Space Efficient Algorithms for Distinct Elements in a ... - IBM Research


   "!$#&%')()#* +,- ./!012#)3$(45,6278! 9;:=?>@BAC?NOGIH;GQPRPS@

TUGIH7VRW XY:7:7W?Z[M2\

1] ^=_a`abcId[` eSfUgChjiakaifmlonIgpnqihorsf+t/uv/wyx8zlj{Ehjiig}|~[€phjrlj{Eƒ‚o„2ihjinEhjia‚…iaf†lji‡ˆlj€U‰‹ŠŒj[ŽSSg}nEnEhj€'rsgljilj{Jiƒfm‘E’qih €p“8‡'rs‚”ljrfEklia|iaƒiaf†lj‚•rf–g—‡Jgl˜gˆ‚”l…hjigp„,r™lj{–‡Er™š›ihjifml•‚…nIg}kiœljrƒi’q€}‘JfI‡'‚až–Ÿ?{EinIgpnqihgp|s‚…€Unq€}‚…i‡ €[nqiaf n'hj€[’E|siƒ‚gp’q€[‘'l¡‚…nIgpkai5|s€„2ih¡’q€}‘JfI‡'‚“¢€}hlj{Jr‚/n'hj€[’J|iaž?eRflj{Jr‚nIgpnqih/„2i‡'ia‚…khjr’qi8lj{Jia‚…iog}fJ‡‚…ia£¤ih˜gp|=€[|s‡Ei¥h gp|~[€}hjr™lj{Eƒ‚a¦¤nEhj€£mrs‡Ei?n'hj€†€}“¢‚7“¢€}h7lj{Ji?i'r‚”ljrfJ~¡‚…nJg}kai,|€„?ih7’q€}‘JfI‡'‚a¦†gpfI‡‡'€†ka‘Jƒifml=€[‘Eh gl…ljiaƒnElj‚gl7‚…€[|£mrsfE~¡lj{Ji €}nqiafˆnEhj€[’E|iaƒ‚ažyeRf§nIgh…ljrka‘J|sgph¦;‡'h˜ga„,rfJ~1“¢hj€}¨‚…ia£¤ih˜gp|*€}lj{Ji¥h8nIgpnqihj‚a¦›„?i•‚…‘E~[~[i‚”l8„,{m©ka€[ƒƒ€}f—gpnJn'hj€¤g}k˜{Ji‚ ‡'€fE€}l‚…iaiaªlj€©'ria|s‡n'hj€[~phjia‚…‚“¢€}hlj{Jr‚,nEhj€}’J|iaž « ¬*­®2¯±°§² ³"´/®±µ°­ *¶ ·p¸¹º»¹q¼†½p¾}¾p¾p½¹I¿À;·yÁÂ¥·}ÃJě·}ÅOÆ·¡Ç'ÈQ·pÉ¢·pʝ·}ÅE¸aÂ2ȋ˥ÇEÊÌÁěś͢Î'·}ËÂ¥·¡ÇmÈ;¥͢Ïp·¡ÐÒÑEÓ8ԛÍÕÆaÔÓ/·8Öq·pśÇ'¸¥·¡ÀI×ˆØ ÐˆÙ=ºLÚEÛE½p¾}¾p¾½¥ÐÜJÝ Þ…Å߸ԛ͢Â1àOÁmà;·pËÓ·ˆÓ8ÍáÉ¢ÉÀ;·ˆÍ¢ÅJ¸¥·}Ë¥·[Âj¸·}֖͢ÅâÆÇEěÅJ¸¥Í¢Å›ãU¸¥ÔO·§ÅIěÊ1À;·pËCÇmÈyÖqÍÕÂj¸ÍáÅQƸ·}Éá·}ʝ·pÅJ¸Âä7å+ÍáÅæ¹ç͢Ŗ¸¥Ô›·+Âj¸Ë¥·[Ámʝ͢śã ʝÇqÖq·pÉRݝޅÅÒà›ËaÁ'Ƹ¥ÍÕÆ·EÑÐ ÁmÅOÖÒèéÁ'Ë¥·ÇmÈ긷pÅçÉ¢Á'Ë¥ãE·CÁ'ÅOÖçÁmÉ¢ã'Ç'ËÍḥԛÊÂoÊ1ÄO˜¸ƒ·ëq·}ÆpÄq¸¥·ÃJěÍÕÆaìJÉ¢× ÄO¥͢śã"ÉáÍḘ¸Éá·Â¥àOÁ'Æp·'ݝí¡Ô›Í¢Â Ë·}˜¸¥Ë͢Ƹ¥Í¢Ç'ŧÇ'È긥·pňʝÁ'ì'·[·pëqÁEƸ¡ÁmÅOÖQî†Ç'Ë/Öq·¸·pËÊC͢śÍÕÂj¸Í¢ÆÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥÔOʝÂ,¸¥ÇIÇ1͢ś·pïÆpÍá·}ÅJ¸}ÑqÁ'ÂÍs¸8ÁmàOàQ·[ÁmËaÂ,¸Ç1À;·5¸ԛ·Æ}Á'Â¥·yȋÇEË ¸¥ÔO·Öq͢˜¸¥Í¢ÅOƸy·pÉ¢·pʝ·pÅJ¸Âyà›Ë¥ÇEÀ›É¢·pÊ"ݱí¡Ô›·pË·ȋÇEË¥·Ó·ÆpÇ'ÅOÂ¥ÍÕÖq·pË¡ËaÁmÅOÖqÇEʝÍáÏ}·}Öçðòñ[½¥ómô…õ”Á'à›à›ËǤëIÍ¢ÊÁ†¸ÍáÇEňÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥԛÊÂ}Ý ö±÷˜ö øúù5ùû˜ü¥ý=þ ÿ›ü
  Ç'ʝà›Ä›¸¥Í¢Å›ã縥ԛ·"ÅIěÊ1À;·p˝Ç'ÈÖqÍÕÂj¸ÍáÅQƸ·pÉ¢·pʝ·pÅJ¸a͢ÂCÎ'·}Ë¥×ßΆÁ'ÉáÄOÁ'À›É¢·ˆ¸Ç¸ԛ·U֛Á†¸aÁmÀOÁE˜·"ÆÇEÊCÊěśÍá¸j×'Ý  ·pË¥¸ÁmÍ¢ÅéÃJě·}Ë¥× Ç'à›¸¥Í¢ÊCÍ¢Ïp·}˝Æ}ÁmÅ ÄO˜·Uä å ¸¥ Ç OÅOÖ⸥ԛ·UÅIěÊÀQ·}˝ÇmÈoÄOś͢ÃJě·"ΆÁmɢě·[ÍáÅúÁ–Ö›Á†¸aÁmÀOÁE˜·—àQÇJ¥¥·}˜͢śã–Á–Æ·pË¥¸Á'ÍáÅ Á†¸¥¸¥ËÍáÀ›Ä›¸¥·'Ñ Ó8ÍḥԛÇEÄq¸ÔOÁ¤ÎI͢śã¸¥Ç1Â¥Ç'Ë¥¸,ÁmÉ¢Éq¸¥Ô›·5ΤÁ'ÉáÄO·}Â}Ý Þ…ÅJ¸¥·}Ë¥ÅO·¸ËÇ'Äq¸·pËaÂ?ÊÁ¤×Ó/Á'ÅJ¸±¸¥ÇƒãEÁm¸¥Ô›·}˱¸¥ÔO·yÅIěÊ1À;·pË,Ç'È=֛͢˜¸¥Í¢ÅOƸ/Öq·}˜¸¥Í¢ÅOÁ†¸ÍáÇEÅ Á'ÖOÖqË¥·[¥¥·}¡àQÁ'˜͢ś㝸¥ÔOË¥ÇEěã'Ô+¸¥ÔO·pÊ"ÑQÀOÄq¸oÆpÁ'ÅUÇ'śɢח¥·p·¸¥Ô›·1ÖOÁ†¸ÁÇEÅOÆ·ÁmÅOÖ+ÔOÁ¤ÎE·ƒÎ'·pËקɢÍáʝÍḥ·[ÖUʝ·pʝÇ'Ë×'Ý/ޅŠ˜à;·}Æp Í ;Æ ã'·}śÇ'ʝ·+à›ËÇ'À›É¢·pʸ¥Ô›·UÉ¢·pÅOãm¸¥Ô ÇmÈo¸¥Ô›·"ãE·pś·"˜·[ÃJě·pÅOÆp·"Í¢  ›ëq·[ÖéÁ'ÅOÖ߸ԛ·UÅIěÊ1À;·p˝ÇmȕÖqÍÕÂj¸ÍáÅOƸ§ã'·}ś·}ÂCÓ8Íḥԛ͢Š¸¥ÔOÁm¸ Â¥·}ÃJě·pÅQÆ·•Í¢Â5Öq·}Â¥ÍáË·}Ö*Ý  ÍḥԗÆpÇ'ʝʝ·pËaÆÍÕÁmÉ=֛Á†¸aÁmÀOÁE˜·[ÂÁ'à›à›ËÇEÁEÆaԛÍáÅOヸ¥Ô›·•Â¥ÍáÏ}·oÇ'È Û  ƒ¸¥·}ËÁ'ÀI×E¸·}Â}ÑJ֛͢˜¸¥Í¢ÅOƸ8·}Éá·}ÊC·}ÅJ¸¡Á'ÉáãEÇ'ËÍs¸ԛÊÂÊÁ¤×Å›·p·[Ö ¸¥ÇÒÄOÂ¥·—ʝ͢śÍáÊÁ'É¡Â¥àOÁEÆ·—Á'ÅO֖¸Íáʝ·+àQ·}ËC·}Éá·}ʝ·pÅJ¸}ݖޔ¸Í¢ÂÍáśȋ·}Á'¥͢À›Éᷗ¸¥ÇÒÊÁmì'·—Ê1ěÉḥ͢à›É¢·—àQÁ'˜·[ÂdžÎ'·}˸ԛ·+ÖOÁ†¸ÁÒ˜͢ÅOÆp· ¸¥ÔO·§Â˜Ô›·}·pËÁ'ÊCÇEěÅJ¸Çmȸ¥Í¢ÊC·§¸¥Ç"ÉáÇIÇEìÁ†¸ƒ¸ԛ·§Ö›Á†¸aÁ+͢ƒàOË¥ÇEԛÍáÀOÍs¸ÍáÎE·' Ý yśȋÇ'Ë¥¸¥Ä›ÅOÁm¸¥·}Éá×EÑ*ȋÇ'ËÁU˜¸¥Ë·}Á'Ê Ó8ÍḥÔßä å ֛͢˜¸¥Í¢ÅOƸ ·pÉ¢·pʝ·}ÅE¸aÂpÑJ¸ԛ·pË·oÍÕÂ8ÁàO˥džΆÁmÀOÉá·oÉádžÓ/·pË/ÀQÇEěÅO֗ÇmÈ •ðòÐ"ô/Â¥àOÁ'Æp·5ÇEŗÁmÅIקÖq·p¸¥·}˥ʝ͢ś͢˜¸¥ÍÕÆÁmÉ¢ã'Ç'ËÍḥԛʨÓ8ԛÍÕÆaԗÆpÇ'ʝà›Äq¸·}¡ä7å ·ë›ÁEƸ¥É¢×' Ý ,ÎE·pÅçÍsÈ8Ó/·§ÁmË·§ÆÇ'ÅJ¸·pÅJ¸Ó8Ís¸ÔæÁ–Û  ñ1Á'à›à›ËǤëqÍáÊÁ†¸ÍáÇEŸǠä7åJÑ?ÁmÅI×Öq·p¸¥·pËʝÍáÅO͢˜¸¥ÍÕƧÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥÔOÊ Ê1ÄO˜¸˜¸¥Í¢ÉáÉ ÄOÂ¥· •ðòÐ"ôÂ¥àOÁ'Æp·'Ýޔ¸ƒÍÕÂśÇm¸•Ä›ÅJ¸¥Í¢É±Ó·CÍ¢ÅE¸Ë¥ÇqÖqÄQÆ·CËÁ'ÅOÖqÇ'ʝ͢Ï}Ám¸¥Í¢Ç'ÅU¸ÔOÁ†¸•¸¥ÔOÍáśãJ•Âj¸aÁmË¥¸o¸Ǘ͢ʝà›Ë¥Ç†ÎE·'Ý 緝Ó8Íáɢɱà›Ë·}Â¥·pÅJ¸ ·ëI¸Ë¥·}ÊC·}Éá·}ק·ï§ÆpÍá·}ÅE¸yËaÁmÅQÖqÇ'ʝ͢Ïp·}֗Ámà›àO˥Ǥëq͢ʝÁm¸¥Í¢Ç'Å+ÁmÉ¢ã'Ç'ËÍḥԛÊÂȋÇ'ËyÆpÇ'ʝà›Äq¸Íáśã§ä å'Ý ±ö ÷  yü
"! í¡Ô›ÍÕÂàOÁmà;·pËȋÇqÆÄOÂ¥·}ÂoÇ'Åç˜àQÁ'Ʒ͢¥ě·}Â}Ý$#ÌË·}Æp·pÅJ¸•àOÁmà;·pËØ %†Ù±ã'Í¢Î'·}ÂÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥÔOʝÂ5Ë¥ÄOśś͢śã—Í¢ÅÒÂ¥àOÁEÆ·'( & ðjÛ*)mñ,+.- É¢Ç'ã,ÐUôÝ í¡Ô›·•À;·}˜¸yÉádžÓ/·pË¡À;Ç'ěÅOÖOÂ8ÁmË· •ðòÉáÇEã,ÐUô•ØsÛÙ2ÁmÅO/ Ö •ðj0Û )†ñô5Ø 1†3Ù 2q¸ԛ·ƒÁmÄq¸ԛÇ'Ëa¡ÍáÅ–Ø %¤Ù7Á'Â¥ì§Ó8ԛ·p¸¥Ô›·}Ë¡¸¥Ô›·}Ë¥·•ÍÕÂ8ÁmÅ"ÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥Íá¸¥Ô›Ê ÊÁ†¸aÆaԛÍáÅO㈸ԛ·}Â¥·À;Ç'ÄOÅO֛•Ç'˃Á—Å›·pÓÌÉádžÓ/·pËÀQÇEěÅOÖçÆpÁ'ÅÀ;·CàO˥džÎE·}Ö݃ޅÅÒ¸¥Ô›ÍÕ•àOÁ'àQ·}ËÓ/·ÖqÇqÆěʝ·pÅJ¸ƒÇ'ÄOËÁm¸˜¸¥·}ʝàq¸ƒÁm¸ ÁmÅQ˜Ó/·pËÍáÅOã1¸ԛ͢ÂoÃJě·}˜¸¥Í¢Ç'Å*ÑOà›Ë¥·[˜·}ÅJ¸¥Í¢Å›ãÁmÉÕ˜ÇC¸¥ÔO·ƒË¥·}Éá·}ΤÁ'ÅJ¸5ÁmÉ¢ã'Ç'ËÍḥԛÊÂ/ȋËÇ'Ê-Ø %¤Ù Á'ÅOÖ+Ç'ÉÕÖq·pË8É¢Íḥ·pËaÁ†¸ěË·'ÑOÁE¡Ó·}ÉáÉ7ÁE¡¸¥ÔO· à›ËÇIÇmÈò¡ÇmÈ ¸¥Ô›·ƒÉ¢Ç†Ó/·pË¡ÀQÇEěÅO֛Â}Ý Þ…Åú˜·[Ƹ¥Í¢Ç'4 Å %ÒÓ·UÖq5· Oś·+¸¥Ô›·"à›ËÇ'ÀOÉá·}Ê+Ñ ›ëâśÇ'¸Ám¸¥Í¢Ç'ÅúÁmÅOÖ ÖqÍÕÂ¥ÆpÄO¥¥Ç'ʝ·UÆÇEÅJÎE·pÅJ¸¥Í¢Ç'ÅQÂpÝæޅÅúÂ¥·}ƸÍáÇE6 Å 1ÒÓ/·+ãEÍáÎE· Á–˜ÄOË¥ÎE·pזÇmȃÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥԛÊÂ1ȋÇ'˧ÖqÍÕ˜¸¥Í¢ÅOƸ§·}Éá·}ÊC·}ÅJ¸ÂCÍáÅ ¸ԛ·"Ç'ś·põRàOÁE¥˜¸¥Ë·}Á'Ê ÊCÇqÖq·}ÉØsÛpÙRÑÕØ %¤Ù”Ñ¢Øá Û ¤Ù”Ý ޅŠàQÁmË¥¸¥ÍÕÆěÉÕÁmË[Ñ,Ç'ÄOË à›Ë·}Â¥·pÅJ¸Ám¸¥Í¢Ç'ÅéÇmÈy¸ԛ·UÁmÉ¢ã'Ç'ËÍḥԛÊÂCÍáÅªØ %[Ùy͢ʝÇEË¥·—·ëqà›É¢Í¢ÆpÍs¸§ÁmÅQÖéÖq·p¸Á'ÍáÉ¢·}Ö⸥ÔOÁ'Åâ¸ԛ·"Ç'ËÍáãEÍáÅQÁmÉR8 Ý 7y·ëI¸Ó/·+àO˥džÎE·§¸¥ÔO· ¸jÓ/ǗìIśdžÓ8ÅÒÉádžÓ/·pËÀQÇEěÅO֛ÂȋÇE˃ËÁ'ÅOÖqÇEÊCÍ¢Ïp·[Ö ÁmÉ¢ã'ÇEË¥ÍḥÔOʝÂ͢Ÿԛ·Ç'ś·põRàQÁ'ÂÂo˜¸¥Ë·}Á'Ê4ÊCÇqÖq·}ÉSÝCޅÅOÖq·}·}ÖÑ*¸¥Ô›·}Ë¥·ÍÕÂÁ+ãJÁmà À;·¸jÓ/·p·pŖ¸ԛ·ˆÉ¢Ç†Ó/·pËÀ;Ç'ěÅQÖ *Û )mñÁ'ÅOÖ縥ԛ·—ÀQÇEěÅOÖßãEÍáÎE·pÅ–Í¢Å»Ø %†ÙÇ'È*Û )†,ñ +9-.ÉáÇEã,ÐÒÝ í¡ÔO·—ÁmàOàOÁmË·pÅJ¸Ó/·}ÁmìIś·[Â¥ÂÇmÈ8¸¥ÔO· Û

:@?BADCFEHGJID>LKHK; I
ALG@?qA