABSTRACT 
   !"
$#%&'(

)*+) )-,.0/))1!12 #432 5,+!6 /)7) #48 :9 ;POQ=LE  G =RS6#%31BC)/D # G (
('.
E)KUVW 2"X P4#J  %6)=/27rA2Is ,+#%)0 C)
J 2 =L7/)Z  #%,  G ))0 :/D2 =.
%S%) 3 2P
#%3M 2 G  #H%A#%.),+) ) /)t3, 2PF G  #4%', #J #%"#% 3 >

1. ? =X tLSINTRODUCTION )%+=LM[ 2 A2#%32 5,+F6 /)V) #4'[:9 ;

, ,%#%/= #%" [=£0
#J(Z #%/ *=J  #%$,.0/))#%3.RALM2#%%

23 LM#% 3W3", vxw yxz+{K|~})€and ‚„ƒN…)Subject )€ {7…M†* ‡Descriptors ˆ‰‹ŠHŒgˆ=ŠHz+‰NŽ;‹!6 /) K 2
',+  #44J72#%3"2 *,+DF6/)>_rA2#%P/2#J

)/ 
. != 
.V#% G *  / # G EFS2#%3"2. 5,+F6/ 9.Z )]‘^’“=kgih dFjnE”imo0jd•–iD—˜ u >%™"> vPw š z„›"€.…=…)zVœI= = #4,,%#%/= #4)>V?](F/ =RC60(:9.;¬"
. #%))R+
/D2 ›žŠ!)€.›"=} €0Ž[;~ %%)EUM/D2 #% / 
))˜ u > ŸYw yxzC{W|~})€ °J )RC=£0
#J: 2x/)" G %
#%"W@ ]LS(  I ‚„ƒN…))€ {7…M†* ‡ˆ‰‹ŠHŒgˆ=ŠHz+‰NŽt9.,+)/#HJ ];
,+S'U,,%#%/= #4 )' ®‹A?¯± M  P  ")+,+ #%N>t;0/)ELM#J 2&.
+[  A)19.Z )]‘^—d%nj+b"h0lcZ“=mDiD——dFj0nI—¡—”iD’*— 7 */=¬/D2 #% G I2#%3"2 [)7.LM#4. 2Y!

2#%E#%$@, ,%#%/= #%"„> General Terms ;‹F6 /)"R+U%3"#J 2 &R¢~s.,+#%)0  #%" ² ~6=³Z‹, %)§#%)NF, 0/)LM#J 2:
)[ 8#%62=L´ Y6,8 2_ = G #4 %)I K ]LA )(', , , #4 )J1 (
P 2 *2#%327) .LM#4 2/=,/)#J ]6DT/)#%)0 J0>®As ,%"R"F' ].,. #%/=N)$",+ #4_
/2& µ¶·¹¸º»g¼‹½1º¾¿½1ºÀ"À Á'?5 =X Q" G #4
 2

2 #4Z  )3PLM#4%.)
J @#%Q,+!6 /)M%")R0#%/M 2  ,+ )0 #H#%Z 
/ #%". % G )N,4%)%#% #% VDs , %"#J =„> u =£0
 J0R G #4 %,  #% #%#%3* /D2 #4£0
Q, 4=.E #%,+ 0 x%$#%7 2 #4P/2#J )/D 
">W S
. : 2"X x%#%  % ))/2(LA6 2 M2M+))( " Q *Z 
. 2  )% $,.",+ #%) 2 G #4 %x, #J #%" #4 3[, %)&> U G #4 %@, #J #%" #4 3E )/D2 #4£0
‹!~.
")Q :9.;@E2E+)& /#%+=(#%7w Ÿ>trA2Q, " %)¹#%A Z !=à p8, #J #%"^, %) &dFj”iDc
iDciDj+miKncZbDl o  ? Ew v~w ©  > Q.)tC#% DF) /)3, 2*),.))0 G #J %)#%& 2x, 3&>V 2 x3, 2W) 3"'x
=( 6 )/  2 *,+  #4t,%%)%#% + ]LS)) G  #H%))>[rA2

 A/)/))x #%):E ]LS G  #4%)x(?5 =X :/)4#4)K 2 x 2 [+)Z

, #J #%"#% 3K#%[/D2 #% G =YLM2Y 26  ALS)#%3"20 [V 2  =.3")P+ ]LS))< ]LSK, #J #%" *#%[6s.#%6\>KrA2I,  %)´~ 2 #%V 2 $#%M 2  2'#%.F6 #%"_#%&#%0 F ) /)(3, 2¦#% ", 2#%Z #%/= =8)
328 W G =M 2  ,+ )0 #HN,4%)%#%´s.#%Z E#4I 2V, "3&>t®Ms [ , 4R+#% DF) /)x3, 2_/=1J&+x, ,%#%=( 1kdFcim”ik bgm¡"m)h dm$ncbDl.o  QU D>@? 6.0)6 6/)" #H.6 2&#%0  #J  #4I :.),+).)/#4t#%[ 2M,."3&>rA2M 2 ,."%)¹#% DF) /):3,2_#% 2 #J V 0) V#4.)

#J!x 2AF/ @ 2 SE,+ )0 #4 , %%)%#4 C /)/)))tA/ 
%JP#%,+#4 %A Q+A#%,%) )#4* /2=.
%">t9*(,, , #4 Q, #%#J ]6D #4/=6 x+ /2)K 6\ G :"[,%%)@)&/)/)'=£0
)Z  #% G #4 %', #J #%" #%3 > q7S, )0 V L`3,2x )g! G #4 4S, #J #%" #%3 ,."%)&>QqYxx#J :PabcDd\bgf)h4i*dFj+k0il iDjk0iDj+miPncbDl o0> rA2 #4$3,2p )/ $% 2_,+ )0 #H%%p,%4')[ (/)/)))( 2 M6)$/D 
%J$0/)/)
#%(/2)
%#%3.>@?

4x3"# G S', #%#% [ #%/EFE.#%BCD)0 t#%[„,%4 /)/))I 6C>¬rA2&3,2¬#%/)" Z 
/ =`! kgb”5b  “ ÃncbDl.o&E 2[,."3&>(9.$#% x#%P%[ _.=LM#J 2

2 '  =L§3,2(LM#J 2(/D /4Q(.)4) )>?5 V#%A  /) G  2V#% F6 #%"$~,+ )0 #4C, %%)%#4 E,  /)#%)J*,+"#% 4M+!A 2 E/ 
./D2 =
%#4 3QZ   )>@U  L G #4 4*, #J #%" #%3&%3"#J 2  WK%3#J 2 !'3,21/)Z 
/ #%"W*%(,.))0 =„>QrA2xs.,+ #%)0 [)
J "p G  #% ]`°J 6,, 4#%/= #%"I2=L

2 :/)Z 0 x#%,  G ) Q6/D2 #4 G =K7/2=.
% %) 3 2)> rA2 'Z 
/ 
.'~ 2#%M,,+#%V!"%%=LM)>9.)/D #41­*#%

.
/)) G #4%A,  #J #4[, %)&>‹9.)/D #4[Ÿ, ))0  ^#%/D))0 :.° #% #%^"
._3,2 .)\> rA2 43#J 2!x3,2K )~/)Z 
/ #%"Y G  #H% , #J #%"#% 3S#4%%
Z  =*#%*9.)/ #%*v >9.)/ #%[©M/)"[ ,)~ 2ts.,+#%)0 ‹)
% [ #JBC 3, 2* 4)R &4$ #%/)
=( 2D #4#% 3BC)/ V" G #4%P,

#J #%" #4 3 >tUVI°%J0R./)" /)%
#%" Q '3"# G )(#4&9.)/D #4 ª>

2. ®@QPROBLEM , 0/)t=£0
#%,DESCRIPTION ,+):LM#J 2[P
J #%,%EU„¤Q~x*
J

#%,%:)(.
%))R 2  G #4%*, #J #%"1, %) #%S x6,6 2 G  #4%)E~:, 3 [ #JBC S)[ ¬.
%))RM7 2 =RM)`",+ #%"$//))6 2 .#%BCD)0 )`.
%)/=¦+&,.)/)=.=¬#%p,% %)\>@? E#%E G #%"
A 2 E", #J #%"I)
J %%=L§ ,%%)0)/)/)) M+t#%,%) )Q#%x/2)
J #%3.>@UV$#J 6=62 )%,&*/2)
%E *, 
/):*2   /2=.
%">  ­0>%™"> “cSbV’P– h ”\d l+h4i@’6iD’[“c¡V’[“=k–.h%bcAbce m od!”im”\–ci"!$# bcDd\bgf)h4i&%Mbc”\dF”\d“j dFjn'%Ac“gf)h4iD’ dF—I”5“&l.bc”\d\e ”\d“j[”!oiMabcDdb"f)h4iD—SdFj ”5“xkdF—)(=“dFj ”„—iD”\—*!+ dF”!oxciD—l im””5“'’P–.hJe ”\d lh4i$’6iD’“cD¡K’“=k–.h4iD—-,/.+“7”!o.b”PabcDdb"f)h4iD—$dFjÃkd 0ViDciDj” ’iD’“c¡$’[“=k–.h4iD—Pmbj@rA2 2 6s.#%Z =R 2 /2/))A 2 /=&+Q ")(#%&/2=.
%#%3.> %Mbc7 ” :+“_’3b 2d!’*)d ? i6”!o i6cib"h @d ? b"f)h4ixl.bcbhFh4ih dF—’
“cIb ndFaiDj6lcZ“ncb’A, rA2 Q,+  #4N,%%)%#%¹#%()",+ #%" Q  +A#%, 4)0 ='xV/D2 =
4D=>UVxA)",  #%"M6)I2 G ", ,+ 
#J #%) *+/D2 =
%= #% 2/)"0 „Z ,6 26 2 )>@rx6s.#%#%¥)E 2 =%#4¥)%P,%44#% !:3# G )1, "3&R+LSP )=&  /20$(,, , #4 I, #%#% AUI#% V2
4(+: =$ 2 M 2'#%,%)

 #4KE, %%)@)&/)/))P=1"7I/ #% G #4 %&,  #% #%p/=¦"J8+_. #%=`#%pY.= #J /= =:/D2 =
4D=>@9.QP,,.",.#H A3,2P )#% G  #%,+ 0 #4*,  G #H.#%3/))/ t#% F6 #%"[! G  #4% , #J #%"#% 3 >?]P 2Ms @)/ #%NR0LAELM#%% "V#%/ )0 V,,.g/2¦ q7LM#%%„%*,.))0 E43#J 2EN 2 '  # bcdbgf)h4i %Mbc”\dF”\d“j dFjn %EcZ“gf)h4iD’pFtQ
)'x/2#J )/


.">

3. ¨&0'DEFINITIONS =.#4E':9.;&, ,AND %#%/= #%PPROPERTIES ,."3/=:+@),.

0

))0 =&0(
:b”5b Sh%“ E cbDl.o  E >C?5 M )/D V 2  I.),+) ) /)#%)VS+ 21U„¤ ",+ #4Q_)[ $",+ #%"#%#4 '#J  #%"&V+D ]LA)&#J  #%)>

A B

B

(b) Interference Graph

4

     Ÿ.>%™>Q Ê xb”5b Sh%“ E cZbDl o
  E dF—Sb'kd\e cim”ik SiDd4n o0”ikxncZbDl o 

  ‹oiDci¹dF—Vb —iD”“
m“’Ql–.”5b”\d“jj+“=kgiD—t”!o b”„cilciD—iDj ”CÊ!#"(“Dl iDcb”\d“j— bj+k&’iD’“c¡_“Dl iDcZb”\d“j —$5h%“=bgk1“c*—”5“ci  !% d!—P”!oiIik=n0i —iD+” ‹odmok0i &@j+iD—A”!oi~lcimik0iDj+miVcih%b”\d“j—
c“’ j“=k0iD—EdFj #`”5“Ij+“=kgiD—xd!j #!' )( 'cilciD—)iDj ”\—*”!oiPj –’fiDc[“
k0ih%b¡—
“cbj(ik=n0i ( !* )( AcilciD—iDj”\—”!oiQm“’Ql–.”5b”\d“jI”\dF’6i“
b j+“=k0%i +!, )( VcilciD—iDj”\—”!oiabcdbgf)h4i'bgmmiD——)ikIf¡b*j“=k0i +7“jYik=n0i ( .-0/1+  ,

UV6=.3" ( !2  -I 3  +PLM#J 4 2  )( @.)4=.A)@ 2 S 2 )/ ",
 #4xU1= 3 LM#J 2"
. E.)4=P), )0 S, /)= /)M)4 #%"LM#J 2#%I #J  #%"„>U±Z  #%/x/D2 =
4:P
Z M"+D( 2',.)/)=.)/ )4 #%"  D°)YW 2I
 3,2@U6= 3Q) #%3P EMZ  #%3x! W, )
. 5.I, ))0 *W)8;~  #4/
4J0R-= 3K) #%3` _ rA2@'® ` #J)/D %2=LMN 2 @#% ,
G #4 4NF:U N¤ ",+ #%"N>pUV`#J =X 6=Z< K)( 2 )  S!(LS(3"K#% 1 2I3,28/)" Z 
/ #%¦. #%%)RSLS  °: # bcdbgf)h47i Cj+k0il iDjk0iDj+mi E cZbDl MŠ!‡+} @ € ?A yxzC{K|‹ˆ ŠF…)z+‰ zB:CD‰„€.DB5€€.‰‹›€FEI ˆ |~ž ˆ‰G6H
CIE6I?J

2'#%.),+) ) /)Q)4 #%2#%,1"3P 2 G #4 4! *3"# G ('®+P>      Ÿ.> ­0>QÊ # bcdbgf)h45 i Cjk0il iDj+k0iDjmi E cbDl o4 # C =E  dF—xbjK–.jkdFcim”ik9 SiDd4n o”ik6ncZbDl oKL MNOPQ ~o iDci  d!—[b(j“=k0i—iD”cilciD—iDj”\—abcdbgf)h4iD*— !R d!—[bj`ik)n0i—iD” ”!o b”VdFj+kd\mb”iD—[”!oiDci6dF—*j“Kk0il iDjk0iDj+mi(fiD” SiiDj¬”!o i6” t“ j+“=k0iD—&“
b`ik=n0i ( -'+"!xd ,F3i ,@!x”!o iDci1d!—Pl.“”iDj ”\db"[email protected]cb"hJe h4ih dF—’±fiD” SiiDj”!oiD’ ,=P )( tcilciD—iDj ”\—A”!oi
“cZmDiE“cEi 2”iDj” “
dFj+kgil iDj+k0iDjmDiPfDiD” SiiDj7”!o i:” t“6j“=k0iD—x“
ik=n0i ( -'+3,

®@ 2M/)4 #% [="6#%[F
 2 S °#J #%")R"LA)=*   °Q 2 Q  bgmmiD——'—iD”‹M!"%%=LM)Ž      Ÿ.> Ÿ> E dFaiDj1b3  E  6 SNO"! ”!oiÊMmmDiD——.+iD”M“
abcdbgf)h4iUT !'V;WWQ3  T "!dF—V”!oix—iD” “
’6iD’[“cD¡I“l iDcb”\d“jKj“=k0iD—'”!o b”Mb"mmiD——!T ,

Q=L-LA: ="$ [
#%4$
,$ 2V°Z G #%"( G #J  4(#4 ),+ /)&3, 2N>- t`#%0 
#J #%"„RE#J 2D&#%$ .(#%8 2 &/)/))6 'W)7",+ #4¦#%

, )/= )0 t * 2 A[,+ #%NR. 2)M ]LSP,  #%A2 G ,+ )0 #4+, %%)%#%&>A9' 22
4+ *#%.),+).)/Q=.3"'+ LA))$ 2)&> 

     Ÿ.> v.> :No& i td!cD—”xËE–.dFh%kYX # C E e 6 “c1bj¡ ” t“[kd 0ViDciDj ”~abcDd\bgf)h4iD—TOZMbj+kT[ !Nd
”!o iDci:i 2dF—”\—VbVl.bdFc “
—df)h d!jnj“=k0iD—
c“\ ’ VQWWQ3  T]Z Abj+k%V;WWQ3  TQ[ "! ”!oiDci:dF—'bj1dFjk0il iDj+kgiDj+mi[ik=n0i  T Z T [ 3,

®&8®  LM#J 2§/./)%)_Ã= 3Y H).)RQLS72.%

2K/=Y0-/)
.  #%3` 2Y=.3"7LM#J 2^ )4).)R:¬ Z F K'®+ LM#J 2¦/./)%)[ KKVU P>@rA2$s ,%$#4 ®‹#%3"
_™62  LMx 26.#%BCD)0 P/"Z 
/ #%" *&?0  F/)D  V,28`'  4V? V ™"> u ,)( [ 2:#% DF) /)x3, 2 !& 2 #4$s , 4RV 2 K#%0  5#J  #%"§.),+).)/#4(#% '®+^  A/)#4 )„R 2 G  #4%; V§±6)[+ 4%0/= =& * 2'')6.
%">trA2'+° M P
J #%,%)
4.LM#4. 2$#4ELAZ =C> rA2 _#40 
#% #%p#%¦ 2#%[°Z I
#%4¬:.)#4 Y#4.)

#J!P)P,+ #% 2 SE  S ),+  ~ Q=/2  2=>& S
x [%t 2#% ),+) )0 :,#JP G  #4%)  Y
!
'F G  #4%Y, #J #%" #4 3 > ¨()§/)/)) ,%%)%#% #%: G  
%JW#4, %))0 =1K(/2)
%=> OV LS G =R "'I//)))V6=6  G +:%  ,,+= S#%* 2 EE/) Z ),*#4[/D2 =
4>®
 2  "Rt 2 )&
)%)6= 3)6)YrWs./)%
.

2 )[2 [F
~= 3)'#%7 4Q? V ™RNLS[/)" #4 ' 2 *,+"Z #%#%%#J ]Y 2 x ]LSW,+ #%[6)K+I/2)
%=7 1 /)0 ".Z ),[#%[V!
 2 @
#%4P 2S3, 2[ >‹UV LSS=Q V#%0 
/) 2F"%%=LM#%3'.° #% #%xN’[“gfd\h dF”\¡ dFjkg “  ¨$/ q +F, 0/)= #%3x x 2 V/)" G D#4  4Q? P> Ÿ > ©> E dFaiDj_b3  E  6 NO "! :Noi W“gfd\h dF”\¡ IdFj+kg“ 7“
—D“’6itj“=k0i+[dFj  E !  +"! dF—$bK—iDcd5iD—(“
m“j”\cZ“"hE—”il—(—”5bc”\dFjn
cZ“’ ”!oi*l.“—dF”\d\“j “
+p—Dmoik–.h4ik%™"> : t“[“Dl iDcZb”\d“j&j“=k0iD—Qbcitl.“——df)h4iQ”5“ f iM—Dmoik–.h4ikx”5“'”!oiE—b’6iVm“j ”\c“"h.—”il(d
bjkP“jh ¡d
”!o iDdFc ’[“gfd\h dF”\¡ dFjkg“ —:“aiDcDh%bDl, rA2 #4*, ",+D ] 4V? V ]­Q3"# G )S  #%+#4.F6 #%"6F G #4 4V,  #%

#%" #%3 RC
Q[F
 2 %0&#%  4V? V ]­[2=LMV 2  

4 2 Q)*,+ #%E,#JE/)" )/ )606$#%  ,+) ) /)M= 3V2 G E 2M", ,+ 
 #J ]x x+#%,% )0 =W:,%%)A,+ #%x#4Y(/D2 =
%">(9."*

2 )´2 G x*
/2&+  DQ,,+ 
#J #%)Q 2_ 2 )>:9

2 2
46)³] I2 #432A, #%#J ]I#% G  #H%, #J #%" #%3.>‹qYE/)%/)
4  2 ,."#%%#J ]P„=/D2#%.),+) ) /) =.3""R"P6gt#J @, #%#J ]x #%/">‹rA2#%, #%#J :#4.F 6 #46/)", 4D )t 2 Q4Z E/"Z 
/ #%"I"
 4S #4% ? ,+).)/)7  V, 2N>

     Ÿ.> 0> :No i :NodFcZkMËM–d\h%kYX # C E eFËQiD—” “cEbj¡ ” t“§kd 0QiDciDj”Iabcdbgf)h4iD—KT Z bjk T [ !$d
”!oiDci¦i 2dF—”\—Yb l.bdFcP“
—d\f)h dFjnj+“=k0iD—-pbjk7+
c“’MVQWWQ3  TOZ *bjk VQWWQ3  T [ "!bjk !  -    +  !„”!oiDciVdF—Ebj dFj+kgil iDj+k0iDjmDiWik=n0i  TOZTQ[ $dFj # bcDd\bgf)h4i Cj+k0il iDjk0iDj+mi E cbl o ,B“cKiDaiDcD¡_l.bd!c1“
j+“=k0iDO — - bj+k +!*”!oiDci1dF—&b lc“"fb"fd\h dF”\¡:”!o b” -Wbjk +6’b¡xblgl ibcMdFj”!oi—Db’iVm“j”\cZ“"h —”iA l @d!”!odFj*”!o iDdFct’[“gfd\h dF”\¡ dFjkg “ -— ,SÊjkV”!oiMik=n0i AiDd%n o” P  T Z T [ dF—[”!oi—–.’ “
”!oixlc“gfbgfd\h d!”\d5iD—
“cIb"h!hNl.bdFc— “
—df)h dFjn[j+“=kgiD—x“
VQWWQ3  T]Z :bj7 k V;WWQ7  T[ 3,

rA2ADs,%S#%*®‹#43
EŸV2=LM‹ 2 #4 ),+ /)t= 3  V3 2 G 2#%32N, #%#J Q 2'= 3  V3WC  WD> 9. G #4%)U V  ))I [+:4%0/= =( .#%BCD)0

G  #4%P, #J #%" )>'qÃ2#%%P 2 P#%0 !)/*3,2W/=.  $,. G #4.& 2#%$#%.F6 #%"pF(, #J #%" #4 3 RVY
. ",. #46N, #J #%"(
J 6=6+',.
/)=„>  A)K"1 2P,  G #%"
' D°#J #%"W 4t#4 4*?].),+).  ) /) V,2NR.LA: % [ D°V 2 4t#4%:;~ #J

#%"_;~" 4 F6%%0>      Ÿ.>
> #bcDdb"f)h4i %bc”\dF”\d“j %EcZ“gf)h4iD’ d!—~”5“Sl.bce ”\dF”\d“j`”!oiabcdbgf)h4iD—dFj ”5“Kkd!—()“dFj”V—iD”\— !bj+k_”5“W’[bDl`”!oi —iD”\—Q”5“*”!oi’6iD’[“cD¡P’“=k–.h4iD-— ,—– mo$”!o b”@”!oiQ”5“”5b"h AiDd%n o” “
”!oiWik=n0iD—_“
b1ndFaiDj # bcdbgf)h4i Cj+kgil iDj+k0iDjmDi E cbl o ”!o b”MmcZ“——'”!oiPkd 0QiDciDj”AabcDdb"f)h4iMl.bc”\dF”\d“j —'dF—’[3b 2dF’b)h ,      Ÿ.> >QÊpabcdbgf)h4iNl.bcD”\dF”\d\“j[dF—@bV—iD”N“
j+“=k0iD— “
# bcdbgf)h4i Cj+k0il iDjk0iDj+mi E cbDl.o¦”!o.b”[bci1b"hFh%“=mb”ikY”5“ ”!oi:—Db’i:’iD’“c¡’“=k–.h4i3,

œ H‡zŠ!=ž~{ ? ;~0/)=.
-'4t#4 4-? ,+).)/) V, 2 u " Z 
/ #%  4Q?V ] t)Z

C‰|‹} A:U¦®   ~;~  #J #4#%3:[ 2 G #J  4#% ),+) ) /)*3, 27/=Y+*=.
/)=1 _¨& s u
.

, %)&>W?]< 2#%P)/ #%"„R@LS(,.))0 P LAW%3#J 2)> rA2x°Z '*#% 2 [%3#J 2 !:/)Z 
/ #%3$ G #J  46#%.),+) ) /)[3,2„>&rA2 )/)"7" #% G #4 % ,  #% #%743#J 2&>QqYP
: 2 Q 2 P%#%Z '/2=.
J #%37LM#J 2p%" 3")Z I, 2¦%) 3 2ÃIKLA)#%32 6!
/D #4p#%
=6 2 
3"2$ 2#%E,,+=>

C

11

7

D

B 18

17

B

G

15

3 D

A A

G 16

5

>MŠ!‡+}N€ '# A%$
>!E zB;C C'&)(* !)€YJ

21

22

œ !‡zŠ!)ž~{ $¬;~0/)=
._4S #H%_;~  #% #%#%3Y 
¨()$ A CD‰|~} A'U 4t#4 4(?].),+) ) /) V,2 L LM#J 2¦ G  #%/))  + N+ 7 +-<   N+ =7  †[})|‹} A4t#4 %P;~  #J 
#4 . 7V . < . 7  R .8< +.˜ ¯Q."J6)%)/ V*  "˜ UV#%3"[ 2 M E :Q J*)%)/D = . 7 .8grA2M'®+ÃLM#J 2/./)%)t )4).t#% Z !=1 &QU  0W =#4 3$ 2 = 3)'LM#% 2Y )4)0>6?

Z )Q 2$bgmmiD——*—iD”Y’“gfd\h d!”\¡ dFjkg“ rA2, #%#% NI#% ),+) ) /)M= 3V#%@ 2M
[ 6 #4KE4~ 2 *, %%)@, " #4%#J #%):t 2* ,+ #%" x 2 P//)): 2*,#JP G #4 %))>_9

2 Q,+  #4N,%%)%#%´
=6F G #4 %', #J #%" #%3 /=P  G ‹+S%"Z 
. 5)Z #%6 =C> ²
.~/)Z 
/D #4  4S #4%? ,+).)/)A  V,2K/=72 %/./)%):#%   : ),+ /)3,2NRLM2 #4% 2)V/./)%)S)
% A#46#% !6 #%&%"#4$?]0 !)/ V,2„> U43#J 2±­M
)‹3)=.:Z  )3' ,  #J #4x 2 S  )  2t#%,
. 4t#4 %A?] ),+) ) /) V,2P#% M ]LS.#4Z ³]"#%0 ‹ 8. 7  .8~rA2 @° Z ~.t#%~#43=' )#J 2 . 2 t  @ )>‹q7tJLE).~/D2 0"t 2 s ‹, #J #%" =   1$7  & 2 I/= I 2 _H 3")Z (= 3&LA)#%32

3"#%:+ LA))W ]LS(.[ )>[q7[/=YJLA=.: )W

#%'06/D2 0"#%3[."JI#4(0I/=> 5. DISCUSSION 5.1 ?1 2 #%Comparison )/ #%"„RNLS[2=L of0Graph _s.,+#%Models )0  2 G  #4%

C

3/4

F



œI|‹| FŠF›"ˆ =Š!z+‰‹… ? € { C E H0C E6'&P€.…) ??]¯§®‹#%% D ™ ™ ?$ #JBC)0 #4N¢t£0
 #%" ­™ ­0™ ?? UV%J ,+%°J  ­ ­  $ v 5Z 3   #%/)x®‹#%J  v"v ŸŸ $% ¢@%%#%, #%/=®‹#%% D Ÿg© Ÿ"© $ ˆ !:€ ?AP‚N›ž€ G‹} H€ … ‹ˆ…)€ G¬z‰\G‹Št€€.‰C{Kz G€ F… J



( !€. ( ! €.

YJ

,  #J #%"#% 3=$# bcDd\bgf)h4iCj+k0il iDjk0iDj+mi E cbl oE.) #%.)=*2 )%,t/D2 =
% ', 
/)2 S/2)
%"> q7'
6h dF—”A—Dmoik–.h dFjn'LM#J 21 2 '%"3)Z ', 2&%) 3 21 ,.#4#J ][!
/D #4N>@U* 2/2=.
%)E Q, .
/))6#%$ #%*
4 =W/2#J )/ 
.[LM#J 27 ]LS&U „¤ ,+ #%"7
#J  I LA[6)> rA2 Es.,+#%)0  E"6 G  #4D ]P+°J t,,%#%/=

#%" E

%J$
=6#4$:9 ;‹> ®M G °% DM, ,%#%/= #%"„R LS&
#44< ]LS 4t#4 4_, #J #%" #4 3KLM#%% ,.
/$.#JBC)0 P
J *! 2 I LA13,2` 4)> „#4Z Q/D2 =
%#4 3$#%
=& $,.
/)P/2)
%)V=W .#%BCD)0 ,  #J #4W
J )>xU /D2 =
4P, .
/)=&LM#J 2 
G #4%,  #J #4#%3P#%E%*2 =LM$ x+Q/),)

0

0

1 A

B

1 A

B

2

2 C

C A

3

3/2

B 1/5

2

A

3 1/5

2 4

A

D

C

C

4

C

C

1/5

5

A

1

B 2

1

1 D

5

6

6

8

8

D

D

7

7

B

B

>MŠ!‡+} €
!E ˆ‰'G H'ˆ Š!ˆ * H€ CD‰G€|€ ‰'G€.‰‹›"€ E  ˆ|~ž €*B5z €W €=Š\{KŠF‰‡'J I

>MŠ!‡+} €!E ˆ‰'G H'ˆŠ!ˆ ! € CD‰G€|€ ‰'G€.‰‹›"€ E  ˆ|~ž¬ˆ 5B )€I €=Š\{KŠF‰‡'J I

LM#J 2¦ 2_/2=.
%&%) 3 26LM#J 2 G #4 4_, #J #%" #4 3 > rA2'/2=.
%Q)
J Q '4#%Z =$#4&r‹ 4[™> rA2M°Z t/)"%
#4@ 2M/2=.
%M43 2M#J  #% LM#J 2"
. G #4 %K, #J #%"#% 3 >¹rA2 _#%)RQ% 2 G #J  4x³Z
Z #%3" =` 1 2II)Y
%"> rA26/2=.
%):#%Y 2#%P/"%
7 _ : g[ 2 6" G .

3KP2 #%3"2D()8.LM#4. 2p (%\> rA2 W  #%1 2 #%V  %P2  L^ 2 Q 2P/2=.
%)QPJLE).Q 2 %"3)Z P")>_rA26)/"K/)"%
7#4K 2#%' %),. )0 A 2/2)
%%) 3 2 E)$"$,  #% #%#%3*
J

? DF) /) V, 2N>trA2'Ds ,+D#4 E2 =L^ 2 M?].

FD)/)$  V, 2Ã/=  (2)%,p `#%,  G _ 21/2=
%%)3 27#%YZ :E
P, ,%#%/= #%" )>&rA2 *=" u ./)%)VLM#J 21. 4=.VH=£0
)0 J()&#%&606P
J #%= #4*('9 ; , ,%#%/= #%" )> ?]pW/)))RV 2_?]0 !) /) V,2 /=  M, #J #%"$ 2 G #4 %) V%\R#%/'%N 2  G #J  4*#%7 2,."3 6#%/)%
.=7#%^rA2#%6)
J $/)". ° 2 AT/#4/P+Ds , %"#J #%3Q 2 E
)  .LM#4 20
#% 3 4S #H%@?].),+) ) /) V, 2' ) #% G  #4%', #J #%"#% 3 >

 ) /) V,216)& )=& I+P/)Z 
/ =W! D #%[ %# 3 >~rA2M'® Ã 4t#4 %?.),+).)/ V, 2„ s , 4V+F' #%#4 3*#%M2=LM(#%_®‹#%3
:ª.>trA2 Q

#%#4 3:BC)/ S"6 2#%Ss ,%V#%A#%%%
Z  =$#%I®‹#%3"
> ®‹#%3"

I2 =LM 2P3g#%¥)=W#J  #%" :H ' #%[ #%3 >(? =X x#40 Z #4 3& _) 2 P#%Y 2 [ 2#J7#J  #%  #%#%3M%0 2Mh%“=bgk—„@,+"#%%S M+@s.)/)
)#4:, %%)S#JA 2  )
3"2K
*+DM_.
%))> rA2#%EDL   3"))0 M/ 
%%$#%/))M 2V,+ )0 #4 )/)/)V,%%)%#%&>

9

5.2 Retiming effect on Variable PartitionrA2~ ing #%#%3E )+ 2 t.)4)"'® *U  L 4t#4 4*?].),+).

9

6. rA2ICONCLUSION  $ A
/)/))Z!
E)P+=.=K,.0/))[s

G ,%'2 #%3"2DVI//)).LM#4. 2(6#%, 4)0  #%3`
V)8)> 9.&)= /D2ÃLA(2 G  +))_." x G  #4%x,  #% #%#%3.> S
V:2=LM

2 P#J */=rA2 3, 2 )

%%*
=[[ 2#%@, ". %) #%? DF) /)A  V,2„>'qYx2=L 2 Q 2D*#%#%[ ,+F/ #%"1#%& 2#%Q3,2_.)\>r /4: 2 G #4% ,  #% #%#%3V, " %) SBC)/D # G )J0RLSA, )0 V L 3,2*.)\Rg)J 4S #4%E? ,+).)/) V, 2NR"   )/D#4+I 2$,+ )0 #4E)xU_ 4S #4%P?].),+) ) /)  V,2  )t#%*#%/)0 %J

0

1 A

B 2 C

1 3

0

4 C

2 A

1 A

B 2

5

C 3

6

0

8 4

D

3

1 A

C

B 2

7

C B

A

5 3

9 6

4

8

C

D

4

7

A

5

B 9

6 8 D

5

7 B

>MŠ!‡+}N€  A &€.z‡ˆ‰‹Š!Œ"€ GWŠ!)€ ˆ)Š!z+‰‹…ˆ B)€V€=ŠF{7ŠF‰‡'J 7. wJ™:¨(REFERENCES  4.RC?] /">%R. %
Od4ndF”5b"h.d4njb"h E% cZ“=mDiD——D“c

b’*dFh ¡ Kbj –bh RN™ g©0> w ­ 'UV%"3 G #%/)))R ?] /">%RCÊU.%Me „™"™=­'™ ™"™=­v R U u ¨KR+­««.™"> w v:¨K>+Ux>.¯:>+9.32#J=R;‹> u 2=L'R+ u > P> N)"R Z¢~s , %"#J #%36
N  5)[ #%( #%3"#J  #43, 0/))R I#4D  %EcZ“=miikd!jn—P“
”!o i  ”!o Cj”iDcj+b”\d\“j+b"h @“j
iDciDj+mi*“j&ÊMm“–.—”\dm*— ! ."l iimo !Ebjk . d4nj+b h %Ac“=miD——dFjnR+, ,N>­Ÿv .­ vgŸRCU u ¨KR ™  ª.> w © 'Ux>9.
 ´(9C>¨&%#%CR 9#%*
J )
 F/)x%%0/= #41#4(/) '3) #%"(!Q
  P)6I#4, )R $ Ê = : cbj — ,,PiD-— , Ê–.”5“’ ,Mh4im”\c“j , .¡—” ,%R G >©R,,„>­ v0­ .­ªv RCU, => ­«"««.> w ª u >+¢E> „)#%"1  .>+ V>9  s  R ¯V #%#%3 Z  /D2." "
M/)#J/)
#J 0R 6ÊVh ng“cDd!”!o’*dmbR G >ª.R ,,N>© 0Ÿg©0R™ .™> w @> ®S> u 2 RUx>9C> ;~
3"2NR(¢E>Ox> ]¨K>9.2.R ]¯  #%_/D2 =
4#% 3 Ž@U %0",(,#%,+)%#%#%3 %3"#% 2 &R &C :cZbj—Dbgm”\d“j— “j @“’Vl–”iDceFÊdk0ik xiD—d4njK“
Cj”iDcncZb”i k ~dFcm–dF”\— bj+A k .¡—”iD’*—R G >„™=ªR, ,N>­"­  .­Ÿ RN¨&=>„™   > 

9