Learning Curve Bounds for Markov Decision Processes ... - UCSD CSE

17 downloads 0 Views 239KB Size Report
analyze these learning curves for a simple con- ... learning curve for an MDP measures how the agent's ...... ing to act using real-time dynamic programming.
      "! # %$&' ()* +, +- ./%0*12435 768:9"; +*'-  6%2=  '3?,  @%ACB D EGF%HIEKJMLNOAQPRSAQF%TUNOAQVXWYF%TZECD&[\LNOWYF]_^%` ab7cCdeb7fhgYif1j,klimlinokqp7r msrIcst aiu0vQwQdxrIdeklic_r msyzb+r f{cQklcQn | rI}e}~rp{CwQ}eb7d{de}€cQ}{dekldewQd{bi g‚b+p{QcQimlionƒ „o…† u‡Qb7f{}ed1ˆCd{feb7b‰d+ŠO‹\Œ+Ž‘I’G“ a\r u-”•fekqtCnboŠ | † oQŒX“ … –—I˜O™šI›•—œ‰™CXž Ÿo¡O¢£I¤O™+¥_¦X¡O§¨q©O ªS¨~§X«› ¬®­1¯o°Q±Q²³_° feb‰dewQf{cÂi µb7fdeklu0bÁ‚\Qb7f{br f{b&u r cCƒp¶mÇrI}e}{kÇp‰r mSrIm·noif{k·d{Qu‡} gYiof½Ã_cstCklcQn1iovQdeklu r mv_imlkqp~klb7}nklµob7cr#p~iu0vQmlb7debSt b7}xp~f{klvQdeklic i gdeQb | r f{´i µ‡b‰cGµCklfeiocQu‡b‰cGdXÁSjr }{b+t ic d{Qkl}2tCb7}~p~feklvQd{klic½Š | rIfe´oi µ2tCb+p¶k·}{klic vQfeiQp~b7}{}eb7}h¸ | ¹º }~»½¼\kld{wQcstCkl}‘Ž de•b7}eb r mlnoifekld{Qu‡}p~iu0vQwQdeb-d{Qb‡d{b7u‡v_if~r m%}{dxrIdekl}ed{kÇp¶}-desrId p~iowQcCdeb+tMfeb‰¼¾rIfxtC}f{b7vQf{b7}eb7cCd-r c klu0vsiofedxrIcCd1p~mqr }e} feb‰µb+rImQ¼\Qkqp{‡rp~d{k·iocQ}mlb+rt d{iâp¶icQ}{k·}{deb7cCdXŠCm·iocQn Ždeb‰feu/nCr klcQ}XÁ iIg¿v•fei”•m·b‰u‡}\klc tCb+p~kl}ekliocÀr cstMp~icCdef{imÁ‚\Qb niGrIm iIg¾mlb+rIfecQklcQn klcÂdeQb‰}eb |M¹2º }kl}dei Ã_cstÂr0vsiom·kqp~ƒ ‚\Qb1p~mqrI}e}ekqp7rIm rImlnif{kldeQu0}OgYiof%}eiom·µCklcQn | ¹º }\tCicQiodSr v•vQmlƒ d{sr d'ƒGklb7mqtC}\d{Qbu rXÄQklu&wQuÅb~ÄQvsbXp~deb+t;f{b7dew•fec;vsb7f klc&d¼iklu‡v_if{dxrIcGdZ}ekldew_r dekliocQ} ,¸Ykq»Z¼\Qb7c0deQb'vsr f~r u‡b‰deb7f{}%i g wQc•k·d0deklu‡boÁƀcUmÇrIfenob }ed~r deb;}ev_rp~b7}XŠ2p¶iu‡v•wQdeklcQn de•b | r f{´i µb7cCµCklfeic•u‡b7cCd½r f{bSc•id×r'vQf{klifeko´CcQi ¼\c½Š r cst¸Yklkq» d{Qb7}eb rXµb7f~r nb‰}1tCklfeb+p~d{mlƒ-k·}cQiodgYb+r }{kl”QmlbÈCklcQ}ed{b+rtOŠ ¼\Qb7c#k·dkl}½c•idOgÌb+r }{k·”•m·b'¸Ët wQbSd{i1d{QbS}{klÒ7bSiIgsde•bS}{dxr d{b\}evsrop~b+» d{QbrInb7cCd u-wQ}{d-b7}ed{k·u r d{b deQb‰uɔCƒ®}edeiQp{srI}edekqp deiávsb‰fgYiofeuÉd{Qb;feb owQklfebXtÕur d{fekÐÄÏiv_b7f~r dekliocQ}+Á4€cÆd{Qb7}eb b~ÄQvQmliofxr d{klic®i gde•b }ed~r debM}evsrop~bÁʀc®de•k·} p7r }{bŠ p7rI}eb7}XŠ½iocQb&u rXƒtCb‰µGkl}{b-}edeiQp{srI}edekqp-rIvQvQfeiXÄQklurIdeklic•}+êlŒ~Š%ŒŒ Š mlic•nb7fb~ÄQvQmlif~r deklioc-deklu‡b7},b7csr ”•m·b'u‡iofeb1rp‰p~wQfxrIdeb Œ+“‰ìQd{i\deQb7}{b1r mlniofeklde•u‡}_desrId½b7}{deklurIdebdeQbfeb w•k·f{b+t#}edxrIdekl}Ž b7}{deklurIdeb7}r cst#u‡iofebk·c gYif{u‡b+tt b+p~kl}eklic ŽËu r ´CklcQnsÁ e d kqp~}ZfxrIdeQb7fd{sr c-p~iu0vQwQd{k·c•nSd{Qb7u/b¶Ä•rop~demlƒCÁO‚\Qb7}{b1r vQv•feiXÄCŽ ‚\Qbmlb+rIfecQklcQn&p¶wQfeµob1gÌif\r c |M¹2º u‡b+rI}ewQf{b7}\Qi ¼ l k  u rIdeklicQ}•feb7mlƒ1ioc}ed{iQpe_r }ed{kqpb~ÄQvQmlif~r deklioc2iIgQdeQb%}{dxrIdeb%}{vsrp~b d{QbÍrInb7cCd+Î } v_b7f‘gYif{ur c_p~bÏtCb7v_b7cstC}ÂiocÊdeQbÏrImЎ e d  i 0 u b+r }{wQfeb\d{Qb1f{b7dewQf{cQ}\r ded~rp{Qb+tdeivsrIfedekqp~w•mÇrIfSp~iowQfe}{b7}\i g mli ¼b+t;b~ÄQvQmlif~r dekliocÂdeklu‡bŠZчÁM€cÏde•k·} vsrIvsb7f ¼b  r ¶ p e d l k  i c½ÁZ€c | ¹º }XŠd{Qb7}ebf{b7dewQf{cQ}1r f{b\deQb'}ewQu0}i g½feb‰¼¾rIfxtC} rIcsr mlƒCÒ7b\de•b7}ebmlb+r f{cQklcQn&p~w•feµb‰}%gYiofSr#}eklu‡vQmlbSp¶icCŽ e d _  r  d deQb&rInb7cCd1rop7p~wQu-wQmqrIdeb7}i µb7f\d{klu‡bÁ d{feim'vQfeio”Qmlb7uÓ¼\k·d{®wQcstCkl}xp¶iwQcCdebXtÔf{b7¼¾rIfxtC}XÁՀc €c nb7c•b7fxrImˊ•mlicQnob7f\b~ÄQvQmlif~r dekliocd{klu‡b7}mlb+rt0dei-u0if{b2rp‰p~wCŽ vsrIfed{kÇp¶wQmqr f+Šhu‡b7d{QiQtC} gYfeiouÖ}{dxrIdekl}ed{kÇp‰r m1u0b+p{sr c Ž fxrIdebb7}ed{klur d{b7}×rIcstu0ifeb,k·c gYif{u‡b+ttCb+p¶k·}{klicCŽurI´GklcQn_Á_‚\Qb kqp~}&rIfeb wQ}ebXt;dei p7r mqp~w•mÇrIdeb mli ¼Sb7f”_iwQc_tC}ic;de•b mlb+r f{cQklcQnÀp~w•feµb0gYiofrIc | ¹º u‡bXr }ew•feb7} Qi ¼d{Qb r nb‰cGdXÎ } rInb7cCd+Î }Ov_b7fgÌifeu r csp¶b×klcde•b%deQb‰feu‡iQtCƒCcsrIu‡kqp_mlklu-Ž kld1ÑÙØÛÚՊsÜ5ØÛÚՊsÝÂÞÊÑ ß+Üà¸qÃ_cQkldeb+»‰Šs¼\•b7feb v_b7fgYiofeu r csp~b-tCb7v_b7cst }&iocÀd{Qb‡r mlmli ¼SbXt b~ÄQvQmlif~r dekliocÀd{k·u0bŠ чŠv_b7f vsiom·kqp~ƒÂb‰µr mlwsr d{klic½Á † cÔklu‡v_if{dxrIcGd owQb7}{deklicágYiof ÑÊkl}%d{Qb\cCwQu-”sb‰f×iIg½deklu‡b,}edeb‰vQ}¾rImlm·ioded{b+tv_b7fvsiomЎ }eiomlµGklcQn | ¹º }&kl}-Qi ¼4deQb7}{b }edeiQp{srI}edekqp rIvQvQf{iXÄ klu r dekliocQ} kqp~ƒÂb7µrImlwsr d{k·iocÏr cstáÜÛkl} deQb0}eklÒ7b i gdeQb }ed~r d{b }{vsrp~boÁ%€c deQkl}mlk·u0kld+Š ¼b1vQf{i µCkÇt bâr#mli ¼Sb‰fS”_iwQc_t p~iocGµob7fenob&d{i‡d{Qbp¶ifef{b+p~d&rIcQ}e¼b7fr }'deQb b~ÄQvQmlif~r d{k·ioc deklu‡b deb‰cstC}\dei-klcCÃ_cQkldƒGÁ iocÀd{Qb-feb7d{wQfecái g\vsiomlkÇp¶k·b‰}desrIdr vQv_b+r f#ivQd{k·u r m ”srI}eb+tKic‡klu0vsb7f‘gYb+p~d\}{dxrIdekl}ed{kÇp¶}+Á | io}ed ¼Siofe´ÂicádeQkl} kl}e}ew•b_r } gYiQp~wQ}{b+táic | ¹º }&¼\•i}eb feb‰¼¾rIfxtC}r f{b‡r d{deb7cCwsrIdeb+tM¼\klde;deklu‡bÁ'‚\Qkl}kl}ât icQb ”Cƒ klcCŽ def{iQtCwsp~klcQn r‡t k·}~p~iw•cGd'gËrop~deiof+Š½ ?ŒoŠOr cstM¼Sb‰k·noCdeklcQn ã äGå ° ±•æ\ç1è1³_°Qé{æ å de•b feb7¼\r f~tC}ÀrId‡deklu0b ‡”Cƒ XÁ/‚\QbÂtCkl}xp¶iwQcCd0gËrp¶deif0kl} p~iocGµob7cQklb7cCd,gYif\”_iwQc_tCklcQn&b‰}edeklu r deklioc-b7fef{ife}XŠsrI}\k·d}eb‰de}2rIc | rIcGƒ-v•fei”•m·b‰u‡}k·c tCb+p~kl}{k·iocrIcst‡p~iocCdefeiom×p7rIc‡”_bu‡iQtCb7mlb+t b ¸xŒ s» gYif deQb tCb+p~kl}{k·ioc r } | r fe´oi µÍtCbXp~kl}eklic®vQf{i p¶b7}e}{b7}¸ |M¹2º }x»7ê됏ì‘È\rIvQvQmlkqp7r d{k·iocQ} vQOf{i b+p~p¶d{b7k·}eµo}Xb‡Á%€Qc-iofevsklrIÒ7iofedecÏkqp~dew•klmÇu0rIf+b ŠCrÏp~d{klÞ  i Q c klcsp~mlwstCbMnGr u0b~ŽvQmqrXƒGklcQn_ŠcQb7d¼if{´Íf{iwQd{klcQnsŠ\f{i”_id0csrXµCk·nCrXŽ feb‰mÇrIdeklµb‰m·ƒ-mlklded{mlb1b Ob+p~d'ic‡d{Qb&rI}%n”_b7b7cCƒod+iÎ }csvst b‰d{fQgYiokl}%feuQirIf{csklÒ7p~ibc-Á€Ìsg%rX¼µobb deklioc½Šb7mlb7µr d{if }xp{Qb+t wQmlk·c•nsŠSrIcstÂ}{Qif{deb7}{dŽvsr d{ÔvQf{i”Qmlb7u0}+Á tCb7u r cstr¾ÃQÄQb+tmlb7µob7mCi gsv_b7f‘gYif{ur c_p~b¾rIcstrIm·mli ¼ &d{i1µrIfeƒCŠ ‚\QbnoiGrIm½i g%mlb+rIfecQklcQn-klc | ¹º }1kl}'deit k·}~p~i µb‰f1de•b&p~iw•fe}eb de•b-feb owQklfebXtÂb~ÄQvQmlif~r d{k·iocÀd{klu‡b7}}xp‰r mlbrI}Ñ Á yOkl´b~Ž i g×rop~dekliocQ}+Šoif%v_imlkqp~ƒCŠ de_r dƒGklb7mqtC},deQb'urXÄQklu wQuÆb¶Ä v_b+p~d{b+t ¼\kl}ebŠIgYiof½Ã•Ä bXt ½ŠoicQb1p‰r c-feb‰mÇrIdeb'deQb1rInb7cCd+Î }%v_b7f‘gYif{ur c_p~b deiÂd{Qb r mlmli ¼SbXtÂb~ÄQvQmlif~r d{k·ioc®deklu‡bÁ®‚\•k·}-¼\r }‡t icQb klcÔr í~îïððñ~ò ó2ô‰õõoðñ~öö~÷2øSô‰ðÌùúñ~û ï üúò ýÌòþXÿ òoñî%ô ðÌüúõ +ñ-îñ~ò óñ~ð Gî%ô oðÌüúõ Xñ ÿ º_† aágYf~r u0b7¼Siofe´ ”Cƒ Zklb+p{Gd{b7f+ê ’Iì‘Á yOb‰}e}k·}´CcQi ¼\c‡r ”_iw•d | ¹º }¼\k·d{-wQcstCkl}~p~iwQcCd{b+t-f{b7¼¾rIfxtC}XÁ €cÏd{Qkl}‡p7r }{bŠ\d{Qb niGrIm\i gdeQbÀrInb7cCd-kl} dei;Ãscstád{Qb v_imЎ kqp~ƒ desrIdƒGklb7mqtC}d{Qb-urÄ klu wQuÙb~ÄQvsbXp~deb+t feb7d{wQfecÂv_b7fw•cQkld deklu0bÁ \b7f{b\deQb\vQf{b7}xp¶feklvQdeklioc-Ñ kl}×µrop~wQiowQ}+ŠrI}wQcstCkl}Ž p~iowQcCdeb+t f{b7¼\r fxt }âp¶ifef{b7}ev_ic_t d{i‡de•bmlk·u0kld ØÓÚÆÁh‚\Qb 







!"

$#

(

*),+

%'&

.-"

/10

(

2

435) +

















    

76

98

:3;),+

ÜØ" Ú >Ý Þ   ¸qÃsc•k·d{b+» < "6

0

8



-

(

-





8





6



3

/



/

0



de•b\b7cCdefeiovCƒ ¸   »,vQfei µCkqtCb7}Sr#}eu0iCide mlinCr fekld{Qu‡kqpZu‡b+rŽ }ew•feb i gdeQb cCwQu-”_b7fiIgvsiom·kqp~klb7}2 @ ¸   »7Á Qf{iu"}{b+p{Ž dekliocÀ’_Š½¼b-srXµb‡rKm·i ¼b7f”_iw•cst ˸   »âicÂde•b‡r }eƒCu0vCŽ deiodekqp%tCbXp7rXƒfxrIdebdesrId×p{srIfxrp¶deb7f{k·Ò‰b7} º f+ê  ! D   ! ` ì    Á \iowQn•m·ƒ0}ev_b+r ´CklcQn_ŠOdeQb‰c½ŠOgÌif}ew p¶k·b‰cGd{mlƒ mqr fenob&µrImlwQb7}i g Ñ rIcst ÜŠC¼bsrXµb  º f ê  ! D   ! ` Kì U ?          ¸Ì’sŒX»

−3

3

x 10

%6

2.5

3

2 1.5



1 0.5 0 0

0.02

0.04

0.06 ψ

0.08

0.1

0.12

ZklnwQf{b | rXÄQklu‡klÒ+rIdeklicMi g m·cê  D•¸ ! »# ` ¸ ! »Ëì2i µb‰f ! gYf{iub _Á½¸“ o»7Š_¼\Qi}{bfeb‰}ewQmldnklµb‰}2r mli ¼Sb‰f1”_iwQcstKic d{Qb tCb+p‰rXƒ‡fxrIdebŠ DzÁ 6

/

'

-

-



‚\Qkl}‡kl}-d{Qbp¶iu-”QklcQb+t mlk·u0kld&d{sr d-d{QbÀb¶Ä v•m·iofxrIdeklic®deklu0b v_b7f vsiom·kqp~ƒ®b7µrImlwsr d{k·iocÔr cst®d{Qb;}eklÒ7b;i gdeQb;}ed~r d{bÀ}{vsrp~b nf{i ¼/d{iklcCÃ_cQkldƒÀr drÃQÄQb+t;fxrIdebÁ‚\Qb&f~r d{k·i Ý®u0b+r }{wQfeb‰} de•b b~ÄQvQmlif~r dekliocÏdeklu0b‡Ñ"klc®¼\sr d‡rIfeb c_r dew•fxr m\w•cQklde}-gÌif r c |M¹2º ¼\kldeÂwQcst k·}~p~iw•cGd{b+tÂf{b7¼\r fxt } Ôcsr u0b7mlƒÀd{Qb‡}{klÒ7b i gdeQbM}edxrIdeb }{vsrp¶bŠ1ÜÂÁ  CƒÏr febMdeQb7}{b csrIdewQf~r m1w•cQklde} ‚\Qb;feb+rI}eiocÆkl}‡d{sr d klcÔiofxtCb7f d{i rop7p~wQf~r d{b7mlƒÔb7}ed{klur d{bÀr v_imlkqp~ƒOÎ }b~ÄQv_b+p~d{b+t0feb7d{wQfec½Š•kld×u rXƒ”sb'cQb+p~b7}{}xrIfeƒ‡d{ib~ÄQvQmlif{b de•b}{dxrIdeb }evsrop~b }{b7µb7f~r m'deklu‡b7}#i µb7fXÁÍyZr fenob µr mlwQb7} i gÝ b7cQ}{wQfeb0desrIdb+ropeÂv_imlkqp~ƒ b‰µr mlwsr d{klic kl}”srI}eb+t;iocÀb‰cQiwQno }ed{b7vQ}'dei-v_b7fgYiofeudeQkl}\b~ÄQvQmliofxr d{klic½Á yOb‰d\wQ}S}{´b7d~p{¼\Cƒ-d{Qb    'mlklu‡kld½klc0b _Á_¸Ë“ … »%kl}cQb+p{Ž b7}{}xr f{ƒ gÌifklcGd{b7feb‰}edeklcQnMm·bXr fec•k·c•n‡”_b7srXµCklif+ ê ì‘LÁ \b+p‰r mlmdesrId de•b âk·”•”Q}&r mlnoifekld{Qu5b7}ed{k·u r d{b7}&bXrp{ϵrIm·w•b-gYwQc_p~deklic  D ”Cƒr#fxrIcstCiu4¼¾rIm·´-iIg×mlb7cQnode чŠ•deQb7c iowQdevQw•de}1d{QbvsiomlkÇp¶ƒ ¼\klde®de•b”_b7}{d‡b7u0vQklfekqp7r mfeb‰dewQf{c½Š  ! DzÁ † }-ÑÖØ ÚՊ%d{Qb xp¶icCgYw•}eklic 0vQfeio”sr ”•k·mlkldƒ º f+ê ! D  ! `‰ì%”_b+p~iu0b7}b~ÄQvsiocQb7cCŽ dekqrIm·mlƒ-}{ur mlm_gYiof2rIcGƒ0cQic ŽËiovQde klurImOvs iomlkÇp¶ƒ 2Á † }2ÜØÛÚՊ Qi ¼b7µb‰f+Šde•b7feb r f{kl}ebrIcÂb~ÄQvsiocQb7cCdekqrIm·mlƒ;mqr fenob-cCwQu-”sb‰fi g cQiocCŽËiovQdeklu r mCvsiomlkÇp¶k·b‰}+ Á \iw•nQmlƒ}{vsb+rI´Ck·c•nsŠCklc-deQb'deQb‰feu‡iIŽ tCƒCcsrIu‡kqpmlklu‡kld'deQb7}{b d¼Si;b Ob+p~de} e”srImqr csp~b-iowQ d ;deiMnb7cCŽ b7f~r deb klcCdeb7f{b7}ed{k·c•nmlb+rIfecQklcQn-”_b7srXµCklifr }r#gYwQc_p~deklicMi gSd{Qb fxrIdekliÝÂÞ Ñ&ßXÜÂEÁ 'c d{Qb ide•b7fsr cstzŠsd{QLb kl”Q”Q}1mlb+rIfecQb‰f b~ÄQQkl”Qklde} w•k·d{b&d{feklµCkqr m%”_b7srXµCklifkÐg¾iocQmlƒ Ñ Ø Ú ¸ËrIml¼¾rXƒC} }eb‰m·bXp~deklcQn0deQbiovQdeklu r m_vsiom·kqp~ƒQ»iof1Ü ØÖÚ ¸YcQb7µob7f1io”QdxrIklcCŽ klcQn-rtCb owsrIdeb}{dxrIdekl}ed{kÇp¶}x»7Á ¹ b7µb‰m·iovQklcQn;deQb7}{b kqtCb+rI}gYw•fede•b7f+Š\mlb7d º f ê 2$#% &'&)( @ ¸    »Ëì tCb7c•idebMdeQb v•fei”_r ”QklmlkldƒÂdesrId-deQ*b âk·”•”Q}‡r mlniofeklde•u"iwQd‘Ž vQwQd{}1rv_imlkqp~ƒ-¼\kldeM¸ K D  DC»%Þʸ    »‰Á‚\Qb7c ¼SbsrXµob1d{Qb gYiom·mli ¼\klcQnp{sr klc i gklcQb owsr mlkldeklb7} º f  2 #/% &'&'( @ ¸    »  U º fê B2 @ ¸    »¼\klde  ! D   ! ` ì U  º f ê  ! D   ! ` ì < ¸Y’C» D     ‚\Qb Ãsf{}edklcQb w_r mlkldƒc•ideb‰}&d{sr dr d#m·bXr }ediocQb-vsiomlkÇp¶7ƒ 2 !@ ¸   »u-wQ}{d2f{b7nkl}{deb7f‡r •k·noQb7fb‰u‡vQklfekqp7rImfeb7d{wQfec®de_r c ` gYiof  2$#% &'&'( @ ¸    »7Á;€cÏnob7cQb7f~r mŠQi ¼b7µb‰f+Š%d{Qkl}&kl} cQid- r }ew p~klb7cCdâp¶icstCkld{k·iocÀ}{klcsp~b ¼Sb-r ml}ei f{b owQklfeb desrId2c•iiodeQb‰f v_imlkqp~ƒÂ¼\kldeÔtCk b‰feb7cCd‡p~iCif~tCklcsr d{b7}‡}~r u0vQmlb7}rMQkln•b7f-feb~Ž dew•fec½Á®‚\QbM}eb+p~iocst®klcQb owsrImlk·dƒCŠZb _Á\¸Y’C»‰ŠgYiom·mli ¼\}#gYfeiouÖr }ed~r cst•r fxt0wQc•k·ioc ”siowQcstOÁ yOb‰d½wQ}ZcQi ¼Âfeb+p‰r mlm}{iu‡biIg iowQf½v•feb7µCkliwQ}Zfeb7}{wQmlde}XÁ Qf{iuÔ}{b+p{Ž dekliocÀ“QŠ•¼Sb ´CcQi ¼ÊdesrId1klc d{Qbmlklu‡kldSiIgSmqr f{nb}ed~r deb-}{vsrp¶b7}+Š 

(













(





6

D

 



/



| iofeb\gÌifeu r mlmlƒŠX¼Sbp7r c0dxrI´b1d{Qb1d{Qb7f{u‡iQtCƒCcsr u0kqpmlk·u0kld½klc b _Á_¸Ë“ … »d{i-i”Qd~r klc mlklu ' Ü Œ mlc º f  2 #% &'&)(@ ¸   »   U I¸   » ÂÝ  ¸   » < Ò7\b7iof{deisbŠ d{d{Qsb7r c-d'd{kÐg¿Qb\d{QvQbfeiof{”sk·nor C”•d\k·mlskldr ƒ csº tKf}e ê 2$kqtC#b% &'&'iI( gS@ b _¸ ÁO ¸Ì ’G»Ë»hì•klp‰}\r m·c-b‰}e”_}bSde}~¸Ìs’Gr rIokqct » dei $-klcd{Qb deQb7f{u‡iQtCƒCcsrIu‡kqp\mlklu‡kld+Á€ c nob7cQb7f~r mŠOd{Qkl} iQp7p~wQf{}%r d½µrImlwQb7}½iIgsÝÀÞ®Ñ-ßXÜÊgÌif½¼\•kÇp{d{Qb kl”Q”Q}Omlb+r f{cQb7f srI}\}ew p~klb7cCd}ed~r d{k·}{dekqp~}'dei‡f{wQmlbiw•d  Cd{Qb‡¸Ì}ewQ”_iv•deklurImÇ» v_imlkqp~klb7} 2 @ ¸    »7Á ‚\Qbp~iou‡v_b7dekldeklioc‡”_b7d¼Sb‰b7c I¸    »\r cst  ¸    »\d{i‡tCb7deb‰fŽ u‡klcQbde•b2}{klnc‡iIg×b _Á_¸Ì’G»kl}deQb”srImqr csp~klcQn rp~d\d{sr dnklµb‰} fekl}{b\deiklcGd{b7feb‰}edeklcQn ”_b7srXµCklifklc&d{Qb1d{Qb7feu0iQtCƒCcsr u0kÇpZmlklu‡kld+Á \iodeb•i ¼Æd{Qb&v_r fxrIu‡b7d{b7f1Ýáu‡iQtCwQmqrIdeb7}\d{Qbfeb‰mÇrIdeklµb p~icCŽ def{kl”QwQdekliociIgSde•b7}eb owsrIcGd{kldeklb7}1d{i‡d{Qb&i µob7fxrImlm½µr mlwQb#i g%deQb feklnoGdsrIcst0}ekqtCbÁ‚\Qbp~f{kldekqp7r mZµr mlwQb Ý  ¸    »Þ ̸ ¸     » » ¸Ì’G“o»  kl}½d{QbSµrImlwQb%i gOÝrI”si µob%¼\Qkqp{de•.b kl”Q”•}½mlb+r f{cQb7f%kl}r ”Qmlb%d{i b7mlklu‡klcsrIdeb\gÌfeiu>p¶icQ}{kÇt b7fxrIdeklic¸̼\klde;vQfeio”sr ”Qklmlkldƒ-icQbX»2rImlm de•b&v_imlkqp~klb7} 2 @ ¸    »‰Á&‚\CwQ}d{Qb‡p~icCd{iwQf{}i g¾p¶icQ}{dxr cCd Ý ¸   »klc‡d{Qb  )CvQmqr cQbb7c_p~mli}eb#feb7nok·iocQ}\¼\Qio}ebvsiomlkÇp¶k·b‰} srX µob&ƒo b7ddeiM”sb0b7ml k·u0klcsr d{b+t r } p7r cst kÇt•r deb‰}gYif#deQHb kl”Q”•} v_imlkqp~ƒGÁ0€cÏv_r fed{kqp~wQmqr fXŠ%Ý  ¸    »&Þ  b‰csp~mli}{b7}-deQb0b7cCdeklfeb v_imlkqp~ƒÂ}evsrop~bŠ\¼\•k·mlb Ý  ¸    »‡Þ5Ú:p~iocQ}ekl}{de}‡iIg&r }{k·c•nmlb v_iklcCdÔdeQb-p~iCif~tCklcsr d{b7} i g\deQb-iovQdeklurIm½v_imlkqp~ƒCŠ¸  `   ` »7Á ZklnwQf{7b Â}{Qi ¼\} }eb7µob7fxrImi g&d{Qb7}{bÏp~icCdeiowQfe}0gYiof‡d{Qb 9 : ;6= ? 9"! @ AC 9 | ¹º ¼\klde G/ÞÕ$ < „ rIcst-f{b7¼¾rIfxt tCkl}ed{fekl”QwCŽ deklioc½Š % ¸ H »‰Á hideb\•i ¼ÂdeQb\b7c_p~mli}ebXt feb7nok·iocQ}}eQf{klcQ´klc}eklÒ7b r }de•bµr mlwQb'i g¿Ý  k·}\klcsp¶feb+rI}eb+tOÁ €c&rIcsr mlinoƒ\dei'b _Á¸Ì’G“o»7ŠX¼Sb,urXƒ2rIml}ei1tCb~Ã_cQb¾r'p~fekld{kÇp‰r mCµr mlwQb Ý ¸ »0desrId‡}{w p~b7} d{iÏf{wQmlb iwQd0vsiomlkÇp¶k·b‰}‡¼\kldeÔb¶Ä v_b+p~d{b+t feb‰ dewQ f{c  D  Á \bXp7r mlm\de_r d‡v_imlkqp~klb7}-¼\klde  DÕÞ  mlklb icÂmlklcQb7} ¼\kldeá}emliv_b G  rIcstÂklcCdeb7f~p~b7vQd ¸~Œ G-»  klcÂdeQb   )GvQmqrIcQbÁ \b7csp¶b‡de•b-µr mlwQb-i g1Ý  ¸  »#urXƒ ”sbgYiw•cst ”Cƒ urÄQk·u-kÐÒ7klcQnb _ÁZ¸Y’C“»hi µb7f'deQbf~r cQnobi g9rIcst  desrId1mlklb ic0deQkl}\mlklcQbÁ ‚\Qbmlb+r f{cQklcQn1p~wQf{µbgÌif½r c | ¹º u‡bXr }ew•feb7}ZQi ¼Àd{QbSrInb7cCd+Î } v_b7fgYiofeu r csp~bklu‡v•fei µb‰}O¼\k·d{deQb\r mlmli ¼SbXt\b~ÄQvQmlif~r d{k·iocdeklu‡b v_b7fvsiom·kqp~ƒ0b7µr mlwsrIdeklicZŠQчÁ€c d{Qb deQb7f{u‡iQtCƒCcsrIu‡kqp\mlklu‡kld+Š de•bb~ÄQvQmlif~r deklioc‡deklu0b2kl}\u0b+r }{wQfeb+t0klc wQc•k·d{}\i g%de•b}eklÒ7b i g de•b}ed~r deb }ev_rp~bŠzif1ÝÂÞÊÑ ß+ÜÂÁ'j%b+p‰r wQ}{b&d{Qb âk·”•”Q}1r mlniIŽ fekld{Qu?kl}'nwsrIfxr cCd{b7b+tMdei‡iowQdev•wQdr-v_imlkqp~ƒ‡¼\klde #% &)&'(

gYiofb¶Ä v•m·iofxrIdeklicÕdeklu‡b‰}KÝ  Ý  ¸  »7Š#¼SbÂio”QdxrIklc rámli ¼Sb‰ f ”_iwQcst0iocd{Qb&rInb7cCd+Î }'vsb7f‘gYif{urIcsp~b”Cƒ‡vQmlid{deklcQn  µb7f{}ewQ} Ý  ¸  »7Á 



1-





$

6





-

8



0.5

*

0.4

α = 50 0.3 ω



0.2 α = 10 0.1 α=0 0 0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

ZklnwQf{b  ÆaiocCdeiw•fe} iIgp~iocQ}ed~r cCdÀÝ ¸   » klcÆd{Qb, ) vQmqr c•bÁ‡‚\•bp~iocGd{iwQf{}&b‰csp~mli}{b‡v_imlkqp~klb7 }de_ r df{b7urIk·c;p7r  cCŽ tCkqtQrIdeb7}#gYif de•b âk·”•”Q}v_imlkqp~ƒGÁ † }ÝÅØ:ÚƊ%rImlmSv_imlkqp~klb7} ¸Yb¶Ä•p¶b7vQddeQb iv•deklurImsiocQb+»1rIfebb‰m·klu0k·c_r debXt gYf{iu p~icQ}{kqtCb7fŽ r d{klic½Á,‚\Qbr }ed{b7fekl}{´Kt b7cQid{b7}deQb#m·iQp7rIdeklic0i g%de•bivQd{klur m v_imlkqp~ƒGÁ 6

µ

'

1 0

10

0.8

1−υ/υ∗

0.6

−1

1−υ/υ∗

10

7

(

-

0.4



−2

10

10

0

1

10

2

10 α

3

10

4

10

0.2

0 0

200

400

600

α

800

1000

ZklnwQf{b „  v•vsb7f”_iwQc_t iocÀ¸~Œ #% &'&)(xß ` »\µob7fe}{wQ}ÝÂgÌif de•b 9 : ;6< = ? 9"! @BADC 9 | ¹º ¼\k·d{ GÓÞ5$ < „ rIcstáfeb7¼\r f~t tCkl}ed{fekl”QwQd{klic½Š &%_¸ »7Á‚\Qb-klcQ}eb7d}{Qi ¼\}&r0mlin Žmlin-vQmliod2b¶ÄGŽ deb‰cstCb+t d{i-mqr fenob7f\H µr mlwQb‰}SiIg,ÝÁ 6

de•bgYfxrIu‡b7¼if{´2iIg | r fe´oi µ&tCb+p¶k·}{klic-vQf{i p¶b7}e}{b7}\¼\klde wQcstCkl}Ž p~iowQcCdeb+t0feb‰¼¾rIfxtC}XÁ 'cQb;µGklf{dewQb iIg&iw•fr v•vQfeiCrp{Ôkl}‡d{sr d0gYiof‡}eklu0vQmlb‡b~Äsr uŽ vQmlb7}'¼Sb&p‰r c wQc_tCb7fe}{dxrIcst klc nofeb+rId2tCb‰dxr klmZQi ¼ÊdeQb r nb‰cGdXÎ } v_b7fgYiofeu r csp~bklu‡vQf{i µb7}¼\klde-kld{}Sp7r v_rp~kldƒ dei&rop owQklfeb\u‡iofeb rp‰p~wQfxrIdeb}ed~r dekl}{dekqp~}+ÁZ‚\Qb}eQf{klcQ´Ck·c•n\feb7nok·iocQ}½klcÃ_nwQf{b 1rIcst de•bSv_b7fgÌifeu r csp¶b¾p~w•feµb\klc#Ãsnw•feb „ f{b7µbXr mQd{Qb\mlb+r f{cQklcQn1”_b~Ž srXµCklif,gYfeiou}ed~r f{d1dei#ÃscQkl}{ ÔdesrId\k·}XŠCgYf{iu?r }{dxrIdebiIg×klu-Ž v_i µb7f{k·}{Qb+t0}ed~r d{k·}{dekqp~}\d{i-icQbi gvsb‰fgYb+p¶d1´CcQi ¼\mlb+tCnobÁ‚\Qb7ƒ r ml}{i‡feb‰µb+rIm¾rI}eƒCu‡vQd{id{kÇpâfxr d{b7} i g¾p~iocCµb7f{nb7csp¶bd{sr dp~iowQmqt cQiod\”sbv•feb+tCkqp~d{b+t0gYf{iu}eklu‡v•m·b'}ed~r dekl}{dekqp7r mp~ic•}ekqtCb7f~r dekliocQ}+Á ‚\Qkl} tCb7d~r klmlb+tÕvQkqp~dew•febÏiIgmlb+rIfecQklcQnUk·} d{iԔsb®p~icCd{fxr }{deb+t ¼\kldeÂd{Qb‡u-wsp{;¼SbXr ´b‰f&}{dxr d{b7u‡b‰cGd de_r diovQdeklurIm%p~icCdef{im b7u0b7fenob7}\klc‡de•bmlk·u0kld×d{sr d\d{Qbr nob7cCd\µGkl}{k·d{}\b+rp{ }ed~r d{bklcCŽ ÃscQkld{b7mlƒiIgYdeb‰c½Á Sb‰d2b‰µb7c;deQkl}¼b+r ´ob7f}edxrIdeb7u0b7cCdfeb7u r klcQ} r c-iovsb‰c owQb7}{deklic gYiof%urIcCƒ}eklu-wQmqr d{klicCŽ”sr }{b+trIm·noif{k·d{Qu‡} wQ}{b+t0dei-}eiomlµb | ¹º }\¼\klde0wQcstCkl}xp¶iwQcCdebXt feb7¼\r f~tC}+êlŒXXìeÁ † cMk·u0vsiofed~r cCd\mlb7}e}{ic;gYf{iu vQf{b7µCk·iowQ}¼Siofe´ klc }ew•vsb7f{µCk·}{b+t mlb+r f{cQklcQn kl}-de_r d deQb }{sr v_b7}-iIg2mlb+r f{cQklcQnÂp~wQfeµob7}rIfeb cQiod wQcQklµob7fe}~r mQr cstâµr feƒ'gYf{iuÕvQfeio”Qmlb7u/d{i1vQf{i”Qmlb7u;Á  b%b~ÄQvsbXp~d de•b}~r u0b‡dei”_b d{fewQb gÌif | ¹º }+È'deCwQ}-b7µob7cÔ¼\klde•k·cádeQb 96: ;6= ? 9"! @BAC 9 | ¹º Šok·d}eb‰b7u‡}mlk·´ob7mlƒde_r d\pe_r cQnok·c•ndeQb feb‰¼¾rIfxttCkl}{defekl”Qw•deklic Q¸ H »½p~iowQmqtr Ob+p~ddeQbr }eƒCu0vQdeiodekqpOf~r deb i gp~icCµob7fenob7csp~b gÌif iwQf-”_iwQc_tC}-icÕ¸  `  #% &)&'( »‰Á®‚\Qkl} }ew•nnb‰}ede} d¼inoiGrIm·}âgYif'gYwQd{wQfeb0feb7}{b+r f~p{ -wQcsp¶i µb7f{k·c•n deQb µr f{klb7dƒ i g\m·bXr fec•k·c•n‡”_b7srXµCklife}d{sr d&p‰r c;i p‰p~wQfklc | ¹º }+Š r c_t;wQcstCb7f{}ed~r cstCklcQn;de•b gYb+r d{wQfeb‰}-desrIdurI´b k·d#b+r }{k·b‰f&iof srIfxtCb7fZdei'm·bXr fec#ivQd{k·u r mXvsiomlkÇp¶k·b‰}+ÁZ‚\Qb7}ebkl}e}{wQb7}%r cstâide•b7fe} r f{bm·b¶gYd%gÌifgYwQd{wQfeb¼if{´ Á ‡0H /O F 1QB RÌE TZ]_>E 5ÂEGFOV  ‚\Qbr wQd{Qif{}Sd{sr cQ´ ‚ Á GrrI´C´imqrrIcst º Á ¹ rXƒCr c gYiof%wQ}{b~gYwQm tCkl}xp¶wQ}e}{k·iocQ}+ÁÔyZˆ®r ml}eiÂrp{´CcQi ¼\mlb+tCnob7}-}ewQv•vsiofed-gÌfeiu 1ˆ nf~r cCd\a ¹\† Ž … ’C ’ … “•Á



-

ZklnwQf{b „ }{Qi ¼\}r;vQmliod‡i g-¸~Œ ß ` »-µob7fe}{wQ} Ý ¸ »-gÌif de•b 9 : ;6< = ? 9"! @BADC 9 | ¹º ¼\k·d{  GÓ Þ5$< „ rIcstá feb7 ¼\r f~t tCkl}ed{fekl”QwQd{klic½Š6 % ¸ H »7Á‚\Qb klcQ}eb7d}{Qi ¼\}1d{Qb&v•m·iod1iocÀr0m·ion Ž r f{kldeQu0kÇpâ}xp7rIm·b0dei •k·noQmlklnCd1d{QbrI}eƒCu‡vQd{id{kÇpâ”sb7_rXµGkliofi g de•b&”_iwQc_tOÁ\€c vsrIfed{kÇp¶wQmqr f+ŠOrI}2ÝÂØÛÚՊ_deQbw•vQvsb‰f2”_iw•cst ic;¸  `  #% &'&'(7»”_b7srXµb‰}1r }eƒCu0vQdeiodekqp7r mlmlƒ-r } ¸  `  #% &'&'( » Ý Œ ¼\kldeÞ “  ¸Y’o’G» ¼\Qb7f{bde•b2b¶Ä v_ic•b7cCd ÞƐoß“#kl}1tCb7deb‰feu‡klcQbXt-”Cƒ‡d{Qb}emliv_b i g1d{Qb‡mlion Žm·ion vQmlid&rIdmqr fenob‡ÝÁ ‚\Qb0b~ÄQvsiocQb7cCdp‰r cÍrIml}ei ”_bÀµob7fekÐÃsb+tUr csrIm·ƒCd{kÇp‰r mlmlƒÂ”Gƒ®b~ÄsrIu‡klcQklcQn;deQb ”_b7srXµCklif0i g

I¸    » rIcst  ¸   »-klc®deQb;cQb7klnC”_if{QiCi t i gdeQb;iv•dekЎ urImO vsiomlkÇp¶ƒGÁ \b7µob7fe d{Qb7mlb7}{}+Š¼b&tCi‡c•id´CcQi ¼Êi g¾rIcCƒio”CµGkЎ iw•}&u0b7deQiQtM”CƒÀ¼\Qkqp{Âde•k·} v_i ¼Sb7f mqrX¼ p~iowQmqt;srXµb-”_b7b7c nw•b7}e}{b+t ”_b~gYif{b7srIcstOÁ   æ å ³ 3{è1¯Céeæ å ¯ €cÕdeQkl} vsr v_b7f ¼bÂsrXµobÀwQ}{b+tÕu‡b‰deQiQtC}gYfeiouÉ}ed~r d{k·}{dekqp7rIm u‡bXpe_r cQkqp~}-d{iÂ}edew_tCƒ®deQb v•fei”•m·b‰uÖiIg#t b+p~kl}eklicÔrIcst®p~icCŽ def{im”srI}eb+tUicÕklu‡v_b7fgYbXp~d‡}{dxr d{kl}edekqp~}XÁق\Qkl} ¼¾rI}tCiocQbÀklc 6

-

-

-

3



'6

(  (½±B( å ³(Z¯

êlŒ~ì † Á -ÁGjr f{dei_ŠGˆOÁ sÁCj%f~rtCd{´bŠQrIcst-ˆOÁ º ÁCˆCklcQnZÁyOb+rIfecCŽ klcQn d{iÀrp~d#wQ}eklcQn;feb+rImЎËd{k·u0b&tCƒCcsrIu‡kqpv•feinofxrIu‡u‡klcQnQÁ            , •Œ ) ŒX“ •ŠsŒ …… •Á êëXì ¹ Á º Áj%b7f{de}{b7´r }XÁ  L  L    !"$#   %Њ+µoiml}+Á 'Œ &ϐ•Á † de•b7csr1ˆ•p~klb7cCdekÐà p Šj,b7mlu‡iocCd+Š | † ŠOŒ …… QÁ êë“X(ì sÁ † Áj%wsp{´Cmlb7¼Á )  *  0 + ,   $.-0/     !#   1   ¼ S/  i2f{ ´O ŠOŒ 1 …… Q Á   2  Q3Á oiQc  klmlb74ƒ & ˆCiocQ}+$Š hb75 ê ’ ì&aÁ Á Zk·bXpeCd{b7f+Á ‹ p~klb7cCdÂfeb7klcCgÌifxp¶b7u‡b7cCdÂmlb+rIfecQklcQn_Á €7 c 68       *9  ;: ;  "/ A@  B   5= CD/E +  ')   $ GF   H Švsr nob75 }  *) …o„ Á | iofenGrIc Nr w u r c½ŠCˆQr c | rIdeb7i_Šsa † Œ …… ’_Á ê Xì ¹ Á 'r wQ}{}emlb7f+Š | LÁ N'b+r f{cQ}+Š Á-ˆOÁ-ˆCb7wQc•nsŠ r c_ t Á ‚\kl}eC”CƒGÁ hk·noif{iwQ}mlb+r f{cQklcQn p~wQf{µb-”_iwQcst }gYfeiou>}{dxrXŽ dekl}{dekqp7r mCu0b+p{sr cQkqp~}XÁ7€Ic 68   :   J9'  K: C  "/  =?>L@  B   M= /  +  ?)   $ NF  !#  0 Švsr nob7} „ $)  „ Á | if{nGr " c NrIw u r c½ŠˆQrIc | r d{b7isŠ a † ŠOŒ …… ’sÁ 

6

8

(

28

(

ê ì N Á \wsrIcQnsÁ" +  (>   B 7Á oiQc  klm·b‰ƒ & ˆCiocQ}+Š \b7¼MSif{´OŠ$'ŠZŒ …  „ Á ê „ ì | Á | r f~p~wQ}\r cst Á | klcsp Á  H/  H*9  +J    H   +J L  -H/  $ ¶Á ¹ i µob7f+Š$hb7¼5Sif{´OŠOŒ …… QÁ ê ìây%Á N&ÁˆQrIwQmSr c_tˆOÁ º Á½ˆCklcQno½Á | rIfe´oi µÀtCb+p~kl}{k·iocÂvQfeiIŽ p~b7}{}eb7}0klcÏmqr f{nb-}ed~r d{b}{vsrp¶b7}+Á€cM68       J9  

     "/ K@  !B  ! 7= /  +  )   $  F   H ŠvsrInb7} •Œ )Q  •Á † a |:º feb7}{}+5 Š hb7¼ Sif{´OŠ Œ …o… •Á ê … ì Á ˆOÁXˆCb7wQc•nsŠ ÁXˆCiu0vsiom·klcQ}{´CƒGŠ7rIcst Á7‚\kl}{G”CƒCÁ+ˆCd~r d{k·}‘Ž dekqp7rImQu‡bXpe_r cQkqp~}Zi gsmlb+rIfecQklcQn'gYf{iuÊb~Äsr u0vQmlb7}+ Á 6       =     o *) o … ŒoŠsŒ …… QÁ êlŒ+ìâˆOÁ º Á0ˆCklcQn½AÁ \b7klcCgYiofxp~b‰u‡b7cCd®mlb+r f{cQklcQnr mlniofekldeQu0} gYiofSrXµb7f~r nob~ŽËv_rXƒi urIfe´i µCkqr c tCb+p~kl}eklioc-vQfeio”Qmlb7u‡}XÁ €c 68      J9  

  +  3= H9 0   (#    C   $   ‰ŠvsrInb7} „ *) „  QÁ †'†1† € º f{b7}e}XŠ ˆCb+rIded{m·boŠ½Œ …o… ’_Á êlŒŒ¶Sì ÁOˆOÁZˆCwQded{ic½ÁOyzb+r f{cQklcQn dei‡v•feb+tCkqp~d#”GƒMdeQb u‡b7d{QiQtC} i gdeb7u0vsiofxr mtCk b‰feb7csp¶b7}+Á >     )   $  0 … )C’’sŠ Œ …  •Á êlŒ+ì2‚Á  rIde´Cklc½Š † KÁ 'r w½Š½rIcst | Á½j,k·b‰QmÁO‚\Qb-}ed~r d{k·}{dekqp7rIm u‡bXpe_r cQkqp~}-iIgâmlb+rIfecQklcQnÏr;f{wQmlbÁ  0   J9> 0 0  6       ’ …… Ž  •ŠQŒ …o… “QÁ êlŒ+“ìâaÁ  r d{´Ck·c•}Àr cst º Á ¹ rXƒGrIc½Á hŽmlb+r f{cQklcQnsKÁ >    

)   $  % „… )  … QŠ_Œ …o… QÁ ¬  é  ( å %¿² 3{è (½¯ €c deQkl}SrIvQvsb‰cstCkÐÄ&¼b1tCb7feklµob\b _ÁC¸Ë“I’G»ZgYiofdeQb\mqr f{nb7}{db7klnb7cCŽ µr mlwQb#i g\deQb def~r cQ}‘gYb7fu r def{kÐÄzŠ  E ; O 8 D P Š½rIcst b _Á¸“ „ »\gÌif klde}%w•vQvsb‰fS”_iwQc_tOÁ½‚ide•k·},b7cstOŠomlb7d =8tCb7cQiodeb\de•b1b7mlb7u0b7cCde} i g½d{Qb1mqrIfenb‰}edb7klnb7cCµbXp~deiof\i g½de•k·}urIdef{kúÄ&rIcst #0klde}Sp¶ifef{b~Ž }ev_ic_tCklcQn-b7klnb7cCµrIm·w•b   :E ; O 8 D P  P2Þ #08:< ¸Y’ » 8

3 2.5

8

.8

2 1.5 1 exact 0.5

8



(

(













P

‚\Qb;b7mlb7u‡b‰cGd{} i g&d{QbÀu r d{fekÐÄ  :E ; O 8 D P r febÂr mlm'vsio}ekldeklµboŠ r c_tQb7csp¶b\”Gƒd{Qb º b7f{feiocCŽ •feio”sb‰cQklwQ}deQb7iofeb7u;ê „ 쑊X¼bS´CcQi ¼ de_r d ,¸Ykq»Zde•b\mÇrIfenob7}edb7klnb‰cGµrImlwQbSkl}v_i}ekld{k·µobȕ¸Yklkq»Ode•b\b7klnb7cCŽ µbXp~deiof¿p¶ifef{b7}ev_ic_tCklcQndei1d{Qkl}½b7klnob7cCµr mlwQb%srI}½iocQmlƒ2v_i}{kldeklµb b7mlb7u0b7cCde}+Èr c_tá¸YklklkÇ»'cQi iodeQb7f#b7klnb7cCµbXp~deiof&srI}de•k·}#vQfeiovCŽ b7f{dƒGÁ •feiou ¸Ykq»7ŠC¼bp7r c rI}e}ew•u‡bdesrIdSd{Qbb7klnob7cCµb+p~d{if\}~r dŽ kl}Ãsb‰}-deQb0cQif{ur mlklÒ+rIdeklicÂp~ic_tCkldeklic  8 =8)Þ ŒÁ  }eklcQn de•k·}XŠCkld\k·}\}{def~r klnCdgÌife¼\r f~t-d{i-}eQi ¼ÕdesrId ¸Y’»  8 Þ Ü Œ # ¸~Œ 6 8 » J Ü Œ I #  ¸xŒ  " ; G-"» G M 6 8 }eiomlµb7}b _ÁC¸Ì’ »‰Š ¼\kldeC #-p{Qi}{b7c-klc&r'}eb7mÐgqŽep~ic•}ekl}ed{b7cCdgËr }{Qklic dei0}xrIdekl}gYƒ  8  8 Þ ŒÁˆCwQu0u‡klcQn”_id{ }ekqtCb‰}2iIgSb _ÁZ¸Y’ » i µb‰f 4dei-b7c gYif~p~bde•k·}1p¶icQ}{defxrIklcGdXŠC¼Sb#i”Qd~r klc Œ\Þ Œ ,# K D J + Œ "Ü G -  #   6 8; G  ¸Y’ „ » 8 ¼\Qkqp{Àkl}b owQklµr mlb7cCd'dei b _ÁZ¸Ë“ ’C»7Á \b7csp¶bŠ”Cƒ }eiom·µCklcQn-d{Qkl} b owsrIdeklic¸ÌcCwQu‡b7f{kqp7r mlmlƒQ»7ŠQ¼b i”Qd~r klcÀr cMb7klnb7cCµr mlwQb#i gSd{Qb def~r cQ}‘gYb7f'ur d{fekÐÄ-¼\Qi}{b2b‰k·nob7cCµb+p¶deif'kl}\nklµb7c0”Cƒ‡b _ÁO¸Ì’ o»7Á 6



6

-

-

-

/







-

-

/





-

8





bound

0 0

0.5

1

1.5 λ

2

2.5

3

ZklnwQf{b  f~r vQQkqp7rIm-}eiom·w•deklicÊiIgb o}+Á¸Ë“I’G»;r cst4¸Ë“ „ »‰Á ‚\Qb/tQrI}eQbXt mlklcQbÊkl}ÔdeQbÅvsiomlbÊdesrIdÔiQp7p~wQf{}/r d #  Þ urÄ 8  68 G   ;  k·cáb _Á¸Ë“I’G»7Á ‚\Qb m·i ¼b7f vsioklcGd i gklcGd{b7fŽ }ebXp~deklicÂkl}d{Qb‡}{imlwQd{k·ioc gÌifdeQb0b~Äsrp~d#b7klnb7cCµr mlwQboŠ #ZÈdeQb wQvQv_b7f\v_iklcCd\kl}\deQb}eiomlwQdeklicgYif\kld{}SwQv•vsb7f'”siowQcstOÁ 6

'





‚i‡b7c•}ewQf{bd{sr d#iwQf}eiomlwQdeklicÂp~iofefeb‰}ev_icstC}-d{i de•b   *  b7klnb‰cGµrImlwQbŠ7kldOkl}Ob7cQiowQnd{i\}eQi ¼á¸Y”CƒdeQb º b‰fefeiocCŽ Qf{i”_b7cQklwQ} de•b7if{b7u»d{sr d1rIm·mZdeQb#b7mlb7u‡b7cCd{}\i g =8SrIfebv_i}{k·d{klµbÁ •feiu b _Á¸Ì’ »âdeQkl}¼\klmlm%”_b-defew•b‡kÐg #  #  Þu rXÄ 8  68 G   ;  Á \# ioÞ deb# d{sr r csd't0deQdeb _r fed2klnorIG”sd'i sµor bc_det •k·}e}'kqtCµb r mli wQgSbb Š•skld1ÁZ¸u‡“ ’Gio»hcQisd{r i}cQkqr-p7rIv_mlim·ƒ-mlb&tCrIb~dŽ p~f{b+r }{b7}+ ŠOr v•vQfeiCrp{QklcQn‡r#ÃscQkld{b2µrImlwQbr $} # Ø"ÚÕÁ ZklnwQf{b  klmlm·w•}edef~r d{b7}\deQkl}'”sb7_rXµGkliof+ŠQr mliocQn-¼\klde deQb#nfxrIvQQkqp7rImO}eimlwCŽ deklioc dei b _ÁZ¸Ë“I’G»hgYifrfxr c_tCiuvsiom·kqp~3ƒ 2 @Ԗ $ XŒ ¢  ‰ÈOdeQb }eiomlwQdeklic'iQp7p~wQf{}%¼\Qb7f{bSd{Qb%vQmlid{}½iIg d{Qb%mlb~gYdr cstâfeklnCdOsrIcst }ekqtCb‰}SklcCdeb7f{}eb+p¶d+Á%€dkl}SbXr }eƒ-d{i&}{b7b'gYfeiouÙdeQbhÃsnwQf{bdesrId%deQb b owsrIdeklic srI}ârwQcQk owQb}{imlwQdeklioc dei0deQb feklnCd\iIgSdeQb v_imlb r 6d # Á \b‰csp~bŠ,deQkl} mÇrIfenob7}ed}{imlwQd{k·iocÏp~if{feb7}{vsiocstC}-d{i deQb urÄQk·u‡rImOb7klnb7cCµrIm·w•b-i g1de•b-defxrIcQ}gÌb7f-urIdefekÐĽŠOr }-p~mqr klu‡bXt klc‡}{b+p~deklioc ’sÁëQÁ ‚i‡io”QdxrIk·c;r c wQv•vsb7f#”siowQcstMic d{Qkl}2b‰k·nob7cCµr mlwQbŠz¼Sb cQid{b de_r dd{Qb }ewQu0ur c_t klcÏb _Á,¸Y’ „ »kl}&r;p~iocGµob~ÄÂgYwQc_p~deklicái g Hr 8ec_Át €c ŒÁvs‚\r f{•deb7kqcp~wQmqr fXŠC}ewQv•vsio}ebd{sr d H 8kl}\”_iwQcst b+t0”sb7d¼b7b7c; Œ U # "Œ G J I #   Œ -G # Œ G M H 8  #    ; -G ¸Ì’ o» ¼\Qb7f{b1d{Qb1wQv•vsb7f”_iwQcst klc-b _Á•¸Y’ »kl}%d{Qb1mlklcQb+rIf½gÌwQcsp~d{k·ioc klc H 8OdesrId×klcCdeb‰fev_imqr d{b7}%”_b7d¼Sb‰b7c‡d{Qb\mlb~gYdsr c_t}{kÇt bÎ }%µr mlwQb r d H 8 ÞՍr cst H 8 ÞŌÁˆCwQ”Q}{dekldew•deklcQndeQkl}mlklcQb+r fzgYwQcsp¶deklic i g 8Gc•id½iocQmlƒ\mlb+rtC}Zdei1rIc2w•vQvsb‰f½”_iwQcstzŠ+”•wQd×rIm·}{i\b7csrI”Qmlb7}½iocQb deH i#vsb7f‘gYif{uÙdeQb'}ewQui µob7f%}{dxr d{b7}\klc-deb7f{u‡}%iIg½deQb'µr f{kÇrI”Qmlb7} K D-Þ  8 6 8 rIcst D-Þ  8 6 8 8 Á‚\CwQ}+Š_}{wQ”Q}ed{kldewQd{k·c•n b _ÁC¸Ì’ ? »ZklcCdeib _Á•¸Y’ „  »r cst#b7? µr mlwsrIdeklcQH n'deQb'}ewQuÅi µb7f%}{dxrIdeb7} nklµob7}1¸rXgYd{b7f\}eiou‡br mlnb7”•fxr» ; #AUÊ Œ J I G0# ¸~Œ 8G #_» M  D J I #¸ #  ¸xŒ  "-G-G-»~¸~»¶Œ ¸ # - G- »» M  D < ¸Ì’ … » \b‰vQmqrp~klcQndeQkl}OklcQb owsrImlk·dƒ'”Cƒ1b owsrIm·kldƒCŠ~¼Sb,feb+p~i µob7f½d{Qb%vQf{b~Ž }xp¶feklvQdeklioci gQb _Áo¸Ë“ „ »_gÌifOi”•dxr klcQklcQn1rIcwQvQv_b7f”_iwQcstâicdeQb b7klnb‰cGµrImlwQ$b #½Á‚\•b2nofxrIvQQkqp7r mO}{imlwQd{k·ioc-dei-d{Qkl}Sb owsrIdeklic0kl} r ml}{i}{Qi ¼\cÏklc ZklnwQf{5b QŠ¼\Qb‰feb kldkl}b+r }{klm·ƒ;}eb‰b7c®desrIdkld ƒCklb7mqtC}¾rIc wQvQv_b7f1”_iwQc_t‡ioc‡d{Qb}eiomlwQdeklic0dei-b _Á_¸“ ’G»‰Á 6

6