Relational Clustering for Multi-type Entity Resolution

Relational Clustering for Multi-type Entity Resolution Indrajit Bhattacharya

Lise Getoor

Department of Computer Science University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742, USA

Department of Computer Science University of Maryland College Park, MD 20742, USA

[email protected]

[email protected]

ABSTRACT



   
!"#$%&')(*+,'-'.$0/


12  3435
76+$ 8+9
1 $
:8 ;=?
@ $"  $"
=' '.$
A$
:87(BC(*"5 96! 9D?C6+$$4
E F0>' 05 G5
76+$ 8 
1A$
:8
76CE H'.$
I)$0G
8/ ;HJ* -$'.$$
GLKM*C$
:8H'N6+OP
H+MH
76 4-7
4
)%+M-'N
8%QQ
6Q,KM-0" ?6#G  44";SR2T+"M"004 U#8%V405 F'.4 5W$
1 '.$
XD:
1
Y$"5
S6+8OP$
 9"
T7# #3K0$?6Z4"
1S 4%+M62$'[$
$;VRM"0%+M6 $
:8\0" 5 
2
 9#9
7 B6 X3,$ 95 W$
1!+"K 9$ 
76& 0
,$]+M$4
X ^$05 8,"
2 B6 X0()
1\_/ +#?4
)#?$>00K5+$/`K706!4:6  )()
! 9#9
C#

"$X16N;


)0X $'[$)QC4E
8% ; x

'[$
F46 XAE7?B0"'[^$] 4 H+M"1X+/

 >$0ATQ5 89 ! 0$
:X#"
A05 y3KK $+9#/ "
P0T
S$] $>"40"
S6+ E
>05+z4,'.>0 9:
1 6 5  $Q
V05XY0;2JnX6 8"
7 )  ? L\$
:8 0 95+"
QK06\
+#]+FW0
1X
1/ 9+;!{34$
:F+?X$Q 90!XD?_ 9
7 G049 9# 
5
;A|E$] 4 "78'^(*FF47
1_%(*4$
05  X6 _'[!e }""
rq> "fG
76ce }""

rqE f9B$Z#!4

D? 8TLKMEE4E
76+9:96 5 N8's$T#CKM3#06 e }"

0EqE "f;^%
$*(BX6++ >W0
1F04 U#8%'n 00K 5 --XD?$
3
_$"5
: K5+-0Q _* E049 9# ' EM EQ()~EM0"
!- 96P; J*+"K KM4F4
:W
1\()
(B36+S
 005 4aB A$ U#6T$
:8*?> 8"6:KM
0" ?6P; %
_'.$+6+$$4

1E7G%(B,$X6+G$'[$BCA4)
76+8/

1.

INTRODUCTION


V
2 9"
G $TS$'a(*+L')$/

:96 57 ?>
C5 
,  9(V5 n)D"G66+
7 "9
+'.$$
;s%
 $^(*X6  G0" 5 
+ 0HKM4-€.‚ƒ0„m€[…‚;*{!


'[$0
12 !4\5
76+$ 8 
12
8% ;b?
c2 9 9


6 
L
+"" ?Q5  94 M$Q'a
8H
'a() 9X

'*$'[$
$E3
8N(*Q(B"5 96& 9D?F!"dE6 $$4
F 

\KMFM
9  8 QK 1"55;FJ* Q K †
S
:?" ?

$"  $"
S'He 05 "f 5
76+$ 8+9
1Q
8A
6TKMdB$0$ 8T

0 9:
1\L5 8 L+MC'-$
:8FC _4_4L50
1

 >
8%Q$'.$$
)
A"  $"
TF 0E
8;HJ*

E6 8OP$
) 9"
AA#C"K0?6!4"
1F!;

+"K 9$g4B5 49

L1"5 90$* "5 1" "5 G45 B08/ $
";Ah] 4 9$A
 576 ,45+$A+0"
N7(),(B,
63

J*a
8%_0 5 "
T "K g*1
$X#6"
0U6+$XK  
$WC
SQ 
F 9

13 8$X5+Q
 8Y‡ ˆ‰+BŠ‹:

i 1"5+F5 A()
!$1""
>
!%(B6 8OP$
a91")$'[$>_ 

ˆŒ:nŠ#ŽI
6T0"4a's 0C "X*$0" ?CQ5 89 a%+M

4C5
6 $ 8+
1QK+j%$Lk.E$00M
76 $
C+"K dl+
0/

'*
‡ ˆ#‰ GˆŒ:*Š#Žo;T
 9,M$n(*4M"0_+M6&$
:8

5+X H 9
1571"  $009
1!()
(*Q(B"5 962 D?_\6+$$4


0 95+"
r
Y 9"
 a6X & 5W$
1  K !;YR

() 
5
+X0B'.$*,A4A5
6 $ 8+
1,
8%\km$/

 M"0a094 98405+B7#*
096 - 9"
-KM$%(B


'.$
_0 95+"
Mdl
76 6#XK70I() $"n()
4$1"
1


8B'nL5 8 -%+MH
"66+89
_C8B00K5+;R

(*T6#XK70EE 

1TT6 XK70M(*L(B"5 U6\ D?,T6+$/

 0Z 0$
:+ 94
0r] M94$
:X A$05 83
r%(*V

49
() 
Y%(*S5 $X6 #T$'[$0
1&& T4

8X
@6 X0$FQ6 4
W0X#_"6+"
X1"$Q'-$ U#/

 n(B 963K+j%$Lko6 6+5 #9
!
767p#AX63 9
D"1"#d;

"
 I$
:840" 5 
\"$a00K5+$/`"
 8K70 
;

q>6 5  "
&E4M0X
:>
6 X 

1T'[CKM2$/ $5 X 
 8+0!
6c'.!W0/OP$?
0;g
r
'[

1X"
Ns6+$$4

1 ]+)jW9
EC
$00\'[ $"
0 U6 
1L
'."
'[tL5 8 A0"5 $l+4"WG'[$
 $S()9  ,
!KM Z5
9u 5SD?$@7#!
vKM 506r\jW
XK \
b6 W0K5 6b6 XK0C
76=(*2Q5WT
'[$\()
(*SX6 Q'U"w6+OP
46#XK0GM"00K 8Y()8Z6 8OP$0/

2. RELATED WORK

J*374KM
Z

9#1"!KM:6:Y'>(BDV
c6+6 5  "
N

X6\ 9
D"1""P
76!/o$'.$$
,0" 5+9
n;)a$C(*,:9( 0"4'A
(BDMBK 5 F:$(_
_$]+5W?; |>L
C054#0_M00CR=
D+ $,‡ ˆ‘Žo; J**0X6 8"
 7+?XL>
,0" 5 
4 9 D:B#$]:/ 57 n04 98%
T C6 $0$ "
a'sE$
:8;GJ*E7 KM
$]:
0?-(*DQ"
6  i

1F ]+)W0
1,04 U#0/ 8%F405 -‡8Š‘::ˆ Š"+’ ?‹#Ž ^,KM*506,'[H5
05M$:06 
8%Z0" 5+9
n;“J* S! "XrV5 0&"6 ? 05M+06S 9184A7#E 
SW0
104 U#8%\405 

This paper appears in the Proceedings of the Fourth International Workshop on Multi-Relational Data Mining (MRDM-2005), August 21, 2005, Chicago. The proceedings were edited by Saˇso Dˇzeroski and Hendrik Blockeel. The paper is published here with the permission of the authors, who retain the copyright of this material.

'[” UKM 6!6 X3‡ ˆ‹:P 7•:Pˆ•#Žo; J*3 "K –4D:
()
Y2KM!X6Y"4 5 X
7  8 ;r—+ 
4M0X
E'[ 5,C"
$z4
$&005,
6 XT$ 9

1  () 41"? -L\45 2()8V
$]+M
09"T 1"8 4

i
76 
1+] #L0 95+"
EF K !;EJ*QD"$

—+5 4W+W4^'[
7?)L5 8 -$'.$$
G, )4)7#/

4$
04P'.^6 9
1A I
:?" ?H"4 5 
1* G# I'[/

M$$X#"
Q
L 8(-+F$0" ?6V
765 Q#


i 
 83
763$4  
1LX
Uu 5 *44"
 8  96&e K  D /

 8(*+A0$$ 8396 $
: i 6 ‡ ˆ"’ Pˆ#‰Žo;

'[


1 f_u:5 D: 8

i
6TM$
:9 I6+5 #,‡ŠŒ+Mˆ˜+nŠ#’Ž`;

J*44W,"44
 8SW576+6 K 9K 91X
8%S0 95+/

J* a1"5
76+(BDF'.BM"0
1C$X64 9
D"1"aH K7K  9W $ U00 i #9
V K ™(*,6 
_K S|   9$1"G
762—+5
:_‡8Š"ŠŽ` () ! 9KM 
1378,'BX6+C'["š(*36 8OP$


"
QX0D,90 +
1E7M$H8X"
;G¦B"
096+$^B'["  #()
1 $] 4 >'[ª‡ ˆ’#Žo«

i CTKM ¬

F; ž

¬

>D?0

41"6 ›Xœ!2›

/`XœT"
4K0F'A1$/ 4$
:_4
1\86+8OP$


$
 83a+D:5#-$A G‡ ˆ"Ž7?>K5 8)5M
T 9-(BDM; ž

+?X$A)XD?C 9#9
7 s'.#5 a9
"5
a'[

6 X&9
1X"
@7?TKM
c+"M06v‡8Š)Œ+aŠ‰ -‘Žo;

ž


7
+/


Z
76v V
y
8%vX"$&'[ S()8Ÿ 9#9
/ 0 y
7 8 0!KM%(*$
r\
8a 9D?&#z4 U#"
b
76r$/ 5  0N;,£B7#0XX7#0:T
76&$ ‡ Œ#Ž^ M"0_6+8OP$
 405 $*'.) 9#9
7 I04 U#8%T
60 #(v #(= -
TKM $"QK 
6_()83#00K5 a049 9#4'.)94+#?645+*W/  5 "
y
=W+
: $\"  9KMX"
v1X ;“qE"
1V$! _‡ ‘Ž $0" ?4
8,'*Q5 89 L%+MCK S+"71?#9
13 9
7 $+96+
$F
V\6+M
6 
$S1Xn;3J*6 "+L!780/o()0 $"
 99#9
V  "X 07#>F1X&7E
:6+a'[F  M
9 6+5 #L8>
76\ 9 8A'H049 9#C00K 5 ; | 5 07$T7?F45
9u:5 C
:6+F
\,1X!'[>X&0/ 0K 5 ! 5378* $K V009
12Ye 1 9K7 ofB0" 5 
() Y(*36 050Q9
c—+$$"
@Œ+; Œ+;@h^6 
6YR2$00 $XD ‡8Š˜ŽN
64¤>:  9)$* s‡ ˆˆ#ŽP7?)+"M"0604 98%_405+ '[ 9#9
7 6 X)K5+I

CH"
$]:I'7$
:8>0 95+"
n; ¥"KK 9 W4:6 $ 9T7TXD?&
c"5
!
$X$
KM%(*$
\6 8OP$$
:A
8%0 5 "
S6+0"
A7?>KM
!+/ M064'.*
746_
Q$"1"
89
T

7#5 X M U
1571>+/ $00
1T
76!'[E$X#"
&X
1+;a{3#¦*  5šE -‡Š‹Ž^5 0 $"
76+89
7 ?X
76+"

i  96+n'.s
"5
C$$'[$
$-
6E50H Uu 5 

$4 9()8=96r7X4$$Y+5 \M#6c 9/ 
7 PW05 $5 ";H§NM$A ‡8Š#ŽI"66:0*A K ~'6+9_/ K 1"57#
1=›%$
:8 4$
:
0œ sM
9  82')Q5  9L%+M 
C^
$]:I'5
W055 6a]+5 "6  5 4
;sJ* $E+/ M04T+"KK W_1"
$X?Q4:6  sE 5+,CjW"
 6+W09K 5 "
T#?$*8-'I
89$-9
$4G's$/`4
"
B9
6+ 54$
:;s¥X1E$^ n‡ ˆŒ#Ž5 0G *96 A'741"
1a:U6+
$ E  #(ZG¨7(Y'70"

1CKM$(*
Q6 8OP$
^80/o()90)6+$/ $90
C#?$CL5 8 F
!%+M;C¥05 9$C `‡ ˆ#‰ŽG "M0 1"
$_ K7K 9WQ$ U#"
7 G4:6+ s'[X4$(*D!'.,M"W/ 
1, )8X"
X
1C+"K 9$!;J*_00G,4 
1  1"8 4Q'.Q0"

12#?$F5
D+
()
0$_'>$
:8; {3 Xb$3 Q‡Š•Ž,+0
\'. E1
X?& U
1571 '[ 6+ i

14 K7K !6+W09K 5 "
\#?a(B 96 A()\5
D:
()
K+j%$>
7696 
8%T5
$0X
% ;H£G70X0:4
76\  ‡ ‰Žn+"M0CF1
X?E1"54:6 $ 7'.j%"
-
8%_$0" 5 / 
n;^%
W"6'nM$0'[4
1LF80/o()0>470
X0DP (B 5 0,L 9$
:A1"5T"#9K E'[AXT'.$
CQ+6 $-  $
:8T 9KM m;

1X(- s
76!aD 90
7
&—:D"
;A­I„®*½a¯8¶

Sˆ˜=%
f a¦B"
+'.$
&"
r¼H$0Z§I#1"SqC#XK70 — 
91 M¦B "P—: LKM$EŠ‘"‘‰+;

6 XS(-$"5 0S  "
4()$! $326+94$
0"
 
!'.#5 $/`K06r04 98%@KM$%(B
=
=LK1"5 "5 '[/

ž

°?±ƒ€[[²:³Q®a´±ƒ4¾S€.µ €.µ:°!½E®®±·$€o„m€o±µZ¿)¸+¯9‚®$»%
Z¥^ ;V'

D 0
c$& ‡8Š$ŽQ9
0:6+52$ U#"
7 _6+6 5  "
Ÿ9
 $XX  #?$SV 9#9
;¢¡, U0
9D"v$2 T‡Š$‰Ž4$
/

1X(- o?F;— 9D
;­I„®„"¯ °?±ƒ€.[² ³Q®P´±ƒ*³Q€.µ €.µ:°,„®X¶

®$±·$€m„m€o±µSƒX¸ ¯9‚®C€[µS¯„ƒo° ‚F¹?„`„?º„®$‚®$»B%
T¼E§nqE£G/‘‰ NŠ‘‘‰+;

i $ U6+;VR=
D: $!‡ Œ˜Ž>
76V4

J*$0B?$0E6 8OP$
IW09
1"#G$X#"
'  G4GM$ 
6  # 82W0
136 8L6 WX
Q()  B
,(*DP;—+"494$ 7M$-0 95+"
\
3KMC6+"
>K706304 8"
>8 ";^R 
350a"
E'n>
4$]+W9
1L4:6 G'.)W0
1QX / 
1+ M7 B"
45
64,)X0D4'n8 E# 9
1 ;a(-/ ?N $QC66+
7  9#9
7 G
'[#9
nn
&$4a' a?
:5?>5  *'I aM$ 
6 a$X#"
-6  K !F7M$lNC"6 6 8"
 ^
'."
&!+:96 F'.5+0/ E:96 
L,'m$C7#>(*$'.$$
,#L L4"; J** MA'I
8%_0 5 "
T7BKM
4A'. 5 -'sL5X4' a(*D
!8X
!X
1T‡8Š#’:Mˆ‰+Pˆ"’Žo;

3.1 Multiple Entity Resolution

R= 9 ! SKM#?!%(BV8X"
=W0
1"(*$\5 06@V4/

"#L Q7M$,8X
2 K !N8CC4L9
$$W9
1T
Hn$> 0
s
, 9 5 W0X?B]4 ^' Q5 8/`
8% 0 95+"
n;bJI2 9KMX#")!W0
1"$'.$M$*K5  
r66 8"
Y  3M$48 "*$"
X
@'.$
42$ D:
76 H'N
8 ()X_40$ 9"GLKMAQK 1"55;^J*  K 
1"F5Y!0
S()$Q5 89 _%+MF')
8Q
6 4KMC0" ?6!09L5 8X
"5 0 8 ;*%
\05 U#7CW0
1"a/ '.QZ„¸:[² ±ƒL
6r…‚µ¸‚L
8Q
Y"6 6 8"
V\À+„À ‚ƒF
8/ ;

ž

0054
147#> LW0
1E7?FKM
S0$ 8\06

!0X#5 ,6+8OP$
C$'.
$,ÁÂ()29L!6+zQ/ 5 L K ªK  0$ '-Á e F; ž

i WL8X
VW09
1\4
"


1X(* mf+
6e F; —:D"
f?GA5 B
76e ¼E§NqC£G/‘‰+ ž

Š‘‘‰+fs>F?
:57() QF0
76S7Fe >D?0

1X(* mf


6@e aD 90
7
Z—:D"
f^Q 5  4
76@e ¥^ ;V' 4ˆ˜ %
f H¦B"
+'.$
4"
¼G0&§I14qCXK70^—+
8/ 1 M¦B "P—: LKM$EŠ‘"‘‰+fP- C?
:5A$'.$$
";G¤>a  '+$0B78GWCa6 LK1"5H
76 :96 5  8 ;IR= 9 H8 ,
GKMG C6 8z45 8>0" ?ae ,; — D"
:f
764e aD:0/ 0

Y— 9D
fHe ž

1X(- ofIQ
2$]:04 8&44"
&%
76+9


9W>
74F
76!8E>$$0X
 8\
a"K::"5A7#,e ,; ž $'[$G> -4)5 H
_-e aD?$0

ž

1X(* mf

1X(* mf; ž

'.

A?
:5 *$'.$$
+8**"$046+z_5 8:8'N
B4M"00K "  0 9"A A(*,?
:5*'.$
B()8 "5 B0M9 Ã66 
D:
() 6 1";

3.2 Joint Resolution Using Entity Relations

|!"5+!$] 4 "a3!
!7#X6c@K0$"& 26+M
/

6 $
4"
1! 6 8OP$
,0 95+"
Z6 $90
_$"0LQ5 /

3.

A MOTIVATING EXAMPLE

R2*() 9 
(c4"#*- K ©'N$ U#"
7 7
8%FW/

 T+M; R2T
ZD?440 5 "
c6 0"
\¹ ‚À ‚µ7¹ "
X2$F
20C(*_$&#!ƒ‚$¯„‚0¹;T—:91
 i 
 8 

 5 "

76Q 91 1" H)6 8OP$$
:H005$G7#H"4-5 Q50
1

()$
L*$0" 5 "
_6 0"
B#-"6+E·±"¯.¯9‚0·$m€.…‚$¯ Ä?,



Q  5W0X?B$] 4 H'["bBK K "1X 9)6+"9
N;^¦B
/

KM^Q5 E0$s)D"";n§n$I5N9  5W0X#G ^$ U#"
n'.n

096+$I H+"K 9$v' 00+
1*-$"
W05 $IA6 XK70H'+M$

8X
S6 "
n+()$E E "
)
aCM$75+/

5  )
6T8X#9
+'[”L 9 9
\'I7M-$'.$$


H
76L?
:5; ž

M7 4"  $6rK:YX() 
1 3(BKn- D?S¦B8#—:$&‡8Š#ˆŽ`;

€.µ?
:5 ;

ž

5+*Å^ƒX€.‚s7M$?()X_1"HÀ¸º¯ €[®0² ‚¹


S5  CC&·±"¯.¯„?º±ƒW„`±ƒa'-
$E5  C8'

ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇG ÆÆ ÇÆÆ ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG ÇG Ç ÆG ÇÇÆGÆG ÇÆ ÆG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÇÇG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆG ÆÆ ÆÇÇÆÆ ÆÇÆGÇG ÆÇG ÇG ÇG G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç ÇG Ç r5 Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ Æ r1 G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç G Ç e1 Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÆÇG Æ ÇÆÆ ÇÆÆGÇG ÆÇG ÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇG ÇGÇÇÆ ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉÈÈ ÉÈG ÈÈ ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG É ÉÉÈG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÉG ÈÈÈ ÉÉÈÈÉÈ G ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG ÉG r6 È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È È ÉÈG r2 e2 ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉG ÈÈ ÉÈÈ ÉG G É ÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉGÉ

R Agrawal

Rakesh Agrawal

R Srikant

Ramakrishnan Srikant

Fast Algorithms for Mining Association Rules

Fast Algorithms for Mining Association Rules in Large Databases

VLDB−94

Proc of the 20th Intl. Conference ...

C1

C2

ÊGÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊG Ë ÊË ÊGËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËÊ ÊGËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê r3 Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê e3 Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê r7 Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËÊ ËG ËG ËG ÊGËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËG Ê ËÊ Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍÌ ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍÌ ÍÌGÍG ÌG G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì G Ì Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í e4 Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í Í ÌG Í ÌÍ Ì ÍG Ì r4 Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì r8 Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍÌ ÍÌGÍG ÍG ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍG Ì ÍÌ ÍÌGÍG

h2

h1

ko"d

kmKMd

Î)Ï[Ð7ÑIÒ#ÓcÔ7Õ&Ö%×MØÙAÚn×7Û ÜÝ[Ó2Þ?Ï[ß× ßÏ[àMásâ!ÜI×ÒâÓ+ãvÏ[áNßàZà7äâÓ:Ò#åMÓ+ã=×7ÑIßænà7Ò ç-Üs×Ü^Ó:Ò!ßÏUßÝ[Ó×ásãvåMÓ+áNÑIÓ&âßÒÏ.áIÐMâ"èVÖ%äHØéFæIÓ Þ"à7Ò#Ò#Ó ê âÜ^àMáIãsÏ.áIÐY×7ÑnßæIà7Ò ç^Üs× ÜHÓ:Ò×7áIãcåMÓ+ánÑIÓTÒ#Ó+ë`Ó:Ò#Ó áIÞ"Ó+âQì4Ï[ßærßæIÓ\Ò#Ó âà7Ý[åMÓ+ã@Ó+áNßÏ[ßÏ[Ó+â"è

 $\(-8QL4L7M;LR2Q\50F0L 9"
,

(-+EKMQ+"+U#L$]+M0C   0" 5 
;F%
S0_'

D?F"
F0" 5+9
6+0"
2 6ST
 $;CRL3KM$/


74^'.*$] 4 ""() Ce ,; ž

1
K F0" :
1Qe F;:—:D"
f?
76e >D 0

— 9D
f '

ž

() F(**#*4"Ws"
i 6 $
:;IJ*C 6L5naKM ?)e ,;

$'[$aQ_6 8OP$$
:Ee a#j%

ž

1X(- mfs
76 e >D?0

ž

1X(* mf:$'.BEEe >D?0

1X(- mf+
8%Q9
G0"+04a$B9
WX
>'I8-41"  ž

1X(* mf;

1X(* mfs#L Q4L5+n0


 $b·±"¯.¯„?º±ƒW„‚4()8c !0" ?6r5+$
:8=e8— 9D
f; ¤a( (*F
S1TKXD34F7ME8X
>() 9XnP
&"6 6 8/

3.4 Positive And Negative Relational Evidence ž

0'U"©-
H 9 5 W0X6_
_5 H$] 4 9"$HKK+/


_C7:9
1E?$0L04 U#G8 :#"-
(cKM$
46 $4
6

"1X 9H 9"
s
, 0aM
9  8CKM^506,I"6 6 8"
7

SKMSÅ^ƒ€.m‚µrº$Ä44T5+_
8;J* QD"L5 

:96 
_()$
V"9 9K ";\¥M$LS·$€.‚0¹2º$ÄQ $F7M

4!
i 6+
_7#43(*M$4'.$
Z  


6%(*SM$Q·±"¶·$€.‚0¹38')$V86VK: 4

4aM$G
8% ;^| "  #()
1F A4A+"6P?%(B,U6+


7M$
8% ;y'>%(*2094 9T7M$$'.
$3#\/`86

M$A8X
AQ5W)?C96 
 n?
:5>8X"
;A—+Q(B

K C4CM$a
8% :7#A0$"L>66+
7 n:8/

0 9"EC7#
 8!6+90X#C?
:5A$'.$$
;

6 $
E-3#EC4";^>(*$?$+ 9"
 s:96 $


—:49 9#s6+M
76+
$9$nKM$(*$
C780()0G$0" 5 "
F6+0"


4 90FKMCµP‚o°?„m€.…‚B
404a0;G|B$] 4 9"%(BLM$


YT 0
!'> 9
4
1S$'.
$
ZKM3 /

$'[$
$Q7#_#&·$€.‚0¹º$Ä_4M$Q
8%25
/

5+6=K cS 9
7 FD"Z
%(*D=4:6  a'.!


D? 8_,KMA6 5 9+*)%(BF5  G$'.$$
G7B

$0" 5 "
T M"06K ¥X1Q$) ‡ ˆŒŽo;H¤>aIj%"
-W/

·±"¶„¸:[² ±ƒX®)'s E4CM$A
8% ;

 5 "
Z
ZKMM$0'.46V?
() 
Z TK0$"6Y6X\
H 9"
 m;HqE8OP$
H70()0a6 $90
B
4W  7KM)"6  26 M$
76V"
ZXZ450
1S%(B29
Y96 ;cJ*

i W

5 0B647#X4$B'.*M#9
1F'[5+*#?$B7B'I'[/ 
$)
76_ 8*0" 5+9
!6+0"
;GJ* >0
760"5+>' 6+M
6 
)9G:UC#?$ 9BKM%(*$
78G'N$'.$$
;GJB(B 6+8OP$
L6 0"
Q
:?" :
13 44_$'[$
3#6 M
+/ 6+
E
76T E6 $M
76+
C
!¨7(Ÿ"$,e X79
fM'H#?$ 9 /  
1F78;HJ* 9*¨7?B'+jW"
*0 5 "
(--
0:6 5 64K  {3¦*  5í$G I‡8Š‹Žo; ž

(*)#"-9  5W0X#6_50
1E"5+G]_/

 ""$$ U#"
KM%(*$
F'.$
?() 
L# 9K *
F  6 X:
2KM_XD?

:!5
,!
0:6 5$
76

9$?$X1 4E0" 5+9
\6 $M
76+
;

3.3 Local And Global Resolution

`QLKM
V
6r‡ ˆŒ:*‘#Ž*7#_0"440 5 "
@6 $90


4. PROBLEM FORMULATION

%
a 9"
 I$
:840" 5 
\ "K !:(*E#"E0"4

 9 9
V'-$'[$
C!
8F
76S'[î C0$F'*$'U/ $
-(*a(*"5 963 9D">Q96 $
:8'U _km5
9u:5 ":4
 UdG$" 8/

$"
='F9
6 :96 57 3$
:82()Xr$Z0 "5 96rKM  M6N;B%
3()a'."  ()P(*C() 9 5 0, 9(B$E0LX7#X$ ï 
76ðEQ6+
a
8-
764$'.$$
;^R2A()  P50Eu 5 8/ i   635 M$)0, $0$) D? ï?ñ ò 
63ð ñ ó 6 
E9K  
6@(*!()  E5 0

ï ñ ô 
6cð ñ ï V6 $
\ 5 ',9K 9$ ï ñ òrõ=ô d; ? RA#>1"?$
,0*'N$'[$
$*ö õb÷ ð#øù  ()a4$'U/

km000/`7
6'[

$
Bð-s8#00K5 $sð ñ ò I ; J*H$'.
$^G+M6N;NR A1"?$
 )M"00K )%+MGú õ ÷û ø%ù>
4A6 

6Q v %+MCð ñ ü '.>X!$'.$$
,> 0K0$"6N;*J*E$'[$
$

 "I 3¯±·„"¯ƒ‚®±"¯ ¸:m€o±µS6 L9
SQ04'BL%(*T?
:5

õv÷ï øùF0Q)$'.$$
CðF7 8_96 6 
V
8%2 9KM -ð ñ ó ; ¤>4!$'[$
!
76V8 00M"
6 
1L
>
$0 8T'I a4a%+M";hG

W0
1"e ¥ ";'A Tˆ˜Y
:f )¦B
'[$
$3"
V¼H$0§I1


8%

FKMae $]+M06PfE 8L
_$H0G(*  m;H|G]_/

qEXK0-— 
:91" -¦B "*—++QKM$Š‘‘‰+fB
76@e ¼E§NqC£G/ ‘‰ HŠ‘‘‰ fN
\F"
$]:>'G"5 E$] 4 ,7M$E!KML$]:/ $
76 6'.E
$)0$A'^7M))#">E4C?
:5$ L0" ?E !;^J*-(*E()  I  s°"¯±"ºX„¯nƒ‚®±"¯ ¸:m€o±µ4'.A04 #00K5 >" 95 -'.>
3
8% M;>(*$?$ )
a 8/

00M"
6TQ
8Aý

ï  04-8)#()
300K5+ ï?ñ ò +K5+->$
:8A
,6 8 &K0$?6N;FR=7#E(*_K0$"_L_#00K5 $ ð ñ ò 'I9
6 :96 57 M$'.$$
;^R2>
319
Eð ñ ò LKM>1"
+/ $X#6K Q0"4a6 W0"
  $0B'[t >#009K 5 G'N 00M"
6 
1,
8%Fð ñ ó ; x K::"50 8 -
8%L 9KM B'M $'[$
$,L
>"K 0$?6P; x 5 > "K ™>4#?E

KM $'>KM"5+Q 5
76+$ 8 
1\
; %
2Q(*X6 H

 966 $
c0$'E
ý

õ–÷ï øù 
6Z !
8%Z 9KM ð ñ ó 'C
76+9:96 5 -$'[$
$1"?
Y!K0$"6@#00K5 $
76


8%  5W$Q0$0M"
76+LS"
4"
W05$6Y$
:8
76   '.$
G9
C 5 W$B$00M
76_E)4-$
:8 ;|

+M-' >$'.
$;

"5+Q5


1\$] 4 "(B(B"5 U6V D?T 1" 

R2G()  :"
0U6+$s 9#9
7 
'[#9
QKM$(*$
F$'[$


i
6



&$ 9Z5Q9
Y  9$$?!
8%$0" 5 "
N;YRT()  A005 4

'.5 B 5W$:
)'.BX45
6 $ 8+
1C
8% ;{3QKM04'

!$'[$
TS"K 0$?6P)
T
76+9:96 5  8 )K5+

$'[$
$E
!,
W056\ 5W$>, 0$
:6!50
1

4$QKM$*'^  M0/6 1"$;R,C1?
\Q0a'^  M0/6 1"$

E 5W* 9KM ð ñ '.BX_$'[$
$"; ž  '.$
H7B 4LKM$L'ES 5W
6&KMT'> T4 MG() 9X



þ

õ ÷ÿ ø%ùA
76,B4$QKM$0 9C'PA'.$
*
_A  M0/6 1" v ^ 5 6QK ,^ +M$0/`6 1* 9KM +ð ñ ;I'7$'[$
)ða $5 

Q 0!_%+M

ÿ  
!ð ñ ™õbÿ ;*¤>CA5
9D?E ,
 µM±Ő \00 $U#"
y'C +M$0/`6+1"
76Z'.$0/




9KM A(B ž



'.L 4 5W$;!JI!WX#0QOX2$'U/ ñ ü $
!KM 
1"_2&0$7X#\ 5W$4
76@4XcWY


\ +M$0/`6 1

78C'G 5W$QkmE$
:8XdA>7?CF1" WC:96 $



V  M0/6 1"TV 9!$'[$
$T',K 80X0

'.,KM
1F4L
SL4$1"6N;FJ*LD?$T Q05/

+M;^J*A +M$0/`6 1G
 5HD"AKM0$B+6 $


04', $ 95 W$
12 1" w_!6+WX
$!405+2km

$
;

8'N(*>0054)7#B $4#>
76+9?>'s00 9?E0$


 8$
? 8   A04 98%405 d*G4  6P;J*

4"
1QC
8;-
3 $A(*X6+ C
3 9KM a'H'[/

04 U#8%405 LXD?F
\$"5
,404 98%2
2


$ 5+3
c \4\ +M$0/`6 1S\ 96c

00K 5 -'s>'.$
)
T >%(B_ 5W$;H
366 8"
N

X $;3¤a(í _0" 5+9
Y6 $90
L
L
6 M
+/

(*(-
L 04 98%405+\
MXT U6+\'

6+
;)%
W"6\' i
76 
1_,
8%T UKM >'.E\$'[$


jW
:aA  9$$?F$0" 5 "
N;*J* ,405+C0"5 96TXD?C



6 :U6+57 9 8 5 FX0D&F\+6 $,4$
:82 9KM$ 9L'- 

$"5
: aƒ0‚$¯„‚0¹-$0" 5 "
Q6 $90
7#^7?BKM$
L6 

'.$
-  9$$? 8  () $a a$
:84 9KM Pð ñ ó 's
:4'[/ 
QðT,6 8 &
¨5
6SK \QX_'*
S 9KM

 $+50 8 ; ž

ð

7#0$
;





X6 
1 8 >094 98!405 E
6 -4KM

$]:
6 6>A"
096 $KMC$'.$$
B00K5+
6E 9"


'.E
$)$'[$
$Cð n'I$T,00 96!()83  ñó 4C  M0/6 1" ";Hð ñ ”õ ð ñ ; Jn_D?A-4a"
$$""
096 $- E $a$] 4 9



J*„mmƒ€oº$¸:‚F®€.³L€m¯„ƒX€.mÄ·±³aÀ+±µP‚µ I'E04 98%4#/ 05 F  "D:E#> F04 98%!'^F00K 5 að ñ ò '^C$'U/ $

cT%(*2 5W$;v%
@"5+T0"A8405+4

0 ()
V9
Y|s15 \Š?ko"dF
76  $00M
76 
1!$'.$$
F$/ 0 ?63
_
8a
3|s915 4Š?kmK7d;RC#"CLX I'^1" 

04 U#8%&KM$%(B
&%(*T"K 0$?6S$'.$$
4
4;Q%
"66+8/

'.$
)()8T'.5 )
3X38X
n;G%
8X"
S¦aŠð -
76

"
N+(B>#"a,ƒ‚$¯„m€o±µM„¯N®€.³L€m¯„ƒX€.mÄ_·±³aÀ+±µP‚µ P7* 9 D:

ñ ò=õ e F; ž 1X(- of ð ñü ñ ò™õ ñü õ õ e 5+f; A$'[$
$\ð 3'E%+MT7M-027#ð ñ üõ e 7M$fG
76

$E07#Q
n;EhG& 5WCC00 9#6&()8 0C'



ð aE5  *$'[$
*()8!#009K 5 Bð




76Vð







e ,;H—:D
f
76%+MLð



 



 B04 98%F'G$ U#"
s G%(B>
8^^ 5 W/ 6+1"BF $B'.$
*B(Ba(*
B,XD?A
L5
;

ñ ò=õ e |7W ž 184B'[A{3
9
1 ž 00 9"
Ta5 9$f9;GJ*  '["5+0L$'[$
$-ð B^a?
:5 G()8Qð ñ ürõ e ?
:5"f
76Fð ñ ò=õ e ¼>§nqC£G/‘‰ f;v—+4 9 8 *$X#"
y¦B‰_'["5 $'[$
lað ð











       

|B)$H$'.
$ (*)(-
B 9 D_
*#G 8-#009K 5   5AK5+a> E0" 5+9
26+0"
a7#>?CKM
!XD?




"
! !;A—:M i    (*C(-
:A  "D\#a F$ 95 W$a UKM 



ð ñ '- 0_$'[$
$;!Jn\9  5W0X#4,50
1!5 F$] _/  S'[  |s1"5+ZŠ>05 M0S(B ?S 86+r0 ?6r


76Vð 4'A%+MTe 5+fHð 4'A%+MTe 7Mf^
6Yð 4'a M e ?$
+5 "f;

J* 0$Q')5
6 $ 8+
1!
8_ýZ

÷ï ï ï ï ù s() $ )     )      a    + 5       G   
  8        B  ) ( 8      7
  4  $   ï ï ï ñ= ò õ e aD?0 ž 1X(- mfI
76 ï ñ ò©õ e >D 0

&—:D
f ï C7M$ ()8c8  ï ñ òîõ e |7W ž 9184L'.3{3

1 ž 00 9#9







6







A5 H
§I#1">qEXK0f 
76




4

*E
'[$
$>?
:5 *() ï e8ˆ˜2
$
7#9
7 B¦B
'[$
$_"
¼G$0\§I1

ï ñ ò“õ qEXQ£B0NŠ‘‘‰ f;*¦B  8  5+B$'.$$
-ð



$0M"
764L5  -$
:8



ð !
76Zð







 


764ð a$0/





ï *0L-ð ñ óbõ ð ñ óŸõ=ï :()  0$0M"
76Z5+T$
:8 ï 30&7#ð ñ ó–õ





ež

1X(* mf^
76Ve8— 9D
fN$'.
$F
$ 95 W$




6



_/

0M$?$  ;G¦B
096 A E5+0
)094 983's>(*_M$ $'[$
$L() 9XV#?$,\KM_0" ?6V
762W  BKM$ 9
1! 0X3
V 5W*



ð

 



&7:
1Sð 3
76

 

7:
1

;EJ*,%(* 5WEQ00 9#6&()8S"
L6+1"LXn ÿ 
6 ÿ 0M$$? 8 ;TR2Q(-
FT'm_
3 _049 9#





405 a a'.$-* A(*Q6 1"$)E00 963()8 4L0" ?6& 5W$  5W


6

 



F
6

049 9#;



I()X C()7#,D?$>


6&ð $00M
76& ñ ógõtï ; ž 0 n7M$C$'.
$Cð $
:8 ï C
76T"
:5>$'[$
Að E
63ð >_
8% ï ";

L6++
4C
7#5 F'HC 9"
 ^04 U#8%\4M"

;


;Y>(B37?%(B $X#"
B0&Qþ

%(B7M$ 5W()  >
KM!
096 6c04 U#
51"N;

ð









R2Q 0!7?,F  M0/6 1"$M()&00M"
6&8X/

J* -$'.$$
Gð





 "5 1"_ð



ÿ M0
,$3F 9 K X9
63'[ 
V9F $0
6Fð ñ ð ñ õ



 

õ ª ÷ÿ ÿ ù ; #a00 964()84  M0/6 1"



$X#"
¦aŠ";aJ*) 9/







ž

 


V005 _LK "5 1" _5 LK 2KM"36+90$500"
Z

%
8U    ()
!  n$'[$
AKM "
1__6 W
$a 5W$  £B5+a 8> 9
7 04 98%31" >5\
\WX1C e8—:D
fG'.$
3
76c 
@ 2e ž

i WA

1X(- mf*$'.
$!

ð ñ ð ñ ; õ õ õÿ R2>04 9 800 9#, a$B'."5+-$'.
$*() +M$0/

0 9"6N;)
3E'["  #()
130$
7(BQ6+0$KMF
\8$X?

6 1"

 9
7 I094 98 ;



ÿ ;B%
3$W>')7M(*C()  s50C E$6 1F T05KW85+Q'.L +M$0/`6+1"";LC()  BKM_5
76+$W :6&F


 5W9
1S 1"8ª7#L "$X1F L6:+
74L
75+4'

6 1"C
:?" ?E4>7
T(*Q$'[$
;

5.

RESOLUTION BY CLUSTERING

J* EX0DT'^ 9 9"F$
:8$0" 5 "
SKME+X06

6. SIMILARITY MEASURES

%
Ta0$$"
n(*C'.  8\6  i
E C049 9#!405 

>F 9"
 s 5 W$
1_+"K ~() $CE1? IAQ 5W/

KM$(*
,%(B>
8%E 5W$HsA(*$91 6LQK 9
"
F' 

*-$'[$
$-0FG"0)7#*00M"
6C a4

00K 5 _04 98% 
6& 9#9
7 B04 U#8%&KM$%(B
&

$
:8Q
6Q5L
_-4-$ 95 W$;sR2-L19
)E16+


61" 91 Q45 X#"
7 *
76 $4 1"8 49W/

1"1 94$X?L 5W$
13 918!M() $LC
!WX1L 

05$)A#F
:? 9"6N;



$5 0
L0$



õ™÷

ø ù3'Q‚µm€.mÄ ·¯ ¸:®‚ƒ®,$¨$F"5+Q5+0


|a(*
8%!$ 95 W$



ø 
6



78>094 98!!KM

6+ i
63

!" !#  $%$'&     ( ")#   &+*-,     /.0"1.  $%$%&  &2*, 3" 45"

     k

ø

() $

d õ

kWŠ

^d

k

ø

d

k

˜

ø

(*A
T1?9
50AC 
D1"A4$0) 9D"a0
1 > 
DL,405  a 9"
 s04 98%TKM$%(B
%(*Q 5W$;

d

k`dPn ^094 98E': G#00K5 $I
76

i W,6+ i
Q70()0404 98%S405 LKM$%(B


§nC5

%(BC  M0/6 1"$;sR)7?) 8"6:_
6Q7#G()H(*)(-
:

yŠ

C
096 $G'.B 9
7 M04 98%_)* A$ 95 W$G UKM  k`d

'HC$'[$
E
SXS6 1"N
6!
>$E00K5+;E—+

F4 9"
 -04 98%VKM%(*$
4%(BS
2$ 95 W$

'.C
\6 1"M(*,
096 $a,Q5 8/`0$A'G$ 95 W$E 9KM P"



76L $Q) 9
 8Q"LK
6,()8_(*1"  &
76Š

G;s%


'.XZ'.$
S00 $U#6@()8c8;c>(*"$B T$'[$0/

 E'. 9 ()
1%(B_05K 0$"
(*F6+90$50-E(*404 U#8%


-
76$X6 
1" 84A 5W$* UKM *
F +M$0/`6 1)


$"4M"

-
\6 $X o;

KM4'AL5 8 Q%+M;!JI!  "D,4 5 W$Q')X2%+M 0X$  "(*A6  i
)> MB #jW$
'[*
_6+1"A^-0

6.1 Attribute Similarity

')$ 95 W$F 9KM ,'["î8,7#F')!05 U#,%+M";|

EXD?A%(*$'[$
$_00K 5 C
76!$5+
E 5FKM$/

 4C_(*\5 F 5W$

(*$
_˜>
764ŠB
76+s -6 $1*'704 98%FKM$(*


 +M$0/`6 1

R2!0054T 3$]+W
304!K7093094 98Y405+

ž

 !;



 1"Q 54
6 $Q1$Q094 98KM$(*
ž


S405+Q7#


76&T%+M ÿ

: $

 00K5+;R4#4
LD:9
1!
:&$L005 4 "
 KM"5+F _#009K 5 _04 98% 405 ";

  ; : $

$] 4 "sTe 5 _+j%$"
Nfs'._6+1"




V"5 L$] _/ ÿ ;T| 9 8 n'.L

û P_+j%$"




ð ñ yõ

ð ñ ”õ=ÿ

ñ ürõrû ù

# i E 0Q0054+9
E
SKML5 06\
5 E0X$4";>R2

JI,XXDL(*,6 1G'[-04 98% "(*)()9  M
096 B$B /

&M$
:9 9 82506 8OP$$
:L#009K 5 404 98%2405+

jW$$"
_'[4XZ M0X$  ;

'[>6 8OP$
) 5 W$)78a6 M$
76 
1Q"
8)%+M;

0$C04 98%!9aL}?X6 04 98% ;C|a%(*0$

a(*?

 $%$%&

k`dG6  i
$GA04 U#8%4's#009K 5 GKM$/

(*$
(*Q$
:84 5W$;HhHX3$
:84 5W$*9), 9 9
'*$'[$
$C()&8,()
#00K5 $;—+(*Q
6S35 0  G04 98%,405 ^7#IXD?n(*a00K5+na6  i
 

?

EE FHFHGJLJIKIKEE

i
76+9
1E)1"1$1?E6 WX
)KM$%(B
_%(BC 5W$G1"?


\80()036+9WX
405 ";&{!
V  "XL7?4KM
+"M06Y'[1"11?#9
12#?$Q70/o()0!6+WX
$_KM$(*
 -%(*, 5 W$a‡ ˆŽ`;GJ* a6+5 9#- 9"
H    8Q0X
/ 08?"«L8'-$'.
$Lð#øAð



7#05 9A%+M



;4—+_0
1" 


DQ405+ABXD?B )49
Q5©80/o()0C6 WX
Qkm  3#] L5î70()0\04 98%dLKM$(*$
Z(*& 5W$4  Q4WE 
C'.,"5 E5 M0;¦B45+9
109
1" 4 
D 04 98%T)u 57"6:XE
T E?$X1"C
:5LKM$*'^6 W
A0/ 0K 5 4 5F
V! 5W;

ž

44z4
_ 8$
7#9"



û

 $   k ÿ ø

d õ

ÿ


76

A@ BC D  ?  @ BM D N: $  : $  PO $ô ð Mk

ô

ô ð Mk ò

ô

;YJ*$
Y T04 98%'>(*S6+1"

ÿ øC
76

k ÿ ø%d

k ÿ

ÿ

ò

Qd õ

'[

d0d

J*#?$X  *049 9#2'[Q 46 1Q&
2KM4"K X
6 K 50
1L0"4C+" 9#C111""
S"MX"
%+M«



#6 5 9s 
V 9 G $

6+5 9#C'*ð ø ()9  G 0!KM46+5 9#C'Bð

$"44"
Y405 '.

4G 84}?X6Z049 9#Y46  i
6Y

04 98%_KM$%(B
4%(BF$ 95 W$*'s#009K 5 ;J**B04 9 

ž

 

k ÿ ø

ÿ

O $  $  

d õ

‡

k ÿ ø

ÿ

c#?A 

dŽ

J*!1"11?#"
="MX"
r$"5 96ZKM\ #]Y&(B1" 6 QK
"
T"$)> M$; ?
SC780()90404 98%&405 F'.F6+1"N(*Q
50>
111""
3"M$X#9
3 D?

 BQ

F 9$5 9> A$ U#/ Tô "
 I04 98%TKM$(*
%(B_
8% 5W$AA'["  #()«

 &2*,   

80()0_470
&41:aKMC
X
&4$ 0
X#9"

ø

k

#00K5 !'[TXr
8%Z 5 W$-()Xr !4"W D? 8

 BQSRUTVW TXCY    3Z    Z  

d õ

Tô

ÿ ø

#00K5 >" 95 >'.)>5
76+$ 8 
1Q
8%19"
 E"K 0$?6

k ÿ ø

%÷

ø ñ

ÿ

ÿ

dù

ñ

#00K5 $3'L 9 E'.$
T9
=T 5W$;tJ*$
y &0/ 0K 5 C04 U#8%3'[E_ 5W$a7aA C049 9#!'H 8 $ 0
X#9",00K5+;

J*H(*)()9  M  L‚0¹° ‚C¹ ‚`„€m¯7®€.³L€m¯„ƒX€.mÄ*KM%(*$
4%(*, 5 W/ $E0
Q8E]  9$ 8S
096 E?$0!6 1_00 $U#6&()8 F 5W$; x

K0$"H45+9
1-H094 98,KM$%(B


6.2 Relational Similarity

%(B,6 1BB 
*
_ a?X1"A
:5LKM$H'P$'.
$B



(*$
!%(*Q
3$ 95 W$A"
0U6+$
1_ C 5W$A7) $

$AEu 576+X,
!,?$X1"F
:5QKM)'H6 1E00 96

¤a$]:E(*"66:0!& 9"
 L094 98b405  KM$/

#C 963_:9Q>"K0?636+1";*J*$,#,
M"W/ 0K 9,(-+a6+ i
Ca04 98% ;)R2F]  ,0"4,M"008/ K  98A$,
76'. 5 a
!0"4E005 AA#C' 
";

6+1""?()  9A45 
1>)6+1"A6 $X 04 U#8%4'M%(*, 5 W/ ()8!!$ 95 W$;

6.2.2 Neighborhood Similarity

¦B  8  
005A()6+1"E6+$X P04 U#8%BA45 /

6.2.1 Edge Detail Similarity

ž

X
7 ^4 $]+8% ;

hHXS
8%!$ 95 W$CC00 96S()&40$C'H6 1>7#

0 N8CC
a0+9 ^
$$4
X  8

5P6 *6 1")6+$X 094 98L() 
Q 5 W$G41""; ž

0
76

 '.$
_$"
X
6Y
Y8_KM 
1\ ; a$  *7#_


62 K7K 8&44M$0
$
:,005 C()$,6+$X 6

'.$
4ð,00 962()2
&"K 0$?6&:+M$0/`6+1"Fð ñ ; J* 
V6 130$ ñ '[
Z$
:8 5W 2KM36+$/

780/`()0\04 98%@"4 5 X#9
Z'[6+1"44  8@
$W/

ð ñ îõŸÿ ð ñ ©õ ù ;EJI1"5
76!a9
ñ îõ“÷#ÿ 4G'n5 G$] 4 9)
|s1"5+FŠ:'U$B(Ba#")$0" ?6Q  ež



W055 'EXZ6 1"T07#X 8Y'._X0DV'a$ U#/ "
 M
8%L0" 5 
n; >0
1F,4)
$$a$] 4 9?'.

i
6\



)6



87  9 

1X(- of '.$
G0,G 5W$





G
:X
^$'.$$
Bð


76!ð 
! C6 1L0$A'.> F$ 95 W$E



 

0@'.T !X0Dr#7
6N;bR= SZD?\0$
0\'. 0"4>> 9#"
8a
)KME
0#03Q  D3#

ñ ªõŸ÷ÿ ÿ ù +
1QC6+1"A00M"
6 
1__ E%(*Q8X"
>
:?"  /

%(B5+a
8


1_e ž


8

1X(- of;HR-()  M
(=6+ i
),04 98%_405+)'[*

8^'76 1?0A7^1?
,70/o()0-04 U#8%F405+"



3[




6 ï 4KM,
096 $6S04 9M8a ï
Q
0#0'._KMV'-$îS/5  Q!7M$L()8 
T6 1

ï

      
76

ï

֕

ï

ï

ï



"1$;B
W6N ' ï 07#>
7#09$9)
3+E0X ï

ï #ùF
76



  

 

  

÷ï ï #ù?  ÷ ï ï ùT
76 ÷#ï ï ù $
27#Q 0&0 "5 U6 $"5
_Q01
 i  
Q 9
7 ):96 $
4'._$LKM
1\ 

4 9 6N* $ ·„µ µM±>KM!\4\
c0
!$c

4,5+)$
:8 km8's $7?E04 9>00K5+)-(B  [d;

7447
Z"
3$'[$
$";=J* 9
@KMTXD?
Z
/


4 $B(BX6  () $*G
B(*,
8%_$ 95 W$G()80_/

5
FK:&4 9#9
7 *049 9#V405 ";!J*049 9#

 9Q00K 5 ,7?_ _446 1"4W05 $5 $8'*$&#"

KM$(*
(*S 5W_78QLÃ$$S'A4$1
1!$:" 9#

 F®„³4‚aµP‚€9°#²+ºX±ƒC·¯ ¸:®‚ƒ®^C()X_$Q7?)6 1:7#B


 9
7 I"
W0X
;

6 1"$

/%5  ;R2T#"T05 V
W0X9
_'[4"$06+1"7

05+z4
) 9"
 n:U6+
$>'.aK K "1X 9,
8%4$0" 5 / 
n;

7. IMPLEMENTATION

R2_() 9 B
(t'[ 9Ã4
"
V')
1+KM :62'[Q

1: $

?
_ A04 98%Q405+-'.*C78B'N 5W$ (B)


$ 95 W$;=A 9 -4(*37?!6+ i
6

k ÿ 0 d dQ4%+M6 +j%$"
'N 5 W$B 9KM B'.-
46 1" ÿ ; ž 0  '.-
4
 $ 95 W$  ñ ,40$F')6 1F00 96V()88;3J*


 

]\ $ 

(BQ
&'[ 9 8&6+ i
, F+M6\
1":KM :6 A'["  ()«

\^$  `_ a :b$  Xk

dc a

¤a*

d õ

k ÿ d

k

d-'.

50T16: 1"1 "4$X#9"$ 95 W$
1\ 1"8 î



Z  ÿ

G7064
4A4)6 1a()8C 5W/ 1X(- mf)
6ye8—:D"
fH'.$0/

$
A7?>KM
30 ?6!
45+A 5 W$




76



EK5+

 T$L$'.
$W9  A6 0M$06Y#?_7M$_$ 95 W$

 

  !\  e$ Tf &   \ h *ije*     
76

      \ e$ Tf &         g\^h *ije*    


6?
:54$ 95 W$


76

;&J* 
5 /

 4
1":KM  :6 Q'[_ TM$_ 5W$ 96+
9 m«

k d õ k "
:5*
1":KM  :6 GA6 8OP$
« ?k

d õb÷

2
76

#

ù?;-£B5+A 8

k

d õb÷

ùA
76

d b ù ; õ ÷ ¤a(C-'. ! 9"
 >04 98%@405 \KM$(*
Z%(B

$
:8@$ 95 W$'.3205 9#T M*(*!XD?!S}?#X6 04 98% KM$(*
&8,
1":KM  :6 ,'*C M;4¤> *}?X6094 984
KM)
7#5 X  8$]:
6 6L'[-L5 88/ 0;_|s
7   N'.CL"$X  ^049 9#SKM$%(B
& 5W$E(B 
\1"1$1?F#?$A 9 N%+M)AKM'.«

 2& *,     k

ø

d õ

O $ @ kM D \ $   \ $   ‡

ô

$ô ð Mk

k

ød

k

d; 
00  L
6 96#@6+5 9#Y78\Á


096 $
1!8F049 9#;3J*$
8L8$X#? 82 D:C 78C()&_ 1"$W,094 982
76S4$1"$E!;LJ*_ 8/ 1"8

49
A()
\ L04 98%\'[E L 0WC78

'm  9aKM (ŸF 0 " 96N; J*H 9"
 + 5W$
1C 1"8 KM1
s()8Q,$'[$0/ 
,001"
634_0X#F$
:8T$ 95 W$;B—+Q4WX#0)()N C$ 95 W$E#F6 0"

6!
63$CA
_ 9#9
7 s:8/ 6 $
,#>  nKM$(*$
! 5W$; ž

)F05 8M  I
89 n4$1"

(*5 96@ $5 K706@0  8c
r00K 5 !04 98% G()@ ()7#_(*(-
_&#""96N;JI26+ G()Y^(*(*5 96V 9D? SKM W0XZ T 5 W$_0\7#_0"4 9
7 ):96 $
 \KMQ "$X16N;LE(B"5 U6  030M$6 5 S _ 918ª8' 
89 7$ 95 W$H"5 U6LKMA41"6L()8 "5 H04 98%Q"4 5 X/ "
G
76F5P6#"
; x


* "
L^>001"
_ B4*
89

onB 8n 

 5WBF
Q(*C$'[$
$B7#B?A00K5+

bn 

>n bn 

()L8 $

on

>96+
9 s

#P

;Q|,$] 4 "P(B_\4$1"4e ž

'

()8Ye ž

8'[6

ž

*
76



>
S
89 6\'. ž

8'[6

  fM$'[$
$

+fs$'.
$_L()ce ž

; ž

+fs$'[$0/


;Ca#(B?$M'[,6+"9
a() $Q 9WE
74$aM#C?$0 '[u:5 
 8  9D"C¦B
0" }?
0>-%
6 9

74 G


d0dŽ

R23()  > 9 )4 µP‚€9°#² º±ƒ0² ±±¹V®€.³Q€m¯„ƒ€.mÄTKM$(*
Z%(B $ 95 W$;“¦B45+9
1
76c5 P6
1
1+KM :6r04 90/ 8QH091
 i 
 8_XM$B$"45+X"
  8_47#6FE  ‚0¹° ‚4¹ ‚`„€m¯s®€.³Q€m¯„ƒ€.mÄ;aa9> 9
C
\F?$X1"L
+5 QKM$A'
1":KMAM$)
8% ;



OP$$F 0"
Yu 5 _"6 "$0 8 ;T|C 40'*05X"_/ 4"
3 UW>
4

,4,5  a 9KM n
\KMF001
63

78>"
83()$
S $T7?F6  5 4
A/5+a()8\96 
+/

p

 I
74$aA(B  m;)|a$] 4 " (*Te L; RV
1 f+$'[$
$

q

()  sKM,4$1"6()
! $TF/5+A()8 e Q;7§nmf;Ck.R

q

()  I 90441"a Fe Q; §nmf+$'.
$; d_J* A0 "5 U64 #? KM W0X! $09
!01"
 i 
 8T5
76+$* C005 4 "
7

6.3 Handling Negative Relational Evidence

—:&'.*(B3#"3
096 $6Z 9
7 AW055 T"6 6 8/


7 H:96 
L'[C(*!5  E$'[$
F$5  8S$'.$0
1 ! 445
6 $ 8+
135  L
8% ;T>(*"$s 9
7 $+96+

VKM
1"?TL(B  m;

,ê0Ù

96 
 i 6E50
1)Ae K  XD:9
1 f "X>Áî
)* 8%Cu:5 5

S'Q\05 U#\%+M";™"
1cK7DrZ"5+S$] 4 9 |s1"5+YŠ)05 M"0!Se ž

l>m Jl

J*Z 918

90CC6+1"CW05 $5 ,
76T'[aX3%+MBj%5WA  "D3A(

'U"

1"X6 
1Q"5+B 9#9
7 N$ 95 W$
1Q 1" 4B'.-
8%_$W/ " 5+9
k

*L5 88/`0$^5
9
QM$X*
76L *
1 /



(*T6 05 0_0?X *4 4$
:X#"
Y
6VM$0'.
$T005$

ñ

KM :6L 0&!Q5 88/`0$,
1"$
$X o;!%
58? 8 I(B4" 8/ 
Q4

i
76 

> "0WA 5W)78A#aX3WT
6T4$1*!;s>$

ž

e 0'[fH0M$_'A
1"/

?F:96 
QC6+8$ 8\ 5 6SK TF"LK
6\04 90/ 8 405 ;%1
Q(*3$'[$
C()896 
 H
74; `'M(*-
 8_
096 *#009K 5 8H04 U#8%Q(B"5 U6_KM-"$0  1"n;a#(B?$s'B$ 6 3
F#"4
&049 9#2
2 8 6 1"GW05$5+
C(*BG 9$09
 
6EAKM 9$?Gs $ $00M
76FA4a
 ;^J*-*$¨$6K _>6+" 
! E8a"$X  s04 98%T()
! E 9"
 04 U#8% 405 C-'m$6!9
3-(*$ 9 m; R2T 021
3W0
1$_ 9
7 A
W0X
Q'[ $ 95 W$
1+;=%
Z
V 9
7 a6 
G$394 3
/ W0X
:F7#Q
!%(B!$'.$$
Q M
1S
2 446 1 
VKM6 5  F')XV;\%
5 L$] 4 9s
\#0/ -(y04 U#*a
74)e ,; —:D"
f+
763e F; ž

1X(- mf#

6+46YKM\K @ \00K 5 \04 U#8%r405 T7

() L&KM$"44"
&'.46 8OP$$
:L5 F\?_ 4Ckm
9 967d
74?8H9H$]:04 8,5
 D? 8L^F()   9 9KMXA()8Q-4)5   G()8Q(*C$G5+ ()8!96 
 n
4; %
"66+89
\50
1S!0$"
6020"5+'[Q6 $49

1 44"
Y
74- 6X#/6+?
@  ?@Z 0KM!_/   6P;

ž

‡ 9W,
74 i WE
9 ŽGQK
"
S
& Q6 X

QQK 91558'-4$]+9WLQ5 89 

i WF
74C()87

sr =r


89 ^'.F _ 9WF
74";Q|,$] 4 "N"5 1"Ve PK+
0D Pf

Sr

,
CT44"
& UW,
74"^e ¡_; PK 
0D:PfP()  GKM_$"
096:/

tr

$6YQK15"5 Q8'Ce ¡C$


PK+
0D Pf^
6ce ¡,#


 5+45  4$'[$
$4
Z !6#X+;

ž

PK+
0D Pf

LK1"5 "5 L$'[$0/


C,$'[$
C()8244"
S 9WF
74C4
CKM 0/ W0X M6_
_AK 0
$a'N$ U#"
7 M:96 
)9
4 )'[í' /%5  0 7>6+0$KM6!KM""; x


$4M
9 B6 5 9
8%  5W$F7?4KM$
96 
+/

 i 6Z
6V 5W$4#"TKM$
@KM W0XM6NB 3 1"8 

 u vwvwxzy {{C|2}z~ 3€‚€‚xB|2ƒ€s„j~ …†w‡{Md€‚€U{Cˆ‰€‚Š‹v …Œ Ž…Š‹v xB…xjs„† Œ%„Ž€‚ ‘ }„Ž|+Š ž

W

'

"44


9W


74



" UK 

#

ž

8$X#C#?$aL'["  ()9
1!W ;

   ø

 ø

;,`

$4"-'[" E
6 96#,0$a  I8AA
:?" ?C8 $








76V
0$0F "
Q8L'[

ø

é*×äsÝ[ÓtÔ7Õ

dC'["
/

6+96L0$F
6&41"> ”3$#_
$(©$ 95 W$ ø>

 Ÿ

>XSWnN8C96 $
: i 

 T$5 0
 8 0W478_'a 5W3k

)£

âÑIÒ#Ó+â>ì4Ï[ßæ

£

š¦

nÞ"×Ý[Ó+ã

 M'

 0aX0D:*aM$0'.464$z4
 845 09
1F

76 ] 6+0/

w§«© Ö

Nà7ë`ßéFÎ*ê

™Ø#è

EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS

'[$
A0X&E
76!47E C 9"
 
8%W/

l>m Jl CêÙ

dH()8*K7060  8"
T0/

0K 5 ;Va$(*T$M0Q$05 8Q'._0
1 9T
8%V0 () $E(*,
 80" ?E$'[$
A'E5  )%+M";IR,6 
)0 9"C?
:5-A7M; J* 

i W,'*Q8X"
V6 X0$,9C 4¦B8#—+$$L6X0$

$"
X

1 8X#9
_&7M$L'U"

'["5+6 8OP$
_49


 
- 

1 :1"
7 9 8$6_K _9 G$G m;9‡8Š#ˆ#Žo;BJ*

¡Cq>q™¦B5 Zˆ˜˜"Œ

Ó HŸ !Ù

2p

PÕ



 A
:X
6r
vˆ‘: ""V7M$;“J*  5  '.TKM Jn$" 95CF 9184(*F405+, ,M$0'.
$

²´ ·j~ ¸ ÂÄ ·j~ ¸ÃÆ ·j~ ¸¹jÌ ·j~ ¸¹Ä

LÓ+âßSÎEÔY×7áIã©Þ"à7Ò#Ò#Ó âÜ^àMáIãsÏ.áIÐbÜsÒ#Ó Þ"Ï.âÏ[àMá“×7ásã CéLé

!ç

CéFé

Òl5m Jl +¢ m z£

c×7ásã

,êÙ

ãI×ß×âÓ:ßâ"è

g¬ € vw|C®|+|2† ¶ Ô­Ì ³4µKµ3¶ ·j~ ¸¸·Õ·j~ ¸ ÂÌ ·j~ ¸¹jÌ ³4µKµ3¶dÅ ·j~ ¸¸ÄÕ·j~ ¸¹¹ ·j~ ¸¸jÌ ¶K¬oÇ%È3É†Ê ·j~ ¸¸¹Õ·j~ ¸¸jÌ׺‰»‚¼B¼ÁË ¶K¬oÇ'°4ƒ‡|MÊ ·j~ ¸¸ ÂÖ·j~ ¸¸Ù º‰»‚¼B¼kÍ

; J*L7_•:  Š#\$'.$$
F&‘+ ˆ˜˜ 5 /

†Ï.á NÝ[Ó:Ò

¯d°4± ² ³ ·j~ ¸ Âà ·j~ ¸Ã¹ º‰»‚¼B½‰¾ º‰»‚¼B½BÎ

® ˆ º‰»‚¼k¿ÁÀ º‰»‚¼k¿z¾ ·j~ ¸ ¸ ·j~ ¸¹Ä

ì4ÏUßæáIÓ+Ï[ÐMænê

LÏUßÓ NÓ:Ó+ÒL×7ásã

d¯ °4± ¶ ·j~ ¸¹ ÂÖ·j~ ¸ÃÆ ·j~ ¸ ÂÃÕ·j~ ¸ÃÆ ·j~ ¸¸·Õ·j~ ¸ ÂÄ ·j~ ¸¸ÄÕ·j~ ¸ ÂCÚ

±

1"y
$1c +09$3506r9


6 X0$a?EKM
T7
76+/` 9KM$ 96N;

y×7ásã

N×Ò#à

ä^à7ÒæIàPàNãc×7ásãYÓ+ãIÐ7Ó3ãIÓ:ß×7Ï.ÝGâÏmÛ2Ï.ÝU×ÒÏ[ß Zë`à7Ò

5 4
;rJ* \0
76c6 X0$9401
 i 
 @ 91$lE# >



CéLé

3Ø#ç ×ásã

² ´ ·j~ ¸¹· ·j~ ¸¸· º‰»‚¼B¼ÁË º‰»‚¼B¼kÍ

=Ï )Рє ^l Ž” /lœ™

é*×äsÝ[Ó

Ò#Ó+Þ"×7Ý.Ý_ë`à7Ò

sˆ: •"‘"ˆ-$'[$
ICŠ"Š‹?)5  
:X
6E
4Š" ˜‰>6+ $/ km>hG¥Gd$"
X
T7M$T'U"

-Øç N× ÒàSÖ

¬­€ vw|M®|2|2† ² ³ º‰»‚¼B½‰¾ º‰»‚¼B¼‰¾ º‰»‚¼B¼ÁË º‰»‚¼B¼kÍ

®ˆ ³«µ3µ3¶ ·j~ ¸¹· ³«µ3µ3¶dÅ ·j~ ¸¹¸ ¶K¬oÇ%È3É†Ê º‰»‚¼B¼ÁË ¶K¬oÇ'°4ƒ‡|MÊ º‰»‚¼B¼kÍ

R2-M$0'.t$" 95"
G
_%(BC8X"
6#X0$^'[g6+8'[/

 5 "
3 1" ™k

!ç

Ó+ãIÐӐãIÓ:ß×7Ï[ÝâÏmÛ2Ï.ÝU×ÒÏ[ß –Ï.á

TÎCèMéLæIÓ4Û Ó:×7âÑIÒ#Ó+âaÞàPÛ Üs× ÒÓ+ã2× Ò#Ó

GÓ:åMÓ+ásâßÓ+Ï.á Ö

8!u 5$5aQD?> C 18”0 UK ";

8.

CéLé

×ásã

ßÓ:ÒÛ2â,à7ë)ÎEÔ3ÑIâÏ.áIÐ&å × ÒÏUàMÑsâQâÓ+Þ"à7ásãI×Ò YâÏmÛ Ï.Ý[×ÒÏ[ß @Û Ó:× ê

;&Q 0 5 P6#

 >04 98%405 G'.- ,e  96Nf+ 5W$*78; ž

š” ^l /” ^lœ™ ¡l>m +¢

¢ +¢ 2¤C¥ 2£4¦ k§ ‹§S” ¨§ 8© gª

aÓ:Ò#ëà7ÒÛ ×ásÞ"Ó àë

ÑsâÏ.ánЪáIÓ+Ï[ÐMæPä^à7ÒæIàPànã

±

Ô­Ì j· ~ ¸ Âà ·j~ ¸ ÂÌ ºØ» ¼B½Ø¾ ºØ» ¼B½kÎ

'E3 1"84_'.T6 $9
16+5 #4
@$4_'>  0X6 8"
 C $09
nE$  ,
6y|BŠ 
y780()0V6+5 # 6+0"
;c`44 X9  8@
+'.09K ! 
096   )78

J*FKMWaK70 9
QM$0'[
,>()8S}?Ta0
76#0

05 U# 8&'[,>hG¥sP0!!e K  D:
1+fn+?&C4  6

W0
1A049 9#C'.H¦B8#—+H
76F—: 6F§n"
W
C'.^EhH¥s;

C]+0X$^-M
U 76+5 #;HJ*G+?QX


JnX
08?, "05 LOP$$A ,K70$ 9
L6+8OP$
 83
!E(*

‘‘  'B05 )6 5 9'.HKM46 X0;^J*-
:5LKM$'

6#X0$;2R= T8_"6 "$0 8YOP$$_ $09
Z'[4>hG¥Ÿ/

M
9 n6 5 9C78A'^5+A'.$
A'U$AK  XD+
1

6 5 
12 S|BŠS405+ST205 8)8T94+#?_  >'.

,ŠŒ: ‹‹?’L'[E¦B—+$a
76 Š Œ‰+ ‹‹+ŠF'.a>hG¥s;

¦B8#—+$$E
76$K 4 #?$)|BŠ,)(*  m;

o’

“ ž

” ^l

• 2– %—˜

4"5+K70$ 9
Vk CéLé

l>m Jl

d(*\47T()Z! +K 96

,ê0Ù

±W´ N­B¶ a­S405+F‡ ’Ž77#BHKM
40()
4C"5+M$0'.

”"5 M0'.4)KM3'.4A'EK0 
C'[aKM

6#X0$;

Jl

ž

^l>m Al>m Hl

0 P'.CS0
76 0\04 98%S405 

$T5
05M$:06r+?X$'[$]:0/K06@
Y0/ Ù

5+9
n;&h^00
9  8 G8_514
CJ-|I/`%qC|y049 9#2'[

()837#)405+C
6TA9
5 
T"5 M0'.46TK 

# 
13D?
20,()8Y ]+QD?
X
1T5W/

50
1a6+1"G6 $X 094 98 ;|H¦B8#—+

,ê

í()
$91:KM :6404 98%5 M$0'[4G )K70$ 9


l>m Jl CêÙ

,êÙ

Ÿ1$s 0


1!T0$"
60&W0
13094 98S405+";4}?#/oR=
D: $,

Q 1"$WCM"00K Q$  ()8 ?0\1"&5 X$ ;,%_/

$M06rYKM& SKMW!0$"
76 0=04 98%r405+&'[

• 2– %—˜

 #?$4
E#?$C _K70 9
4F1F'[FEhH¥s;PR= _

±W´ N­B¶ a­G;aRY 0=$]+M$4
\()8Ÿ Y}?y
76b 

4 #?4$
:I,
HM#H U#1")
L$4'P|BŠ""
*7

5” /l

—: 6 §n"
W
405+;

CéFé

"
 8SM0C780()0

#26 $90
;!—+
_ 6 5  _ 9#9
V,0X
08?"

” ^lš™

(B_ 90 57#

CéFé

() 9X\4#?A

0W
$9$C9


” ^l

 L80()0Q#\6+0"
E


CéFé

†K 3XD:9
140X
08/

;l>m

?Q "05 ;_¤>Q7#CE0056+ C
F0_()8

Hl Ù

!ls8L6  ,
FD?_80()036+0"
;

›” /l k” /lœ™

05 M$:063 "X

CéFé

! CéFé

ž

,ê0Ù

,êÙ


6

Á“

b6+5$I$0IXG#?$NHK70$ 9
GK E‰‰ ='.¦B8$/

“

—+$$Ck.'[~˜ ñ ˜˜"‘,Q˜ ñ ˜˜?d*
764K ˆ‘ “'[->hG¥=k.'U"~˜ ñ ˜?ˆ‰ _˜ ñ ˜+Š#’d; ž 0  EhH¥V7B4a
T‹‰ ‹"˜"˜˜L05a6 5  

“



780!7#Q&Š ™4 #?4$
:>
V|BŠ40X
0 U#,!4

7
!‹

9 H'- 045
+/

l>m Hl

_
76

Cê

l>m Jl



‰?˜"˜_$0$A8;

§n D:9
1)4^ "0 8F#n H0 5 "
F6 $09
I'U"Ÿ¦B8$/ —+$$ (B>(*,K ELU6+
8'[0"4E
$W
1_"LK
7#"


1l>m Jl

049 9#\ 0 " 96\'.F6+96 
136+5 #;,RF"
0U6+$

'E6 $90
4K 

 CKMW

QŠE)
!KM,X?6T#?$a  P 0 " 96 ;

0K !'.!
r#009K 5 $/`
 8Z4:6  m;yJ* $S\
WX
$T


JIK ŠL$X6 E|BŠ_ 9$?6\K 3,'.5 , 1"8 4E()

a6#X0$G()$A$'.
A78-a?$0_04 9BK5 G0$/

›ž

5BW0
1F04 98%_405+G$"5 6_()T—:'[XJ-|I/`qC| ()  9EJsK 9EˆE0()*AKMW-|BŠ>
6_A00M
76+9
1L+$/ $90
b
76c  >'.T \'."5+! 1"8 4T'.3Xy6X0$

,ê0Ù

7#Q(*5 96@KM36 8z45 8444MW/


63˜ ñ ‘‘+Š,'.a>hG¥s;

7
3C]4 AKM#?F
76T >#F6 5 9;*J*0F





:0N« p"p#(-(-(C; ; 
  m; 6 57p+j%$XpD+6 6 5 Mp
6 $]P;  4

R )(*"5 96T D?a,7
D ž "
3¦B5 0XF
6 ž
76+(v{3#¦* 8/ 

5 t'.) #:96 
1C>5+* UKM *'.*E¦B—+$-6X0$ 
76cqE#:96c}
0
@'.+:96 
12\5   9KM '.  >hG¥@6#X0$;^R>M$0'.46!"6 6 8"
 N 
9
1_'.>KMn;

Ñl>m Hl œÛ Ü MÝ«Ü sÞ +
P
MÞ ¨Û ß BÝ ß Þ 2Ý 
MÞ àÛ Ý 2Ý wÞ ›Û â CÝ â Þ

 0V0$ 8r+6 $6@K 

,êÙ

5 09
1234\048/

98%c 0 " 96=K:c ?$X1"
1Z"44
="  9KMX"
b7#0/ $
;J*_'["  #()
1S4$] 4 «

Û

CÝ

oƒ‚€.®ºX‚0·X²Ÿ· 4ƒ‚€.®ºX‚0· c·

Û



±#²:µV³©´

o`„ÅG„ƒ0„m¸+³L€o¹?„!® *`„ÅG„ƒW„m®¸+³L€o¹?„!®¸ "±Ä?„ #

Þ áÛ

±#²:µV³š® 

o®W² ±ƒXo¯ € a‚V‚\² 4®W² ±ƒX`·¯ € a‚V‚\² 

¯  o³4„#² ‚¹?‚…„µ® B³_„#² „?¹ ‚…„µ2®ƒ€m¹#² „ƒ 

%‚$¯.¯ €o±mG° A‚$¯.¯ €o±^°

`¯ €.…‚ #‚ÄTº *¯ €[…‚ Ä3º 

Û -Ü ã
Ý -Ü U
CÞ ^Û%
‰ÝH
Û Ý bÞ ­Û

Þ =Û +
â Ý +
Þ ¨Û 2Ý º$ƒW„ $€.µ € 3° ,º$ƒW„ $µ€ 3° 

"„ ‚$¯º$€[µ:° ¯NÀ

`¯ €.mm³_„µµ3³Q€o·X² „?‚$¯M¯ ¯ €.mm³4„µ3³

² L
76

+
MÞ

"„ ‚$¯º¯ €.µ ° ¯9‚®X¯ €`‚,À+„"·

BÝ

#

 o®±µM¹?‚ƒo°?„?„ƒW¹4² I®Xµ7¹ ‚ƒo°?„"„ƒ0¹

¹¸ º$µ€o· !·X‚ „ƒXÄ >¹¸ º$µ€o· €-· #;

ž


$91:KM :6_04 98% "8B6+ H
XD?-01"
 i 
 8_ 
1" '._8 $_6 X0$;&J*4 $]+8% ')6+1"T6 $X9 B6 M$
76 


&]4 F'B0/

"
!Q
:5QKM-'s'.$;B`A1()>u 5"6+X#  8T()83 C /

o³Q€.µ `±µ® *³L€.µ`±µV„µM¹ƒ0‚Å º 

$X1"Q
:5 QKM$)'G6 1"$>M$a
8%\
76! 
# 8!()8 ?X1"

() _^*05 8G'N>7#0)$0;^J* )00K5+$/`"
LK70$/


:5LKM$A'H$'.$$
>9
\X&6 1";>R= 9 ,L?$X1L6 1"


$*

-D?- A1" B 6+99
'[-KM40A0$*'

0Ã,A4E'.aKM\6#X0$?$X1",
:5QKM-'6 1"$aM$

]4 L09L5 8X
"5 0 8 H()"$Q 36+0"
Y 0 " 96N


8%SFˆ ñ '[L¦B8#—:$F
62‹ ñ Œ‹T'.,EhH¥y() &$]+ 9
 a6 8OP$$
A
] $5 "
44;
"
0XW:$"4 $]+8%Q'

5 9 8S7#" 1" H0Q

0
E$
096 >
4) 9
";

Þ

>l>m Jl ›" )" ;" /l>m Jl Hl>m Hl

|s15 \ˆ!0 #()Q(~M$0'[
"#Q'.

'[


$91:KM :6 094 982, 9
F
2 4?$X14
:5QKMC'

'[>0/


$91:KMEM$>
8% 7() 9X&9Cˆ ñ Š#4'.,¦B—+$C
76\‰ ñ 4'. EhH¥s;

,ê0Ù

 E%(B46#X0$-()8!0+
1_QK 9
"
(*1:

0K 5 
62 9"
 *04 98% ;SA 9 G7,() 


bL˜+

 4049 9#2,K7062
 82
V00K 5 F
6&() 
8LF() "  82 9
7 m;SJ*  F0(í7

CêÙ

=4Š

î()

KMy
1":KM :6y
6y6 1" 6 X C049 9#="5+M$0'.

d"

 ,K70$ 9
>#?$Q„"¯.¯: 5$a' G;)¤>C

,êÙ

Execution time

XD"

1400

6 
X1Q'G 9#9
7 HKM W0X 
1
S 0F$]+M$4
 () $]+ 9
B() 48-*KM$0$G7
4 aK0 
E$?
4()


P"

44TWXK !
@M0'.
T#?$40+
1

Ÿ
Y
1 /

KM :6c04 98% ;b—:1"
 i 
 8 -"
\ 5W?!KM


«l>m

KM W0X M6&5 0
1T00K5+Q
76! 9"
 ^:96 
"

Hl Ù

Cê

™"5+M$0'.4A LK0 
$>?$
!()
S 9 74LŠM()

CPU time (secs)

˜ ñ () Q'[C>hG¥=M$0'[
FMD:C#"5
6 ˜ ñ Š_
76!
0X 9)O;^-
3 0_KM>K0$?6-6+1"C6+$X P04 U#8%

1000 800 600 400

4
EL00K 5 ,#KM$9
13#?$  D?6 1"$ $Q
76 $ 95 W$aC4$16T5 09
1Q 9
7 n:96 
, "
";

Sl>m Jl " Bl>m Hl S"

|s15 EŒC0 #()BM$0'.
$>'

9#9
7 MKM W0X 
1+;R=$


” ^lš™

,ê0Ù

SB˜:

200

t()85 -5 0
1C$/

,êÙ

)() 9X,s?$ i 6,K a^05 8; ž

CéFé

0

tHU6+
 

 
$0s'[

˜:^M$0'.
94+#?,#?$,4K0 
T
6 
6+" 

>"

1?9
N;=|4EhH¥sHM$0'.
$T'm  90 8V()8c 1"

()8Z
1+KM :6Y049 9# ;VhH6 1!6 X -049 9#Y(-/

ä"

$?$LW9  *M0'.4,05+ 0
1" 8(B  m;&hH?$
2()


ATTR* RC (Nbr) with Bootstrap RC (Nbr) w/o Bootstrap RC (Edge) with Bootstrap RC (Edge) w/o Bootstrap

1200

 7˜+;ŸJ*\KM$WTM0'.
!'[!¦B8#—+35
76

vŠ"^8

6+ KM$0$7
c\K0 
S'.\¦B8#—:$3
76@9TK S

0

10 20 30 40 50 Number of References (in Thousands)

íì

Î)Ï[ÐMÑIÒ#Ó

0” /lœ™ ¢

IÕrÙaÚNÓ+Þ?ÑIßÏ[à7ágßÏmÛ Ó=ë`à7Ò

CéFé

60

îl>m Hl +¢

Z×7ásã

,êÙ

ì4Ï[ßæ~áIÓ+Ï[ÐMæPä^à7ÒæIàPànã~×ásãtÓ+ãIÐÓ=ãIÓ:ß×7Ï[Ý_âÏmÛ2Ï.ÝU×ÒÏ[ß gà+åMÓ+Ò

¢

å+×Ò IÏ[áIÐVáNÑÛSä^Ó:Ò4à7ëAÒ#Ó+ë`Ó:Ò#Ó áIÞ"Ó+â_Ï.árâ náNßæIÓ:ßÏ.Þ!ãI× ß×7âÓ:ßâ"è

 ?\ "0\2˜ ñ ‘V|BŠ!'.3>hG¥s;GJ*0511"W7#6 1 6+$X M-E 9K 9>9
6 #-'I96 $
:8_?$
_() "5+-"
096+/ 9
1&00K5+;\F0 "5 96 #(B?$FKM
6  0405 8

JIa0-(V* 1" 40 *()8_
0
1>
+5 QKM$I'

i
76_M
9 P6 5+/

$'[$
$>
!F6 X07(*,506\_W
 $F1
Xa'.


 576 AK  XD:9
1 :()X50-#00K5 $G

 9;^J* s0511"WII1"?
,M H()8,04 U#
74

LK1"5 "5 )6X:;^RE+0$?6'.#5 A'I> s6 X0

8)-M"00K 9EF96 
8'[T6+5 #*()83F1"36 1E'n$/

()?$HM"00K 9: 9D?* )?$X1)
+5 QKM$s'M$'[$
$*
76

9K  98!50
1_6 1,6 $X n04 98%3 "
";

6+1"-M$)$
:8  C6+1>'s
1":KM  :6T'.AXT$
:8

æå ” ^lš™ çm/ŸŽè

5+9
4C'


6T#"$X13
:5LKM$F'A$'.$$
4M_6+1"";YJ* T] / é*× äÝ[Ó

NÕ

CéFé

™Ï.á

=l>m Jl ]” /l ém ‰£ êÓ JŸ

ÙaÚNÓ+Þ?ÑIßÏ[à7á¢ßÏmÛ Ó†à7ë

ãn×ß×âÓ+ßâ"è

âÓ+Þ"à7ásãsâtë`à7Ò

CêÙ

!ç

CéFé

LÏ[ß$Ó PÓ+Ó:Ґ×ásã

¬­€ vw|M®|2|2† ³4µKµ3¶ Ì~ · ³4µKµ3¶oÅ Ì~ ¸  ¶K¬áÇ'ÈdÉj†3o{Hëg……vwŠwvw†„xBÊ Ùj~ Ĺ ¶K¬áÇã°Sƒj‡|ào{Jëg……vwŠwvw†„xBÊ Ùj~ Æà ¶K¬áÇ'ÈdÉj†3o{C…Žëg……v-Š‹v-†-„xBÊ Ì2Ú~ Æ· ¶K¬áÇã°Sƒj‡|ào{C…Žëg……vwŠwvw†„xBÊ Ì2Ú~ ÙÚ

×7áIã

3Ù

d¯ °S± Ì+ÃÚ~ ÙÚ Ì+¸jÌ~ Ú · ÌÌ+ÄÙj~ ÚÌ Ì2Ú ÃÄj~ ÂÂ Ú ·¸¸j~ ¹¹ ÚÌ2Ú Ùj~‚ÌMÂ

CéFé

àl>m Hl

\
76 6 8OP$
C?09
C'

,êÙ


 46#X0$;_R2Q(*5 962 D?QTW00C7C _$]+5+"
4\6 $M
76+4"
c$'.$3(B  > D?3 !
:5QKM4' M$
:9 C6 5  &7T
r&6#X+A()r(B&(B$&
 K !2
:0 A6 8$ 8 ;v—: $0!
:5QKMQ05 96@
KM 4764()8a$]+5 
4B"
) N6#X0$BK5  
W6_05 96_0$?)"
8L'[-E$"47#X?)W576:Q'MA6 8'U/

/l>m Jl

'.
Q 1"8 4;\J*4$5 ?,
i š7

CêÙ

îXD?

"
1"$E
\,K0 
LK5 AS 00( 7#> ,0$
76 *"5 1" 8 
#a
E
:5 QKM$G's'.$
-'.A  N?$0"
 '>8;YJ*T 4 020(~ 301"
 i 
:_0M6 5 V7Q

|s
  8  (BE  "D- >$]+5+"
T4B'I C 184; ž

!” /lœ™

A 06_
T|s15 A‰L1?9
W-0+
1C
:5LKM$^'P$'[$
$

 $]+M$4
s(*)5
_"
_LŠ";Š#aÃaq>  7¥s(*$XhH6 1aˆ"˜˜

X"6c()8r 9"
 EKM W0X 
1Y
y"66+89
r M$0'[
CKM
 i *A8) #:U6+;

¥s$
:5  00n0?$;^|s8W?
LJsK )ŒA(*GX6,*] $5 "


3[

4H
¦*¥ y0$"
76+B'N )K70$ 9
*
7646 8OP$$
:G?$0


gl5m Jl

'

,êÙ

3l>m Hl K” ^œl ™

t"
a¦B8#—+)
6>hG¥V6 X0$;

,êÙ

~$]:/

9. CONCLUSIONS

%
\ 9>7MN(B_66+$0>L "K ™'G0 +
1T$'[$0/

M$$6 84XD?*4A4a
4aK70 9
;G£B5 **9*u:5 8


_2L5 8 %+M_'E
84
@ 9
7 a6#X+;ZR

'.W'[G¦B8#—+$$XD:
1A"
C()-L5XE4B CéLé

 M"0)%(BL6+8OP$
B04 98%_405+H'[G$'.$$
G7

7;

`*XD"- "
1$-'.AEhH¥)l KM5 A’C4-- 
1_47#6


096 $G 9"
 M04 98%4"
1E“
"6 6 8"
_C

 *K70 
";R=  9-5 0
1E6+1")6+$X +9^4*$]+M
0?G7


00K 5 094 98;R20((t0049 9#V4#/

Varying alpha: Jaro for CiteSeer

Varying alpha: Jaro Winkler for CiteSeer

0.994 0.992 best F1

best F1

0.99 0.988 0.986

RC-ER (Nbr) RC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*

0.984 0.982 0.98

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0.996 0.994 0.992 0.99 0.988 0.986 0.984 0.982 0.98 0.978

0.994 0.992

RC-ER (Nbr) RC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*

0

0.2

0.4

0.6

0.8

0.98

1

Varying alpha: Jaro Winkler for HEP

0.98

0.975 RC-ER (Nbr) RC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR*

0.97

best F1

0.98 best F1

0.98

0.975 0.97

0.965 0.4

0.6

0.8

1

0

0.2

0.4

alpha

0.97

0.6

0.965

0.8

1

0

4¢ïl>m Hl

NÕZéFæIÓcä^Ó+âß2ÎEÔcÛ Ó:×7âÑnÒÓ+âS×7ÞæsÏ[Ó:åMÓ+ã ä

`£

N× Òànç n× Ò#àê †Ï.á NÝ[Ó:ÒT×ásã

¾

Eˆ˜"˜‰ ;

9
a6 8 $

4:6 $ P'[a
8%0" 5+9
n;7JIX
 N$M0 >
?$08%'^{!0+ 9
76PP¦B 9 1F¥DMMˆ˜"˜":; 6 +9"C6 5  

H¾

H±µ´‚ƒ‚µ7·‚

‡8Š˜#ŽCR ;7h^6 >
63qQ;:R$00XDM; a$ U#"
7 I
WX


‰ü

8–

K706T 

1 ; %
3§H;— 80X+ 6 8 *ƒ0±·X‚‚¹€.µ:°®F±W´

þ ú A— "[²

o÷

Hñ

Xµ‚ƒXµM„m€o±µM„"¯ H±µ´‚ƒ0‚µM·X‚Q±µ!¾ „?·X² €.µP‚

^ÿ

71CŠ#ˆˆ

‡ ˆŽ,¥s;7£G$D:
n;7—+5+?$'s 5W$
16 XQ4
9
1

‡ ŽF{ ;£B 9$
D?
76T,; } ;P{3 
$ ; ž

• —ô 1õd˜ý÷

"
 U#"
S
34 $]
'."
307$;7


10. REFERENCES

‡ ‰ŽC;£B0XX7#0:_
763§^;M ; ž

!±ƒ ®W² ±À±µ

!‚º$Mˆ˜"˜Œ+;

Pób˜H˜

9
1X"
N;7


½A³‚ƒX€o·„µ

ÿ

½E®®±·$€o„m€o±µM‹‰ «Š"Š•"Œ 7Š#ˆ Š˜:GŠ‘"‹"‘:;

•

$0'.A$X6 `„m€[®Xm€m·X„¯

‡8Š#ˆŽL¦a;7§^;M M¡_; £B 9 9D?P
6!—P; §n(-$
";M¦B8#—+« ž

^÷


!5 E8X
\9
6 $]+
1LW+W!;+%
S½

÷

œ˜

H±µ´‚ƒ0‚µM·X‚Q±µ ‡8ŠŒ#ŽL{ ; ž




zñ

E€9°€.`„"¯ ^€oº$ƒW„ƒX€`‚®IŠ‘‘"•:;

I¾

;a$

76 $ÃC
6!—P;} ;7—: '[ ;7J*C4$1#p 5 1"

Varying alpha: Sc. Lev. for CiteSeer w/o BootStrap

Varying alpha: Sc. Lev. for HEP w/o BootStrap

best F1

best F1

1 0.98 0.96 0.94 0.92 0.9 0.88 0.86 0.84 0.82

RC-ER (Nbr) RC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR* 0

0.2

0.4 0.6 alpha

0.8

1

1 0.95 0.9 0.85 0.8 0.75 0.7 0.65 0.6 0.55

RC-ER (Nbr) RC-ER (Edge) ATTR ATTR* 0

0.2

0.4 0.6 alpha

ko"d

tå

Î)Ï[Ð7ÑIÒ#Ó

Ó JŸ 3Ù



kmKMd

Ñ£

t¦

nÞ"×7ÝUÓ ã

¢

M¢

GÓ:åMÓ+ásâßÓ+Ï.áY×7â4âÓ+Þ"àMásãn×Ò ZâÏmÛ2Ï.Ý[× ÒÏ[ß 7è

• —ô 1õ3˜ ¨r

 K ~'[A 91"F6 XK0;%


G¾

CNŠ‘"‘":;

‡8Š$‰Ž,qQ; ¼L;+¡, 90
D?#M7—P;7{3 0X+M
76

+¢



•—

 

1+;7%


•˜

 E— ž 

$]:«H| ”QK 1"55-
4*_96+
 i K 9C$
:8;

›—

•

â

a¾ „°?„ $€.µP‚»

ˆ˜˜? ;74 M; ž

‡8Š‹Ž

;7{3#¦* 9 5 

•

ؗ

À ‚0·$€o„"¯ X®®X¸‚F±µ

b—

‚³4„µm€o·

Xµ‚o°ƒ0„m€m±µ

Š‘"‘•+;


76T£a;R2  9
$;7¦B"
76+89
7 I4:6 $ 9-'

•

›—ü

$'.$$
";7%
ž

ˆ˜˜‰ ;

ž

P—Mö‰÷ ›—

 K !« ž ‡ ˆ˜Ž

I½

Eˆ˜"˜˜+;

ž


1+

Xˆ˜"˜":;

;h-;M{3
1",
76\¦a;¥s;7h^ D"
n;J*

i  96TX
1

šób˜J˜

9184)
76! 9#"
;%


;h-;M{3
1",
76\¦a;¥s;7h^ D"
n; ž

EnŠ‘"‘"‹:;


T$z4


6 
/`
76+M
6 
- 1"8 ”'[>6 $$$
1

š˜ œób˜

  ]+ 8T6 5  ,6 XK0E$X6 ;%
Š‘‘?’ ; ‡ ˆ Š$ŽLÀ7¸:m€.µ °

Mÿ

¸:ƒX…‚Ä®7Œ"Œ kWŠd« Œ+Š •"•:

6+ 97
76TqL;7}"$
0
N;M¦B 5W9
1

 9
7 s6XL50
14#00K5 E
76 9
DT
+'.#"
n;

і

%


ñ k




P‚ G¾S€[µ€.µ °„µ7¹

ˆ˜˜"Œ:;

Ϟ 
‰Ý­—Mö‰÷ H—

€.µ F½AµM„¯ Ä®€.®

3±ƒ ®W² ±À

‡ ˆŒŽF¥X1
63¥s;q>"4
1";7{35 88/`$ U#"
7 IX6

šób˜J˜ û 



D1";7%


I½

ؘ

X

3±ƒ ®W² ±ÀV±µ3¾S¸+¯ m€m¶m¿)‚$¯„m€o±µM„"¯ F„`„

¾S€.µ €.µ:°ˆ˜"˜‰+;

‡ ˆ#‰Ž,L;¥05 9+M£A;M{!#0mM£a;7{3 NP—P;+A500  mM
76

•

;7—+ 80$;+W6+
8%5
$0X
%
768X"


H—ü

X
1 ;+%


7ˆ˜˜"Œ+;

‡ ˆ#ŽF¥s;a:9D:5 )
76RŸ; R ;7¦B" 
n; ž

 $XX

M½H—X7ˆ˜˜‰+;

1X 9 I4:6+ M'.a$X63 
D1";


‡ ˆ•#ŽL—P;JI%j06:P¦a; ž

Pób˜H˜

Cˆ˜˜?ˆ:;

;+¡C
K  DM
6\—P;{3
"
n;§n

1

"K:jW$A96 $
: i "
T5 -'.>
'[#9
!
1X#9
n;

—

Xµ´±ƒX³4„m€o±µ

•

¾\¤a$()M0a£BNM¦ ž

0½A¾

Mÿ

+ sˆ Š +ˆŒˆ˜˜?:;

9
 ";7§n#

1QW09
146 8

;7¦B
N;

h]  "8
1_ 9
0 A'[a6 
/`
76+M
76+
-6 X

‡8Š#Ž

1

PÕSéLænÓVÓ GÓ+Þ"ßà7ëQánà7ß\ÑsâÏ.ánÐrä^àNàßâßÒ#×ÜsÜsÏ.áIÐvëà7Ò&Ï.áIÏ[ßÏ[×Ý.Ï Ï.ánПßæIÓYÓ+áPßÏ[ß bÞ"Ý.ÑsâßÓ:Òâ!ëàÒcÖ%×MØ

ÑsâÏ.ánÐ

ž

0.8