VESPA: A Benchmark For Vector Spatial Databases


    ! #"$ &%'"()+* ,-'"$+./$ 0/ 1243658749&:=7@?A2B9DCFEHj GI9>;HNkJ03Aai2@KlKL7M_`3OQTNP9[9:R7MQTSU9HSTQVN 7M5Xj WYSV7ME[9Z\=2]W^7M5X?A367BQTbOW#m _`QTa)?A36QVbOcdEDe`STQUfBa\ghQUaiKE n#oOprq)sutwv‰o6oOswx@~tyituyiŠŒz|‹{$q)yituvtŽ#p]}Bx]tw~~xBoA€\sw‘uqi~t“x]’@ƒ”B‚|‚d4„oO~ˆxM…6tu•Bsw}B~…†swqi€F„‡–H‚h”4#xB€F— ~x]oOoAsw~ˆxB€ o6q)v+sutwqiv~„™˜]oO–Bx@ty)š›yiqYz|s^{$]yiœ#v…OoOp]oF}B –@twoAšžs qi 4…F…O~}]oOŸxB…OoF¡ # n O o r p #xB~ˆFo6sw‘u~¢t£’ yizh¤8oOqYv+x]…^qi–]~„™oO˜r‘¥xBtwoAyis†sw”[v ¦œ#§M…OzV‘OyYs^v+©qY¨ªx>y qiqF…F[ }B”kŸ ¤8qYx]…^–]oO‘¥twoAs†”r#— u‘€i« prs^¬®qiqYpBtw­O~ˆ–]¯6qY°Y~„>…L±]B²F~qYxB¯Ft^zT³'qyisw´ qYv+qisw…6oLq)~ˆtw„~~ˆ~¢vyitw~xƒpkoO‘0yY‘¥su’4zVt^yi‘¥qitws0x@oOtwvt$–Btw‘Oo'yB‘¥¶›v+twyi–]qis^~x@‘qY’+€F–]o qYqip]‘qip]x]€F„&~~…†o6q)qYx©twxr~ˆqYyisw„~x]’4‘u‘OoL‘u”]~‘0twqiy\x]yiq0z„ˆs^q)q)qiswswx]oL€F€io+…OoLoOµ@x@yi}rtuz‡s^qYpBqYxM„rswtwyFtw~¢twpky'~yioO€F‘ž‘wo6qiyiyY„‘Šz zV‘¥yi’Bs‘¥tw‘uo6p]vqY‘tw~ˆqitw„$yP]•kqYo t^q©}]‘uvo†yMB…OoO„„o†‘qYx]qix]„¢’·&qi‘ux]yizUt£š›o6¸qYsw…Oo ~oOqYx@swtw…^„¢–]’~¢twšŽoO…6~¢twtw–·}4swoO‘upr‘0qYtwtw–r~ˆqYqY„Žt]qYqY„„ˆt^y†qMšld‰#]q)y†t^š›qio6•rqYo6‘us†o ” •kyiqiz„¢oOtwoO–]‘ux'}]yi…^}]zTo6–€Fš¼–‘¥’4‘¥v+’4‘¥tw‘¥qioOtwx@voO’¹v+‘Ohq)‘utwpr¶›~ˆqY…–Btw…6~~ˆ‘\qYyF„0v~‘\]prpBqYq)t^swswqYyi~‘u•r•ryFqYqix]‘u•B‘|o„¢’·yi‘¥zk’4qYtw‘¥t–Btwo›oO„o†vzVqY}]‘©‘¥xBt…6–]twprq†~q)yFsux]o&twqi„¢•k’„~¢o6t£’oOBxº}]yYo+s|•Btwtw}]–ByX~„¢ot†tw”›pk–]o6o©twsu–]zV„UoAyYqYswsw…Ao»v+Ÿ»–rqiyix]q†zž…6qoo šŽq~U•k4oOoOxB„¢’ƒ…A–B}Bv+‘uo†qYHsw”BŸ‘¥t^zVyiqis+x]]Fq)oOs^…6ƒtwyi‘us'prq)‘utwpr~Uq)qYtw„®~UqY]„#q)t^BqiqY•]t^qiqY‘u•ro0qi‘u•ko6oO‘'x]…^tw–]–rv+q)tq)sw…OŸky)4o6¶›sw–]‘~‘qXp]s^qiqipkxBo6€Fsªo8p4yYswzoO‘ut“oO’4x@p]tw~¢‘Š …†~ˆx©qi„Ht£š›½#y¾¥ \‘¥’4zT}]‘¥twxBoO…6vtw~yF‘O˜Bx]tw‘O–]”4ožqYxryi•4¿£‘uoO–]…6y†tušŽŠŒsw‘›oO„ˆ–BqYy†tw~š¼yFx]twqi–]„doªB•kqYoOt^x]qi…^•]–]qiv+‘uo`q)swÀ‡Ÿ'yF‘¥–]twqi€Y‘$swo)•k ]o6ÁLoOx+Âd”k~ˆvqix]pB©„oOvtw–]oOox@tw4o†o6 Š twpBB–]sw}]o#y)…AMtw¨ª~ˆ~UF4¦žo'o† 4»yF‚·•M•@¿¥’»qio6„…6€FtwtuoO–BŠÃ•4yio+s^swq4~‘¥oO’Brx@‘¥¶›twtwo†o6–]voL‘'B•kqYoOqYt^xBxrqi…A»•]–Bqiv+tw‘uyoqYswqi¨ªŸ\„„¦žy†‘uoAšÚ‡bOà@c[á 5X7MÖD36mraY9>W|bO7Mc[365XaÑ>7MW^36aYmrҌWiÑ[EkSrKž?Ac[c[QTQV9[bOcÓ]WY7M;@36ÔLa`c[?Oai7M3A36aLÓ47MaY36?AaªaiN»?wK#7@2?LÕH?6c[3AQTa+9Hã]b)QTÑ[ÕHai74W^S]?AQTmr24QT9¹9HN[ä W›Kž24cHÒH7@Ö>?0aibY9H74bO9»c[5X?Ac[7MQVW036m‡WA׆årØOW^Ùk?AÚDai5 ÛYÜ NQVkÝ£WƒÞÃ2rß æB?Ac[çUèrQVWX7Mޙݣ9HâWAN8årW^é[?AêYaiëŒ5PØ ß æ4ë†çTìX;Žîuà@9ºÚ‡Û6?Aêc[ÖDa·aY749HÖHbOWAcHaY589HbY74a&3Amk24WiÒ`E4KžÖDc[aY9HQVbObOc&c[5XWAaY74ai3Am mk?6Wi2©E58749H74W^mrK#QU9[aY3ªÓ¼?ANkc[aYa'?6ã]7MQTÑ[STaiaiNïW^?AQTb)2424958ä c[ÕH2@74Kí3AQVWAÒÃ247B9HWw?W ÖDÓBaYa)9[?wK#ai36aY74aiSU9¼STåP74NkSˆ?6QUñXaY36bY9HÑ[7@SU?6?iQU;fBa8j 9»Õ[3A2@2BfBÕ>aY2]36WAfr74QUSTaiW\KòbY242M9HқbYN[aY7@36?O9[7MQUÖH9H7BÓ&W^a\?6c[ÖDaYaYQT39HbOҌc[Ñ[5X9>b†74?A3AQT24mk9>W#7MQTW0STQˆ?wÕ[åð3A2@24fr3+QVNkÕDaiaYN3AҌÖr24åð365Xó ô@7Mõ¥9H; bYaƒQVW Ö?6Hc[7BaªW^aFÔLø0N8c[eW^a ÕHù#747MZÑk?AQV?Aúí7McHSH24ø0NH3OWL7@e'?6Ö>gh74aFÖHgXbY747MNkWA58aiaFWNka ÑH7M7b)?KL?A7MQT7Mf49836aŽa\aF2B7M2MÖk36Ò$ûwSUåƒai?Ab)c[Ww?^a?Oö¥7M249[Ó436aYQUažaiaF9BQTN»98?6aiҌ?A24N'cH3aYN[QT7X7@3?OWANk7MÑ[aFÖHQUW^?67BQT7MW^Ó4ÖHaž98SUó a+ü[2MÒdE6ÖDý@7aYõ¥9>; WAjbOÕHc[7@?d5X?6?AQTcH747MQTS[36WhmPa)Õ>÷rҌ2B?624QUaY39]9H?hf4WAQUaiQU2B?|b)98?AKL2B?A743^2 Wö ?6QTbY58ai24W^58Õ>?2BÕH?A3^7McH?O36a+7MQV9]W^Ҍ2B?ªÑ[9H9H?6WX2b)?AKžQVQTNk24QUaY9H?A9]c 74?ASUQUQU74?wҌåPåSˆ?6aY7 2M36Ò9HWAÑ[?67@c[QU?6?6aƒQU74fBÖ[aðø0SUa`e74Õ[Ö>ù#Õ[aiZþ9H362BbOúÿ74c[bO5XcHø07Maie'Wi36m8; gh
0Õ[gI369k24WAҌåkÓ42BWw3O3^?67M?6aYÑ[55 9H7M?AcH7M?AaY9>7MST?LNå4ELbY?A242»9[Ñ[2º7MSVNXSTa)SU2@÷kÖDKÅQVa`Ww?6Ñ>ÕDQU9[W^aYaFÓº3ANPҌ24Õ[ÖD36Ñ[582MÖ[?A74STcQV9Hb)?Ab)STå2a

HÖ7f@7B7MW^QTaFSVN&7MÖ[WASTÕHa&7MÖD?AQVaY7M9>SdbON[c[7M5X?67M7MÖ>36m74WAab)2B?OÑ[7MST36NºÓ4a)ÖD?6aiaNҌ24?A2@Ñ[KL9HNº7M3ON[?6cHW#7@W^?PÕH7MKL?A74QV7MW8SdWAã]Ñ[Ñ[Qˆai?O3A7MårÖ[QTST9[aÓXҌ247M3X9HN»Ñ>W^7Ma9H74KžSUåkQU?AWAcRQTWi; 7¹f4aib)?A2B3^ö óÖD aY 9Hõ£ÔLbOEcHc[Kž58a`c[74Ö>QVbO3AaFcímïWw?LcHQVW&mr749[WPaY2@÷kÖ>KžÕ[ai9XSUaYQVb)9Ra)QU÷k?ASTÑHQVåòWwWA?6aiQU7M9[Nï9 Ó QT9íÖ>ai7Mai7¼3A9H?AbOc 9rc[Ñ[5XWA5©bY7MQUÖ>36aimƒai9H3Pb)ҌaF242MW3ÒWAÖDWAÕHaYa)7M9H?^?A?6bOQVQUcH7M9HS‡58ÓBN[W·747@3Aó?Om‡ 7MELÖH E 7M7B H9HW^E aFNò W@QTQTõ¥
WW»;ªÔLc[
QTc[Ó4 a c[
'STåíe`
24î j36QU
'ai9]e`?Aî aij N ?6Ҍ2B2@3`K#ÑH7436WAN[aƒWPKž36Qˆ7B?6cðWw?6aYfB3&aib†NH?6247@?63\7HW^;#Õ>ÔL7@?AcHQV7MQTW»SN[QVW7M?63674aiÖH7B74W^2BWAai9HWi7M;>Ö[îuST9¹a4E74Ö[N[ÑkN[?Qˆ?6QU5X2B9d7MEdm4aF74WW 

'
\e`e`îî jj 2BQU9HÕ>74aiÕ[367MÕ[?A36aF24WÕ[36KžQV7@QU?A?Ac a 367BaiWƒ74?AS#c[N[a7M?62B7¹9[a·W^aYN[?6Wi7@E›?O7¼Qˆ?XW^QVaYW©?58b)Ñ[2B363A3Aa»ai9]Nk?AQˆSTñPåbYW^Ñ[ÑHSˆ?8Õ[Õ[?6ST2¹QUaFaYN÷kÕ>Ҍ2Bai33AQT58aY9]?ƒ
\Kže`QUî?Aj cïNkWw?OQ D7M9Hai3AN[aiW9B?P7@?N[7M7M?6367¹24ÑHW^9HaYN?8WA Q 'YaiÖdWiE; j 9[2M?6c[aY3|Õ>ai3^Ҍ2B3A5X7M9>b)aª749H7MSTåkW^QVWdQVWhÕH3A2@frQVNkaiN\ÖråXó  õ£EFÖ[Ñk?$?AcHQTW|QTW|582436aŽ2436QTaY9]?AaFN+7M3624Ñ[9>N cHK#N[7M7B24?6WL3674mXÖ>ÖHaicH74aY74WA9aŽW0ÕD7M9[9242MÕ[?0aiÑ[5ƒÖDSV7@aYÕH?6aicHQU92B749+ҌWA24QT?6WLSTcHSU2@2B7MK#9»9 ai?A?ANc[c[aa?Ac[?AÓB36QTaY58249[ÑHaaiÓ436?Oc»7M7M?AmBQUQT9]24aY?A99»28Ҍ2M2B?6Òc[3›W^a+74ÕH9HÕ[7M7M36?A24STQVåk7MÕDW^Sd2BaFN[W6WY7M7M;iS‡?6îu7X9©24қWAWAa)24bY?O5824W58a#ŒÕ[a43ASTaF; ÓHa)b)?A;|aYa9]ó ?$ÖD )aYKõ 9>†2BE[bO3Ac[Ö[m‡5XÑ[Ei?ž?A7Mc[?A36aic[mr3AQVWiaW ; aYe÷k?674c[58j aY3Õ[SUÕ[a'3624Ҍ2kÕDb)2BÑ>W6W^7MQTSV9[W'Ó8cH2479f4aƒW^Õ>ÖD7@aY?AaYQV9¼7MSr9Hûw2B74QU3A9362@74K#SUÓBaY243'36QUQˆ9 ?6c[W65Xb)24W'ÕDóaƒ ! 4?AõdcH24743ž9 QT9H7»NkbYaY24÷r58QT9[Õ[ÓSTa)ó ?6aXü@õ¥Ö>; ai9HbOc[5X7M36m‡E‡ÒŒ243 Ҍ582B3aY9]f4?OaFWYÖDb†× ?6aY249H3AbOö£c[ÖH5X7BW^74aF3AN¼mXW^KžÕHc[7M?AQVbOQV7McS#QTN[WL7@36?Oai7Mã]ÖHÑ[7BQT36W^aiaFNXW ?6WAc[2824?AÑ[aFSVWwN¼?LҌQVÑ[Nk9Hai74b)SU?ASTQTå 249HWA747MSU?AQU?wQVWwå&Ҍå¹749H?AN»cHaP74W6Ҍ24W^aFSTSTWA2@W#KžÕDQU9[aY3AÓҌ243A36aF58ãBÑH74QU9H36b)a)a ö

B
; 74WAaL2M҇ÑHW^aB;4îu58Õ[STaY58aY9]?O7@?AQT249824ÒD?6c[aN[7M?67W^?A36ÑHb†?6Ñ[36aiW7M9>NXãBÑHaY36QUaFW›2M҇?Ac[aÖ>ai9HbOckö 5XWAc[742B3AÑ[m¼STN&W^cHÖD24a+Ñ[WwSV?6N 36749[QU24ÓB?©cB?AÖDҌ24a36K#ÕH74743^36?6NdQT;bYÑ[ST743ASTåð?AQT5ƒa»b)2B9HW^ÑH5ƒQT9[Ó>E$749HN 24Ö[?67MQT9[QT9[ÓN[7M?67ðW^aY?6W  ;#:RQVNka83O7M9[ÓBQU9[ÓҌÑ[9Hb)?AQT249H74SUQU?wå‡×dÔLc[a8Ö>ai9HbOc[5X7M36m·W^cH24Ñ[SVN7BWAWAaiW6W`7BW'ST743AÓBaƒ7&36749[Ó4a 24Ò$WAÕH7@?6QT74SdN[7@?O7MÖH7BW^a'ҌaF7@?AÑH3AaFWž74WLÕD2BW6W^QTÖ[STa4; üH"; SV[b7MY367MÓ4SVa7MÖH7BQUWžSTQˆ?wQTWå‡×@3Aî¥aF?ªã]Ñ[WAc[QU3624aiÑHNSTNƒ?A2&ÖDažbY7MÕ>362]36åPWAWAQU24ÖHÑkSUaL??6?A2c[a+Ó4aYÕD9HaYaY3A3OҌ247@36?A5XaLN[7M7M9H?6bY7aWA7Ma)9H?674W$SU?6åkcHWA7@ai?ªWL74?6cH3Aaž7@?`7BWŽ743AW^a\5X3674aYSUSTSkaY2Bf@3Ž7M9]74?W ?62X7©Õ>7M3A?AQVb)Ñ[SV7M30bY249]?AaY÷]?F; W?6A28aY9]W6?A_`7@aF?6NƒÑ[QTW^a\QUҌ9XåP?A28?6?6c[c[?6QVc[aiWŽWAa+ÕHa7M7474ÖHÕ>W#WAaiaYҌ3ª2B9>KLSUb)STa2@74K0WŽ2MWYқNk$× ai7Mf4#09raiåà SU%Y2BWAê Õ>Ñ[aFQU?6N®Ø7M;4&ÙÖHîu%YSU98aê ?6aY'aY÷r36QUQV58?W^?AWªcHQT9[7B2MÓXWžÒ‡?AÖ>78cHaib)a9H24bO7M58c[ÖD5XÕH2@7Bf47Mb†a036?0m‡bYW63AErbOQU?A?Ac[c[aiaYa3A5XQV7[ÖD7[EMaYE[QU9>?#74bObi9Hc[7MN5X987MN[ÖD367@a`mP?O7©WAÕ[aYҌ36aY24a)9 3ö ?624aiқW^WA?A5XQT9[7MÓ`STS®ÕHÑ[?AaF3AWwÕD?02B?OWA74aiWAW$mkQVW#W$Ó4Ҍ24aY309HaYKž3Oc[7@?AQVbOaFcN+ÕDWAå]aY9]3AҌ?6ß 24c[36a)58?6QT74bi7M9HSTb)SUaå‡)è bi7M( 9+Þ * Ö>ê0a ë65ƒà@-Ú aF, 74Þ WA-Ú Ñ[,.36ai'LN®Qˆè0?/®cHÛ67BàMW›áUà71YSVáU7Mê236Ó4'a?69]c[ÑHa 5 N[ÖD7M?6aY7 3 ÓB24ÒLaY9[WAaiQ i36ai7MWi?AE®QT24Ҍ9P3624WA5-2Mҙ?wf4KLaY7M36å36aWAbY5X749P7MSTS“Ö>Eda'5XÑH74WAQUai9 NP58?A2©aY58bY242B9H3AW^å¹?A36N[ÑH7@b)?#?O7N[7MW^aY?67M?6W\Ö>74?6WA2·aiWªf4ai?A3AcHå·7M?LSV7M74363AÓ4a0aP24NHÒ|7@7+?67KžQVWANka)a'?OW\3674?A9[c>Ó47@a? 5XÕDWAQUaY5©7M3O36W^Ñ[m©QVSVW^7@?A?A?AaY2©a#9]?A?SVai7MW^"ù36?#Ó48a?Ac[8 W6a`bY74W^ҌSUåkÑ[a#W^9H?A5Xb)ai?A957MQT24ÕH9HW›74bY÷kSU2@QU2k?wf4åXNkaYÑH367MQTWƒ9[9HÓNó 7@7`õ£Õ>E‡aiST?6743^c[3AҌ2BaƒÓB3Aa#245X74Ök7M3AûwaF9>aF7[b†b)?^;aö¥Ôh36242\aYÒ®SV7@N[?Ac[?A7@QTa?624a49>'E7MK#3î S›a#N[jc>7@7?Oø07Mf4"ùÖHaª7B4Ñ>W^îwW^aƒ61 aFN+5›=›e2B?6c[W^?AaLó Ó4 Ö>367aaiõ¥$E49H?6'bOc[ckg a ö WA74ó  ÕHÖ> 47@2@õ£?6fBEhQTa74?ASHc[a)a»aY÷k÷]Õ>Nk?6aiaYai3A9HNkQTWAÑ>aYQT9>b†24?Ab)9HQTaif4W'WPa»ó YcH24õ£7ErÖ[f47Mûwaai9>b†NPWA?Ac[ö£ø02B2@3AeKžQTaY9íù#9]Zl?6?6aicHN¼úWŽ7M3636749[Ó4aFNƒQU9 *ð3A2@K0W#KžQU?Ac,*¹bY24STÑ[589HWi;>ù#7M3ONkQU9>7MSTQˆ?wå‡×*+


´ ~oO„ˆ.-#qivo „ˆ„ˆqYqYxrxr xBs y†išŽqi„xB}Bo6o s

´ ~ˆo6„U©nLo0/rxB~¢tw~ˆyix {$yFvvoOx@tw‘ ~ˆpkx@yFtw„¢oO’4€i€Fo6yFs x o6oO§M€Ftw}Bo6sw„Uq)xrs#qY„>–B¾“o6n §Bqi€iyFx w s ‘¥tusw~ˆxB€21436587 x8€FoOBxB~4o69[s^o6qYswtwo6o†xM tªs^x]qiqixrv4yFoOv‘ „¢’ :ryq)t ; ±]=¬ ,@r³ nžqYt^q`‘uo6tª„UqYxr4y)šŽx

´ ~oO„ˆ. -#qivo ‘¥‘¥t^t^q)q)twtwoOo xrqYvo pkyip]}]„ˆq)tw~ˆyix

´ ~oO„ˆƒn#0o /rxB~tw~yix {$yivvoOx@tw‘ ‘¥pktuyisw„¢~’BxB€i€2yF1436x 587 sw€io6oO€Fx]}]oA„ˆs^q)qYs#two†–B©o6§Bs^qiqY€Fxryi4x yFv„¢’ ~x@twoO€i; o6±Bs =¬ < >H³ nžq)s^t^qYq'xr‘u4o6yFtªv